Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this be an absolute NO for you? Golliwog encounter.

995 replies

skatermom · 20/01/2024 16:13

We've recently moved to a new village. Really lovely place, really nice people. We needed a Violin teacher for my DS who is in secondary school. His teacher lives too far away now and we were looking for somewhere that wasn't too far away.

How lucky we were to find a classical string instrument teacher a walking distance from home. I spoke to him over the phone and he sounded lovely. He is in his 50s and teaches lots of children in the area. He also plays the guitar and sings in the choir of the local church. We went to see him in his cottage-like home for an assessment and he took us into his small music room. It was gorgeous! Lovely instruments around, beautiful decor, very old style but really nice. One side had little figurines of angels and fairies, one wall had really old photos of what looked like old relatives from before the 1970s, he had a frame of old miniature trains etc.

I sat on the rocking chair he offered while he talked loads around planning the ABRSM grades and the different classical violinists. I'm not very musical but listened on. Then it was time for my DS to play so I sat back and listened while looking around. I looked towards my left and there was a cabinet with glass dolls and about 25 miniature Golliwog / Gollywog figurines. Now, I should probably say here that I'm black.

I froze from shock and just looked on and pretended not to see them. I'd never seen one in person before! When we finished, we made some follow up arrangements and left with a promise to get back in touch.

The man was so very lovely, seemed so kind and welcoming and encouraging that I don't know whether to be offended!

AIBU to ignore it and just keep taking DS for the lessons? He's the only one at the level we need in a 3mile radius.
What would you do in my shoes?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
CurlewKate · 26/01/2024 06:46

@Josette77 Indeed. Also, it is very hard to believe that anyone could look at a gollywog and not think "Hmm-that looks a bit dodgy."
Even if they had somehow lived in a bubble for the past 50 years. Which this guy obviously hadn't-what with being a qualified music teacher and all.

TipulophobiaIsReal · 26/01/2024 08:05

Runnerinthenight · 25/01/2024 21:31

That makes so much sense! Great post.

I think there's a part of a lot of us that feels, I don't know, a bit 'tainted' about having had them?

I never liked them anyway so I never had any attachment to them whatsoever, and I have no idea where the ones we had went! I imagine they were thrown out when my parents had their house renovated 40 years ago.

I think too you just really want to get it across that you didn't ever have the things for any racist reason? Because you didn't know at the time it was a thing.

As far as I'm aware, I've never even touched one, so thankfully I've never had to resolve this particular dissonance for myself (the first time I saw one IRL was in a shop in a seaside town a few years ago, and it gave me a jolt TBH).

But my older DP had one as a child, and what you say about feeling almost "tainted" would fit well with his feelings about them — his reaction is something like anger, that as an innocent child he was implicitly and explicitly inculcated with beliefs and attitudes which he now considers unacceptable and wrong, with golliwogs being one manifestation of that. He sees the culture he grew up in as flawed and harmful, and the people he loved as imperfect (as of course they are, just like everyone) with some indefensible views.

I guess there's a lot of ways to resolve the dissonance and he's found his. It's less comfortable than believing that golliwogs are fine and people are just making an unnecessary fuss, but realising that your parents have feet of clay — and more broadly, that not everything you grew up with is perfect, and that you can love people, and think fondly of a time or a culture, while understanding that these things are flawed — is part of being an adult IMO.

I also think that some of the defenders of golliwogs are resolving the dissonance, not by believing that golliwogs aren't racist, but by believing that racism is okay. But because it's not really the done thing to out-and-out say that you think racism is okay, they'll use the golliwogs-aren't-racist tack when arguing.

Ilovecleaning · 26/01/2024 22:54

Itslegitimatesalvage · 20/01/2024 16:18

Someone his age will have them because they were a children’s toy when he was a child. He’ll have probably collected them decades ago, they’ll hold childhood memories and that’s all he sees when he looks at them. Obviously now they have a very different connotation, and they are offensive and really not something to be cherished but some people still do. I’m not going to sit here and tell you that you’re wrong to feel how you feel because you’re not wrong. But I don’t think I’d look at this as the racist violin teacher but rather the nostalgic and rather politically tone death violin teacher. I wouldn’t let it stand in the way.

He’s only in his 50s.

Runnerinthenight · 26/01/2024 23:36

TipulophobiaIsReal · 26/01/2024 08:05

As far as I'm aware, I've never even touched one, so thankfully I've never had to resolve this particular dissonance for myself (the first time I saw one IRL was in a shop in a seaside town a few years ago, and it gave me a jolt TBH).

But my older DP had one as a child, and what you say about feeling almost "tainted" would fit well with his feelings about them — his reaction is something like anger, that as an innocent child he was implicitly and explicitly inculcated with beliefs and attitudes which he now considers unacceptable and wrong, with golliwogs being one manifestation of that. He sees the culture he grew up in as flawed and harmful, and the people he loved as imperfect (as of course they are, just like everyone) with some indefensible views.

I guess there's a lot of ways to resolve the dissonance and he's found his. It's less comfortable than believing that golliwogs are fine and people are just making an unnecessary fuss, but realising that your parents have feet of clay — and more broadly, that not everything you grew up with is perfect, and that you can love people, and think fondly of a time or a culture, while understanding that these things are flawed — is part of being an adult IMO.

I also think that some of the defenders of golliwogs are resolving the dissonance, not by believing that golliwogs aren't racist, but by believing that racism is okay. But because it's not really the done thing to out-and-out say that you think racism is okay, they'll use the golliwogs-aren't-racist tack when arguing.

Edited

The thing is, our parents didn't have a clue either! I can't begin to convey the innocence with which people bought into these things - people literally did not know they were offensive! I don't know how hard it is to understand that!

I can 100% say that my family and my peers were completely unaware of any pejorative connotation!

Your DP's parents did not necessarily have "some indefensible views" - they were literally unaware! I certainly do not blame my parents for my brush with gollies. They did not know anything other than that they were free on Robertson's jam. Give people a break.

Runnerinthenight · 26/01/2024 23:40

Josette77 · 26/01/2024 06:39

When he found out they were racist though he said he would move them, and launched into stories about how special they are to him.

If I found out I had something racist in my home I'd get rid of it.

But would you if there was an emotional family connection?

I don't know. I might keep them and hide them? I don't know, I've never been in that position.

TipulophobiaIsReal · 26/01/2024 23:58

Runnerinthenight · 26/01/2024 23:36

The thing is, our parents didn't have a clue either! I can't begin to convey the innocence with which people bought into these things - people literally did not know they were offensive! I don't know how hard it is to understand that!

I can 100% say that my family and my peers were completely unaware of any pejorative connotation!

Your DP's parents did not necessarily have "some indefensible views" - they were literally unaware! I certainly do not blame my parents for my brush with gollies. They did not know anything other than that they were free on Robertson's jam. Give people a break.

No, they do actually have some (IMO) indefensible views. Or did; one of them has just died.

But WRT golliwogs specifically, the portion of his anger/resentment that's related to that particular objectionable cultural surface is, I believe, somewhat broadly directed — at the whole system from history through society through his own family, because it's impossible to disentangle exactly who's responsible for what, who had what knowledge and views. For him, and also for me when discussing the issue.

I can't say that I completely agree with every aspect of how he might apportion culpability (to his family, his surroundings, himself, his culture, whatever) but I didn't really feel it needed saying again that, fifty years ago, his parents may or may not have had a clue what golliwogs were, their history, why people might find them upsetting, or what harm they might cause. The subject of what people might've thought or known fifty years ago has already been well covered on this thread, and what I wanted to discuss is how this one particular fifty-odd individual that I know has managed the transition from childhood golliwog-cuddler to adult who finds them repugnant. It might not be the healthiest way, or the happiest way, but the subject I wanted to expand upon was how people manage the cognitive dissonance I mentioned earlier, not the opinions of two random adults in 1970 that nobody here gives a shit about.

TipulophobiaIsReal · 27/01/2024 00:08

Or to put it more briefly: my post wasn't about what DP's parents knew in 1970. My post was about DP's feelings about how he was brought up.

Runnerinthenight · 27/01/2024 00:16

TipulophobiaIsReal · 26/01/2024 23:58

No, they do actually have some (IMO) indefensible views. Or did; one of them has just died.

But WRT golliwogs specifically, the portion of his anger/resentment that's related to that particular objectionable cultural surface is, I believe, somewhat broadly directed — at the whole system from history through society through his own family, because it's impossible to disentangle exactly who's responsible for what, who had what knowledge and views. For him, and also for me when discussing the issue.

