Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resist 'eviction' by unhinged landlord

92 replies

goodnightspoons · 05/11/2023 21:08

*previously posted on Property, but the situation has evolved into an AIBU...

We’re in the middle of building works and have rented temporary accommodation at a neighbour’s flat.

We have an informal agreement done via WhatsApp (I know, I know..). The owner lives in another country. They mentioned they have long covid / memory problems.

We agreed to stay 4-6 weeks, with the caveat that we may need to extend due to the nature of building works. The flexibility was vital to us, and the owner fully understood and was ok with that.

At 4 weeks she tried to kick us out, giving 5 DAYS notice. We pushed back as our place won’t be inhabitable until the 6 week and 2 day mark absolute minimum (when the flooring is laid) - even then, we’ll have no kitchen. She now wants us gone by 6 weeks (2 days too early for us).

It transpires she’s desperate to sell her place (threat of repossession) and thought she could market it whilst we’re here but has decided it’ll be less hassle with us gone.

During our stay she’s caused endless disruptions, including having the place painted (specially fun with our toddler). She stayed for 6 days - claims we are lodgers, though we were not told of this in advance and assumed we’d have exclusive use of the place. She tried to get US to arrange for estate agents to take pictures and viewings of the place (again - no mention of this in advance).

I feel sorry for her as she’s clearly not well in the head but she’s the one who’s dropped us into this mess.

I think the fairest would be to honour the flexibility of our agreement and let us stay until our kitchen is ready - which would be 7-10 days longer than she wants. I don’t see how that would make a huge difference to her sale but would save us a world of pain. AIBU?

(BTW I don’t want to ‘just’ move to an Airbnb - moving, with a toddler, whilst juggling a job, and overseeing building works is a huge headache in itself. And Airbnb’s are 4x the price)

OP posts:
Nagado · 05/11/2023 23:17

I feel sorry for her as she’s clearly not well in the head but she’s the one who’s dropped us into this mess I disagree. You’ve dropped yourself into it. What on earth did you think would happen, moving into a flat for an unspecified period, with unspecified payment terms, and owned by someone who has disclosed to you that they are suffering with their mental health? You made the decision to leave everything vague and agreed over WhatsApp so you’re now reaping the consequences of a really silly decision.

I agree that it’s shit for everyone but I think you’re behaving really shoddily. You know she’s not well. A repossession has to be causing her all sorts of stress and you want to make things a million times worse by making it difficult for her to sell and leaving her wondering whether she can afford to have you evicted or whether the lack of any sort of agreement means that she’s stuck with you unless she can find someone who wants to buy with you and your family in situ. And that’s not going to happen, is it? You could be the difference between her losing her flat and being able to sell it. All because you don’t want to have the inconvenience of being without a kitchen for a short time? I think you’re taking advantage of a vulnerable woman who has trusted you to behave decently.

And what are you intending to do if the house is repossessed and you’re evicted with an hour’s notice? Because it’s entirely possible that could happen.

SaveMeFromMyBoobs · 05/11/2023 23:24

Lots of people live in their houses while getting renovations done. If all thats left is the kitchen move into your house and do what everyone else does and set up the fridge freezer and microwave in another room and use paper plates or wash up in the bathroom for the week!

Pumpkinspicelattetime · 05/11/2023 23:28

Is the 7-10 days extra on top of the 6 weeks? If so, then you are clearly the unreasonable one here. The agreement was for 4 to 6 weeks and she is honouring that. You are the one who isn't and are choosing to make life difficult for this poor woman because works on your house haven't gone as planned. You may have legal rights, depends on the agreement or lack of, but you are a dick to extend this beyond what you agreed.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 05/11/2023 23:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

IfIcouldchooseagain · 05/11/2023 23:32

You agreed 4-6 weeks, she asked you to go at 4 weeks and you didn’t, now she’s asking you to go at 6 weeks and you’re refusing?!

Get out of her house! Yes I know you don’t want to. But, and this is important, IT IS NOT YOURS.

You’re the nightmare, not her.

angelikacpickles · 05/11/2023 23:54

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

Myfabby · 05/11/2023 23:58

and you say she's unhinged? So unfair.

She's being more than fair to you.

During our stay she’s caused endless disruptions, including having the place painted (specially fun with our toddler).

WOW. Her life should be on hold because of your precious toddler? so if you were painting your home, would what you do with your kids?

This is why people don't do nice things anymore.

If I were her, I'd have moved all your things out at the 4 week mark.

Myfabby · 06/11/2023 00:03

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

no we are not.

She is being highly unreasonable. How does her flexibility whilst her own home awaits trump her neighbours urgent need to sell as she's under the threat of repossession?

angelikacpickles · 06/11/2023 00:06

Myfabby · 06/11/2023 00:03

no we are not.

She is being highly unreasonable. How does her flexibility whilst her own home awaits trump her neighbours urgent need to sell as she's under the threat of repossession?

Edited

It doesn't, except for the fact that the owner agreed to it?

Myfabby · 06/11/2023 00:09

angelikacpickles · 06/11/2023 00:06

It doesn't, except for the fact that the owner agreed to it?

ok, you're right. the OP is right too. The owner is wrong, and unhinged and wrong in the head.

goodnightspoons · 06/11/2023 00:18

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

Yes this is the crucial point - the flexibility was agreed on. It’s building works.

OP posts:
HamBone · 06/11/2023 00:23

I’d still get out of there and into your own house, OP. You can manage without a kitchen for a couple of weeks and the stress of dealing with this situation will be over.

JustTalkToThem · 06/11/2023 00:24

You’re a cheeky mare. If hotels and Airbnb are so expensive for one extra week, it means tht you got a great deal for the previous stay.

Anotherparkingthread · 06/11/2023 00:26

If you don't have a tenancy and didn't get one, then you're a lodger. It will be impossible to prove otherwise because you do not have assured shorthold or, well, any kind of tenancy or legal contract.

Given that you have no tenancy and no right to stay in the property she could literally throw all your things outside and have police remove you from the house and it would be perfectly legal. She is doing you a massive favour by agreeing to honour the original 6 week timeframe, I'd have thrown you out by now if it were me. You should probably just rent a cheap hotel or air BnB for the few days you need one and call it a day. You're only making your own life difficult.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 06/11/2023 00:27

Just move back into your own house. I lived without a kitchen with a toddler and a baby for 2 months in winter (relevant as we also had no heating at all downstairs because of the stalled work). Anyway, it's doable, crappy but doable. You're lodgers so she can legally kick you out without repercussions.

No flooring? So what? I haven't had any living room flooring down for over two years, fingers crossed I'll get it sorted within the next year haha it's just not a priority.

I get that some people want their homes to be perfect, but I grew up my whole childhood with our family home being renovated bit by bit. I'm a grown ass middle-aged woman now and my parents are still finishing off renovations (they haven't had a kitchen for over a year now and are coping just fine). But my point is, you have a roof that you own that you could be living under, and yes, you'll have temporary stress of living in what feels like a building site, but it's short term and then you'll have no stress from the current living arrangement.

Anotherparkingthread · 06/11/2023 00:28

goodnightspoons · 06/11/2023 00:18

Yes this is the crucial point - the flexibility was agreed on. It’s building works.

Also I think the flexibility wouldn't have been an issue if you weren't hindering the property sale. She probably assumed she did you a favour by letting you stay for reletively cheaply and in return you would be in to allow viewings and accommodate the estate agent and decorators. Which is a perfectly reasonable assumption given the circumstances. She would likely have no issue with you staying longer if you were obliging.

RantyAnty · 06/11/2023 00:35

Do you really not see what a CF you are?

If I was them, I'd have your belongings out out the front and change the locks.

goodnightspoons · 06/11/2023 00:41

What im taking issue with is that we were never told about any of this in advance.
We assumed we had exclusive use - sharing was never mentioned - she lives in another country. She asked us if she could stay on the day we moved in. Sorry but thats not on. Thats a totally different arrangement.
If your airbnb was being painted during your stay wouldnt you like to know in advance? (We literally moved out of our house to avoid being around painting)
What i didnt mention above is that we were going to tidy the place up for pics but she decided to cancel them and kick us out instead. We tried.
She wont even talk to us to figure something out.

OP posts:
squidgybits · 06/11/2023 00:42

I want everything but I don't want to pay for it

Desperateinseattle · 06/11/2023 00:52

sorry but this is ridiculous. If you can’t afford to house yourself properly (come the fuck on- how did this ever seem like a good idea to organise a short tenancy over WhatsApp?!) during renovations then you weren’t ready to start the building work.

yes she should have been transparent, but it is her house. Put yourself in an air bnb and get on with it.

GuessItsANameChange · 06/11/2023 00:57

I absolutely disagree with the majority of posters on here.

It sounds as though you have an Assured Short
Hold Tenancy (particularly as both Shelter and the council have said that seems to be the case).

They won’t be able to give you a definitive answer, though, because it comes down to contract interpretation (a matter for the courts) and yours does not sound like a straightforward contract to interpret.

In all likelihood, though, you are entitled to two months’ notice.

I don’t understand why so many posters are giving you a lashing. Even a short term tenant is a tenant and the onus is on the landlord to properly paper it and, when terminating, to do so lawfully.

alchemisty · 06/11/2023 00:59

I know a lot of people like to have a dig at OP on AIBU but in this case I really think you're being extremely unreasonable.

Usually, flexibility is understood to be 2 ways. The benefit of a more "informal" arrangement is mutual flexibility. I'm actually on a more flexible contract/agreement (albeit written and signed) with someone concerning something right now, and it's understood that either of us can back out or request to extend at any time / certain points in time.

As for exclusive use vs sharing, that wasn't discussed and I really don't see why you'd assume exclusive use; lodging arrangements are pretty common too. I suppose one indicator (though not final) might be how much you're paying. Are the rates more reflective of lodging or exclusive use? Do note shorthold tenancies tend to cost A LOT more than long tenancies, not less.

Finally, all the other things like having works done, estate viewings and pics, she definitely should have given you a heads up. These are normal things for landlords to have done while tenants are in though (again with some general heads up).

goodnightspoons · 06/11/2023 01:08

GuessItsANameChange · 06/11/2023 00:57

I absolutely disagree with the majority of posters on here.

It sounds as though you have an Assured Short
Hold Tenancy (particularly as both Shelter and the council have said that seems to be the case).

They won’t be able to give you a definitive answer, though, because it comes down to contract interpretation (a matter for the courts) and yours does not sound like a straightforward contract to interpret.

In all likelihood, though, you are entitled to two months’ notice.

I don’t understand why so many posters are giving you a lashing. Even a short term tenant is a tenant and the onus is on the landlord to properly paper it and, when terminating, to do so lawfully.

Thank you. Honestly, i feel like Im living in a parallel universe. Legally we're entitled to reasonable notice (Shelter said that's 28 days absolute minimum).

In any case, I think people are right to pick up on the fact she's not well, and although we've been seriously messed around I rather get out at the 6 week mark and be done with it.

OP posts:
GuessItsANameChange · 06/11/2023 01:09

She asked us if she could stay on the day we moved in.
Was that in writing? Because even that alone would strongly suggest a tenancy, rather than lodger agreement.

goodnightspoons · 06/11/2023 01:15

alchemisty · 06/11/2023 00:59

I know a lot of people like to have a dig at OP on AIBU but in this case I really think you're being extremely unreasonable.

Usually, flexibility is understood to be 2 ways. The benefit of a more "informal" arrangement is mutual flexibility. I'm actually on a more flexible contract/agreement (albeit written and signed) with someone concerning something right now, and it's understood that either of us can back out or request to extend at any time / certain points in time.

As for exclusive use vs sharing, that wasn't discussed and I really don't see why you'd assume exclusive use; lodging arrangements are pretty common too. I suppose one indicator (though not final) might be how much you're paying. Are the rates more reflective of lodging or exclusive use? Do note shorthold tenancies tend to cost A LOT more than long tenancies, not less.

Finally, all the other things like having works done, estate viewings and pics, she definitely should have given you a heads up. These are normal things for landlords to have done while tenants are in though (again with some general heads up).

Re the rate - During our accommodation search we came across a place which was the same price, definitely exclusive use (they sent us a contract template) and were okay with flexible exit date, but we turned it down as it was 10 mins away whereas this is on the same road... Obviously kicking myself now for MANY reasons. Yes, definitely been naive going into this.

OP posts: