Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resist 'eviction' by unhinged landlord

92 replies

goodnightspoons · 05/11/2023 21:08

*previously posted on Property, but the situation has evolved into an AIBU...

We’re in the middle of building works and have rented temporary accommodation at a neighbour’s flat.

We have an informal agreement done via WhatsApp (I know, I know..). The owner lives in another country. They mentioned they have long covid / memory problems.

We agreed to stay 4-6 weeks, with the caveat that we may need to extend due to the nature of building works. The flexibility was vital to us, and the owner fully understood and was ok with that.

At 4 weeks she tried to kick us out, giving 5 DAYS notice. We pushed back as our place won’t be inhabitable until the 6 week and 2 day mark absolute minimum (when the flooring is laid) - even then, we’ll have no kitchen. She now wants us gone by 6 weeks (2 days too early for us).

It transpires she’s desperate to sell her place (threat of repossession) and thought she could market it whilst we’re here but has decided it’ll be less hassle with us gone.

During our stay she’s caused endless disruptions, including having the place painted (specially fun with our toddler). She stayed for 6 days - claims we are lodgers, though we were not told of this in advance and assumed we’d have exclusive use of the place. She tried to get US to arrange for estate agents to take pictures and viewings of the place (again - no mention of this in advance).

I feel sorry for her as she’s clearly not well in the head but she’s the one who’s dropped us into this mess.

I think the fairest would be to honour the flexibility of our agreement and let us stay until our kitchen is ready - which would be 7-10 days longer than she wants. I don’t see how that would make a huge difference to her sale but would save us a world of pain. AIBU?

(BTW I don’t want to ‘just’ move to an Airbnb - moving, with a toddler, whilst juggling a job, and overseeing building works is a huge headache in itself. And Airbnb’s are 4x the price)

OP posts:
Fluffypuppy1 · 06/11/2023 09:23

IfIcouldchooseagain · 05/11/2023 23:32

You agreed 4-6 weeks, she asked you to go at 4 weeks and you didn’t, now she’s asking you to go at 6 weeks and you’re refusing?!

Get out of her house! Yes I know you don’t want to. But, and this is important, IT IS NOT YOURS.

You’re the nightmare, not her.

This.

From her pov she’s probably now thinking that you’re going to keep on extending the time you live in her property.

If you’re just waiting for your kitchen to be finished, move back in your own property asap and stop being such a CF.

towriteyoumustlive · 06/11/2023 09:24

goodnightspoons · 06/11/2023 09:14

Thanks for your balanced messages.

Although its been brutal posting on here it’s actually been v helpful to gain perspective. We’ve been so caught up in it we can’t see the wood from the trees. Posting on Property clarified the legal perspective (and since Shelter/council were on our side we felt ‘entitled’), whereas this whole situation is more than legal - its someones life.

You need to be VERY careful here.

If this IS deemed a tenancy, then you become legally obliged to pay rent for 6 MONTHS which is the minimum tenancy term.

So you demanding an extra few days and taking legal action to stay could result in you having to pay rent for 6 months rather than just the 6 weeks you were looking for.

It sounds to me like a short term holiday let style agreement. There was potentially flexibility but that is no longer available.

Personally I'd just find an airBnB for a few extra days and put your belongings in one of the rooms of your house being renovated.

WaltzingWaters · 06/11/2023 09:45

Due to huge renovations taking longer than planned and out temp rental coming to an end , we’re currently living in a house that has no kitchen and no flooring downstairs with a toddler. It’s stressful, yes. But we’re managing by me taking DS out throughout most of the day and we’re of course saving lots of money on not staying in an air bnb. It’s temporary and manageable.

SisterMichaelsHabit · 06/11/2023 09:48

You've already had sound advice on your other thread that you've chosen not to take. You are choosing to leave your poor toddler in this chaotic situation. I don't know what else you want from people.

Myfabby · 06/11/2023 09:58

I think what's particularly horrible about this, is that you are happy to call the LL unhinged, mental,INSANE, unstable when it suits you. When negotiating a subsidized rent, none of those things apparently mattered.

It's just like the thread with the tenant suddenly applying for her LL's property to be listed after enjoying 10 years of subsidized rent because he wants to evict her to do repairs and charge market value rent. All of a sudden, she's a custodian of the heritage and is repulsed by millionaire toffs

I don't know how you can in all good conscience do what you're doing. I really pray she doesn't lose her home.

