Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I had a date with a guy I met off tinder and his arms were covered in self harm scars.

649 replies

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 01:41

So I’ve been talking to this man for afew weeks over WhatsApp now and he seemed really nice. We had lots in common such as love of dogs, music taste, read the same books and so on. We also have children of a similar age. Sounded too good to be true. So we met up tonight for the second time and went to Pizza Hut, and it was really hot in the restaurant so he took his hoodie off and I couldn’t help but notice his arms were covered in scars. They looked old but I was a little taken back as I don’t know anyone that this. I was trying not to look although I felt a little awkward. Am I being unreasonably judgemental or is this a red flag?

OP posts:
Iaminthefly · 11/02/2024 02:36

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

JanglingJack · 11/02/2024 02:41

There are plenty of people that threaten to kill themselves or the kids or... It's horrifying that some actually follow through with their threat. I bet they didn't SH. Manipulation is a control thing. A bullying tool.

I'm sure it's happened plenty, but it's a vast unfair generalisation.

Concaren · 11/02/2024 02:41

Some self harmers can keep it together 99% of the time. However you don’t want to be there for that 1% of the time. They can unintentionally be very manipulative.

wending · 11/02/2024 02:43

Some people have a more visible reminder of issues they may have had with MH. I would t judge someone with old scars (or new) same as I would t judge you for taking antidepressants in the past.

You would find judge someone currently taking antidepressants?

Just interested I'm not being combative.

JanglingJack · 11/02/2024 02:53

wending · 11/02/2024 02:43

Some people have a more visible reminder of issues they may have had with MH. I would t judge someone with old scars (or new) same as I would t judge you for taking antidepressants in the past.

You would find judge someone currently taking antidepressants?

Just interested I'm not being combative.

I think the n's are missing. Wouldn't on both counts. That's how I read it anyway.

WaitingForMojo · 11/02/2024 02:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

WaitingForMojo · 11/02/2024 02:55

It just means that at some point he’s struggled with his mental health and had an unhealthy coping mechanism. Like most people.

JanglingJack · 11/02/2024 02:56

Oh is there, I'm going to lay off those, have my jacket potato and go to bed. Yes, I'm keeping strange hours tonight 🤣

I hope it's not trolling, I hate writing a serious post to find it wasted on the author!

Codlingmoths · 11/02/2024 02:58

I do think many people find their teens hard and then just go on to live a regular perfectly stable life, I know a few.
A firsr date in Pizza Hut wearing a hoody would be a non starter for me, after I was about 16.

winterwarmer8274 · 11/02/2024 03:00

His scars are physical, plenty of people have similar scars but you can't see them.

Drugs abuse, drinking too much, violence, isolation, eating disorders, gambling etc.

Life is hard and sometimes people find it too much to cope. I have a period in my past where I did things I am not proud of, but I'm lucky enough that no one who meets me now will find out unless I tell them.

He's not so lucky. I wouldn't judge him, but I would want to know the background and what work he did to get better.

Fitandfree · 11/02/2024 03:11

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

It really isn't, there are lots of victims of DA, where the perpetrator uses threats of self harm, as a cruel means of manipulation. Children are also seriously damaged in situations like this.

MariaVT65 · 11/02/2024 03:11

I would need to have an honest discussion with him tbh. Especially as you have kids.

I personally wouldn’t date anyone with mental healh issues after someone I was previously involved with ended their life.

It would depend whether it was due to external factors such as abuse/bullying/trauma or a general mental health problem.

JanglingJack · 11/02/2024 03:13

Codlingmoths · 11/02/2024 02:58

I do think many people find their teens hard and then just go on to live a regular perfectly stable life, I know a few.
A firsr date in Pizza Hut wearing a hoody would be a non starter for me, after I was about 16.

Haha I'd seriously consider it for a bowl of potato salad though.

It's also one of those dates where you're stuck there, can't really make a hasty exit.

I did date a guy a few years back who had SHd and had issues. It was to be able to talk openly to someone, but then he turned out to be a complete alcoholic psycho. Oh well, made it out in one piece!

AnImaginaryCat · 11/02/2024 03:28

It's not a red flag, not in the actual sense of the term. (Well it depends what you think the concern is.)

But if you feel that you don't want to take on a relationship that has the potential to be complex from your own mental health point of view then you don't have too see him.again. You are not at a stage in a relationship where there's even a hint of obligation of any sort to each other. Same as he doesn't need to take on being in a relationship with you because of your past depression potentially coming back mean it could be conplex for him.

By complex I mean it may be too difficult for either of you to deal with a mental health crisis because of your own fragile mental health. Thing is though you've no idea how fragile or resilient he is theses days. So you'd be making that call based on nothing but assumption. He wont know hes making that call unless you tell him.

You could ask him, be candid and say you've noticed the scars. Again only you can call if that's the right thing to do but in my opinion it's better than letting it build up in your own mind as something it might not be.

HoweverWeare · 11/02/2024 03:37

The Pizza Hut hoodie combo is a double red flag for me. But I guess you agreed to Pizza Hit so it isn’t for you.

I wouldn’t date someone who disclosed to me that they had serious mental health problems. Nope.

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 03:59

AnImaginaryCat · 11/02/2024 03:28

It's not a red flag, not in the actual sense of the term. (Well it depends what you think the concern is.)

But if you feel that you don't want to take on a relationship that has the potential to be complex from your own mental health point of view then you don't have too see him.again. You are not at a stage in a relationship where there's even a hint of obligation of any sort to each other. Same as he doesn't need to take on being in a relationship with you because of your past depression potentially coming back mean it could be conplex for him.

By complex I mean it may be too difficult for either of you to deal with a mental health crisis because of your own fragile mental health. Thing is though you've no idea how fragile or resilient he is theses days. So you'd be making that call based on nothing but assumption. He wont know hes making that call unless you tell him.

You could ask him, be candid and say you've noticed the scars. Again only you can call if that's the right thing to do but in my opinion it's better than letting it build up in your own mind as something it might not be.

My mental health isn’t fragile, thanks.

OP posts:
Namechangesab · 11/02/2024 04:03

My DH is the same. They all predate me by many years. I have a couple myself from years ago. If he's shown no further signs of it I wouldn't rule him out. He's clearly also come to terms with it to feel comfortable showing you. Give him a chance.

Far more red flag behaviour out there imo, criminal behaviour, violence, serial cheating, heavy drug user or drinker. And even then i would give a chance to someone I liked and showed that part of their life was behind them (well maybe not the cheating and violence!)

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 04:03

What’s wrong with Pizza Hut and hoodies? It’s freezing outside. A hoodie is just a jumper with a hood.

I don’t think I’ll see him again. There is no room in my life for complications snd I don’t want my daughter being exposed to that.

OP posts:
AnImaginaryCat · 11/02/2024 04:04

AnImaginaryCat · 11/02/2024 03:28

It's not a red flag, not in the actual sense of the term. (Well it depends what you think the concern is.)

But if you feel that you don't want to take on a relationship that has the potential to be complex from your own mental health point of view then you don't have too see him.again. You are not at a stage in a relationship where there's even a hint of obligation of any sort to each other. Same as he doesn't need to take on being in a relationship with you because of your past depression potentially coming back mean it could be conplex for him.

By complex I mean it may be too difficult for either of you to deal with a mental health crisis because of your own fragile mental health. Thing is though you've no idea how fragile or resilient he is theses days. So you'd be making that call based on nothing but assumption. He wont know hes making that call unless you tell him.

You could ask him, be candid and say you've noticed the scars. Again only you can call if that's the right thing to do but in my opinion it's better than letting it build up in your own mind as something it might not be.

So what's the problem then?

WandaWonder · 11/02/2024 04:10

Is it a red flag if women have them or only men?

TooFondOfBooks · 11/02/2024 04:14

Self harm is incredibly common. Given the rate of rise recorded between 2007 & 2014 in England (I assume Covid did for 2021’s survey) I’d be astonished if we weren’t now close to a third of women in the 16-24 age bracket having self-harmed (from the 1/4 in 2014); & a more dramatic rise from the 10% of men in that age bracket who’d self-harmed in 2014.

The Samaritans disagree about self-harm being manipulative behaviour btw. It shouldn’t be confused/conflated with threats to deliberate harm oneself if eg a relationship is ended - that absolutely is abusive behaviour; & frequently enacted by individuals with no history of self-harm &/or suicidal ideation.

Some people scar very badly & the scars do not fade. I have chickenpox scars from over 30 years ago; & I didn’t have chickenpox badly, I just scar badly. Chickenpox, cat scratches, a burn from Home Economics class… I have friends who self harmed & are very badly scarred; & friends who haven’t a mark on them now.

His scars are visible, unlike the vast majority of MH issues. The fact they’re scars not wounds suggests that he probably no longer engages in self-harm: it is also common to effectively “grow out of” using it as a coping strategy (albeit a negative one) as people gain agency, independence, & maturity.

Imagine you had to wear a label saying “had depression & had to take [name of medication]”. Would you want that to be what people judged you on? For it to be considered a “red flag”? He might not be right for you; & at some point, if you pursue a relationship, you’ll need to discuss his scars. But leaping to wild conclusions (& what’s worse, if he in fact fell through a window or whatever you’ll feel an absolute buckeejit for deciding the scars are self harm) & writing him off when you didn’t get a bad vibe even seems foolish, to say the least.

JustTalkToThem · 11/02/2024 04:20

You can choose who ever you want to spend your time with and to love.

However, a man who has recognized his emotions, how he enables those, and how to improve that acceptance - well, that sounds like a wonderful role model.

MariaVT65 · 11/02/2024 04:20

As an aside, I think hoodies and pizza hut are getting too much of a bashing op. It was your second date, i wear hoodies as a 35 year old woman and sometimes i just don’t feel like paying the extortionate prices at zizzi/prezzo etc. I think my 4th date with my DH was at KFC because it was near his flat.

kkloo · 11/02/2024 04:34

TooFondOfBooks · 11/02/2024 04:14

Self harm is incredibly common. Given the rate of rise recorded between 2007 & 2014 in England (I assume Covid did for 2021’s survey) I’d be astonished if we weren’t now close to a third of women in the 16-24 age bracket having self-harmed (from the 1/4 in 2014); & a more dramatic rise from the 10% of men in that age bracket who’d self-harmed in 2014.

The Samaritans disagree about self-harm being manipulative behaviour btw. It shouldn’t be confused/conflated with threats to deliberate harm oneself if eg a relationship is ended - that absolutely is abusive behaviour; & frequently enacted by individuals with no history of self-harm &/or suicidal ideation.

Some people scar very badly & the scars do not fade. I have chickenpox scars from over 30 years ago; & I didn’t have chickenpox badly, I just scar badly. Chickenpox, cat scratches, a burn from Home Economics class… I have friends who self harmed & are very badly scarred; & friends who haven’t a mark on them now.

His scars are visible, unlike the vast majority of MH issues. The fact they’re scars not wounds suggests that he probably no longer engages in self-harm: it is also common to effectively “grow out of” using it as a coping strategy (albeit a negative one) as people gain agency, independence, & maturity.

Imagine you had to wear a label saying “had depression & had to take [name of medication]”. Would you want that to be what people judged you on? For it to be considered a “red flag”? He might not be right for you; & at some point, if you pursue a relationship, you’ll need to discuss his scars. But leaping to wild conclusions (& what’s worse, if he in fact fell through a window or whatever you’ll feel an absolute buckeejit for deciding the scars are self harm) & writing him off when you didn’t get a bad vibe even seems foolish, to say the least.

The Samaritans also say:

Myth: People who say they are going to take their own life are just attention seeking and shouldn’t be taken seriously.

Fact: Talking openly about suicide to a loved one, colleague, professional or a Samaritan can help someone work through their thoughts and help them find a way to cope. People who say they want to end their lives should always be taken seriously. It may well be that they want attention in the sense of calling out for help and helping them get support may save their life. Being able to talk openly about suicide can help someone work through their thoughts.

They don't talk about the possibility of manipulation, even though it is extremely common. And I understand why they don't, because they want to prevent suicide, but their myths/facts are extremely biased for a reason, they're not necessarily the truth.

My ex self harmed in front of me as a form of manipulation, and also threatened suicide to manipulate me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread