Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU if I expect my husband to work more days than me so I can stay at home with our child?

425 replies

Newmumma123 · 21/10/2023 20:32

I am currently 38 weeks pregnant and I am due our first baby in ten days. Me and my husband have been together nearly seven years after meeting online when we were in our late teens.

My husband is an engineer and works 5/6 days a week with a 45 minute commute each way. I am a primary school teacher and I currently work four days a week after cutting down my hours two years ago to support my mum who was diagnosed with BPD but I am now off on MAT leave until June next year. We used to car share to work as we both worked in an area 45 minutes from where we currently live, however when I fell pregnant I decided that I will move to another school closer at the end of my MAT leave so that one of us is close by for our baby who will be in nursery three days and looked after by grandparents two days at that point.

Originally, we discussed the option of me going back five days a week after MAT leave but after talking with other friends and family who are teachers, lots of them have said how stressful it is balancing motherhood and full time work. Over the last few weeks, I have been considering when taking a new job getting a three or four day contract so that I can actually spend sometime looking after the child that I have grown for nine months.

Tonight, I said to my husband that I'd like to go back to work four days after MAT leave instead of five and he said that he would like to only work five days instead of six and that I should go back to work five days so that he can do five days too and doesn't have to work 7 to 12 on a Saturday morning to help bring in a bit more money (cost of living!). If I did four days we would pay one day less a week for childcare and my wages alone pays for childcare/ plus covers my percentage of bills too(this is without the funding that should be coming into place in September 2024) so we should financially be fine if we are careful with money. My husband said to me that our child will miss out on the development but honestly, I feel that I am well equiped to fill that gap as I am early years trained and an educational professional myself plus being the mum (I also don't feel like I should be justifying myself as the mum). My husband is coming across very jealous as he feels we should both work five days so we can both be with our baby on the weekends however I feel that its best for our baby to be with one of us three days out of seven rather than two of us two days out of seven.

My husband has always had this attitude that I get a 'week off' every 6/7 weeks and quite honestly, it annoys me as being a teacher is HARD work physically and mentally. I can't just switch off when I get home. I also don't want to work five days and have someone else look after the child that I have grown and will birth. I want to be with him whilst he is young. My husband has attacked my work ethic and has described me as being 'soft' because I want to be at home.

Alot of this rides on me being able to get a contract for specific days but my husbands attitude is really annoying me. He said why should he have to scarifice time with our baby so I can have more time with him. My answer back was I have scarificed a year out of my career, my pension contributions and my body plus the mental toll of looking after a baby in order for us to have a child. I feel that he should work a bit extra so that I can spend more time with our baby as I am his mummy. We have ended up having an argument as I am very upset as I don't feel like he understands just how important I will be in our childs life and I feel that he is a bit jealous of how much I will be needed more than him by the baby.

AIBU with my feelings of wanting to stay at home with our baby one day a week ? Should I go back to work five days after MAT leave so that we both have an equal amount of time with our ten month old ?

Please help!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Katiebaby3009 · 29/10/2023 11:26

YANBU. I’m sorry but Mums do most of the caregiving and organising and are usually the default parent. Most men seem quite happy with this arrangement so I’m not sure why so many people are saying that Dads and Mums are equal because they simply aren’t! Of course Dads are important but it is not the same role by any means. It is also not unusual for men to work more to support their families and for women to take the hit to their careers. It is important that he does get time with the baby too so I would probably say that him not working weekends is a reasonable request.

Mumof3girks · 27/10/2023 18:17

Cos a teacher's job really finishes at 3.30 when the children leave school! There's sorting the classroom out, marking work, planning the next week's worth of work. Planning any trips to do with class work. I home educate 1 child that is never ending planning and preparing work. Since he does 4 full days 1 half day and a sat when needed what does he do the rest of the time. He will have that time with the baby while you are doing everything else that comes with teaching. Plus still cooking, washing, cleaning the house etc. Stick to the 4 days at most

Sashick989 · 26/10/2023 20:56

I think babies do need their mums more than their dads when they are very little. Years gone by when there was no baby formula milk how could men feed them?!? Of course they needed their mums to feed.
You would think that your husband might be happy for you take the extra day off so you could spend more time with your baby so the baby is being cared for by it’s mother rather than a stranger in childcare. You said you’re willing to cut back on holidays etc to spend more time with the baby too and so therefore he could stop working the Saturday mornings. Can you really call 7-12 a whole days work anyway!

Springforward1 · 26/10/2023 16:15

Redkite11 · 26/10/2023 15:53

Do you split household work evenly? If you both work 5 days a week and you also have to do more housework, that would be unfair to you.

I am more old fashioned and so I think it would be fair for you to work 4 days and spend more time with the baby and for your husband to be the provider. However, every family is different and has different values.

Agree every family has the right to make their own choices. As far as early years are concerned, my sister breast fed until her son was almost 2yrs old which is not unusual. She is a well paid professional as is her DH who supported her decision to go part time after baby was born. She still does part time. I'd never deny the right of mothers to do this or say they're being selfish. If dad has to do a few more days than mum to facilitate continuity of childcare without paying for nurseries or childminders, especially if they can aford it, then in my eyes OP you are not being unreasonable. I hear people saying but he doesn't want that. I say perhaps he should put his baby first without criticising mum for giving up her hours and money for their baby. He has plenty of opportunity to be there, in fact every morning, every night & days off, also family holidays finances permitting.

Redkite11 · 26/10/2023 15:53

Do you split household work evenly? If you both work 5 days a week and you also have to do more housework, that would be unfair to you.

I am more old fashioned and so I think it would be fair for you to work 4 days and spend more time with the baby and for your husband to be the provider. However, every family is different and has different values.

flagwaver · 26/10/2023 13:27

Coffeerum · 26/10/2023 06:40

I wonder how much of the mummy knows best crew will be moaning about the mental load and being the default parent in 5 years time.

In addition someone said earlier that she wouldn't let her partner have his child overnight as he wouldn't know how to care for it but unless they're given a chance to learn, which is exactly what a first time mother does, he'll never know and therefore the myth of useless father/ superwoman mother will be perpetuated. When my first baby was born that was the first time I'd touched or held a baby, it was something that I had to learn. Luckily I was abroad so no family to interfere or health professionals to make demands on how I did things. By the time our families saw her, about 5 weeks, I was able to deal with things, much to their annoyance!

SeaMonkeysTookMyMoney · 26/10/2023 12:31

Dads are just as important as mums, and if you wouldn't work an extra day to give him more time with the baby I don't see why you're expecting him to. Your maternity leave will give you more time with the baby than his paternity leave and you'll have every single half term, summer, Christmas and Easter break with the little one for the next 18 years, it doesn't seem reasonable to me to expect him to give up 52 days with his child to give you even more.

And I completely get you wanting to be there as much as you can, and I understand that you feel you're the best person to look after the baby, but that's probably exactly how dad's feeling right now too.

toomuchfaff · 26/10/2023 11:54

YABU.
there's a lot of your text that raises massive red flags to me... You don't come across that you are in a partnership, to you he is an ATM that should go and bring in the money whilst you play the parental role.

  • the baby I HAVE GROWN and will birth.. (dad can't do that, doesn't diminish his role because you got anatomy he didnt)
  • I don't feel I should have to justify myself as mum (dad is dad... why does he have to justify his role?)

your relationship is doomed if you believe your role is more important and should take precedent over his. Youre meant to be in a partnership, youre meant to be a pair, a solid unit entering into parenthood as a force. You'll be a single parent with joint custody before you know it if you don't change your tune.

Roles reversed, how happy would you be if he took the stance you should work more, ypu should work 6 days a week so he can drop to 4 and stay home and be with HIS baby, because he didn't get chance to BIRTH it so he needs to play catch up, much like if he had a surrogate mum... if he started talking about you as though you were simply the incubator and now your role should take a back seat and is diminished? mmm not happy about that I'd imagine. Stop diminishing his role.

Superscientist · 26/10/2023 10:10

It so much depends on your earnings, the cost of childcare and your fixed outgoings

When I was deciding I made a spreadsheet using my take home pay on 60, 80, 100% pay. Make sure it's take home and not gross as tax and insurance is reduced but not proportionally. The same for your partner on 5 or 5.5 days. Would his work permit compressed work doing the Saturday hours over the week?

Cost of child care - remember to take into account any free hours you might be entitled too and the £500 a quarter money from the gov. Note that some nurseries have a discount for 5 days a week. The 2 nurseries we have been at charged just over 4.5 days for the full week rather than 5. So dropping from 5 days to 4 days might not reduce your costs as much.

When I plugged the numbers we were £100 down per month by going to 4 days a week.

5128gap · 26/10/2023 10:01

I actually do think YABU to expect him to work 6 days so you can work 4. But that doesn't really matter. Nor do the opinions of those who think YANBU, as the only person who needs to be on board is him.
No one has the right to insist that someone else works more to subsidise them to work less, however valid they think their reasons are. So it needs to be something agreed upon.
If you can't secure his agreement your only options will be to work the hours you need to to make an equal financial contribution, or consider separating so you can make your decisions independently.

Vistada · 26/10/2023 09:38

TheKeatingFive · 23/10/2023 23:51

That sounds really unfair to me. Why should he work more so that you can work less? It's his baby too.

Because she's Mummy and he's just some guy who their child won't love as much

Honestly OP that school of thought is absolutely gross - your partner must feel so disrespected.

Lazyj · 26/10/2023 08:03

AnnaJD · 25/10/2023 22:49

You are not being unreasonable, mums’ relationship with a baby is far more important as you will be his main carer for his first 10 months and most probably doing most of housework too, also you are right - it would be better for the baby to be in your care than anyone else’s, every new mum knows it and I think people who commented otherwise definitely did not recently have young children. What is unreasonable is that cost of living is so high that it requires two people to work on average 5 days a week to survive, I am in similar situation and would give everything to work 4 not 5 days a week and simply cannot afford it. It is simply detrimental to young children well-being and mental health to be separated from mum for 5 days a week.

I completely disagree with the first part of your statement, and I have an 18 month old. However I would also give anything for either myself or my husband to be home with our daughter more, we both work full time and it's unfortunate it needs to be that way. However , a SAHD is no less valuable than a SAHM.

Lazyj · 26/10/2023 08:00

Lorelaigilmore88 · 21/10/2023 20:37

Yanbu.
Your husbands attitude is unpleasant. You need to do what's best for you and baby. When you go back after mat leave you'll have a whole range of emotions t9 deal with you probably didnt anticipate. And a small baby's relationship with its mother is more important than its father imo.

Wow, what an outdated view you have. Women already get tons more maternity leave than men, albeit if it's statutory the pay is pathetic. My husband's time and relationship with our daughter is no less important than mine. And he is just as responsible for her as I am.

Coffeerum · 26/10/2023 06:40

I wonder how much of the mummy knows best crew will be moaning about the mental load and being the default parent in 5 years time.

LeedsMum87 · 26/10/2023 04:59

This! Up until 1 year baby totally needs their mum more, that’s what maternity leave is for. When Mum returns to work I see no problem in Mum and Dad sharing childcare equally? Baby is already spending time at nursery and with grandparents so why wouldn’t they also spend time with Dad?

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 25/10/2023 23:39

@WrongSwanson and did baby actually have to go for a week? This terrifies me I couldn't even handle my ex having baby overnight at the moment he wouldn't know how to care for or comfort him :-(

WrongSwanson · 25/10/2023 23:28

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 25/10/2023 23:27

@WrongSwanson nooo that's awful!! How old was baby when you split?

Very young, and he didn't see her for most of that year (the police helped us leave,.he wasn't a nice man at all).

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 25/10/2023 23:27

@WrongSwanson nooo that's awful!! How old was baby when you split?

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 25/10/2023 23:23

fitzwilliamdarcy · 21/10/2023 21:32

Sorry but mothers and fathers are not equal in their importance to a baby, a mother is more important in the early years of a child’s life

If feminism means not believing this rubbish then thank God for it.

Early weeks yes, years no

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 25/10/2023 23:21

Enidblytonrocks · 21/10/2023 21:27

AIBU to think that all this fuss over Andrew Tate is just a storm in a tea cup? The man seems articulate, well presented, is clearly successful and has some good ideas. I have a son and a daughter and am not worried about either of them hearing his views or feeling inspired by him. I was thinking that as a family we might spend some time watching his videos because honestly, I can’t see what the problem is. Am I missing something?

podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/its-not-you-its-them-but-it-might-be-you-with/id1696313954?i=1000630631149

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 25/10/2023 23:16

ToadOnTheHill · 21/10/2023 21:14

Offer to pick up a saturday job. Then he gets more time with the baby and the lack of childcare costs on that day will offset the pay gap between that and your other job.

He wont want to.

Because most men think childcare is easy but, funnily enough, those men never want to do it. So offer to met him half way and top up the pot. With his extra day off he can spend time with the baby. Oh, wait, it's only "time off" when the woman is doing it.

ETA: really dig in on the offer. Pick up a few leaflets, talk about job opportunities and whether he would prefer you do two mornings/afternoons or a full day etc. Evetually he will back down and agree hed rather have "family time". Dnt be conned into begging by promising to do all the housework on your "day off". This is a negotiation and you know what you want.

Edited

Yes ! You could tutor on Saturday mornings

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 25/10/2023 23:15

Can you work 4.5? Maybe your .5 off could be Friday morning - you spend that with baby then DH comes home and takes her for the afternoon. You both get 1.1 time with baby that day and save a days nursery fees? That should
Help you DH not need to work Saturdays as often or at all

WrongSwanson · 25/10/2023 22:50

Whyohwhywyoming · 25/10/2023 22:42

Yes this. I don’t know why so many people are pretending that mothers and fathers have the same roles when they just don’t. Which is not to say dads are not important / loved / loving. But it’s not the same.

I wish the family courts could get this into their heads. Because cafcass insisted it was fine for my 10 month old to go away to her dad's for a week at a time 🤷‍♀️

AnnaJD · 25/10/2023 22:49

You are not being unreasonable, mums’ relationship with a baby is far more important as you will be his main carer for his first 10 months and most probably doing most of housework too, also you are right - it would be better for the baby to be in your care than anyone else’s, every new mum knows it and I think people who commented otherwise definitely did not recently have young children. What is unreasonable is that cost of living is so high that it requires two people to work on average 5 days a week to survive, I am in similar situation and would give everything to work 4 not 5 days a week and simply cannot afford it. It is simply detrimental to young children well-being and mental health to be separated from mum for 5 days a week.

TheWonderOfLight · 25/10/2023 22:47

My DP and I had a similar argument before I went back to work (I'm also a teacher). I wanted to be a sahm and he wanted me to work FT. Eventually we both compromised and I went back 3 days, which is working well (thankfully we have grandparents to help). You are not being unreasonable to want more time with your young child. No matter what others say on here, babies are biologically wired to need their mums more as babies/young children. However, it does seem hard for your DP to have to work Saturdays. Maybe you can look at your finances and make some cuts, so he can just work 5 days a week?

Swipe left for the next trending thread