Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resist 'eviction' by unhinged landlord

92 replies

goodnightspoons · 05/11/2023 21:08

*previously posted on Property, but the situation has evolved into an AIBU...

We’re in the middle of building works and have rented temporary accommodation at a neighbour’s flat.

We have an informal agreement done via WhatsApp (I know, I know..). The owner lives in another country. They mentioned they have long covid / memory problems.

We agreed to stay 4-6 weeks, with the caveat that we may need to extend due to the nature of building works. The flexibility was vital to us, and the owner fully understood and was ok with that.

At 4 weeks she tried to kick us out, giving 5 DAYS notice. We pushed back as our place won’t be inhabitable until the 6 week and 2 day mark absolute minimum (when the flooring is laid) - even then, we’ll have no kitchen. She now wants us gone by 6 weeks (2 days too early for us).

It transpires she’s desperate to sell her place (threat of repossession) and thought she could market it whilst we’re here but has decided it’ll be less hassle with us gone.

During our stay she’s caused endless disruptions, including having the place painted (specially fun with our toddler). She stayed for 6 days - claims we are lodgers, though we were not told of this in advance and assumed we’d have exclusive use of the place. She tried to get US to arrange for estate agents to take pictures and viewings of the place (again - no mention of this in advance).

I feel sorry for her as she’s clearly not well in the head but she’s the one who’s dropped us into this mess.

I think the fairest would be to honour the flexibility of our agreement and let us stay until our kitchen is ready - which would be 7-10 days longer than she wants. I don’t see how that would make a huge difference to her sale but would save us a world of pain. AIBU?

(BTW I don’t want to ‘just’ move to an Airbnb - moving, with a toddler, whilst juggling a job, and overseeing building works is a huge headache in itself. And Airbnb’s are 4x the price)

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 06/11/2023 01:16

Is she charging you market rate rent?

goodnightspoons · 06/11/2023 01:16

GuessItsANameChange · 06/11/2023 01:09

She asked us if she could stay on the day we moved in.
Was that in writing? Because even that alone would strongly suggest a tenancy, rather than lodger agreement.

Sadly no, she literally dropped it into conversation as we were holding our moving boxes. Lovely.

OP posts:
goodnightspoons · 06/11/2023 01:21

She's charging £2k per month for a 3 bed flat in zone 3 London. Pretty close to market rate i think (£2,200-£2,500). We turned down another place for the same rate, 10 mins down the road.

OP posts:
JanglingJack · 06/11/2023 01:24

She's unhinged and wrong in the head is she?

stayathomer · 06/11/2023 01:26

‘Unhinged’ and ‘not well in the head’ but you ‘pushed back’ even though you only have a WhatsApp agreement in place? Why don’t you stay in a hotel or a friend/family member for the few days? It’s her place and she was doing you a favour!!!

JustTalkToThem · 06/11/2023 01:27

We turned down another place for the same rate, 10 mins down the road.

Should see if they’re interested in an indefinite tenancy then to cover your flexible 2 days, 2 weeks, 2 months need … because I’m thinking - not?

crowsfeet57 · 06/11/2023 01:27

Just stay until you want to go. She'd never get an eviction order and bailiff's warrant in 7-10 days.

alchemisty · 06/11/2023 01:29

Sorry I realised I misunderstood your OP. I read "She tried to get US to arrange for estate agents to take pictures and viewings of the place (again - no mention of this in advance)." as her not giving you a heads up that people would be coming round.

What you meant was she didn't give you notice that she was trying to sell before you moved it – tbf you will never get that anywhere in London. My last 3 to 4 tenancies ended with EAs and random agency people barging in at every turn. I think it's fair of her to ask you to let the EAs know your available timings etc.

RogueFemale · 06/11/2023 01:40

GuessItsANameChange · 06/11/2023 00:57

I absolutely disagree with the majority of posters on here.

It sounds as though you have an Assured Short
Hold Tenancy (particularly as both Shelter and the council have said that seems to be the case).

They won’t be able to give you a definitive answer, though, because it comes down to contract interpretation (a matter for the courts) and yours does not sound like a straightforward contract to interpret.

In all likelihood, though, you are entitled to two months’ notice.

I don’t understand why so many posters are giving you a lashing. Even a short term tenant is a tenant and the onus is on the landlord to properly paper it and, when terminating, to do so lawfully.

It's not an AST under Housing Act 1988. The rental premises would have to be the OP's only or principal home for the Act to apply. Obviously not the case here where OP is doing up their house next door. OP occupying status is as a licensee, a temporary one. Hence the deserved lashing.

alchemisty · 06/11/2023 01:44

I definitely see your perspective in that you were expecting a more concrete status as tenant, and legally you may have some rights (or you might not). However, I also think it's clear she had a different view of your "under the table"/ad hoc agreement. To me at least, calling her all sorts of names just because she retains certain ownership rights suggests a strong entitlement on your part. As you say, you didn't want to/couldn't afford to pay for an airbnb.

I think what you need to do next time, OP, is to fork out properly / formally for a 6 week to 2 month short term let with a 4 month break clause. That doesn't solve the problem of you demanding a random 2 day extension at the end of your entire contract length (6 weeks) though – you will never, ever get that anywhere in London and maybe the entire world. Other people are not obligated to do charity for you! I'm actually wondering if this is a wind up?

Finally, I could be wrong, but you also seem to be benefitting from reduced rates. Just skimming, but there's only 1 £2000 three bedder short term let in Zone 3 I see on rightmove – and like most places, it's only available for 6 month short term lets, so if you want it for 1-2 months the rate is going to be much higher. The next one is £2500, and then all the other 600 results are above £3000. Again, remember it will be more than the listed price for 1-2 month lets, if the owners even agree.

Fab973 · 06/11/2023 01:48

You are so entitled and bratty I would chuck you out now if I were her

get out of HER house

Dietchocolate · 06/11/2023 01:54

I’m never one to side with landlords. But she’s at risk of repossession if she doesn’t sell asap and you’ve just bought a house.
If you have to slum it a few weeks, do it in your own house and don’t be selfish.

Id have sympathy if you were a proper tenant but you’re not.

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/11/2023 02:02

PussyGalore1 · 05/11/2023 22:49

OP you are being an absolute massive CF. Just move your stuff back into your own house.

This

Just move already, by the time it's taken you to keep posting different threads you could have done a decent bit of packing.

GuessItsANameChange · 06/11/2023 02:42

RogueFemale · 06/11/2023 01:40

It's not an AST under Housing Act 1988. The rental premises would have to be the OP's only or principal home for the Act to apply. Obviously not the case here where OP is doing up their house next door. OP occupying status is as a licensee, a temporary one. Hence the deserved lashing.

So far as I can tell ‘principal residence’ means the place that the tenant is primarily residing during the tenancy. The OP is currently residing entirely in the rented accommodation.

If the OP was absent from the rental property for a continuous or lengthy period, while living somewhere else, then there would be a (rebuttable) presumption that it is not her principal residence, but that does not appear to be the case.

NCNov123 · 06/11/2023 02:51

goodnightspoons · 06/11/2023 01:21

She's charging £2k per month for a 3 bed flat in zone 3 London. Pretty close to market rate i think (£2,200-£2,500). We turned down another place for the same rate, 10 mins down the road.

That sounds very cheap to me. Esp for a short term let. Plus 10 mins walk can make all the difference in London prices, so you're not comparing apples and apples.

Legally, I don't know where you stand. Maybe you do have an ASD and can pay to fight that through the courts if she changes the locks and puts your stuff on the street. But that sounds like the most hassle of all.

Realistically, I think if you make informal arrangements on the cheap you take the risk it won't work out neatly. Pay for a week in an Airbnb or move into your place and eat take aways for a week, and you're probably still quids in on what it would have cost you to rent somewhere through an agency. I also think that if you wanted "flexibility" so badly then you should have paid for it and rented somewhere for eight weeks from the start.

Ponderingwindow · 06/11/2023 03:04

No, I wouldn’t be happy with a relatively short rental of any duration being painted. The last time I had 1 room in my house painted I checked into a hotel for 2 nights so I wouldn’t get sick as I’m so sensitive.

you seem to be leaping to landlord is unhinged though. Could you not have said no to her staying in the place you are renting?

CountryManor · 06/11/2023 03:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Agree, this doesn't seem real!

GuessItsANameChange · 06/11/2023 03:31

One thing I don’t understand, OP, is why you’re posting here. Looking at your prior thread in particular, you’ve already received quite comprehensive advice from both Shelter and the council and they agree that you seem to be on strong legal footing. The landlord said, 5 days ago, that they’d get back to you once they’ve spoken to their lawyer and I take it that you haven’t heard anything.

I appreciate that any uncertainty isn’t pleasant but it doesn’t very likely that you are going to be compelled to leave earlier than you want to leave, despite the landlord’s prior requests to that effect.

If formal legal advice would set your mind at ease, go see a lawyer and take all the WhatsApp messages with you (although, even then, they’re probably going to have to qualify their answer, because it sounds as though your agreed terms lack clarity). If you’ve got money to burn, time to waste and feel sorry for the Landlord, go find an air bnb or whatever.

Posting in AIBU is just going to add to your stress.

kitchenhelprequired · 06/11/2023 07:37

You can't be lodgers if Landlord isn't living in the property. In lieu of a written short term contract I would agree that you have an implied AST. As the conditions of an AST won't have been met (gas safety certificate, electrical inspection, deposit protected etc etc) it's an illegal tenancy with financial penalties for the LL. However, unless you are going to never leave the home unoccupied there's a possibility that they will arrange for someone to access while you are out, leave all your belongings outside and change the locks. The law is on your side but would need enforcing. Legally speaking there is no action the LL can take to get you out now. You could temporarily change the locks to stop anyone being able to access and ignore any correspondence with the LL and move out when you decide to. They wanted the benefit of rent without the legal obligations which either short term holiday rentals or AST require.

poetryandwine · 06/11/2023 08:10

alchemisty · 06/11/2023 01:44

I definitely see your perspective in that you were expecting a more concrete status as tenant, and legally you may have some rights (or you might not). However, I also think it's clear she had a different view of your "under the table"/ad hoc agreement. To me at least, calling her all sorts of names just because she retains certain ownership rights suggests a strong entitlement on your part. As you say, you didn't want to/couldn't afford to pay for an airbnb.

I think what you need to do next time, OP, is to fork out properly / formally for a 6 week to 2 month short term let with a 4 month break clause. That doesn't solve the problem of you demanding a random 2 day extension at the end of your entire contract length (6 weeks) though – you will never, ever get that anywhere in London and maybe the entire world. Other people are not obligated to do charity for you! I'm actually wondering if this is a wind up?

Finally, I could be wrong, but you also seem to be benefitting from reduced rates. Just skimming, but there's only 1 £2000 three bedder short term let in Zone 3 I see on rightmove – and like most places, it's only available for 6 month short term lets, so if you want it for 1-2 months the rate is going to be much higher. The next one is £2500, and then all the other 600 results are above £3000. Again, remember it will be more than the listed price for 1-2 month lets, if the owners even agree.

Edited

This data driven post is hugely useful.

The reality is that you seem to have yourself an extraordinarily good deal, OP. Life teaches us that those usually come with a catch.

TheOneWhereWeDontGiveAPhuck · 06/11/2023 08:47

You need to just leave. It's not your property. You don't get to make these choices.

Ginmonkeyagain · 06/11/2023 08:59

Remember if you argue it is an AST it will also come with legal responsibilities for you. You may find your self having to give one months notice when you want to leave.

DodgyDiagram · 06/11/2023 09:01

At this stage, I’m not sure it even matters who is ‘right’. She wants you out, you presumably don’t want a court case or police knocking on your door. You have a property of your own. Would it not make sense just to pack most of your things into boxes, store those in any room where your floors are already done, and then either live around the building works or go to a hotel?

goodnightspoons · 06/11/2023 09:14

GuessItsANameChange · 06/11/2023 03:31

One thing I don’t understand, OP, is why you’re posting here. Looking at your prior thread in particular, you’ve already received quite comprehensive advice from both Shelter and the council and they agree that you seem to be on strong legal footing. The landlord said, 5 days ago, that they’d get back to you once they’ve spoken to their lawyer and I take it that you haven’t heard anything.

I appreciate that any uncertainty isn’t pleasant but it doesn’t very likely that you are going to be compelled to leave earlier than you want to leave, despite the landlord’s prior requests to that effect.

If formal legal advice would set your mind at ease, go see a lawyer and take all the WhatsApp messages with you (although, even then, they’re probably going to have to qualify their answer, because it sounds as though your agreed terms lack clarity). If you’ve got money to burn, time to waste and feel sorry for the Landlord, go find an air bnb or whatever.

Posting in AIBU is just going to add to your stress.

Thanks for your balanced messages.

Although its been brutal posting on here it’s actually been v helpful to gain perspective. We’ve been so caught up in it we can’t see the wood from the trees. Posting on Property clarified the legal perspective (and since Shelter/council were on our side we felt ‘entitled’), whereas this whole situation is more than legal - its someones life.

OP posts:
goodnightspoons · 06/11/2023 09:21

It’s easy for posters to say we’re being petty / entitled, etc, but not really consider how her poor handling of the situation has coincided with v stressful building works, and our emotions may have clouded our judgement. I mean even if she were legally entitled to terminate our agreement with 5 days notice any decent human would pickup the phone and explain, instead she completely refused to communicate, further escalating the situation. Also didn’t help that during her stay she made various digs at our parenting choices - totally unnecessary, and resulted in us losing a lot of sympathy for her. But I suppose this is where her mental health comes in, and we should rise above it.

Again, thank you for shaking some perspective into me. We’re leaving at 6 weeks!

OP posts: