Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not buying everything DH wants for Xmas/Birthday

109 replies

AviAnn · 27/11/2023 23:10

DH turns 40 on the 23rd of Dec, then Christmas two days after. Usually we don't do big gifts maybe £100 max.
I'll also say DH has a bad habit of seeing something someone else has and getting obsessed with it and wanting it himself.
For Christmas DH was always going to get a new laptop, he's loyal to apple eco-system so we were thinking a MacBook Pro, this is easily £2000+.
On Friday he had to stop by a colleagues house on his way home (she left her laptop and needed it to work from home the next day). He saw her WFH setup and now wants 1000s worth of equipment.
Including

  • Standing Desk
  • Herman Miller Desk Chair
  • Walking Pad
  • Ultra Wide Screen monitor (£1000+ for the one he wants)
  • A mic and webcam
  • Speaker

He works in accounting and finance - basically lives on excel. He has a desk and chair and perfectly good monitor. Doesn't take many meetings and when he does just uses his phone as webcam. His colleague that he wants to copy also does graphic design on the side so I see why she needs this.
Also he doesn't have an office (only works from home 2 days a week), he has a corner in the living room (thought apparently that doesn't matter as his colleague doesn't have an office either (also childless and lives alone so no kids to run into expensive equipment).
We never do spends this big without consulting the other and usually I never say no. But this could easily be £5000 by the end?!!

He thinks it's a worthy investment and it's his big birthday - however I don't think the walking pad or standing function of the desk will be used past the end of January.

I feel awful but I'm not sure I can justify this type of spending. The money exists in our savings but it's no small amount and not something we can spend care free.

AIBU to think we can't justify this sort of expense even for a big birthday?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Teledeluxe · 29/11/2023 19:00

His employer should provide him with anything that’s essential to work from home

alanet · 29/11/2023 18:31

What's on your £5k list of gifts you want on a whim? Write it and give it to your husband.

haribosmarties · 29/11/2023 16:59

So it's not really a present? It's something he wants to buy using joint money?
In that case I think you are being a bit unreasonable. 40 is a big birthday and you say you do have this money spare.. are your savings for anything specific? If not surely its OK to use some of it for his purchase?
Does he always spend a lot of money? If not and this is a one off thing I think I'd let him do it actually. It's a small fraction of your savings... and it might seem silly to you but its something he wants.
I mean swap it out for a designer handbag or something... I feel like if I were turning 40 and wanted to spend a couple of grand on a designer handbag for myself to mark the special occasion.. and we had 40k savings that we had both contributed to, that weren't for anything specific.. and my husband just said no, because he thought it was a silly purchase.... I'd be pretty pissed off to be honest.

LGB87 · 29/11/2023 14:27

This is why completely joint finances are a rubbish idea. Even if it sounds unreasonable, you’ll never understand what he wants and he’ll never understand something you might want.

I work from home and have very similar set up to what you’re talking about (1k Ultrawide, 2-3k PC etc) and it has made a huge difference to how I work. My partner would never have understood it and probably would have been annoyed if everything was joint, but that’s OK because we both contribute fairly to bills/house costs then do whatever we want with our own remaining.

Lulu123450 · 29/11/2023 13:44

He’s acting really spoilt to be honest, what a waste of savings.

RantyAnty · 29/11/2023 12:11

saffronsoup · 29/11/2023 09:31

No there are some women who don’t hate men. Hard to find on this board but not all of us can only ever call men names.

And many are saying he doesn’t even need and shouldn’t get the expensive laptop. And OP seems to be giving. It very begrudgingly. It isn’t just the engagement ring. How many women on here buy beauty products, have their hair done, have beauty treatments, buy make up, have their nails done, buys shoes, bags and clothes that are beyond the most basic and cheapest options available? Women treat themselves all the time. Yo can look clean, presentable and professional for very cheap yet many women spend far more themselves than the bare minimum. Women get given nice and expensive gifts. Women expect their husbands to think about them and get them nice things. and if a wife wanted to buy a comfortable chair for her home office and her husband said no, we aren’t spending any family money for your comfort, you can use old and basic and cheap things - we will keep all the family money for how I think it should be spent on all of us…people would not agree with him and say she was being a greedy asshole for expecting any family
money to be spent on her.

I just don’t share the misandrist views that he is a man and therefore he deserves nothing and should be grateful to get any gift at all and shouldn’t expect any family money to go to him.

