Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this be an absolute NO for you? Golliwog encounter.

995 replies

skatermom · 20/01/2024 16:13

We've recently moved to a new village. Really lovely place, really nice people. We needed a Violin teacher for my DS who is in secondary school. His teacher lives too far away now and we were looking for somewhere that wasn't too far away.

How lucky we were to find a classical string instrument teacher a walking distance from home. I spoke to him over the phone and he sounded lovely. He is in his 50s and teaches lots of children in the area. He also plays the guitar and sings in the choir of the local church. We went to see him in his cottage-like home for an assessment and he took us into his small music room. It was gorgeous! Lovely instruments around, beautiful decor, very old style but really nice. One side had little figurines of angels and fairies, one wall had really old photos of what looked like old relatives from before the 1970s, he had a frame of old miniature trains etc.

I sat on the rocking chair he offered while he talked loads around planning the ABRSM grades and the different classical violinists. I'm not very musical but listened on. Then it was time for my DS to play so I sat back and listened while looking around. I looked towards my left and there was a cabinet with glass dolls and about 25 miniature Golliwog / Gollywog figurines. Now, I should probably say here that I'm black.

I froze from shock and just looked on and pretended not to see them. I'd never seen one in person before! When we finished, we made some follow up arrangements and left with a promise to get back in touch.

The man was so very lovely, seemed so kind and welcoming and encouraging that I don't know whether to be offended!

AIBU to ignore it and just keep taking DS for the lessons? He's the only one at the level we need in a 3mile radius.
What would you do in my shoes?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
skatermom · 22/01/2024 20:43

@DeeCeeCherry
How entitled to think I have no backbone is why I would send my child to the teacher. If I followed your 'advice', even I would be nowhere. There would be courses I wouldn't complete, jobs I would not get and promotions I would have lost. It is having a backbone that makes many POC stay quiet and tolerate the racism we get without breaking down in tears a constantly. Not as though my tears count for anything in this society. If you read my updates, you would see where I explained that I posted on MN because I wanted to know what even white people thought of the situation. I can take a lot and wanted to know if I would be taking too much according to most people in this part of the world. At the end of the day, I am trying to give my child an education and there is a lot that comes with that including sometimes suffering in different ways.

Even if you were a POC yourself, your experience is totally different from mine. I haven't accidentally stumbled on white MN and wandering around aimlessly.

OP posts:
SkulkHollow · 22/01/2024 20:47

PropertyManager · 22/01/2024 19:47

If I refer back to my original statement

"It is an active choice to be offended, sometimes rightly, sometimes wrongly"

Someone may of course actively seek to hurt or belittle another, in your example the child would be attempting to be offensive, most likely to provoke a reaction. This child of course should be reprimanded.

The other child has the option of what to do with that, they can look down their nose at the foolish and unpleasant child, shrug their shoulders and get on with their day, they can be upset and let it get to them, or if they are sharp enough and have the skill and timing, they can hit back with the witty reposte, then move on, especially useful when others are around.

Now I was taught myself this philosophy by a very inspirational teacher of mine, a black man, who had come to England in the 50's, and seen his share of racism, and taught himself to shake it off, and to disregard those who doled it out - he was a razor sharp wit, on one occasion I saw someone chuck a racist joke at him, attempting to make him the butt of the joke, he turned it around so deftly and smoothly, leaving the instigator crestfallen with a canteen full of kids laughing at him.

If someone punches another person, do you think it's an active choice to feel pain?

This whole "you choose to take offense" position is such utter bullshit. It's minimalising the impact that bigotry has and shifting the blame onto the victims, that they are somehow not strong willed enough to be able to shrug it off or not witty enough to come up with a fast response.

No. Offensive is very much given, usually by the kind of wanker who will say "oooh, touched a nerve have I" when people dare to challenge their shite.

SquashedSquashess · 22/01/2024 20:48

I’m 31, and was given a golliwog for Christmas by my grandmother when I was 5. I didn’t like it, and no, I don’t have it now.

It’s not beyond the realms of possibility that a man in his 50s was gifted golliwogs

SquashedSquashess · 22/01/2024 20:50

Also, I think OP has every right not to like the fact this man has golliwogs, and might choose not to send her son for lessons with him on that basis.

But it isn’t illegal to own golliwogs, or to display them in your own home, no matter how distasteful they are to many. It’s that man’s choice to hold on to them, and it’s OP’s choice to take her custom elsewhere

Minymile · 22/01/2024 20:55

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/01/2024 20:38

Wikipedia is just opensource, it's not any kind of authority. The Jim Crow museum states that the image was based on a black minstrel - itself a racist caricature.

jimcrowmuseum.ferris.edu/golliwog/homepage.htm

The Golliwogg was based on a Black minstrel doll that Upton had played with as a small child in New York. The then-nameless "Negro minstrel doll" was treated roughly by the Upton children. Upton reminiscenced: "Seated upon a flowerpot in the garden, his kindly face was a target for rubber balls..., the game being to knock him over backwards. It pains me now to think of those little rag legs flying ignominiously over his head, yet that was a long time ago, and before he had become a personality.... We knew he was ugly!" (Johnson).

Think PP said wiki was basic stuff but it basically states the same as the JC museum.
The comparison is not really appropriate as wiki is not biased.

AbsoluteZER0 · 22/01/2024 20:56

As the guy is providing a service, ideally he should put them out of site as he should be aware by know about what many people think about these items.

SeatonCarew · 22/01/2024 20:56

PuppyMonkey · 20/01/2024 16:27

I’m in my late fifties and can assure you having golliwogs as toys was not common when I was little.Confused

Also even if I did have such a toy as a kid, I am aware times have moved on and am able to read stuff and listen to current affairs etc and have the sense to realise when customers come to my home I should not have racist shit around where it could cause offence.

By way of contrast to your comment, I am in my early sixties and had a golliwog as a child which I absolutely loved. We as a household were absolutely unaware of any negative connotations, it was one of a small number of much loved toys. This was not unusual at the time, Robertson's jam had the golly as a symbol and the badges and figurines you could save up labels and send away for were very much coveted and liked.

As a previous poster said, times change. I seriously doubt any malign intent or wish to offend on his part, especially if he was warm and welcoming. Perhaps, gently, this might help to guide your response?

Good luck, it is a wonderful thing as a parent to give your child the gift of music, it is one I have cherished all my life.

SoundTheSirens · 22/01/2024 21:05

The comparison is not really appropriate as wiki is not biased.

Wikipedia absolutely is biased, on a variety of subjects.

ZeldaFighter · 22/01/2024 21:10

I think this is a really hard situation and I'm really sorry that you've been put in it. I'm late 40s and my DH's nan gave us a fabric gollywog as a present for our son "because my DH loved his!" (DH said later he did love it initially but not once he knew what it signified!) We thanked her and binned it ASAP. She is a lovely kind old lady who never realised the implications.

So it's possible the music teacher isn't racist but unaware or even forgetful that they're there. Perhaps they're on a par to angels and fairies, like in the other cupboards?

I genuinely don't know what advice to offer. Ignore it for the sake of a good teacher is a good choice. Refuse to ignore it and go elsewhere is also a good choice. I'm just sorry that you've been put in this situation and I hope you can find a positive resolution.

Josette77 · 22/01/2024 21:22

MN really is a safe place for racists.

If someone doesn't want to be seen as racist, they shouldn't have racists things. It's simple.

OP if anything this should be a reminder for all of us how much racism still exists.

DeeCeeCherry · 22/01/2024 21:38

Once upon a time...

I cannot believe people are this gullible.

Then again its MN.

FishSpice · 22/01/2024 21:42

DeeCeeCherry · 22/01/2024 21:38

Once upon a time...

I cannot believe people are this gullible.

Then again its MN.

I asked my 19y son about this thread. His first comment was, ‘are you sure it’s true?’
Anyway he said he wouldn’t go back to a teacher displaying racist memorabilia. There is hope for the next generation.

graceinspace999 · 22/01/2024 21:42

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/01/2024 19:53

They were literally designed as a caricature of black people. That is the origin of them.

The idea that they are a racist sterotype isn't just an idea that got invented in the last few years.

I know that. I have read the history of them.

Thanks… but I’m merely pointing out my child’s eye view of them and if you check again you’ll see that nowhere did I say they weren’t racist.

Having said that I maintain that in no way do these horrible creations resemble black people.

In the same way I don’t think Leprechauns resemble Irish People but I understand the racist connotations.

Josette77 · 22/01/2024 21:44

DeeCeeCherry · 22/01/2024 21:38

Once upon a time...

I cannot believe people are this gullible.

Then again its MN.

You are assuming this is made up? Why?

The amount of racism in this thread should make it clear how common these scenarios are.

Mirabai · 22/01/2024 21:45

A leprechaun is a fairy of course a doll version doesn’t represent Irish people! Ifs not based on a derogatory caricature.

graceinspace999 · 22/01/2024 21:52

skatermom · 22/01/2024 16:25

Thank you for your continued replies. Someone said I was making a fuss over nothing. It's trying not to make a fuss that brought me here and it's obvious it wasn't over nothing at all.

I've been thinking about speaking with him on phone and gently broaching the subject. He may apologize profusely and say he's had them since he was a boy etc and he'll get rid of them OR he may ignore me completely thinking 'here we go, a trouble maker'. In either case, as many others have said, it is a conscious choice whether or not to display them because everyone seems to know about their place in society which is out of sight.

I guess the dilemma would been whether to have him as my son's teacher or not if he were to take them away. I myself can 'bracket' the experience and pretend it never happened. But is he secretly resentful of my feelings? Also, he may then have music that may be unsuitable in the same way seeing he is blind to these things. How would I police that? Where does it end? I really wish this never happened.

Thanks again.

I can see the thought and care you have put into your decision.
Maybe the discussion here has made it worse for you? I hope not.
All I can say is that my impression of you based on your posts is that whatever decision you make will be the right one for you and your son.

P.S. Any decisions you make are also easily reversible - good luck!

graceinspace999 · 22/01/2024 22:01

SoundTheSirens · 22/01/2024 20:05

Deep down I can’t help but think that implying that these Golliwogs look anything like black people is in itself offensive.

Do you know anything about the history of the golliwog? They were literally designed to be an ugly caricature of black people. To acknowledge that isn’t to make some “offensive” leap of thought for the first time, it’s just being aware of the genesis of the doll, and to explain why it’s sickening that they’re still excused as “just a funny toy from my childhood”.

I said the opposite. I said they were scary not ‘a funny toy’ at all.

graceinspace999 · 22/01/2024 22:04

Mirabai · 22/01/2024 21:45

A leprechaun is a fairy of course a doll version doesn’t represent Irish people! Ifs not based on a derogatory caricature.

If I said the same as this about Golliwogs you would tell me to educate myself .

Google will tell you how the Leprechaun caricature has been used to depict the Irish as evil, small, drunk and brainless and comparable to rats and cockroaches- look it up.

Fabricwitch · 22/01/2024 22:24

My initial reaction would be that you shouldn't let your son go back to him, but I'm not black.
A black friend once said to me that she can't get upset every time she experiences something racist because it would just be constant, which is awful, but why should your child miss out on the best education he can get because of a racist? Would it be possible, and would you be happier, if the teacher came to your house instead?
I really feel for you in this situation, there isn't any right answer or easy solution, but I think whatever you decide is best for your son it will work out because you obviously care about him very much and are making this decision with him.

Mirabai · 22/01/2024 22:34

graceinspace999 · 22/01/2024 22:04

If I said the same as this about Golliwogs you would tell me to educate myself .

Google will tell you how the Leprechaun caricature has been used to depict the Irish as evil, small, drunk and brainless and comparable to rats and cockroaches- look it up.

I see what you were getting at. There’s two different factors here. One is that a leprechaun is a supernatural being in Irish folk myth “lughchromain”; the other is that the word leprechaun can be used derogatively of Irish people and the image subverted to represent a horrible caricature of an Irish person.

However my point was that unlike a golly which was based on a caricature and cannot be otherwise, a leprechaun is not of itself intrinsically a negative image.

catsoop · 22/01/2024 22:38

FishSpice · 22/01/2024 21:42

I asked my 19y son about this thread. His first comment was, ‘are you sure it’s true?’
Anyway he said he wouldn’t go back to a teacher displaying racist memorabilia. There is hope for the next generation.

"racist memorabilia" 😂

DeeCeeCherry · 22/01/2024 22:45

Josette77
You are assuming this is made up? Why?
The amount of racism in this thread should make it clear how common these scenarios are

The over-descriptive, ponderous nature of the opening post that very neatly ticks all the 'lets bring all the racists/racism deniers out' boxes.

But mostly, the OP sounding about as Black as Dolly Parton. I'm very aware not all Black people sound the same. But there 100% are variable nuances - of course those nuances aren't present at all here. They wouldn't be.

It's always obvious. & by far it wouldn't be the 1st time on MN.

As an aside this subject has been done to absolute death over the years as simply putting 'Mumsnet Golliwog' in Google search will show. I give it a month max before the next flowery story about golliwogs to bring the bigots to the yard

Mirabai · 22/01/2024 23:00

Good Lord, how does a person “sound black“? 😮

Josette77 · 22/01/2024 23:01

DeeCeeCherry · 22/01/2024 22:45

Josette77
You are assuming this is made up? Why?
The amount of racism in this thread should make it clear how common these scenarios are

The over-descriptive, ponderous nature of the opening post that very neatly ticks all the 'lets bring all the racists/racism deniers out' boxes.

But mostly, the OP sounding about as Black as Dolly Parton. I'm very aware not all Black people sound the same. But there 100% are variable nuances - of course those nuances aren't present at all here. They wouldn't be.

It's always obvious. & by far it wouldn't be the 1st time on MN.

As an aside this subject has been done to absolute death over the years as simply putting 'Mumsnet Golliwog' in Google search will show. I give it a month max before the next flowery story about golliwogs to bring the bigots to the yard

Can you tell me how a black person would write this?

Josette77 · 22/01/2024 23:02

Although I'm also curious why it's an issue if any posts expose racists and bigots? Isn't it a good thing people get exposed for racist views?

Swipe left for the next trending thread