Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not buying everything DH wants for Xmas/Birthday

109 replies

AviAnn · 27/11/2023 23:10

DH turns 40 on the 23rd of Dec, then Christmas two days after. Usually we don't do big gifts maybe £100 max.
I'll also say DH has a bad habit of seeing something someone else has and getting obsessed with it and wanting it himself.
For Christmas DH was always going to get a new laptop, he's loyal to apple eco-system so we were thinking a MacBook Pro, this is easily £2000+.
On Friday he had to stop by a colleagues house on his way home (she left her laptop and needed it to work from home the next day). He saw her WFH setup and now wants 1000s worth of equipment.
Including

  • Standing Desk
  • Herman Miller Desk Chair
  • Walking Pad
  • Ultra Wide Screen monitor (£1000+ for the one he wants)
  • A mic and webcam
  • Speaker

He works in accounting and finance - basically lives on excel. He has a desk and chair and perfectly good monitor. Doesn't take many meetings and when he does just uses his phone as webcam. His colleague that he wants to copy also does graphic design on the side so I see why she needs this.
Also he doesn't have an office (only works from home 2 days a week), he has a corner in the living room (thought apparently that doesn't matter as his colleague doesn't have an office either (also childless and lives alone so no kids to run into expensive equipment).
We never do spends this big without consulting the other and usually I never say no. But this could easily be £5000 by the end?!!

He thinks it's a worthy investment and it's his big birthday - however I don't think the walking pad or standing function of the desk will be used past the end of January.

I feel awful but I'm not sure I can justify this type of spending. The money exists in our savings but it's no small amount and not something we can spend care free.

AIBU to think we can't justify this sort of expense even for a big birthday?

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 27/11/2023 23:14

Why would these things be gifts though? Can’t he save up his own money if he wants them?

AviAnn · 27/11/2023 23:17

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 27/11/2023 23:14

Why would these things be gifts though? Can’t he save up his own money if he wants them?

It's a big purchase and we don't have "his" and "my" money it's our money and goes into one saving pot.
We don't have enough money to just throw £5000 away and never will have. The savings we have are for everything holidays, cars etc.

OP posts:
Boomboom22 · 27/11/2023 23:19

No way. 2k already for the laptop is 10x your normal bday and Xmas present combined so point that out and stick to the fancy laptop only.

CobbldyCook · 27/11/2023 23:21

Utterly incomprehensible that you would even consider this. Your joint money suddenly becomes his stuff. In what world would that make sense?!

DNLove · 27/11/2023 23:22

He's being a big bloody baby. Who in their right mind asks for stuff like that for birthday/Christmas. If he works from home 2 days a week in a home with no spare room to use as an office he's doing well to have a desk and chair. You can be sure he doesn't have pricey shit like that in his office.
His laptop will have a mic, camera and speaker. He doesn't need more. Walking pad is a complete load of shit, let's see him click into his excel grid when he's walking and trying to move the mouse. I've worked from home everyday from covid to now with a laptop and a power cable. The only thing I could see him using is a wide screen but certainly doesn't need to be £1,000.
Everything he looking for is the price of a good family holiday and he's willing to sacrifice that for work stuff.
I'd understand more if he said he wanted a £5k watch for his 40th, not office equipment.

user1473878824 · 27/11/2023 23:24

I want an entity ring and a mulberry Alexa. I didn’t get a birthday present because money was tight. The money will be there in the next few months when our anniversary will be. I still won’t expect those things because I’m an adult and we have other things that money is for.

Whataretheodds · 27/11/2023 23:24

Of course that would be madness.

Can he look into borrowing or hiring for a trial period (a couple of months?) to see if he would actually use it?

user1473878824 · 27/11/2023 23:25

And I’d use both those things more than your husband would use his!

Cloudisi · 27/11/2023 23:26

"it's my big birthday" ick

ACynicalDad · 27/11/2023 23:26

Hell no, but you can get standing desks and Herman Miller chairs quite cheaply from office clearance places. I've been homeworking since the start of the pandemic and get bits one at a time when cash is ok, and nothing like the level he is on. If he needs it for work then get him to ask his work to pay.

Blessedbethefruitz · 27/11/2023 23:30

My dp has his birthday between Xmas and New years - we have the same rough £100 budget, and he's also in finance/accounts 🤔 He couldn't do without a second screen for excel, but these are dirt cheap; and obviously a laptop - his work provides both.

A webcam and mic are necessary these days if you wfh - but the ones on a laptop are fine! What is your dp computing on?

I wfh full time, with just a laptop, for reference. I like to roam about. I'm an editor and do a lot of indesign work, but manage fine with no office/workspace. Has suited me since 2016.

On the budget front - your dp is a CF. I've asked for heelys and baileys for Christmas (well under our budget). Your dp can find some overtime/freelance if he wants to fund himself a mega office setup!

flowerchild2000 · 27/11/2023 23:33

I'm a lot like your DH, but I try to find the less expensive version without overdoing it on performance. Most people won't utilize the extra features of a Macbook Pro for instance. I have one and I feel silly because it's way more than I need. I would look at the specs and get what is actually needed and it more than that. There's no way a Pro will be fully utilized just running excel. A full system like he wants is doable on a much smaller budget. The old monitor will be fine, along with a cheaper laptop, non-brand chair, etc. Why does he want an expensive chair if he has a standing desk? Get a cheap chair and a cushion instead. I think it's a bit childish to insist on everything being branded, new and shiny. He needs to mitigate his expectations. I'm a big giver but I also love getting the best deal, and I would feel bad giving less than expected, so hopefully he doesn't throw a tantrum or pout over it.

flowerchild2000 · 27/11/2023 23:35

Webcams and mics are cheap as well! There's always a cheaper but still quality version of any electronics. It just takes some time to read reviews and looking over the specs.

Hibiscrubbed · 27/11/2023 23:51
  • Standing Desk
  • Herman Miller Desk Chair

Why does he need the fancy chair if he wants a standing desk?

He's like a greedy child wanting someone else’s toys…

SashaBIu · 27/11/2023 23:53

I dont see an issue with him wanting whatever he wants....if money was no object. But if you don't have free money sat around then he is being ridiculous.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 28/11/2023 00:06

I'd just ignore and get him what you'd planned for £100. It would be financially irresponsible to spend £5000 of your joint savings on such unnecessary things. He's on another planet. Sure make it special, a nice cake, maybe even a blowy 😝 but he can jog on with his other copycat wants.

Daisybuttercup12345 · 28/11/2023 00:48

How old is he? SIX?
He needs to act his age and not his shoe size.
This would really irritate me. He doesn't need an expensive present for his big boy birthday.He can finance it himself!!!!

Gymnopedie · 28/11/2023 01:26

It's a big purchase and we don't have "his" and "my" money it's our money and goes into one saving pot.
We don't have enough money to just throw £5000 away and never will have.

Which means you'll never get to spend anything like that much on yourself. Is that a pattern, he gets to spend while you make do? What else has he splashed out on - monkey see, monkey want? It sounds a very unattractive trait.

Tell him he'll get the MacBook Pro and think himself extremely lucky. Then invent something you'd like at around the same price and tell him you want that.

avenue1 · 28/11/2023 01:37

Hmmmm, it depends... when is your big birthday?! How would he feel about you expecting £5000 of gifts?

NumberTheory · 28/11/2023 01:40

My DH works from home 5 days a week, so it’s a bit different, but a good set up that cost thousands has made a huge difference to him. If your DH is likely to continue working from home for years, even if it’s not full time, some decent investment in his work set up is not unreasonable.

But I also see the issues with the standing desk and walking pad probably being novelties and with such a large expense in one go and without to really consider what would work well for him rather than being driven by envy for someone else’s set up.

How about taking the stance that it shouldn’t be a birthday present. That you should consider some reasonable investment over time because it’s his work environment, not because it’s his birthday, and maybe you should start with one item from his list (I would go with the widescreen monitor unless his desk or chair are falling to pieces) and put a bit of money away each month for further investments? That should make it more manageable and give time for him to reassess the desire for things like a walking pad.

From a more mercenary perspective that may be a poor plan. When do you turn 40? Will there be 5k of savings to spend on you then? What would you want to do with 5k that’s just for you?

LaurieStrode · 28/11/2023 01:40

CobbldyCook · 27/11/2023 23:21

Utterly incomprehensible that you would even consider this. Your joint money suddenly becomes his stuff. In what world would that make sense?!

Exactly.
God, he sounds like a toddler. Serious ick.

RantyAnty · 28/11/2023 01:47

He's acting like a greedy child.

Would you get to spend £5000 on yourself just for you?

QueenBitch666 · 28/11/2023 01:49

Grabbing cheeky fucker

saffronsoup · 28/11/2023 01:50

Do you have an engagement ring? How much did it cost? Was there a precedent set of expensive gifts for one party that are wanted but not necessary for life?

saffronsoup · 28/11/2023 02:11

I would also bet money that there are women on this thread who have spent family money on their office set up or had family money spent on gifts from their spouse worth more than 100. The idea that no one should ever have more than the bare basics and that anything more makes someone a choosy fucker and an immature asshole…there are a lot of hypocrites on here.