Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this be an absolute NO for you? Golliwog encounter.

995 replies

skatermom · 20/01/2024 16:13

We've recently moved to a new village. Really lovely place, really nice people. We needed a Violin teacher for my DS who is in secondary school. His teacher lives too far away now and we were looking for somewhere that wasn't too far away.

How lucky we were to find a classical string instrument teacher a walking distance from home. I spoke to him over the phone and he sounded lovely. He is in his 50s and teaches lots of children in the area. He also plays the guitar and sings in the choir of the local church. We went to see him in his cottage-like home for an assessment and he took us into his small music room. It was gorgeous! Lovely instruments around, beautiful decor, very old style but really nice. One side had little figurines of angels and fairies, one wall had really old photos of what looked like old relatives from before the 1970s, he had a frame of old miniature trains etc.

I sat on the rocking chair he offered while he talked loads around planning the ABRSM grades and the different classical violinists. I'm not very musical but listened on. Then it was time for my DS to play so I sat back and listened while looking around. I looked towards my left and there was a cabinet with glass dolls and about 25 miniature Golliwog / Gollywog figurines. Now, I should probably say here that I'm black.

I froze from shock and just looked on and pretended not to see them. I'd never seen one in person before! When we finished, we made some follow up arrangements and left with a promise to get back in touch.

The man was so very lovely, seemed so kind and welcoming and encouraging that I don't know whether to be offended!

AIBU to ignore it and just keep taking DS for the lessons? He's the only one at the level we need in a 3mile radius.
What would you do in my shoes?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
PropertyManager · 22/01/2024 19:47

FishSpice · 22/01/2024 19:27

‘In my career as a teacher I have always taught the principle that offence is taken, not given’

You originally just said that people choose to take offence. Which is extremely dismissive when applied to stuff like racism. You did not say anything about letting insults eat somebody up.

So I will ask again, if a black child was offended at being called the N word, is it reasonable for them to take offence in your classroom?

And Was offence ‘given’ by the racist or not?

If I refer back to my original statement

"It is an active choice to be offended, sometimes rightly, sometimes wrongly"

Someone may of course actively seek to hurt or belittle another, in your example the child would be attempting to be offensive, most likely to provoke a reaction. This child of course should be reprimanded.

The other child has the option of what to do with that, they can look down their nose at the foolish and unpleasant child, shrug their shoulders and get on with their day, they can be upset and let it get to them, or if they are sharp enough and have the skill and timing, they can hit back with the witty reposte, then move on, especially useful when others are around.

Now I was taught myself this philosophy by a very inspirational teacher of mine, a black man, who had come to England in the 50's, and seen his share of racism, and taught himself to shake it off, and to disregard those who doled it out - he was a razor sharp wit, on one occasion I saw someone chuck a racist joke at him, attempting to make him the butt of the joke, he turned it around so deftly and smoothly, leaving the instigator crestfallen with a canteen full of kids laughing at him.

BIossomtoes · 22/01/2024 19:47

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/01/2024 19:44

So objecting to racist imagery is only okay if done in a way that is acceptable to you?

It must have taken Olympian level mental gymnastics to come up with that one.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/01/2024 19:48

peakygold · 22/01/2024 14:08

Nazi Germany banned anything golly from 1934 because they were deemed inappropriate for Aryan children. Maybe the music teacher has his reasons for displaying them?

What a load of shite. I know plenty of antifascists, and none of them are displaying racist imagery in their homes just because Hitler happened to object to it too.

graceinspace999 · 22/01/2024 19:48

Just to add. I too saw Golliwogs on jam jars as a child.

I never owned any and disliked them because I thought they were scary.

I never once thought they were supposed to be black people. I thought they were some kind of monster.

I had a beautiful black baby doll and a beautiful white baby doll with a twin pram.

Deep down I can’t help but think that implying that these Golliwogs look anything like black people is in itself offensive.

I hope OP finds a decision she is comfortable with and that her son keeps enjoying music.

I had piano lessons from a blind lady who beat my knuckles with a ruler for not practicing enough. She had nothing on display in her piano room except music books and rulers.
Times have changed thankfully.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/01/2024 19:51

PropertyManager · 22/01/2024 19:47

If I refer back to my original statement

"It is an active choice to be offended, sometimes rightly, sometimes wrongly"

Someone may of course actively seek to hurt or belittle another, in your example the child would be attempting to be offensive, most likely to provoke a reaction. This child of course should be reprimanded.

The other child has the option of what to do with that, they can look down their nose at the foolish and unpleasant child, shrug their shoulders and get on with their day, they can be upset and let it get to them, or if they are sharp enough and have the skill and timing, they can hit back with the witty reposte, then move on, especially useful when others are around.

