Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not plate my 10 year old's pizza?

486 replies

Mastmw7g · 17/11/2023 04:05

DH does most of the cooking and tends to cater to DD. I've become concerned that she will not eat when hungry unless he puts food in front of her. He was out and we had pizza. She told me she didn't see her plate. I said to then grab a plate and join me. She said no and went to her room without eating. DH came home and became upset that she hadn't eaten and said I should have put her pizza on a plate for her.

OP posts:
SoySaucePls · 17/11/2023 11:22

So this is really on ongoing poster where the backstory is neglect and abuse?

How sad. That poor girl. It sounds like some kind of trauma response. She’s asking “do you love me enough to get me a plate”.

it’s like a test.

RecycleMePlease · 17/11/2023 11:22

Tonight, DH made a pasta bake. On finishing and getting out of the oven, he yelled out ‘pasta bake’, served only himself and expected anyone else who wanted some to come get theirs.

Thats really depressing.

My kids and I love each other, we're close, normally have dinner together, often hang out and chat/do stuff together, but sometimes, we eat what we want to eat, at the time we want to eat it - we are secure in our love for each other, and the care we have for each other despite that.

This idea of warm plates every meal sitting together I find a bit much. Sometimes we we want that, sometimes we want our own space, and that's fine.

Whodhaveem · 17/11/2023 11:21

I can’t believe some of these replies, OP’s DD is 10 not 2…

We are a foody family, love to cook, present the table nicely, encourage table manners and a positive eating experience but there are also evenings when we are knackered, doing club runs working late, still working, and/or like passing ships in the night where my DC will be left to their own devices…

whether that’s helping theirselves a tin of tomato soup and cheese on toast, noodles of Ive pre cooked a pizza and salad and left in on the side.

Geez, no wonder we are raising a generation of snowflakes with no critical thinking skills…

Mikimoto · 17/11/2023 11:20

HoppingPavlova · 17/11/2023 11:10

This is just bizarre. Just pizza for dinner, no salad (or anything else). No-one lays the table. Presumably cold plates. Children expected to come and put a slice of pizza on a plate and eat it with their hands

Thanks. Best thing ever. Gold.

I have just alerted those of my (now adult) kids who are home tonight to the abuse they suffered as kids, and still do I guess. One literally has tears running down their face and can’t speak. They want to know what other pearls this site contains. Many, I assure them.

Not sure how social services missed our family tbh. Pizza without salad. Plates directly from the cupboard without being warmed up. Latecomers forced to use the empty boxes as plates to save on washing up/dishwasher🤣. Eating pizza with their hands🥺. IN FRONT OF A TV🤯. No love🫣. How they went on to be successful degree educated professionals (as children of successful degree educated professionals), who knew their parents loved them - how? For the love of God, how😱.

I don’t feel I can reveal the extent of abuse that was suffered on taco or fajita nights. Cold plates. Serve yourself the bits you want. There were both hard AND soft taco’s. Does that count?

This abuse has continued into adulthood. Tonight, DH made a pasta bake. On finishing and getting out of the oven, he yelled out ‘pasta bake’, served only himself and expected anyone else who wanted some to come get theirs. He is a bastard. I’m obviously planning on leaving him. And taking (now adult) kids.

Kids are absolutely howling. At 10yo they were well able to whack however many slices of pizza they wanted (albeit without a loving salad - but with garlic bread - bonus surely????), onto a non-warmed plate and eating it, safe in the knowledge we still loved them, without an international incident requiring a website discussion.

oops - someone's overcompensating with a lengthy reply...

followmyflow · 17/11/2023 11:17

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 17/11/2023 11:13

In the thread where the daughter complains about her siblings is she not complaining about them being awake and playing at 8am on a Saturday?

just being awake and playing is not the problem, playing loudly just outside someones room while they are trying to sleep is rude, regardless of what time it is. people have different sleep patterns, through no fault of their own, it's individual to each person's body. getting enough sleep is vitally important for everyone and especially children.

LittleBearPad · 17/11/2023 11:17

Tonight, DH made a pasta bake. On finishing and getting out of the oven, he yelled out ‘pasta bake’, served only himself and expected anyone else who wanted some to come get theirs.

Thats really depressing.

LittleBearPad · 17/11/2023 11:15

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 17/11/2023 11:13

In the thread where the daughter complains about her siblings is she not complaining about them being awake and playing at 8am on a Saturday?

Yes. And?

Who wants to be awake at 8am on a Saturday when they don’t have to be

SaltedPies · 17/11/2023 11:15

Some rough and ready types on here who are missing the point entirely. It really doesn't matter whether you have rough meal time habits, what matters is a hungry girl who has grown up in a 1 bed room flat as a family of five and whose mother posts thread after thread about how crap t sis that the girls' grandmother and father treat her in a loving and kind way. Slap yourself on the shoulder to prove how cool and casual you are but be careful not to cheer on a mother who publicly slags off her dd. Bye.

Elastica23 · 17/11/2023 11:14

DD2 when she was younger was often reluctant to leave something she was enjoying doing to eat, pee or anything else.

A bit later she was diagnosed with ADHD- not sure if this is related but I just wanted to mention it.

Just adding this as it may not be that she is princessy or has an ED but just doesn't find food a big priority. DD2 is a good eater (14 now- 5'10" and ten and a half stone - I don't think it has restricted her growth!) but I have never fussed about her not eating if she isn't hungry. In fact I think that is healthier than the "Clear your plate!" idea.

I think the best thing is not not make eating or not eating a big deal. What I would have done is go to find DD and see what she is up to, and remind her to come and get a plate and pizza.

MyHornCanPierceTheSky · 17/11/2023 11:13

In the thread where the daughter complains about her siblings is she not complaining about them being awake and playing at 8am on a Saturday?

HoppingPavlova · 17/11/2023 11:10

This is just bizarre. Just pizza for dinner, no salad (or anything else). No-one lays the table. Presumably cold plates. Children expected to come and put a slice of pizza on a plate and eat it with their hands

Thanks. Best thing ever. Gold.

I have just alerted those of my (now adult) kids who are home tonight to the abuse they suffered as kids, and still do I guess. One literally has tears running down their face and can’t speak. They want to know what other pearls this site contains. Many, I assure them.

Not sure how social services missed our family tbh. Pizza without salad. Plates directly from the cupboard without being warmed up. Latecomers forced to use the empty boxes as plates to save on washing up/dishwasher🤣. Eating pizza with their hands🥺. IN FRONT OF A TV🤯. No love🫣. How they went on to be successful degree educated professionals (as children of successful degree educated professionals), who knew their parents loved them - how? For the love of God, how😱.

I don’t feel I can reveal the extent of abuse that was suffered on taco or fajita nights. Cold plates. Serve yourself the bits you want. There were both hard AND soft taco’s. Does that count?

This abuse has continued into adulthood. Tonight, DH made a pasta bake. On finishing and getting out of the oven, he yelled out ‘pasta bake’, served only himself and expected anyone else who wanted some to come get theirs. He is a bastard. I’m obviously planning on leaving him. And taking (now adult) kids.

Kids are absolutely howling. At 10yo they were well able to whack however many slices of pizza they wanted (albeit without a loving salad - but with garlic bread - bonus surely????), onto a non-warmed plate and eating it, safe in the knowledge we still loved them, without an international incident requiring a website discussion.

SoySaucePls · 17/11/2023 11:09

saffronsoup · 17/11/2023 05:47

I doubt this is a lack of skill or ability to plate one’s own food.

It sounds like she isn’t intrinsically motivated by hunger to eat. She also clearly isn’t food oriented. She will eat if the food is in front of her with an expectation that she eat but otherwise she doesn’t eat.

I would have this assessed as it could lead to much bigger issues in the coming years.

This OP. It’s a big red flag.

if she’s otherwise competent, helpful and independent then there’s something around food going on.

Does she not like touching it.

Im suspecting some form of AFRID.

What are her eating habits like. Is she picky.

Pizza is a classic beige food which a lot of ASD people are happy eating but there can be a lot of internal rules in her head about how food is presented and how she must consume it.

The fact she’s rather go hungry suggests there’s some sort of rule in her head about how food must be presented before she’ll eat.

You don’t know what those rules are, even she may be unaware of them.

The sensitive scalp is another giveaway about sensory issues.

Im not sure how you probe into this carefully.

Maybe you could just ask her if the plate is very important to her.

Asking her why won’t do much good but ask her about the place and see what importance it holds.

It may be very very important. In a sequence of steps. So it may be early sign of OCD.

Your DH is right that you should get a plate.

But you need help externally as this may grow.

C8H10N4O2 · 17/11/2023 11:08

LAMPS1 · 17/11/2023 06:22

When you are together, are the meals cooked and served nicely and do you sit down together to eat with a positive spirit to make it a lovely social family time?

You say that your dd eats when her DF makes and serves her a meal.
But that you sit down to eat yourself and refuse to serve her meal, telling her to get the pizza herself if she’s hungry. Where is the love in that ?
Then you wonder why she feels unwanted at the meal table and prefers to go upstairs without. Can you see that not setting her a place as if you don’t expect her to eat with you, is dismissive and does nothing to support good family eating routines. It’s not a question of her being lazy.

There are many aspects to nourishing ourselves. As a parent, I would take the lead and do all I could to prepare and serve a meal with love and good will, making it tempting in terms of the ingredients, cooking, presentation and good loving company around a properly laid table.
Make eating together, even if it’s just a pizza snack, a happy, pleasant experience for your daughter. She’s only ten years old.

That isn't what happened. The OP described pizza cooked and sliced in the kitchen ready for everyone to choose their own pieces to take to the table. Not bread and water to take back to her cell whilst the rest are lovingly served a feast.

Three people including the six year old managed to take their food back to the table whilst the 11 year old leaves to go to her room without even asking for a plate.

Honestly people are so desperate to blame the OP here whereas I'm picturing someone more bemused at an 11 year old who won't eat unless food is plated up in front of them. It is a concern if its a regular occurrence.

OP strategically I'd put food on the plate for now but I agree its not normal behaviour and I'd want to get to the bottom of it as well. Does she ever help herself from shared dishes on the table at meal times or is it the same then?

Hibiscrubbed · 17/11/2023 11:07

LittleBearPad · 17/11/2023 10:41

Buffets usually have plates and cutlery available for people to help themselves. Or do you have to get your own?

Regardless it’s fairly evident the OP does the bare minimum practically and emotionally.

The plates were next to the pizza.

PumpkinFence · 17/11/2023 11:02

Mastmw7g · 17/11/2023 05:55

I thought it was insane that she would rather not eat than put forth effort, but let her choose to go to her room. I spent time with her before she went to bed. We didn't talk about food.

Please see my previous post. You’ll be posting back here in 6months that you don’t know why your DD is in hospital with an eating disorder that came out of no where. Please keep her eating and don’t reinforce to her that you want her to not eat, which is the thoughts going round in her head.

SaltedPies · 17/11/2023 11:02

I won't post anymore on this thread as it's nasty. Posters cheering on a mother who has at the very least very questionable parenting skills and worst case scenario is an abusive nasty piece of work.

This thread is full of people jumping in to validate Op's strange and neglectful behaviour and those who don't see the difference between kids serving themselves and a mother picking endlessly on her 10 year old enviously commenting on family who seem to love and support this poor girl.

It's an abuser looking for validation. Yuck.

IncompleteSenten · 17/11/2023 11:01

Why do you feel it is important that she puts food that you have cooked onto a plate herself? Important enough that if she doesn't you would rather she goes without food than do it for her.

I'm not asking that to judge you, it's just that if I understand why it is so important to you I might possibly be able to suggest things. My sons are Nd and so over the last 20+ years I've had to do things very differently. I'm the furthest thing from an expert but I do have a bit of experience dealing with different behaviours.

What is it you are wanting to teach her by this, well, stand off really, wasn't it?

Is it because you feel she lacks this skill and is physically unable to do it? Is it that you want to assert your authority? Is it your husband that you're actually pissed off at because you feel he babies her and you want him to stop and it's really not about the pizza on a plate at all? Etc

PumpkinFence · 17/11/2023 10:59

@Mastmw7g she might be on the edge of an eating disorder. She might think she has to restrict food. In her head she thinks you also think she is fat and you are testing her by leaving her to help herself and she thinks (wrongly) that you want her to not eat and loose weight.
For the love of whatever god you pray to, please keep her eating whatever way that is. I was a similar age when I started restricting and in my head my parents were in on it and wanted me not to eat and I would have seen you not playing me food as testing me and my will power to see if I could not eat.

Your DH is a loving parent; you are being weird about this. However she eats please keep her eating. For a 10 year old to voluntarily leave the room and not eat and say she’s hungry and you don’t provide food is fucking worrying

LittleBearPad · 17/11/2023 10:59

Pancakefam · 17/11/2023 10:56

Well, I've learned a lot from this thread. When I cook I always tell my partner to help himself from the pans of food, so he can choose how much he wants of what. He must think I don't love him. I'll be sure to include love and napkins for all future meals so he doesn't leave me for my abusive ways.

Good. Because your current approach is crap.

SaltedPies · 17/11/2023 10:57

@Hibiscrubbed Maybe that's common in your circles but don't bother projecting.

@Mastmw7g has clearly issues with her 10 year old dd. So much so that the dd is hoping to live with her grandmother.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4930526-to-be-bothered-by-what-mil-said

MIL doesn't live close, but gets a lot of time with the kids when there's no school. I have four kids, but her bond with my 10 year old is just special. DD calls her on the phone a few times a week, and MIL acts like everything she says or does is brilliant. Whereas my son's just wave into the video, say hi and I love you, and then go back to doing what they were doing.

MIL acts like everything she says or does is brilliant.

^OP has an issue with this.

Socks and puppets also come to mind..............

Pancakefam · 17/11/2023 10:56

Well, I've learned a lot from this thread. When I cook I always tell my partner to help himself from the pans of food, so he can choose how much he wants of what. He must think I don't love him. I'll be sure to include love and napkins for all future meals so he doesn't leave me for my abusive ways.

Hibiscrubbed · 17/11/2023 10:55

Maybe she’s fed up with one child being pandered to by the husband?

followmyflow · 17/11/2023 10:55

wow, i remember that thread, i didnt know it was the same person. she doesnt care if her daughter sleeps well, she doesnt care if her daughter eats well. awful.

Hibiscrubbed · 17/11/2023 10:53

SaltedPies · 17/11/2023 10:50

Oh yes the OP is abusive. And some idiotic posters clapping and cheering her on. Disgusting.

What, pray tell, are you smoking reading?!