Misandry doesn't exist.

Women do work and earn more than pin money these days.

G5000 · 29/11/2023 12:09

Are you really saying that if a man posted that his wife wanted an upgraded home office for her 40th that would cost in the thousands that the response posts would read that she is a selfish greedy immature asshole

Not necessarily. If OPs DH came and said his back is bothering him and he has researched and tried various options and standing desk really helps - pretty sure OP would have a different reaction. But he seemed perfectly happy with laptop until he sees a friend has something fancy, and now must have the stuff as well. Doesn't sound like a well considered decision.

Kpo58 · 29/11/2023 10:14

Hibiscrubbed · 27/11/2023 23:51

  • Standing Desk
  • Herman Miller Desk Chair

Why does he need the fancy chair if he wants a standing desk?

He's like a greedy child wanting someone else’s toys…

I'm assuming because people with raising desks stand for part of the time and sit for the rest.

However if these are needed for work (ie he gets a bad back), then they should be being supplied by the employer and not by anyone else.

SwingTheMonkey · 29/11/2023 10:03

Are you really saying that if a man posted that his wife wanted an upgraded home office for her 40th that would cost in the thousands that the response posts would read that she is a selfish greedy immature asshole and that he should ditch her and who does she think she is expecting family money to be spent on her and how could he stay with such a loser. You really think that is how these same posters would respond?

Yes. Because the sex of the person is irrelevant. It remains a greedy and immature request, regardless of who has made it. And also, because I’m not a misogynist who thinks all women are the same.

saffronsoup · 29/11/2023 09:54

SwingTheMonkey · 29/11/2023 09:49

Oh behave!

If the husband wanted a comfortable chair for home working, nobody would bat an eyelid! He’s asking for thousands of pounds worth of office equipment. I actually can’t believe an adult would behave like that tbh, it’s so out of the realms of normal to me.

And I’ve not read any of the things you’ve mentioned above. No man hating. Nobody has suggested OP not buy her husband anything. Just not the ridiculous list of extremely expensive items.

Women treat themselves all the time.

This is an absolute load of sexist rubbish. And you may not be a misandrist (and again, be not seen anyone on here that appears to be either) but you’re definitely coming across as a misogynist.

All you have to do is read these boards and you will see women talking about hair appointments or getting a new dress or many things of the like. You will also see posts of women expecting gifts and owning jewelry and even having vacations paid for by their spouses .

Are you really saying that if a man posted that his wife wanted an upgraded home office for her 40th that would cost in the thousands that the response posts would read that she is a selfish greedy immature asshole and that he should ditch her and who does she think she is expecting family money to be spent on her and how could he stay with such a loser. You really think that is how these same posters would respond?

SwingTheMonkey · 29/11/2023 09:49

saffronsoup · 29/11/2023 09:31

No there are some women who don’t hate men. Hard to find on this board but not all of us can only ever call men names.

And many are saying he doesn’t even need and shouldn’t get the expensive laptop. And OP seems to be giving. It very begrudgingly. It isn’t just the engagement ring. How many women on here buy beauty products, have their hair done, have beauty treatments, buy make up, have their nails done, buys shoes, bags and clothes that are beyond the most basic and cheapest options available? Women treat themselves all the time. Yo can look clean, presentable and professional for very cheap yet many women spend far more themselves than the bare minimum. Women get given nice and expensive gifts. Women expect their husbands to think about them and get them nice things. and if a wife wanted to buy a comfortable chair for her home office and her husband said no, we aren’t spending any family money for your comfort, you can use old and basic and cheap things - we will keep all the family money for how I think it should be spent on all of us…people would not agree with him and say she was being a greedy asshole for expecting any family
money to be spent on her.

I just don’t share the misandrist views that he is a man and therefore he deserves nothing and should be grateful to get any gift at all and shouldn’t expect any family money to go to him.

Oh behave!

If the husband wanted a comfortable chair for home working, nobody would bat an eyelid! He’s asking for thousands of pounds worth of office equipment. I actually can’t believe an adult would behave like that tbh, it’s so out of the realms of normal to me.

And I’ve not read any of the things you’ve mentioned above. No man hating. Nobody has suggested OP not buy her husband anything. Just not the ridiculous list of extremely expensive items.

Women treat themselves all the time.