I can't say that I completely agree with every aspect of how he might apportion culpability (to his family, his surroundings, himself, his culture, whatever) but I didn't really feel it needed saying again that, fifty years ago, his parents may or may not have had a clue what golliwogs were, their history, why people might find them upsetting, or what harm they might cause. The subject of what people might've thought or known fifty years ago has already been well covered on this thread, and what I wanted to discuss is how this one particular fifty-odd individual that I know has managed the transition from childhood golliwog-cuddler to adult who finds them repugnant. It might not be the healthiest way, or the happiest way, but the subject I wanted to expand upon was how people manage the cognitive dissonance I mentioned earlier, not the opinions of two random adults in 1970 that nobody here gives a shit about.

That was your OH's views.

The vast majority of posters here who had gollies DID NOT KNOW that they were considered offensive!!

TipulophobiaIsReal · 27/01/2024 00:41

I've no idea what you personally did or didn't know and when, @Runnerinthenight. At some point you didn't know, and then you did know, and then you found a way to integrate that information into your existing experiences, knowledge and beliefs.

What I was trying to explore is the different ways that people handle it, psychologically and emotionally, when they are told that something they innocently loved, which was probably given to them by someone they loved (who may or may not have perceived the thing in one way or another), is harmful and offensive.

The reason that interests me is that I think that the endless back-and-forth about golliwogs on places like MN may be a direct consequence of this — of how people reconcile (a) their need to feel that they (and often their loved ones and their culture) are basically good with (b) their knowledge that racism is a bad thing and (c) the information that golliwogs are now generally seen as racist and harmful.

Some people do it by insisting golliwogs aren't racist. Some do it by trying to make sure everyone knows that they and their family had no idea. Some do it by rejecting the idea that racism is bad. Some do it by getting angry at whatever societal and cultural forces and beliefs resulted in a golliwog in their arms, and maybe at the people those forces and beliefs were acting through in their lives. Some probably do it some other way.

Threads like this always turn into a showcase for this psychological struggle, more than any active engagement with racism per se, IMO.

CurlewKate · 27/01/2024 09:05

@Runnerinthenight " I can't begin to convey the innocence with which people bought into these things - people literally did not know they were offensive! I don't know how hard it is to understand that!"

Except that some people did. I am old-older than this charmingly naive, sentimental old violin teacher. And I have known since childhood. Which meant my parents must have known. And I refuse to believe they were unique.

But this really isn't about what we knew then. It's about what we know now, and what we do with that knowledge. Moving them to another room is not reacting to the fact that he has objects he knows to be racist in his home. It's reacting to the OP's concern out of kindness or commercial sensibility. As if he had a picture of a spider he considerately moved to another room when he discovered she was scared of spiders.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 27/01/2024 09:38

I think since your update and visiting the man again and speaking up, you may or may not have made him think.

This is a man who obviously doesn’t come across people of colour much and didn’t think about the Golliwogs and if they’ve caused offence. I’m not saying you should educate him at all but bringing this up with him as it affected you will have made him
think. He may continue to display the Golliwogs, he may not. You’re not going to use him as a tutor. But hopefully you’ll have made him think.

Mirabai · 27/01/2024 09:43

Runnerinthenight · 26/01/2024 23:36

The thing is, our parents didn't have a clue either! I can't begin to convey the innocence with which people bought into these things - people literally did not know they were offensive! I don't know how hard it is to understand that!

I can 100% say that my family and my peers were completely unaware of any pejorative connotation!

Your DP's parents did not necessarily have "some indefensible views" - they were literally unaware! I certainly do not blame my parents for my brush with gollies. They did not know anything other than that they were free on Robertson's jam. Give people a break.

The problem with the “didn’t know” line in adults is that they are very obviously black caricatures. It’s more that they thought they were acceptable because there was a lot of it about, rather than they actually thought they couldn’t be offensive.

I’ve heard the same defence of the p, n and w words in the 70s and 80s. “We didn’t know they were offensive”, and even “they weren’t offensive then”. To which I make the same reply as for gollys: they always were you just didn’t realise.

In that position I don’t know if I’d keep insisting “we didn’t know” rather than “we’re wiser now.”

BIossomtoes · 27/01/2024 09:57

The problem with the “didn’t know” line in adults is that they are very obviously black caricatures.

This is patent nonsense. Numerous people have told you quite clearly that they believed them to be mythical creatures like fairies, elves or goblins with no human connection. Many people who were raised outside big cities never even saw a black person throughout their entire childhood.

Mirabai · 27/01/2024 10:02

Runnerinthenight · 26/01/2024 23:40

But would you if there was an emotional family connection?

I don't know. I might keep them and hide them? I don't know, I've never been in that position.

How emotional can you be about jam figurines that might cause offence?

Mirabai · 27/01/2024 10:05

BIossomtoes · 27/01/2024 09:57

The problem with the “didn’t know” line in adults is that they are very obviously black caricatures.

This is patent nonsense. Numerous people have told you quite clearly that they believed them to be mythical creatures like fairies, elves or goblins with no human connection. Many people who were raised outside big cities never even saw a black person throughout their entire childhood.

How stupid do you think people are exactly? Adults looked at images of minstrels and thought they were an elf? Even if you lived in a white area, there were minstrels and black people on TV and many people were into jazz, soul, rock and roll music. They know what black people look like.

CountFucula · 27/01/2024 10:12

BIossomtoes · 27/01/2024 09:57

The problem with the “didn’t know” line in adults is that they are very obviously black caricatures.

This is patent nonsense. Numerous people have told you quite clearly that they believed them to be mythical creatures like fairies, elves or goblins with no human connection. Many people who were raised outside big cities never even saw a black person throughout their entire childhood.

Yes. Some people without eyes have also never seen a black person in a film, tv show, picture book or anything!

Clarinet506 · 27/01/2024 10:14

Some amazing posts today.

@Mirabai The problem with the “didn’t know” line in adults is that they are very obviously black caricatures. It’s more that they thought they were acceptable because there was a lot of it about, rather than they actually thought they couldn’t be offensive.

  • YES. This is totally it. Even my white grandparents had a golliwog. They were blatantly on the jam jars. It wasn't so much that they didn't know the racist connotations, but that those views were totally accepted and settled. It was probably seen as stating the obvious. The 70s were only a stone's throw in time away from signs on the door saying 'No dogs, no Irish, no blacks'. I'm not sure that most posters, who were probably little tots in the 70s, if they were alive at all, understand the extent of the deeply ingrained racism of that time. Some of the dissonance probably results from the horror of this. And people who gave golliwogs house room might even have been rebelling against prevailing views by embracing the creatures as lovable. (Admittedly that's a stretch.)

@TipulophobiaIsReal, what a fantastic post.
What I was trying to explore is the different ways that people handle it, psychologically and emotionally, when they are told that something they innocently loved, which was probably given to them by someone they loved (who may or may not have perceived the thing in one way or another), is harmful and offensive.

The reason that interests me is that I think that the endless back-and-forth about golliwogs on places like MN may be a direct consequence of this — of how people reconcile (a) their need to feel that they (and often their loved ones and their culture) are basically good with (b) their knowledge that racism is a bad thing and (c) the information that golliwogs are now generally seen as racist and harmful.

Some people do it by insisting golliwogs aren't racist. Some do it by trying to make sure everyone knows that they and their family had no idea. Some do it by rejecting the idea that racism is bad. Some do it by getting angry at whatever societal and cultural forces and beliefs resulted in a golliwog in their arms, and maybe at the people those forces and beliefs were acting through in their lives. Some probably do it some other way.

Threads like this always turn into a showcase for this psychological struggle, more than any active engagement with racism per se, IMO

The psychological aspect of all this is fascinating. There's a PhD in this for someone if it hasn't already been done. The showcase you mention, @TipulophobiaIsReal, blows my mind! That's exactly what this is. And to those of you defending golliwogs, I don't mean to denigrate you at all by underlining this, I mean it more as a collective feature of human beings. We're all bringing our psychological wares to this thread and laying them out for display - I'm doing that too.

Mirabai · 27/01/2024 10:19

many people were into jazz, soul, rock and roll music

My point being that I think @Blossomtoes is older than I am - even back into the 50s there were always black music stars - the earliest rock and roll singers were black - Chuck Berry, Lil Richard etc before it became a predominantly white genre as well as the jazz and soul greats.

AnnaMagnani · 27/01/2024 10:29

Even back in the 50s...

My DM grew up in a very white country with no history of immigration. Even then, her mother took all the kids to see Josephine Baker so they were aware of black people.

Josephine Baker would have been in her 60s by then. So famous black people totally not a new thing.

TempleOfBloom · 27/01/2024 10:37

Racism is complex. It runs deep. It can spread and pop up like Japanese Knotweed when we thought we had eradicated it from within ourselves.

I have no other position than golliwogs are offensive. In their imagery They are a grotesque mockery of black people.

I was brought up by a white mother who marched down to primary school demanding that the reading books my brother brought home be removed from the shelves: Little Black Sambo. We weren’t allowed to watch the B&W Minstrel Show , or On The Buses or any other shows identified as racist.

And yet we collected the dratted marmalade tokens. When I was a student I was an active member of Rock Against Racism… and at the same time sending off for fucking golly brooches.

Such massive dissonance.

And I think it was because I felt positive about the little characters. I didn’t have any negative feelings about black people or associate them with wanting to mock actual black people. Racist context aside, The brooches had a certain retro charm in design. The characters looked appealing. And maybe I somehow thought I was ‘allowed’ to have them because ‘it’s alright I’m not a racist’.

Also, marketing. The ‘collectible’ pull is very strong, something free, and at that time we had a lot less tat and stuff available to us.

I am not defending myself, it was indefensible. And of course one day I thought ‘whatever I feel about these little brooches they ARE offensive about other people’. And that was that. My critical analytical thought was raised.

And that’s a lifelong process.

We do need to look at how we receive, react, decide, and to reflect.

CurlewKate · 27/01/2024 11:14

@BIossomtoes " Numerous people have told you quite clearly that they believed them to be mythical creatures like fairies, elves or goblins with no human connection"

And when they got to the age of about 10 or 11? What did they think then?

MoonWoman69 · 27/01/2024 11:52

TempleOfBloom · 27/01/2024 10:37

Racism is complex. It runs deep. It can spread and pop up like Japanese Knotweed when we thought we had eradicated it from within ourselves.

I have no other position than golliwogs are offensive. In their imagery They are a grotesque mockery of black people.

I was brought up by a white mother who marched down to primary school demanding that the reading books my brother brought home be removed from the shelves: Little Black Sambo. We weren’t allowed to watch the B&W Minstrel Show , or On The Buses or any other shows identified as racist.

And yet we collected the dratted marmalade tokens. When I was a student I was an active member of Rock Against Racism… and at the same time sending off for fucking golly brooches.

Such massive dissonance.

And I think it was because I felt positive about the little characters. I didn’t have any negative feelings about black people or associate them with wanting to mock actual black people. Racist context aside, The brooches had a certain retro charm in design. The characters looked appealing. And maybe I somehow thought I was ‘allowed’ to have them because ‘it’s alright I’m not a racist’.

Also, marketing. The ‘collectible’ pull is very strong, something free, and at that time we had a lot less tat and stuff available to us.

I am not defending myself, it was indefensible. And of course one day I thought ‘whatever I feel about these little brooches they ARE offensive about other people’. And that was that. My critical analytical thought was raised.

And that’s a lifelong process.

We do need to look at how we receive, react, decide, and to reflect.

Superb post, thank you! That is exactly my feeling too!

Anonymouseposter · 27/01/2024 12:37

I’m over 70 now and I understand that golliwogs are offensive and I wouldn’t have them in my house. As a child I had a golly and I also had a rag doll with orange plaits, freckles and seen on pink felt cheeks. I knew in some sense that they were both some sort of stereotype and not like dolls that looked like real babies. I thought they were both loveable toys, I didn’t realise that the golly had anything negative associated with it and I don’t think my parents did either. I also collected the jam jar stickers and sent off for the badges, you could collect them doing different sports. This was over 55 years ago. Times change and as soon as it’s clear that something is offensive and upsetting it’s time to get rid of it. I don’t think the music teacher is necessarily racist but I hope OP has made him think and he has removed them. I do have a cast iron money box from around 1910 which belonged to my grandmother. It’s racist and unfortunately the only thing of hers I have. I would never display it . It’s in a wardrobe. Perhaps I should bin it. I know my children will.

BIossomtoes · 27/01/2024 15:32

CurlewKate · 27/01/2024 11:14

@BIossomtoes " Numerous people have told you quite clearly that they believed them to be mythical creatures like fairies, elves or goblins with no human connection"

And when they got to the age of about 10 or 11? What did they think then?

The same thing I imagine. Do adults reading fantasy fiction like
Lord of the Rings think all the mythical creatures therein are caricatures of humans?

Josette77 · 27/01/2024 15:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.