Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not buying everything DH wants for Xmas/Birthday

109 replies

AviAnn · 27/11/2023 23:10

DH turns 40 on the 23rd of Dec, then Christmas two days after. Usually we don't do big gifts maybe £100 max.
I'll also say DH has a bad habit of seeing something someone else has and getting obsessed with it and wanting it himself.
For Christmas DH was always going to get a new laptop, he's loyal to apple eco-system so we were thinking a MacBook Pro, this is easily £2000+.
On Friday he had to stop by a colleagues house on his way home (she left her laptop and needed it to work from home the next day). He saw her WFH setup and now wants 1000s worth of equipment.
Including

  • Standing Desk
  • Herman Miller Desk Chair
  • Walking Pad
  • Ultra Wide Screen monitor (£1000+ for the one he wants)
  • A mic and webcam
  • Speaker

He works in accounting and finance - basically lives on excel. He has a desk and chair and perfectly good monitor. Doesn't take many meetings and when he does just uses his phone as webcam. His colleague that he wants to copy also does graphic design on the side so I see why she needs this.
Also he doesn't have an office (only works from home 2 days a week), he has a corner in the living room (thought apparently that doesn't matter as his colleague doesn't have an office either (also childless and lives alone so no kids to run into expensive equipment).
We never do spends this big without consulting the other and usually I never say no. But this could easily be £5000 by the end?!!

He thinks it's a worthy investment and it's his big birthday - however I don't think the walking pad or standing function of the desk will be used past the end of January.

I feel awful but I'm not sure I can justify this type of spending. The money exists in our savings but it's no small amount and not something we can spend care free.

AIBU to think we can't justify this sort of expense even for a big birthday?

OP posts:
SwingTheMonkey · 28/11/2023 09:34

amylou8 · 28/11/2023 09:22

The thought of a grown man at his standing desk with his walking pad actually gives me the ick.

Same! What a dickhead! I bet he’s the type that keeps his phone in a little pouch attached to his belt too…

ellie09 · 28/11/2023 09:44

There are lots of things I want - a new desktop computer, desk, bedroom decorated, new mattress, a nice diamond ring.

Do I expect it? Absolutely not.

Even on a big birthday, which was my 30th last year, my mum spent £300 on a cheap holiday (I brought my own spending money as well) and my partner spent around £150 splitting a night away. Overall I got about £500 worth of gifts from family and friends which I think in a huge amount.

I could never even justify buying a 2k laptop for someone's birthday, regardless of the milestone it is.

In perspevtive, I recently booked a week all inclusive holiday for me, my partner and son and it cost under £2k.

Quisquam · 28/11/2023 09:50

I know all work places are different - but I’ve never heard of a place where employees are expecting to provide their own laptops, webcams etc.

ITA - unless he is a subcontractor, why doesn’t his employer provide his laptop, and other equipment he needs for work? Anything else is just his “want”, not a “need”!

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 28/11/2023 10:18

Words almost fail me!

Have you explained to what sounds like a thoroughly spoilt man-child that very sadly, you don’t have a magic money tree and all that cash might be wanted for something else?

I’m almost reminded of 3 yo Gdd having to have it gently explained that Father Christmas wasn’t allowed to bring real babies - it’d be too cold on the sleigh and he couldn’t be sure that people would know how to look after them.

Stompythedinosaur · 28/11/2023 10:24

Well, of course if it is outside the family budget then it's perfectly reasonable not to get them.

But I wouldn't necessarily consider work equipment to be gifts. I think using a phone as a webcam isn't an ideal situation professionally, and having a better set up than that is pretty reasonable.

If you can afford it (or afford some if it) I generally see investment in some work things (be it equipment, work clothes etc) to be an investment in our careers.

Mystero · 28/11/2023 10:30

I would say that's office equipment and not birthday present material.

If he is employed his work might pay for a sit stand desk - he could try doing a DSE assessment. If he is self employed then I would imagine he could claim back the VAT(?) for any new equipment that is a work expense. For the rest, I actually think it would be reasonable to tot up what he is saving in commuting costs by WFH and allocate some of that to getting his home office area set up to suit him. But it needs to be subject to what works for you as a family in the main living space.

Maybe spending on a studybed to move him out of the main living area would be a better investment!

Either way, it's equipment not a birthday present. Knock it down the road until after Christmas.

Bookkeepermum · 28/11/2023 10:33

I work in accounting and use the standing desk. It's well worth the money for me as I have a spinal deformity so constantly changing from sitting to standing BUT it's not a gift. It's something your husband should be investing in himself. Decent dual screens is money well spent too but again, that's up to him. I would stick to your £100 budget and don't get him anything for work.

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/11/2023 10:34

is he 12?

GreatGateauxsby · 28/11/2023 10:35

We make over £250k as an household, have 6 months of living costs in savings and would not dream of spending this kind of cash.

A recent 40th cost approx £1.5k and we felt this was pretty decadent.

the laptop alone is a very generous want not need.

his ask is profligate in the extreme - I’d have laughed in his face.

does he have ASD/autism/some kind of impulse control issue that explains why he displays this sort of behaviour?

30yearoldvirgin · 28/11/2023 10:39

“DH has a bad habit of seeing something someone else has and getting obsessed with it and wanting it himself.”
Is he 5? What a twat!

frazzledasarock · 28/11/2023 10:42

Do you get £5k to spend on rubbish too?

CurlewKate · 28/11/2023 10:44

I'm afraid I stuck at "we don't do big gifts-£100 max" wtf?

ManateeFair · 28/11/2023 10:49

He doesn't even need the £2,000 Macbook Pro for what he'll be using it for, let alone all the other stuff. He's being absolutely ridiculous. Five grand on a home office set-up that he only uses two days a week as a fucking accountant is ludicrous. If his colleague does graphic design then a Macbook Pro and a massive monitor is indeed useful (although not essential) and I suspect she also uses her set-up as a home entertainment system as well. But your DH is being a complete twat if he thinks it's any way reasonable to spend £5K of your joint savings on this. He's acting like a bratty 13-year-old.

ManateeFair · 28/11/2023 10:50

CurlewKate · 28/11/2023 10:44

I'm afraid I stuck at "we don't do big gifts-£100 max" wtf?

Why? What's the problem with that?

Doone22 · 28/11/2023 10:53

That's mental. For starters any new laptop will have built in webcam and speaker won't it? Not familiar with recent apple products but surely that's the normal. Plus if he wants a standing desk he won't need a chair will he? There's loads of cheaper products you can get to convert to standing desk that are worth looking at. But you know its just a passing fad. You married a toddler. Show him these replies.

pontipinemum · 28/11/2023 10:56

No you don't need to spend 5k on him!

But he should talk to his employer. I WFH and they provided laptop/ screen/ offered to buy me a fancy desk when I was chatting about seeing one (I don't want it)

thatwassociopathic · 28/11/2023 10:59

Must be something about that birth date, my ex is 23/12 too and seemed to think his birthday was the pinnacle of everyone's year and he deserved the earth. He's a complete narc. It seemed to stem from people giving him a joint present as a child for bday/Xmas and he had a real thing about it. Can't just be grateful for what he gets always wants more.

Ginmonkeyagain · 28/11/2023 11:03

Umm - why does he want work equipment for a "big" birthday present. If he is employed his employer should be providing the equiment he needs to do his job (perhaps not to the spec he wants), if he is self employed surely he can put it through as a business expense and not pay VAT.

Behindyouiam · 28/11/2023 11:18

I want a yacht.........

Back in the real world, I won't be getting it.

He must know he is being ridiculous!

DiscoBelle · 28/11/2023 11:23

If you can afford it, buy it.
My husbands birthday is on the same day and I’d buy him whatever he wanted so long as I wouldn’t go into debt for it, especially for a big birthday

Tangled123 · 28/11/2023 12:33

He can’t seriously expect something so expensive if he’s only given a month’s notice, can he? Even if you wanted to get him everything, surely you would still need time to save up and/or spread out the purchases a bit.

There might be ways to make it cheaper though, buy from charity shops or claim some of the cost back from his employer. If his employer doesn’t pay, I think you can still get a tax deduction from the government through your tax code.

G5000 · 28/11/2023 12:33

I have many questions. He works in finance, is he even allowed to use his personal laptop for work?
If he needs a webcam and headset, that should be provided by the employer.
Walking pads can only reasonably be used if you need to listen to a presentation. I really cannot imagine working on excel and walking. And it's REALLY annoying if someone in an online meeting has a walking pad, the person is bobbing up and down like peppa pig, really annoying.

but yes he's like a spoilt child who wants what someone else has.

Lolapusht · 28/11/2023 12:50

saffronsoup · 28/11/2023 01:50

Do you have an engagement ring? How much did it cost? Was there a precedent set of expensive gifts for one party that are wanted but not necessary for life?

Funnily enough, when we got engaged I got some diamonds and DH got a MacBook! He asked why men didn’t get engagement “gifts” to which I didn’t have an answer 💍💻

Laffinalltheway · 28/11/2023 13:05

The employer should be supplying all of this, the standing desk, ergonomic chair etc. if they allow working from home, no?

Laffinalltheway · 28/11/2023 13:06

I know my son's employer (one of the big 4 accountancy firms) gave him, desk, chair, twin screens, camera, laptop, the works...

Swipe left for the next trending thread