Now I was taught myself this philosophy by a very inspirational teacher of mine, a black man, who had come to England in the 50's, and seen his share of racism, and taught himself to shake it off, and to disregard those who doled it out - he was a razor sharp wit, on one occasion I saw someone chuck a racist joke at him, attempting to make him the butt of the joke, he turned it around so deftly and smoothly, leaving the instigator crestfallen with a canteen full of kids laughing at him.

Does it not bother you at all that you are shifting 100% of the responsibility for dealing with racism on to the (presumably black) child who is on the receiving end of it? And that you appear to be more critical of a child who doesn't keep calm and produce a witty riposte, and does take offence at being called racist names, than you are of the racist who is taunting them?

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/01/2024 19:53

graceinspace999 · 22/01/2024 19:48

Just to add. I too saw Golliwogs on jam jars as a child.

I never owned any and disliked them because I thought they were scary.

I never once thought they were supposed to be black people. I thought they were some kind of monster.

I had a beautiful black baby doll and a beautiful white baby doll with a twin pram.

Deep down I can’t help but think that implying that these Golliwogs look anything like black people is in itself offensive.

I hope OP finds a decision she is comfortable with and that her son keeps enjoying music.

I had piano lessons from a blind lady who beat my knuckles with a ruler for not practicing enough. She had nothing on display in her piano room except music books and rulers.
Times have changed thankfully.

They were literally designed as a caricature of black people. That is the origin of them.

The idea that they are a racist sterotype isn't just an idea that got invented in the last few years.

FishSpice · 22/01/2024 19:55

PropertyManager · 22/01/2024 19:47

If I refer back to my original statement

"It is an active choice to be offended, sometimes rightly, sometimes wrongly"

Someone may of course actively seek to hurt or belittle another, in your example the child would be attempting to be offensive, most likely to provoke a reaction. This child of course should be reprimanded.

The other child has the option of what to do with that, they can look down their nose at the foolish and unpleasant child, shrug their shoulders and get on with their day, they can be upset and let it get to them, or if they are sharp enough and have the skill and timing, they can hit back with the witty reposte, then move on, especially useful when others are around.

Now I was taught myself this philosophy by a very inspirational teacher of mine, a black man, who had come to England in the 50's, and seen his share of racism, and taught himself to shake it off, and to disregard those who doled it out - he was a razor sharp wit, on one occasion I saw someone chuck a racist joke at him, attempting to make him the butt of the joke, he turned it around so deftly and smoothly, leaving the instigator crestfallen with a canteen full of kids laughing at him.

What a dismissive teacher you are. What about the child who might be insecure, lack confidence, or you know, just be young, and who is unable to shrug it off or come up with a ‘witty reposte’ 🤢What happens to them?

I can just imagine a child approaching you because they’re feeling upset about something someone said, and in order to make your life easier, you come out with your spiel about offence being taken and not given and send the child away with their feelings not being validated. Depressing.

FishSpice · 22/01/2024 19:56

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/01/2024 19:51

Does it not bother you at all that you are shifting 100% of the responsibility for dealing with racism on to the (presumably black) child who is on the receiving end of it? And that you appear to be more critical of a child who doesn't keep calm and produce a witty riposte, and does take offence at being called racist names, than you are of the racist who is taunting them?

Edited

That poster is showing who she is. They walk amongst us. In schools, hospitals etc.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/01/2024 20:02

Basically, the message is- if someone doesn't have a "razor sharp wit" and the ability to wittily turn around a racist remark hurled at them with no warning, well they only have themselves to blame if they are upset by the racism they experience. They need to toughen up and get wittier!

That's it, isn't it?

Shameful.

SoundTheSirens · 22/01/2024 20:05

Deep down I can’t help but think that implying that these Golliwogs look anything like black people is in itself offensive.

Do you know anything about the history of the golliwog? They were literally designed to be an ugly caricature of black people. To acknowledge that isn’t to make some “offensive” leap of thought for the first time, it’s just being aware of the genesis of the doll, and to explain why it’s sickening that they’re still excused as “just a funny toy from my childhood”.

Mirabai · 22/01/2024 20:08

I think @PropertyManager ’s posts are unwittingly an indicator of the problem with the teacher in the OP.

The patronising, cloth-eared minimisation of what these cultural artefacts represent, and the placing of responsibility for any offence on the victim rather than the perpetrator is precisely the kind of thing that a man with a golly cabinet might come out with.

(Using the words of a poc back in the 50s, who would have doubtless had to deal with and downplay horrific racism, to justify that is even more problematic.)

And that’s why OP exposing her kids to the teacher is unwise. We don’t know what his attitude to race but the signs are not good.

FishSpice · 22/01/2024 20:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I am so stupid that I didn’t see this.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/01/2024 20:11

If nothing else it exposes how much blatant racism there is on mumsnet, and how many posters are totally unashamed of their racism.

hattie43 · 22/01/2024 20:13

SoundTheSirens · 22/01/2024 20:05

Deep down I can’t help but think that implying that these Golliwogs look anything like black people is in itself offensive.

Do you know anything about the history of the golliwog? They were literally designed to be an ugly caricature of black people. To acknowledge that isn’t to make some “offensive” leap of thought for the first time, it’s just being aware of the genesis of the doll, and to explain why it’s sickening that they’re still excused as “just a funny toy from my childhood”.

Oh like cabbage patch dolls are a caricature of white people

Cattymonster · 22/01/2024 20:17

I wouldn't go back. (I'm not black, btw.) It's been clear for many years that Golliwogs are offensive to a lot of people, and he must be aware of that. Choosing to display a collection in a place where he gives lessons strikes me as deliberately provocative.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/01/2024 20:17

^ the cabbage patch comment is a case in point

She knows. She gets it. She just doesn't GAF.

Mirabai · 22/01/2024 20:18

SoundTheSirens · 22/01/2024 20:05

Deep down I can’t help but think that implying that these Golliwogs look anything like black people is in itself offensive.

Do you know anything about the history of the golliwog? They were literally designed to be an ugly caricature of black people. To acknowledge that isn’t to make some “offensive” leap of thought for the first time, it’s just being aware of the genesis of the doll, and to explain why it’s sickening that they’re still excused as “just a funny toy from my childhood”.

I agree, and I agree with that poster that as a child instinctively I found them repellent and scary.

In retrospect I think I picked up on the latent aggression in the depiction without understanding it.

That’s why I am somewhat incredulous that so many claim simply not to have noticed!

SoundTheSirens · 22/01/2024 20:21

hattie43 · 22/01/2024 20:13

Oh like cabbage patch dolls are a caricature of white people

I’m honestly cringing for you that you thought that was some kind of smart response.

FishSpice · 22/01/2024 20:22

I am in my 50s and as assertive as they come. I have no problems sticking up for myself or challenging others.

i am not white however and on the relatively few occasions I have had the P word shouted at me it has felt dreadful. I have felt hot and embarrassed and humiliated And uncomfortable in a way I cannot really describe. The idea that I should just brush it off and come up with a witty riposte is just unimaginable. Only somebody stupid, racist or deliberately tone-deaf would come out with that kind of crap.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/01/2024 20:22

I enjoyed watching Rolf's Cartoon Club when I was a kid. But I wouldn't have posters of him in my house now.

And if someone (e.g. a SA survivor) posted that they were triggered by images of him, I wouldn't post to tell them all about how fond I was of him as a child.

Of all these posters waxing lyrical about their fondness and nostalgia for these dolls, very few have gone on to acknowledge that they are no longer consider acceptable. Most have just focused on the enormous amount of fondness they have for them.

CountFucula · 22/01/2024 20:24

Mumsnet have a race problem.
it is really clear every time there’s any discussion around race. Let’s of very questionable views that use either faux naivety or weird comparisons straight from the Daily Mail below the line school of racial commentary. Side order of ‘plain speaking’ and ‘you can’t say anything anymore and it was ok when…’ plus the ageism accusations.

Josette77 · 22/01/2024 20:26

hattie43 · 22/01/2024 20:13

Oh like cabbage patch dolls are a caricature of white people

Lol what? I had a black cabbage patch kid.

Do you think they were racist against white people?

Justpontificating · 22/01/2024 20:31

Just did a simple Google for wiki re the history of golliwogs as I had no idea.
worth a read even though it’s just the basics. ( not part of screen shot)
It seems the saga re them is up for debate constantly.
Heres a screen shot of just a few of them really recently!!

Would this be an absolute NO for you? Golliwog encounter.
FishSpice · 22/01/2024 20:33

I am not white, but I have a white husband and many white friends. They are all non-racist or anti-racist. I am in a bubble. MN really opened my eyes to how many ‘respectable racists’ exist amongst us. I have seen more racist than non-racist views here.

Let us hope the racists here are not raising their children as racists. And that the next generation will challenge their parents and educate them. We can hope.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 22/01/2024 20:38

Wikipedia is just opensource, it's not any kind of authority. The Jim Crow museum states that the image was based on a black minstrel - itself a racist caricature.

jimcrowmuseum.ferris.edu/golliwog/homepage.htm

The Golliwogg was based on a Black minstrel doll that Upton had played with as a small child in New York. The then-nameless "Negro minstrel doll" was treated roughly by the Upton children. Upton reminiscenced: "Seated upon a flowerpot in the garden, his kindly face was a target for rubber balls..., the game being to knock him over backwards. It pains me now to think of those little rag legs flying ignominiously over his head, yet that was a long time ago, and before he had become a personality.... We knew he was ugly!" (Johnson).

Swipe left for the next trending thread