This is an absolute load of sexist rubbish. And you may not be a misandrist (and again, be not seen anyone on here that appears to be either) but you’re definitely coming across as a misogynist.

saffronsoup · 29/11/2023 09:31

SwingTheMonkey · 29/11/2023 09:17

You’ve got a weird obsession with engagement rings. And women behaving hypocritically. Are you a man? Your arguments are utterly bizarre!

My engagement ring was bought prior to having a family (as many others will have been) when our money was free to splash on anything we wanted.

You seem to be completely ignoring the fact that OP is already buying her husband thousands of pounds worth of laptop for a gift, he is now demanding more. That is the only example of greed here.

No there are some women who don’t hate men. Hard to find on this board but not all of us can only ever call men names.

And many are saying he doesn’t even need and shouldn’t get the expensive laptop. And OP seems to be giving. It very begrudgingly. It isn’t just the engagement ring. How many women on here buy beauty products, have their hair done, have beauty treatments, buy make up, have their nails done, buys shoes, bags and clothes that are beyond the most basic and cheapest options available? Women treat themselves all the time. Yo can look clean, presentable and professional for very cheap yet many women spend far more themselves than the bare minimum. Women get given nice and expensive gifts. Women expect their husbands to think about them and get them nice things. and if a wife wanted to buy a comfortable chair for her home office and her husband said no, we aren’t spending any family money for your comfort, you can use old and basic and cheap things - we will keep all the family money for how I think it should be spent on all of us…people would not agree with him and say she was being a greedy asshole for expecting any family
money to be spent on her.

I just don’t share the misandrist views that he is a man and therefore he deserves nothing and should be grateful to get any gift at all and shouldn’t expect any family money to go to him.

SwingTheMonkey · 29/11/2023 09:17

saffronsoup · 29/11/2023 09:05

That is still money that could have been spent on the family and has much less functionality than laptops and work related equipment. You should have been happy with a very cheap ring and accepting expensive gifts when that money could be spent on other things is what makes you a greedy immature awhile.

At the end of the day I dont actually believe that all women on this thread with a home office have only the cheapest of laptops and the most primitive and basic of office furniture and office equipment and that no one has ever sent family money or had family money spent on them for birthday gifts or home offices. Posters are so hypocritical. On one thread they complain their husband only got them some cheap thing for a big birthday and on this thread suddenly no money should be spent for big birthday and doing so makes one a greedy immature asshole.

I do think anyone with anything beyond the most basic of engagement ring - that has no functional value and is money that could do towards so many other things has no leg to stand on in this debate. You can’t say expensive gifts are good for me but not for thee. If OPs ring cost less than £100 then fine, if more then it is hypocritical.

Edited

You’ve got a weird obsession with engagement rings. And women behaving hypocritically. Are you a man? Your arguments are utterly bizarre!

My engagement ring was bought prior to having a family (as many others will have been) when our money was free to splash on anything we wanted.

You seem to be completely ignoring the fact that OP is already buying her husband thousands of pounds worth of laptop for a gift, he is now demanding more. That is the only example of greed here.

saffronsoup · 29/11/2023 09:05

SwingTheMonkey · 29/11/2023 06:46

Sorry, that’s crap.

I’ve got some expensive jewellery and an expensive engagement ring. None of which I asked for or expected. They were given because my husband wanted to buy them and the ‘family pot’ of money was unaffected. We didn’t go without a family holiday because mummy demanded a £5K diamond necklace (I don’t actually have a £5k necklace).

In this instance, the ridiculous demands would decimate the family pot.

The OPs husband was already being bought a £2K laptop. There’s only one immature, greedy asshole here.

That is still money that could have been spent on the family and has much less functionality than laptops and work related equipment. You should have been happy with a very cheap ring and accepting expensive gifts when that money could be spent on other things is what makes you a greedy immature awhile.

At the end of the day I dont actually believe that all women on this thread with a home office have only the cheapest of laptops and the most primitive and basic of office furniture and office equipment and that no one has ever sent family money or had family money spent on them for birthday gifts or home offices. Posters are so hypocritical. On one thread they complain their husband only got them some cheap thing for a big birthday and on this thread suddenly no money should be spent for big birthday and doing so makes one a greedy immature asshole.

I do think anyone with anything beyond the most basic of engagement ring - that has no functional value and is money that could do towards so many other things has no leg to stand on in this debate. You can’t say expensive gifts are good for me but not for thee. If OPs ring cost less than £100 then fine, if more then it is hypocritical.

ZiriForGood · 29/11/2023 08:44

CF to want all of it for one BD.

However, I have, use and need both a good chair and electric standing desks. The standing desk isn't for standing all the day's long, but about a chance to change my position while working .
My chair was second hand and the standing desk from IKEA, so the price was fine for us.

ChocolateCinderToffee · 29/11/2023 08:30

How much did he spend on your last big birthday? Or what’s he planning for your next one, whichever is closer. Tell him you want something that costs £5,000 too. Watch him decide you’re being unreasonable.

Girlmumma1912 · 29/11/2023 08:24

yeah I wouldn’t be buying all that either. Not when he hasn’t expressed an interest in having any of it before seeing it at someone else’s house.
does he even really need a MacBook Pro. The pros are good for graphics/photography etc but for standard use, he’d be fine with a normal MacBook or the MacBook Air! That’ll cut down some significant cost!

Throwaway1234567890000000 · 29/11/2023 07:11

On the flip side, this is tricky because:

  • you have joint money so he can’t just decide to save up and splurge on himself.
  • you don’t say how much relatively you both earn (both full time or he is he contributing significantly more to the pot, or are you?)

I agree he doesn’t need them and he sounds very impulsive (however is he generally like this, will this just be a fad that dies off in a week or 2, never to be mentioned again anyway?) however it’s quite hard to say he can never splurge his own money on something - not necessarily now but never? What if he wanted these things at the expense of a holiday, for example. Surely you both need equal says on the savings, or where you can’t agree, need to agree to split them down the middle.

I know there’s a very strong argument to be made that a holiday benefits the whole family etc (and in our family we would and do always choose hols and stuff for everyone) but at the same time, I also believe that a grown adult has to be able to make their own choices and spend their own money as they see fit - as long as it’s not at the expense of essential bills.

BusyMum47 · 29/11/2023 06:54

I agree with everyone else - he sounds like a selfish, jealous child! I'm not sure I'd have much respect for such a tw@t.

borborygmus1 · 29/11/2023 06:54

If he invested that £5000 in an ISA in a global all cap fund until retirement he would have £18000 based on historic returns or £22000 if put in a pension to a global all cap fund (you get 20% from government if basic rate tax payer). This is all in today's money. Rebel finance school gives a good start in financial education.

SwingTheMonkey · 29/11/2023 06:46

saffronsoup · 28/11/2023 20:37

I wasn’t disagreeing but it also means that every woman who has had her husband pay for expensive jewelry or an expensive vacation or any expensive gift - none of which is also an immature asshole and choosy fucker.

No one needs an expensive engagement ring so I guess at least for women it is easy to spot the immature greedy assholes by a quick look at their hand.

Edited

Sorry, that’s crap.

I’ve got some expensive jewellery and an expensive engagement ring. None of which I asked for or expected. They were given because my husband wanted to buy them and the ‘family pot’ of money was unaffected. We didn’t go without a family holiday because mummy demanded a £5K diamond necklace (I don’t actually have a £5k necklace).

In this instance, the ridiculous demands would decimate the family pot.

The OPs husband was already being bought a £2K laptop. There’s only one immature, greedy asshole here.

saffronsoup · 28/11/2023 20:37

SwingTheMonkey · 28/11/2023 08:58

Reading comprehension is your friend here.

The husband was already expecting a £2K+ laptop for Xmas and birthday. He then changed his mind and wants an office set up worth more than double that, none of which he particularly needs and using funds which will mean the family lose out.

Id say that does make him a ‘choosy fucker and an immature asshole’, actually.

I wasn’t disagreeing but it also means that every woman who has had her husband pay for expensive jewelry or an expensive vacation or any expensive gift - none of which is also an immature asshole and choosy fucker.

No one needs an expensive engagement ring so I guess at least for women it is easy to spot the immature greedy assholes by a quick look at their hand.

MutantBug · 28/11/2023 19:01

Not really directly related to the point but:

Aside from the Herman miller and the laptop, I have this set up and it's cost £700 max. I actually had a Herman miller aeron I got for £200 from an office clearance but it really messed up my neck so I just got an Amazon basic office chair.

Is he picking the expensive versions of everything?!

ChesterAndRaoul · 28/11/2023 18:59

When is your birthday, tell him you'll be expecting the same amount for your birthday...

Allyliz · 28/11/2023 18:09

Birthday gift ..... really !!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread