Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU if I expect my husband to work more days than me so I can stay at home with our child?

425 replies

Newmumma123 · 21/10/2023 20:32

I am currently 38 weeks pregnant and I am due our first baby in ten days. Me and my husband have been together nearly seven years after meeting online when we were in our late teens.

My husband is an engineer and works 5/6 days a week with a 45 minute commute each way. I am a primary school teacher and I currently work four days a week after cutting down my hours two years ago to support my mum who was diagnosed with BPD but I am now off on MAT leave until June next year. We used to car share to work as we both worked in an area 45 minutes from where we currently live, however when I fell pregnant I decided that I will move to another school closer at the end of my MAT leave so that one of us is close by for our baby who will be in nursery three days and looked after by grandparents two days at that point.

Originally, we discussed the option of me going back five days a week after MAT leave but after talking with other friends and family who are teachers, lots of them have said how stressful it is balancing motherhood and full time work. Over the last few weeks, I have been considering when taking a new job getting a three or four day contract so that I can actually spend sometime looking after the child that I have grown for nine months.

Tonight, I said to my husband that I'd like to go back to work four days after MAT leave instead of five and he said that he would like to only work five days instead of six and that I should go back to work five days so that he can do five days too and doesn't have to work 7 to 12 on a Saturday morning to help bring in a bit more money (cost of living!). If I did four days we would pay one day less a week for childcare and my wages alone pays for childcare/ plus covers my percentage of bills too(this is without the funding that should be coming into place in September 2024) so we should financially be fine if we are careful with money. My husband said to me that our child will miss out on the development but honestly, I feel that I am well equiped to fill that gap as I am early years trained and an educational professional myself plus being the mum (I also don't feel like I should be justifying myself as the mum). My husband is coming across very jealous as he feels we should both work five days so we can both be with our baby on the weekends however I feel that its best for our baby to be with one of us three days out of seven rather than two of us two days out of seven.

My husband has always had this attitude that I get a 'week off' every 6/7 weeks and quite honestly, it annoys me as being a teacher is HARD work physically and mentally. I can't just switch off when I get home. I also don't want to work five days and have someone else look after the child that I have grown and will birth. I want to be with him whilst he is young. My husband has attacked my work ethic and has described me as being 'soft' because I want to be at home.

Alot of this rides on me being able to get a contract for specific days but my husbands attitude is really annoying me. He said why should he have to scarifice time with our baby so I can have more time with him. My answer back was I have scarificed a year out of my career, my pension contributions and my body plus the mental toll of looking after a baby in order for us to have a child. I feel that he should work a bit extra so that I can spend more time with our baby as I am his mummy. We have ended up having an argument as I am very upset as I don't feel like he understands just how important I will be in our childs life and I feel that he is a bit jealous of how much I will be needed more than him by the baby.

AIBU with my feelings of wanting to stay at home with our baby one day a week ? Should I go back to work five days after MAT leave so that we both have an equal amount of time with our ten month old ?

Please help!

OP posts:
Debini · 21/10/2023 21:35

I think it’s unfair of you to expect your husband to sacrifice a day with his child for your sole benefit. Surely if possible you should spend equal time with the baby.

Teder · 21/10/2023 21:35

Lifecanbebeautiful12 · 21/10/2023 21:26

I’m surprised at all the PPs! I don’t think you are being unreasonable but this seems to be a symptom of new age feminism and the guise of equality. Of course it is important for a baby to spend time with its mother and you being at home for one day a week is preferable to a baby being in full time nursery. Your husband sounds jealous that you get time off work as you’re a teacher and also that you’ll spend more time at home if you work less. Sorry but mothers and fathers are not equal in their importance to a baby, a mother is more important in the early years of a child’s life. I don’t know if it’s fair to expect him to work on a Saturday to subsidise you working one day less, though. But if you can afford for him to just work the 5 days and you 4 days, I think that’s entirely reasonable!

This is after maternity leave. It’s not with a newborn in the third trimester. It’s not a tiny baby who is exclusively breastfed. There is no evidence to suggest a mother is required for a young child. It is a stable caregiver or caregivers which is often mum but is also dad, grandparents or a childminder, for example.

MissTrip82 · 21/10/2023 21:36

You just seem to think everything about you is special and not shared by anyone? From the importancen of mummy over daddy, to the demanding job only you understand.

I think it’s great you could go part time to care
for your mum - I assume it’s the other grandparents providing childcare - and just as with that decision, both people in the couple need to be ok with it. If one isn’t, it’s not an option.

Wonkasworld · 21/10/2023 21:36

TheFairyCaravan · 21/10/2023 21:26

It’s people like you who give teachers a bad name.

People don’t doubt that teachers have a hard job, and do long hours, but you’re not the only ones and contrary to what you think it’s not the hardest job in the world.

👏 👏

SleepingStandingUp · 21/10/2023 21:36

Newmumma123 · 21/10/2023 21:09

Thanks for providing a broader perspective; I'm the first to admit when maybe I ABU and so its good to gather other people thoughts. Please be kind when posting on these forums, you only know a small part about my life however some of you calling my attitude disgusting because I would like to spend more time with my child is hurtful. I understand that I need to figure out another way work four days instead of five without my husband working extra hours. My husband is amazing and I of course understand he has as much as an important role in our childs life as myself x

Edited

I don't feel like he understands just how important I will be in our childs life and I feel that he is a bit jealous of how much I will be needed more than him by the baby

Well op which is it? You understand he has as much as an important role or you will be needed so much more than him?

You're setting yourself up to push him away and make him feel he has no role beyond sperm and money

In a year or two it'll be "he doesn't do anything with the baby, he says the baby only needs me so why can't he do X on his own"

If you're unhappy with the housework balance, address it as a separate thing.

If you're working 4 days to support your Mom why will you not need to do that in a years time?

I don't think you're unreasonable to want to stay at four days, so I'd work on the financials not the "but I'm so important I have to have three days with him!"
By that logic surely you need to just quit?

How much will you earn on four days vs five? What is the saving (tax, student loan, childcare)? What does he earn if he sticks to Mon-Fri? Are you entitled to any benefits, CB, etc?

LyndaLaHughes · 21/10/2023 21:37

It’s people like you who give teachers a bad name.

People don’t doubt that teachers have a hard job, and do long hours, but you’re not the only ones and contrary to what you think it’s not the hardest job in the world.*

How exactly? By telling the truth about how bad it has become? I never said it was the hardest job in the world. I said it was the hardest job I had done and it has become awful which is why 40,000 left last year. Nursing is another job where it's become awful and nurses are leaving in their droves also. I wouldn't dare tell a nurse their job is not hard or that other jobs are harder. I'd trust them when they say how awful it has become.
Why is it when someone says their job is hard people choose to hear "my job is the hardest and worst job in the world", No one ever said that. But people's perception of teaching is utterly wrong which is why many career changers and new teachers leave quickly once they realised what it is actually like.

Rosieposy89 · 21/10/2023 21:38

OP will be back in 2 years complaining the dad doesn't help enough with childcare

Tiredmummy201 · 21/10/2023 21:38

If he finishes at 1 on a Friday and a half day sat that is 5 days anyway imo .. have you discussed who is doing all the night feeds, household chores etc when you return to work ? If it's a 50/50 split then he must be willing to take on half of the care of the baby too. You could try and find a job that was full time hours in 3/4 days that's what I did, your DH could see about working a full day Friday so he can have each Saturday off ... you might find once he realises baby's can be quite hard work he'll skip off happily to work for a rest.

LyndaLaHughes · 21/10/2023 21:38

I feel that he should work a bit extra so that I can spend more time with our baby as I am his mummy.

To be fair I missed this part and I don't agree with this sentiment either.

Stomacharmeleon · 21/10/2023 21:38

Sorry I am a teacher and am with your husband on this one. And tbh this is something I would have had nailed on before being full term... it seems like you are changing the goal posts.
Have you even got a new contract or a specific day one at a new school? I take it your going to have to go back on same terms to your school for a while?

Teder · 21/10/2023 21:38

LyndaLaHughes · 21/10/2023 21:22

Just to be clear- the point I am making is about the fairness of comparison of hours as the likelihood is from what the op said- that her full time hours will be more than her husbands full time hours. If they were equal- then I would get his point.

There are so many jobs which expect long hours. It’s rare for a decent paying job to allow people to switch off at 5 pm on the dot.

Wonkasworld · 21/10/2023 21:39

LyndaLaHughes · 21/10/2023 21:37

It’s people like you who give teachers a bad name.

People don’t doubt that teachers have a hard job, and do long hours, but you’re not the only ones and contrary to what you think it’s not the hardest job in the world.*

How exactly? By telling the truth about how bad it has become? I never said it was the hardest job in the world. I said it was the hardest job I had done and it has become awful which is why 40,000 left last year. Nursing is another job where it's become awful and nurses are leaving in their droves also. I wouldn't dare tell a nurse their job is not hard or that other jobs are harder. I'd trust them when they say how awful it has become.
Why is it when someone says their job is hard people choose to hear "my job is the hardest and worst job in the world", No one ever said that. But people's perception of teaching is utterly wrong which is why many career changers and new teachers leave quickly once they realised what it is actually like.

We've already had somebody say that teaching is harder than another profession. It's an arrogant statement. I know you haven't said that but attitudes like that take away empathy for teachers.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 21/10/2023 21:40

Tiredmummy201 · 21/10/2023 21:38

If he finishes at 1 on a Friday and a half day sat that is 5 days anyway imo .. have you discussed who is doing all the night feeds, household chores etc when you return to work ? If it's a 50/50 split then he must be willing to take on half of the care of the baby too. You could try and find a job that was full time hours in 3/4 days that's what I did, your DH could see about working a full day Friday so he can have each Saturday off ... you might find once he realises baby's can be quite hard work he'll skip off happily to work for a rest.

We don't know what time he starts work. If he starts at 9am that's one thing, but he could feasibly be starting at 5/6am

Coffeerum · 21/10/2023 21:40

happylittlesloth · 21/10/2023 21:25

She already does it on Saturdays

Does she? As far as I can see it’s only the DH picking up extra work on a Saturday to make up for OP’s current 4 day week and help them with the cost of living apparently.

SleepingStandingUp · 21/10/2023 21:40

Newmumma123 · 21/10/2023 21:16

This is exactly it. He doesn't always do six days but sometimes he picks up extra shifts if we have an extra bill to pay for. We manage on my wage currently on four days but the extra money does help. I also tutor Saturday mornings for four hours a week to cover the difference in earnings by dropping the day a week x

Ok so that's your arguement.

If he works just Mon-Fri he's doing 4.5 days. You do four days plus your half day Saturday. So that's equal time.

If you could work Fridays he could pick up from Nursery early and have a few hours of DBaby to himself.

So baby would be with you one day, grandparent one day I think? Dad half day plus he gets Saturday mornings. So he gets baby to himself two half days, you get baby to yourself 1 day and you're together 1.5 days.

If you've got regular tutoring, he isn't going to be able to work now because you have a baby.

Coolblur · 21/10/2023 21:40

Why don't you work 4 days a week, as you do now, and he drop the Saturday morning? That way you only need childcare 4 days a week, you get one day with your child, and you all have the weekends together. You already have a childcare plan for 5 days a week so you know it's viable from that angle. If the answer is money then YABU.

By the way lots of parents (not just Mums) work FT, myself included and it's fine. You also have the perfect job for childcare (try working shifts) and will have all the school hols to spend with your child, which is great for bonding etc

LolaSmiles · 21/10/2023 21:42

The challenges in teaching are irrelevant to a situation that boils down to "AIBU to think that because I'll be a mummy, I should have what time off work I want and my husband should suck up working 6 days a week because mummy says".

5 minutes on Mumsnet shows there's enough useless, lazy sexist men who opt out of parenting at any opportunity and a lot of women worn out by being default parent (and that's women who WANT their children's fathers to be involved).

Any time I read a thread that's all "but I want all the time with MY baby" that sidelines the father, I think hmm give it a year or two and there'll be another thread:
"AIBU to think DH should be able to get our 18 month old to settle without me"
"AIBU to think DH should be able to manage the children on his own..."

Rtc12 · 21/10/2023 21:42

I think you should have put this info in your first post. If he only works half a day on Friday and Saturday then I think he's being unreasonable asking you to do 5 days. Especially as teachers end up doing lots of work in the evenings /weekends /school hols.

WandaWonder · 21/10/2023 21:42

Lorelaigilmore88 · 21/10/2023 20:37

Yanbu.
Your husbands attitude is unpleasant. You need to do what's best for you and baby. When you go back after mat leave you'll have a whole range of emotions t9 deal with you probably didnt anticipate. And a small baby's relationship with its mother is more important than its father imo.

This is appalling

everycloud3 · 21/10/2023 21:43

YABU.

DH runs his own company and has had to work 7am-11pm the last few days to get a job finished and he's really missing seeing our 5 month old as he leaves when she's asleep and gets home when she's asleep.

Both parents are just as important as each other.

Wonkasworld · 21/10/2023 21:44

WandaWonder · 21/10/2023 21:42

This is appalling

My goodness, I agree with you!

Milliemoo6 · 21/10/2023 21:45

Why will the baby need you more than his Dad? The tone of your post is horrible, you're totally undermining what your husband wants and feels. I also think it's quite sad that you feel like a years' maternity leave is a sacrifice that your husband needs to compensate you for. Surely you both decided to have a baby and actually, maternity leave is such a privilege. Of course its hard, but so is going to work when you've had barely any sleep and are desperate to be at home with your baby.

WeWereInParis · 21/10/2023 21:46

LolaSmiles · 21/10/2023 21:42

The challenges in teaching are irrelevant to a situation that boils down to "AIBU to think that because I'll be a mummy, I should have what time off work I want and my husband should suck up working 6 days a week because mummy says".

5 minutes on Mumsnet shows there's enough useless, lazy sexist men who opt out of parenting at any opportunity and a lot of women worn out by being default parent (and that's women who WANT their children's fathers to be involved).

Any time I read a thread that's all "but I want all the time with MY baby" that sidelines the father, I think hmm give it a year or two and there'll be another thread:
"AIBU to think DH should be able to get our 18 month old to settle without me"
"AIBU to think DH should be able to manage the children on his own..."

I agree. OP's comments like "I also don't feel like I should be justifying myself as the mum" when talking about a discussion with her husband/the baby's father are ridiculous.

Cosyblankets · 21/10/2023 21:47

You'll be back here when the baby is a few months old because he or she will only settle at night for you not dad.
He's the dad, he's not a cash machine. He wants time with the baby too.

readbooksdrinktea · 21/10/2023 21:47

LolaSmiles · 21/10/2023 21:42

The challenges in teaching are irrelevant to a situation that boils down to "AIBU to think that because I'll be a mummy, I should have what time off work I want and my husband should suck up working 6 days a week because mummy says".

5 minutes on Mumsnet shows there's enough useless, lazy sexist men who opt out of parenting at any opportunity and a lot of women worn out by being default parent (and that's women who WANT their children's fathers to be involved).

Any time I read a thread that's all "but I want all the time with MY baby" that sidelines the father, I think hmm give it a year or two and there'll be another thread:
"AIBU to think DH should be able to get our 18 month old to settle without me"
"AIBU to think DH should be able to manage the children on his own..."

Exactly!

Swipe left for the next trending thread