Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I had a date with a guy I met off tinder and his arms were covered in self harm scars.

649 replies

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 01:41

So I’ve been talking to this man for afew weeks over WhatsApp now and he seemed really nice. We had lots in common such as love of dogs, music taste, read the same books and so on. We also have children of a similar age. Sounded too good to be true. So we met up tonight for the second time and went to Pizza Hut, and it was really hot in the restaurant so he took his hoodie off and I couldn’t help but notice his arms were covered in scars. They looked old but I was a little taken back as I don’t know anyone that this. I was trying not to look although I felt a little awkward. Am I being unreasonably judgemental or is this a red flag?

OP posts:
InAPickle12345 · 11/02/2024 19:56

@XenoBitch exactly. This thread COULD have been an enlightening one for some, maybe they might learn something new about mental health and how it is caused, how it manifests, how people can recover from it. But unfortunately it has been completely derailed, by one person in particular, and is doing absolutely nothing to address the OPs question.

Imagine this is read by someone who is sensitive, vulnerable, trying to find love and desperate for a family. This could be enough to make them feel they will never have the life they want and tip them over the edge.

These poisonous, outdated opinions should not be given a platform.

Danc1ng1nthedark · 11/02/2024 20:08

“Spicy heated and robust”
no outdated, ignorant and deeply upsetting. I really hope my daughter doesn’t read it. Great to hear my future grandchildren are going to be damaged regardless- according to 1 poster.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/02/2024 20:17

Tahinii · 11/02/2024 19:28

I think it’s best to ignore uninformed statements from people who not only have no mental health qualifications but also, from those who do not work in the field.

Making blanket statements and being unable to back them up with evidence makes the poster look silly. Life’s too short to expect them to explain something they’ve made up in their head.

Nobody ever has to date anyone for any reason. Personally, I’d ditch someone who took me on a date to Pizza Hut once I was over 16. However, mental health problems can strike anyone at any age so I’d always try to be open minded.

You’re right. I think it’s hard to ignore though when somebody is making a statement which further stigmatises something that already feels shameful or judged and which perpetuates harmful, but false, stereotypes. By ignoring them and letting them stand unchallenged I worried it might then look like the statements were unanimously agreed with or believed to be true by everyone. I can see the logic in ignoring them though.

Ratherstandonacliffandsetfiretomyself · 11/02/2024 20:19

So @Bubble2024 keeps repeatedly insisting that parents who have ever had mental health problems are damaged by this. Also says father was an alcoholic. But apparently isn't damaged. Logic?

My father was also an alcoholic and yes it has had a lasting impact on me. I'd have much preferred a father who had self harmed years in the past by cutting than one actively self-harming by drinking.

Over the years I've massively massively self-harmed myself, mostly through alcohol abuse and starving myself (not anorexia). Yet nobody who ever met me now would know any of this. But if I had overtly self-harmed and had the scars to prove it I would face significant judgement - nice.

ParanoidGynodroid · 11/02/2024 20:37

To those that have been hurt I'm with you. You are amazing and do, of course, deserve love.
I didn't say it before but my beautiful, successful daughter is heavily scarred from teenage self harm. She's gone on to great things, is super fit and healthy and has a wonderful partner. Actually, she's never had problems with attracting a decent, understanding man.

For anyone to say that her future children will suffer because of her teenage problems makes me absolutely furious. Her sensitivity and insight will make her a better mother than some of the judgemental ignoramuses on here.
To prejudge the background of such children, denigrate loving supportive households of and insult their parenting makes my blood boil.

People can choose whom they date, whatever their criteria, that's fine... writing hateful, uniformed garbage about MH issues is not fine.

dottiedodah · 11/02/2024 20:46

I would be a little concerned, however if you get on well just take it slowly. Don't get too involved too quickly

RootVegAndMash · 11/02/2024 21:04

I wouldn't get involved with someone I knew had a history of significant MH difficulties. So in your shoes I wouldn't see him again.

It's not something anyone can really advise you on though. Clearly from the thread there will be opinions from absolutely not to absolutely fine and everything in between.

It's a personal decision with no right or wrong answer imo.

XenoBitch · 11/02/2024 21:08

RootVegAndMash · 11/02/2024 21:04

I wouldn't get involved with someone I knew had a history of significant MH difficulties. So in your shoes I wouldn't see him again.

It's not something anyone can really advise you on though. Clearly from the thread there will be opinions from absolutely not to absolutely fine and everything in between.

It's a personal decision with no right or wrong answer imo.

Some scars are not an indicator of significant MH difficulties though.
If OP is still interested in her date (and TBH, he sounds lovely), then she can ask about his scars in a sensitive way.

RootVegAndMash · 11/02/2024 21:18

Some scars are not an indicator of significant MH difficulties though

Well 'significant' is obviously a subjective term. But I disagree. For me, 'some' scars would be significant enough that I wouldn't take the relationship any further.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/02/2024 21:20

As it’s clearly not a definite deal-breaker then asking is likely the best thing to do before making a decision. I have extensive scarring and don’t mind if people ask about them as long as it’s not done rudely or judgementally. It’s reasonable for people to ask, if I ever did feel worthy of seeking a partner I would expect them to ask and want to know about it. If I was going for a date with someone I met on Tinder I’d probably worry that they might be a deal breaker and think just brazenly exposing them might be something I would do hoping it would open up a conversation I was too anxious to initiate, one of the things that puts me off dating is that I have a lot of issues (self-harm, autism & adhd, previous sexual assault which causes issues around sex etc) and it’s hard to know when or how these should be brought up. Obviously you don’t want to scare people off with them before you’ve even met but equally it would feel dishonest to hide them until the person is invested weeks or months down the line if actually they would be a deal breaker for them. So it may be he is expecting you to ask and happy to talk but just not quite sure how to bring it up himself.

Anyway I think if you ask hopefully his response will also tell you what you need to know, if he’s cagey and unwilling to talk about it at all I would find that a bit of a red flag. If he’s open and honest and able to reflect on why he self harmed in the past and talk about where his general mental health I would see that as a green flag to be honest. I don’t think the perfect partner is someone who has a clean mental health history but rather somebody who understands their mental health and the coping strategies they can use when down to keep themselves mentally healthy, if you talk to him you should be able to gauge how good his understanding of mental wellness is and where he is now before you make any final decisions.

XenoBitch · 11/02/2024 21:22

RootVegAndMash · 11/02/2024 21:18

Some scars are not an indicator of significant MH difficulties though

Well 'significant' is obviously a subjective term. But I disagree. For me, 'some' scars would be significant enough that I wouldn't take the relationship any further.

Scars are old wounds that have healed.

So you would write off a potential date for some preconceived MH issues... when they may not have had any MH issues at all for decades?

If someone took anti-depressants for a while 20 years ago... would you be judging them as harshly?

PaperDoIIs · 11/02/2024 21:29

Here we go again...

SideshowAuntSallyx · 11/02/2024 21:32

There are some ignorant comments on this thread. What I did when I was 16/17/18 has no bearing on my 46 year old self. I gone through a lot worse and haven't self-harmed, I've been depressed and didn't self-harm, because I've grown up and have developed coping mechanisms that don't involve hurting myself.

At 16 I was a mass of hormones, in a new college, lonely, and recovering from being bullied relentlessly for 3 years. I had a loving family and stable family life but that couldn't make up for everything else.

If people want to judge me on my 16 year old self's actions then they are narrow minded and ignorant.

Veggie1965 · 11/02/2024 21:38

Has someone name changed 🤔

RootVegAndMash · 11/02/2024 21:39

So you would write off a potential date for some preconceived MH issues... when they may not have had any MH issues at all for decades?

Yes, I would.

I'd have a lot of 'hard no' criteria when it comes to a dating pool. This would be one of them for me.

I appreciate that's not the case for some (many?). But it would be for me.

RootVegAndMash · 11/02/2024 21:40

Veggie1965 · 11/02/2024 21:38

Has someone name changed 🤔

I name change often.

But no, I've posted twice on this thread so far. Or 3 maybe? I'm not the same poster that it appears the last few pages were about.

XenoBitch · 11/02/2024 21:41

RootVegAndMash · 11/02/2024 21:39

So you would write off a potential date for some preconceived MH issues... when they may not have had any MH issues at all for decades?

Yes, I would.

I'd have a lot of 'hard no' criteria when it comes to a dating pool. This would be one of them for me.

I appreciate that's not the case for some (many?). But it would be for me.

Are you aware that self harm takes many forms... several of which would not have a visible sign years later.

So you meet a man in his 40s... and he has scars from his teens. You would actually give him a hard no for his scars?

If so, that is really sad to see.

RootVegAndMash · 11/02/2024 21:49

Are you aware that self harm takes many forms... several of which would not have a visible sign years later. So you meet a man in his 40s... and he has scars from his teens. You would actually give him a hard no for his scars? If so, that is really sad to see

Yes i'm aware. And yes, I would give a hard no if I became aware, early on, of a history of MH problems in a potential date.

I have all kinds of reasons for this. Some personal and deeper than I want to delve right now. Some shallow. None of which are particularly important or relevant to answering the op's question.

I'm an adult woman with the right to choose my own dating criteria. I really, really don't need my mind changed for me.

DreamVortex · 11/02/2024 22:50

Veggie1965 · 11/02/2024 21:38

Has someone name changed 🤔

🤔

Throckmorton · 11/02/2024 23:33

I'd like to just add a big hug for people like @XenoBitch who have been hurt by the bile and ignorance spewed by various posters on this thread. If it's any comfort, when I see healed SH scars I tend to assume the person has been through hell but has come through it and must be pretty damn strong and brave. Hugs to you all.

ParanoidGynodroid · 12/02/2024 00:25

That's so true @Throckmorton . DD has had this said to her before, from various people, about how amazing, strong and resilient she is to have overcome such difficulties. The response is positive and supportive.

I do genuinely believe that most people are understanding and sympathetic towards people who have suffered mental ill health, so I do hope people don't take some of the cuntishness shown here too much to heart.

Jumpingthruhoops · 12/02/2024 01:14

theduchessofspork · 11/02/2024 02:08

Well it means he’s had some mental health issues he’s struggled to manage. There’s nothing wrong with deciding that means je isn’t for you.

It's responses like this that highlight how far we still have to go to end the stigma around mental illness.
If someone had a physical condition and 'struggled to manage' would they be considered to be outside of the dating pool, too?

defiant2024 · 12/02/2024 01:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

defiant2024 · 12/02/2024 01:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Scirocco · 12/02/2024 01:32

You seem quite angry, @defiant2024 . I hope things improve for you soon.