Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I had a date with a guy I met off tinder and his arms were covered in self harm scars.

649 replies

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 01:41

So I’ve been talking to this man for afew weeks over WhatsApp now and he seemed really nice. We had lots in common such as love of dogs, music taste, read the same books and so on. We also have children of a similar age. Sounded too good to be true. So we met up tonight for the second time and went to Pizza Hut, and it was really hot in the restaurant so he took his hoodie off and I couldn’t help but notice his arms were covered in scars. They looked old but I was a little taken back as I don’t know anyone that this. I was trying not to look although I felt a little awkward. Am I being unreasonably judgemental or is this a red flag?

OP posts:
HarrietTheFireStarter · 11/02/2024 09:23

HoweverWeare · 11/02/2024 07:14

As for the comments about Pizza Hut and hoodies, I'm not clear why anyone is offering their opinions as you haven't asked for those.

Welcome to the World Wide Web. Wink

I imagine you find yourself rather clever and witty. You're not. Clichés are ever so dull.

Dogdilemma2000 · 11/02/2024 09:23

OP - my concern here would be how he seemingly so brazenly showed his scars.

As someone with scars I take massive efforts to hide them from anyone other than people I know really well. I always wear long sleeves. I’m meticulous in planning outfits.

He’s had a short sleeve shirt and a hoodie on a date to a restaurant. Anyone could predict they’d be too hot in a hoodie.

So my feelings here are that he’s shown his scars early in a “take me of leave me” style. He’d rather know now if you’ll accept him as he is or not.

Personally I’d not date someone with active major mental health issues. But if it was in the past and they are mentally well adjusted now possibly.

Only you can decide if you want to go ahead. Either you decide it’s a no or you have a very open and real face to face conversation about it.

Donmeistersleepmachine · 11/02/2024 09:23

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 11/02/2024 09:19

You are right but I wouldn’t want the risk. What if he relapses. Has a very stressful time in the future? Redundancy, illness, bereavement? Do you want to be dealing with that? I wouldn’t if I had kids.

It's a pretty fucking offensive assumption that anyone who's ever self-harmed will automatically relapse just because they're stressed.

It's really not. It's a risk assessment. If a man had previously had anger issues and beat an ex but went to therapy and was genuinely "changed", I wouldn't go near him. If I found out somebody was an ex drug addict in recovery for years, I would run the fuck away. If I found out somebody had schizophrenia but hadn't had an episode for 10 years and was on medication, romantically, I genuinely wouldn't do it. Id back out. And it's because of assessing the potential risk for me. Trust me, I make these decisions from experience and I decide who I am with based on what is good for ME, not to be kind and to not offend. Ignoring all stereotypes or risks and blindly jumping in as if you don't have gut feelings or preferences often leads you to get burnt.

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:24

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 11/02/2024 09:23

It’s pretty naive to think there isn’t a risk of it.

I'm not debating with you because your posts are downright unpleasant and offensive.

They are not. They’re factual.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/02/2024 09:24

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:12

Mental illness and mental health issues are vastly different things. A bit of mild depression or anxiety is different from self harming and other.

i never said shield a child, teaching a child about mental health issues is not the same as setting the framework that mummy / daddy is not safe.

You seem very uneducated about self harm which is not always indicative of mental illness, it is often used to cope with depression and anxiety, especially by teens. I would say at least 50% of my friends self harmed in their teens but most do not have any long term mental health issues. About 25% of teenage/ young adult girls report having tried self harm, that does not mean that a quarter of young women have a mental illness. Obviously self harm can be an indicator of mental illness, but it isn’t always. In my case I believe my self harm is linked to having undiagnosed autism and adhd, once I got my diagnosis and learnt strategies to cope with being neurodiverse my reliance on self harm hugely reduced.

HarrietTheFireStarter · 11/02/2024 09:24

Dogdilemma2000 · 11/02/2024 09:23

OP - my concern here would be how he seemingly so brazenly showed his scars.

As someone with scars I take massive efforts to hide them from anyone other than people I know really well. I always wear long sleeves. I’m meticulous in planning outfits.

He’s had a short sleeve shirt and a hoodie on a date to a restaurant. Anyone could predict they’d be too hot in a hoodie.

So my feelings here are that he’s shown his scars early in a “take me of leave me” style. He’d rather know now if you’ll accept him as he is or not.

Personally I’d not date someone with active major mental health issues. But if it was in the past and they are mentally well adjusted now possibly.

Only you can decide if you want to go ahead. Either you decide it’s a no or you have a very open and real face to face conversation about it.

But why should he hide them? Because you do? I mean, that's a bit judgement, isn't it?

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:25

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/02/2024 09:18

She has visible self harm scars on one arm. People who saw them would probably assume she had a history of self-harm and judge accordingly. When does self harming once/ twice/ a few times qualify as having a ‘history of self-harming?’ Self harm is a such a broad term to cover a range of behaviours with a range of causes, severities, occurrences etc. How do you judge when it is symptomatic of being a person who has low resilience, turns to poor coping strategies and would be a bad, unhealthy parent vs somebody who is free to wipe it from their history?

I don’t actually believe you.

PeggySooo · 11/02/2024 09:25

Some of these comments are so painfully judgemental. Some people wear their scars on the outside, but there's plenty of us with them on the inside.

He has given you no other reason to stay away yet. I'd give him a chance if it were me. Id not ask him about them but wait and see if he explains them himself. It can be very painful to someone to have them asked about scars unexpectedly.

EmeraldA129 · 11/02/2024 09:26

nrft but have read all of ops posts. I’d ask him about them op.

it’s perfectly reasonable that you would notice them & that you would want to understand where his mental health is before moving further with a relationship. If they’re old then he should feel comfortable enough telling you that.

it doesn’t sound like you did judge him, just noticed the scars on his arms in the same way you would have noticed if he had lots of freckles on them.

there are a lot of folk I knew at school that experimented with self harm as kids and have the scars to prove it, but have not had any further desire to do it again and have also not had any significant mental health crisis’. On the flip side there is one person I know that has since spent most of his life going through periods of being committed & released. I find that heartbreaking, but from my experience (just of life, no formal evidence to back this up) that one person does not represent the majority of people that have self harmed. I’m 38.

am aside & not related to self harm, but I was dating a guy who was lovely but very extreme & changeable which left me feeling all over the place… he eventually told me he was bipolar but didn’t want to tell me straight away. If he had spoken to me at the start then some of the behaviours would not have had such a negative impact on me.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/02/2024 09:26

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:25

I don’t actually believe you.

What part don’t you believe?

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:27

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/02/2024 09:24

You seem very uneducated about self harm which is not always indicative of mental illness, it is often used to cope with depression and anxiety, especially by teens. I would say at least 50% of my friends self harmed in their teens but most do not have any long term mental health issues. About 25% of teenage/ young adult girls report having tried self harm, that does not mean that a quarter of young women have a mental illness. Obviously self harm can be an indicator of mental illness, but it isn’t always. In my case I believe my self harm is linked to having undiagnosed autism and adhd, once I got my diagnosis and learnt strategies to cope with being neurodiverse my reliance on self harm hugely reduced.

I didn’t say self harm was a sign of mental illness. I said it was a sign of mental health issues and not something I would consider.

Your story is sad but is still one I would choose to walk away from.

Dogdilemma2000 · 11/02/2024 09:27

HarrietTheFireStarter · 11/02/2024 09:24

But why should he hide them? Because you do? I mean, that's a bit judgement, isn't it?

I never said he should hide them, I said showing them so early in a relationship is a deliberate choice.

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:27

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/02/2024 09:26

What part don’t you believe?

That she self harmed once that led to obvious scarring.

HoweverWeare · 11/02/2024 09:27

HarrietTheFireStarter · 11/02/2024 09:23

I imagine you find yourself rather clever and witty. You're not. Clichés are ever so dull.

Edited

I don’t particularly think I am clever and witty. Sorry if it’s dull, what can I say. I don’t write good content.

thefallen · 11/02/2024 09:27

Kbroughton · 11/02/2024 07:37

I self harmed at university for about 2 years. It was a difficult time. I still have some scars. Now 47, not self harmed since. Director in the NHS. My husband left me in 2022 for another woman and self harming didn't cross my mind. So it may be an issue or it may not be. Everyone is different but if I liked him I would at least want to know his story.

Same. The scars are from a long time ago, I was a teenager struggling. If someone was put off by my having had a hard time a quarter of a century plus ago, fine.

thefallen · 11/02/2024 09:28

Sorry quoted the wrong post

UnimaginableWindBird · 11/02/2024 09:29

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/02/2024 09:24

You seem very uneducated about self harm which is not always indicative of mental illness, it is often used to cope with depression and anxiety, especially by teens. I would say at least 50% of my friends self harmed in their teens but most do not have any long term mental health issues. About 25% of teenage/ young adult girls report having tried self harm, that does not mean that a quarter of young women have a mental illness. Obviously self harm can be an indicator of mental illness, but it isn’t always. In my case I believe my self harm is linked to having undiagnosed autism and adhd, once I got my diagnosis and learnt strategies to cope with being neurodiverse my reliance on self harm hugely reduced.

Let's be honest, though. A person who wouldn't date someone with self-harm scars is also going to refuse to date anyone who isn't neurotypical.

Mt563 · 11/02/2024 09:29

Mariposistaaa · 11/02/2024 09:16

You are right but I wouldn’t want the risk. What if he relapses. Has a very stressful time in the future? Redundancy, illness, bereavement? Do you want to be dealing with that? I wouldn’t if I had kids.

op has had depression and taken medication for it herself in the past. Bet she hasn't disclosed that and doesn't consider it a red flag he might want to know about.

So many people have mental health issues, most are not so easily obvious.

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:29

UnimaginableWindBird · 11/02/2024 09:29

Let's be honest, though. A person who wouldn't date someone with self-harm scars is also going to refuse to date anyone who isn't neurotypical.

My husband is autistic as is my daughter. Nice try though.

HarrietTheFireStarter · 11/02/2024 09:30

Dogdilemma2000 · 11/02/2024 09:27

I never said he should hide them, I said showing them so early in a relationship is a deliberate choice.

Do you think there is something wrong with that and why?

4timesthefun · 11/02/2024 09:33

Mariposistaaa · 11/02/2024 09:16

You are right but I wouldn’t want the risk. What if he relapses. Has a very stressful time in the future? Redundancy, illness, bereavement? Do you want to be dealing with that? I wouldn’t if I had kids.

I think that’s where finding out more information is important IF the op wants to. She isn’t obliged to date anyone.
Speaking for myself, I’m actually FAR more resilient to stress and life circumstances now, because I’ve dealt with my past issues and am very stable. Since my teen years I’ve dealt with some serious issues. My father was killed and his death subject to a public inquest, I had 4 miscarriages including 2 in the second trimester (one later), deaths of other relatives, my mother has been diagnosed with early onset Alzheimer’s and I’ll probably soon be parentless in my 30’s, I nearly died having my 2nd child and spent a long time in ICU, plus all the usual life stressors with a high pressure job and 4 children. No issues at all with my mental health or coping. My DH doesn’t have any history of MH issues but is far less resilient in the face of stress, and it has a far more noticeable impact on his mood and tolerance. If you ask the kids who is made of tougher stuff and is better with stress, I doubt they would pick him.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/02/2024 09:34

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:27

That she self harmed once that led to obvious scarring.

Okay. Obviously I can’t prove that to you, she was drunk and she cut herself badly on her forearm. She didn’t seek treatment, the scars healed as raised keloid scars and they haven’t faded that well. The scars are not obvious from a distance but if you are sat with her they certainly are. Obviously I don’t know with 100% certainty she only self-harmed once but I knew her at the time it happened and she’d never mentioned doing it before or after that one incidence. She doesn’t have scars anywhere else.

Danc1ng1nthedark · 11/02/2024 09:35

Walking away from anybody who has struggled is going to limit your choices somewhat.

I think people who have struggled are some of the kindest, often most resilient and thoughtful people . Your loss.What are you going to do when shit happens to you or within life circumstances? Life isn’t clinical and in all likelihood your teens will struggle in some way.

So many people have self harmed or struggled in a variety of ways when younger. Coming through the other side is a sign of great strength.

PaperDoIIs · 11/02/2024 09:35

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 11/02/2024 09:22

@PaperDoIIs people can have whatever boundaries they like - that's not really what's being disputed here.

But having boundaries doesn't mean you get to be rude and judgemental about other people in the way that's being displayed on here. Some of these comments are awful and incredibly offensive.

By all means don't date someone with a history of self-harm - that's absolutely fine - but what's not fine is saying that they can't be suitable parents, or saying they can't be trusted not to relapse, or that they'll definitely be manipulative in an argument and threaten to cut themselves with kitchen scissors.

Those are only a few of the nasty comments that have been made by various posters on here. Imagine your child struggled with their mental health and people were saying those things.

I don't have to imagine, I was that child/teen/young adult. That is precisely why I'm giving OP the benefit of the doubt. While I'm a decent person , I wouldn't date me at my worst,much less have a serious relationship/children. Because I know exa how it can be, how I can be.

And just like addiction, it never really went away for me. I haven't self harmed since 2015. I had a big gap before that too (2010), but relapsed when really low and something devastating happened. Things happened since, and while I haven't done it, the need was strong. So strong in fact , it was physical too not just mental. My wrists were itching and painful and my brain was screaming... just a bit, to release the pressure. To make the pain go away, to make the itching go away, to make the throbbing go away. Nevermind the emotional/mental need. It took everything I had not to give in.

Donmeistersleepmachine · 11/02/2024 09:35

UnimaginableWindBird · 11/02/2024 09:29

Let's be honest, though. A person who wouldn't date someone with self-harm scars is also going to refuse to date anyone who isn't neurotypical.

Most people tend to want to be with someone similar to them in the important ways. Some people want mental stimulation, so want equal intelligence. Some people want equal ambition. Some people want equal stability. I think those who are offended are just hurt the pool of people willing to date them may be smaller. But that's a bad way of looking at it because there are people you yourselves would not consider due to their lifestyle/looks/personality/work ethic and so on.

I wouldn't want to be with someone with a servere history of mental illness, no. Sorry? I wouldnt bat an eyelid at somebody missing a leg, or someone with mild ADHD or autism. Severe Austim? No, because I want somebody likeminded to me who has the capacity to debate, reason, succeed, in the things that are important to me.

We ALL have preferences. People need to reign in their offence. By what some people here are saying they'd happily go for anybody with any lack of mental capacity, or serious mental illness, or difference in personality, or strongly not their physical type, just becuase they "get along" and "like the same music" and "had a good chat". No.