WillowCraft · 06/11/2023 10:03

She's unreasonable but so are you. The place you saw 10 minutes away at the same rate wouldn't have offered that level of flex either. Most likely you'd have had to stay 6 months and give 1 months notice, leaving after an exact number of months.

Given the extremely good deal you are getting you should have been much more accommodating about estate agents etc.

From her point of view she's done you a favour and is now losing out. She's worried you will end up staying much longer and you are obstructing her sale.

Also quoting shelter etc is disingenuous. That is for people with nowhere else to go, not people with a house they own but a week before they can move in. Unreasonable to waste charity resources on this kind of thing. I hope you give them a decent donation

Caroparo52 · 06/11/2023 10:23

You have no right to remain longer than the owner agreed with you. Tough but you are not her problem. You are responsible for your own problematic situation.
Move out and be a responsible human being. Having no kitchen is not end of the world ffs

Cordeliathecat · 06/11/2023 10:35

Flexibility costs money, especially in London. You are trying to have flexibility on the cheap and it rarely happens. When we had building works done and wanted both flexibility and convenience we went for a fully serviced apartment that we could commit to on a weekly basis that cost us a fortune. Proper short lets are expensive for a reason.

Give the poor woman her house back and accept the fact that trying your luck hasn’t worked out this time.

Ebtsaqt · 06/11/2023 10:56

Yabu

Was it actually parenting choices or was the todfler damaging things?

JamiefromACORN · 06/11/2023 11:17

Hi! I work for ACORN which is a community union for tenants. We may be able to help with this if you drop me a message!

https://www.acorntheunion.org.uk

ACORN || Union for the Community

ACORN, the union in the community.

https://www.acorntheunion.org.uk

femfemlicious · 06/11/2023 11:21

Why not help with the agent stuff. You are
Being really mean.

Cosywintertime · 06/11/2023 11:28

I’m not really sure arguing that she should have picked up the phone if she was a decent person is helping your case. You’ve been given notice. Move out.

femfemlicious · 06/11/2023 11:35

goodnightspoons · 06/11/2023 09:21

It’s easy for posters to say we’re being petty / entitled, etc, but not really consider how her poor handling of the situation has coincided with v stressful building works, and our emotions may have clouded our judgement. I mean even if she were legally entitled to terminate our agreement with 5 days notice any decent human would pickup the phone and explain, instead she completely refused to communicate, further escalating the situation. Also didn’t help that during her stay she made various digs at our parenting choices - totally unnecessary, and resulted in us losing a lot of sympathy for her. But I suppose this is where her mental health comes in, and we should rise above it.

Again, thank you for shaking some perspective into me. We’re leaving at 6 weeks!

Edited

👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿Well done OP. I'm glad you have human empathy. We shouldn't always get hung up on "rights".

femfemlicious · 06/11/2023 11:37

STOP BASHING HER!. she's leaving!

HamBone · 06/11/2023 12:28

You’ve made the right decision, OP.
Leave this stressful situation behind and enjoy your new home. As I said upthread, you can manage without a kitchen for a couple of weeks, it’s abit like camping. 😂

goodnightspoons · 06/11/2023 13:55

I see from a lot of comments that I haven’t given enough context re estate agent pics -
We had actually agreed to help with the pics even though it was less than ideal as she said they couldn’t wait (this is when we first heard re repossession threat, and we were on friendly terms, so of course we were going to help). My partner booked time off work to help. We arranged childcare. She flew over to help too. When she arrived we didn’t hear from her for days, except for the odd comment about our toddler not tidying his toys and being loud (he’s 2!). We had to ask for a sit down meeting with her to find out what was going on as we didn't know if the pics were still happening and what we needed to do - she kept postponing and avoiding us. Finally when we sat down she opened with the line that tipped us over the edge “I brought up my kid as a single mum and never in my life have I lived amongst such chaos”. I think that sums up her understanding of the situation - she had no concept that we are living out of boxes because of building works and things aren’t always going to look neat with a toddler around... (it was just mess, no damage). In any case, it was perfectly doable to make it nice for pics and we were willing, but instead she decided to cancel the pictures and kick us out to avoid having to deal with us any further. If it was that urgent we could have got it sorted. Any time we tried to work something out was met with radio silence. Things went south from there.

OP posts:
Myfabby · 06/11/2023 14:12

@goodnightspoons

I gave you a bit of a hard time earlier. Happy to read your updates. Ignore what she said re parenting- very rude and not her place. But it does sound like this was a stressful situation all round anyways!

Hope the rest of your reno goes smoothly.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread