Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU if I expect my husband to work more days than me so I can stay at home with our child?

425 replies

Newmumma123 · 21/10/2023 20:32

I am currently 38 weeks pregnant and I am due our first baby in ten days. Me and my husband have been together nearly seven years after meeting online when we were in our late teens.

My husband is an engineer and works 5/6 days a week with a 45 minute commute each way. I am a primary school teacher and I currently work four days a week after cutting down my hours two years ago to support my mum who was diagnosed with BPD but I am now off on MAT leave until June next year. We used to car share to work as we both worked in an area 45 minutes from where we currently live, however when I fell pregnant I decided that I will move to another school closer at the end of my MAT leave so that one of us is close by for our baby who will be in nursery three days and looked after by grandparents two days at that point.

Originally, we discussed the option of me going back five days a week after MAT leave but after talking with other friends and family who are teachers, lots of them have said how stressful it is balancing motherhood and full time work. Over the last few weeks, I have been considering when taking a new job getting a three or four day contract so that I can actually spend sometime looking after the child that I have grown for nine months.

Tonight, I said to my husband that I'd like to go back to work four days after MAT leave instead of five and he said that he would like to only work five days instead of six and that I should go back to work five days so that he can do five days too and doesn't have to work 7 to 12 on a Saturday morning to help bring in a bit more money (cost of living!). If I did four days we would pay one day less a week for childcare and my wages alone pays for childcare/ plus covers my percentage of bills too(this is without the funding that should be coming into place in September 2024) so we should financially be fine if we are careful with money. My husband said to me that our child will miss out on the development but honestly, I feel that I am well equiped to fill that gap as I am early years trained and an educational professional myself plus being the mum (I also don't feel like I should be justifying myself as the mum). My husband is coming across very jealous as he feels we should both work five days so we can both be with our baby on the weekends however I feel that its best for our baby to be with one of us three days out of seven rather than two of us two days out of seven.

My husband has always had this attitude that I get a 'week off' every 6/7 weeks and quite honestly, it annoys me as being a teacher is HARD work physically and mentally. I can't just switch off when I get home. I also don't want to work five days and have someone else look after the child that I have grown and will birth. I want to be with him whilst he is young. My husband has attacked my work ethic and has described me as being 'soft' because I want to be at home.

Alot of this rides on me being able to get a contract for specific days but my husbands attitude is really annoying me. He said why should he have to scarifice time with our baby so I can have more time with him. My answer back was I have scarificed a year out of my career, my pension contributions and my body plus the mental toll of looking after a baby in order for us to have a child. I feel that he should work a bit extra so that I can spend more time with our baby as I am his mummy. We have ended up having an argument as I am very upset as I don't feel like he understands just how important I will be in our childs life and I feel that he is a bit jealous of how much I will be needed more than him by the baby.

AIBU with my feelings of wanting to stay at home with our baby one day a week ? Should I go back to work five days after MAT leave so that we both have an equal amount of time with our ten month old ?

Please help!

OP posts:
RAC208 · 24/10/2023 22:30

How important YOU will be in your child’s life? Will the Dad not be important too?

Daisyblue77 · 24/10/2023 23:07

I cant actually believe some one thinks like this. You do realise the baby has 2 parents??you are getting a whole year off with the baby . Although you see this as a sacrifice, many cant afford to have a year off ,your attitude is disgusting , ive not read such and entitled a s selfish post as this for a while

Cpmlmb · 24/10/2023 23:18

I was an educator and tried taking on full parental roll for 4 years and my husband the bread winner, this damaged their relationship greatly so my experience tells me don’t make the same mistake and damage your child’s need for two present parents.
On another note have you looked at it as you would be working about 156 days a year and your husband about 284 if you did 4 days and husband 6?

Mumof2boys999 · 25/10/2023 09:58

Wait until you have had the baby and the baby is 3-4 months old. At that point, you will know better if you and he are baby-centric or not! Then have a proper sit-down talk about work, childcare and finances and see what works for both of you.

Bellypopper · 25/10/2023 10:42

What is it with teachers? They always think they work harder than anyone else?

Cosyblankets · 25/10/2023 10:53

Bellypopper · 25/10/2023 10:42

What is it with teachers? They always think they work harder than anyone else?

I think this stems from the fact that others think teachers work from 9 until 330. This causes some teachers to go over the top proving their point that they work more than this.
I'm a teacher. I've worked with people who do barely more than the minimum and I've worked with those who have allowed it to take over their life. I'd say most do something in the middle. Many years ago my husband had a city centre 9 to 530 job with 20 days holiday plus bank holidays. I was definitely on a better deal.
Teachers complain about their workload because a lot of the work they have to do is totally pointless and rarely improves the students' learning. It was my reason for leaving.

Annemarie81 · 25/10/2023 11:02

You sound sooooo selfish 😒 🙄
People kick off everyday about dad's not been in their kids lives and here's you trying to kick your husband out of his kids life! I don't understand why you can't both work 5 days so you both get the weekend as a family? With an attitude like this don't be surprised if you end up as a single parent in the not so distant future.....

Catxxxxxxxxxx · 25/10/2023 12:06

It would be fairer if you both cut back, you do 4 days he does 5. Win win. I dont see how on a teacher salary plus another salary of 10k more you cant cut 5 hours of his work a week. And if things are that tight it should have been discussed long before you were due to bring a person into the world to take responsibility for

Springforward1 · 25/10/2023 16:12

ConstancetheGardener · 24/10/2023 20:42

What is he , just the sperm donor or an equal partner in your forthcoming adventure.You seem to consider your husband's role as a father much less important than yours as a mother. No wonder men feel excluded from child rearing with attitudes like that and then react accordingly.

In my experience the vast majority of fathers are delighted when mum takes the lead in parenting & the vast majority of mothers are happy with this . My DH is a brilliant father & when ours were children they loved us equally & still do as young adults. When they were sick it was mummy they cried for. All perfectly normal when its a mother & father situation. It's not a competition.

Sofaz34 · 25/10/2023 16:51

It sounds like a big part of this is that you don't want to work 5 days a week because your job is tough. Nothing wrong with that but you can't keep saying it's because you are the mum and your husband probably feels the exact same way and him having to work 6 days while you work 4 is unfair. You get the maternity leave and then it should be equal after that point or discussed and agree by both of you. If its due to money, you need to have a talk about what's affordable and not just put it down to you being the mum so getting your own way. As someone else said, this isn't a good way to start and you will not be able to complain if your husband becomes distant to both you and the baby when you want time off. He will just say you are the mum, you look after him.

Curlyfifteen · 25/10/2023 17:03

Neither of you seem to be focused on the main issue here which is…

what is best for the baby?

of course this question does depend on being able to afford choices.

Personally i think less time in nursery and more time with parents or grandparents is best until childcare becomes more of an educational experience around the age of 3.

i would look at costs and see if you can move somewhere cheaper where u both can work 4 days and each of you have a solo day with baby and possibly cut out nursery costs alltogether with help of grandparents/childminder.

neither of you are totally right or wrong here.

as much as we want equal for men and women they are not the same.

for some women motherly instincts may compel you to want to be home with baby for a longer time than mat leave. This is a natural and biological desire. It doesnt happen to everyone but it did happen to me and luckily i was in a financial position to follow what i felt was good for me and baby. It already sounds like you may feel like this when the time comes.

you and your partner need to discuss what your options are before baby comes. What you do next is individual there isnt a right or wrong but you both need to be happy/compromise.

UnsocialBat · 25/10/2023 17:15

First off, I'm a teacher as well and I totally relate to your feeling annoyed by attitudes towards us "always having a week off"! But that's about as far as I can relate. Neither of you seem to have a great attitude on this issue (yours seemingly that he isn't as important as you, and his seemingly that you've got it so easy) and you don't sound like you're communicating well with each other. Neither one can decide by themselves what will happen moving forward, it needs to be a joint decision. You say you're happy to cut back on things like holidays, but is he? If he's working 5/6 days a week he's probably not going to be thrilled at the idea he can't even get a nice holiday away. From his perspective it sounds a bit like he's being asked to do more and more to provide a life for you that he doesn't get to properly enjoy alongside you (because he's at work or likely physically/mentally tired after work).

I think you need to try to sit down together and talk this through again to come to an agreement together. Take emotion out of it, look at the numbers. Write down his wages for 4, 5, 6 days, and yours for 3, 4, 5 days. Write down childcare costs per day and each of your other expenses. Then work out where you might both be willing to compromise on spending so that you can afford for both of you to work slightly fewer hours (maybe you on 4 days and him on 5?). I'd also recommend taking a look at your own work-life balance. Just because others don't have a great balance and struggle to manage teaching 5 days and having a family, doesn't mean that you can't have a better balance to manage it!! I know very few teachers who don't work 5 days.

FosterMommy13 · 25/10/2023 17:28

Doesn’t seem fair at all that you get extra time with the baby because you’re his mummy…..your DP is his daddy! Neither are more important plus you get all your maternity leave with baby whereas DP will miss out on that. YABU 100% in my opinion and really unfair :-(

Coffeerum · 25/10/2023 20:06

@Dontworkmidweek My husband seems to have become a house wife as he wfh in his start up while I take unpaid maternity leave. Personally I think he should be getting a second job.

You might find yourself having to get a second job when you end up as a single parent!

LeedsMum87 · 25/10/2023 20:54

its reasonable to want to reduce your days when you go back to work, lots of parents do. But I do think it’s fair of your husband to also want to cut his hours to spend more time with his baby too. We sadly don’t have grandparents around to help with childcare so my husband and I both reduced our hours when I returned to work after maternity leave. He has her on a Monday, she goes to nursery Tuesday, Weds, Thurs and then I have her Fridays. I think it’s really important we get equal time with her. Yes, we’ve taken a hit financially, especially as I’m the higher earner but totally worth it.

Clariee45 · 25/10/2023 21:00

Do you both really need to work full time?? Could you not move away, downsize or cut down on anything to enable you to both work part time?

JST88 · 25/10/2023 21:03

Wait until the baby comes and he sees how hard work it is! Lol.

no but seriously, people will say look at his perspective etc. But there’s a very big difference between mums and dads, my DH is the best dad in the world and has the strongest bond ever, babies still want their mums, it’s so important for their development to have the strong bond and attachment that you have as mother and baby nurtured and I think you’re spot on with your line of thought, it’s going to be more beneficial to the baby to be with you 3 days per week than have your husband for the Sat morning. Plus, by the time the baby is ready to go out and do anything he’ll be finishing work and won’t miss out on things with you both.

Stick to your guns you’re totally right!

Findinganewme · 25/10/2023 21:14

I don’t think that either of you are unreasonable. I think that your values don’t align.

Some families have a stay at home mum, a few have a stay at home dad. Many mums I know work part time, others work full time. Some families have a nanny, some use grandparents. The point is, that the couple who are the parents, must be aligned. The values have to be aligned.

i think that you and your partner need to discuss and work through an understanding of your values and then try and balance those with your finances.

in some families, the father is away / working a lot, whilst mum is available and it sounds like that’s what you want, but your husband wants to be involved and have more equal parenting. Both of you are right in your own ways, but together you’re wrong, right now.

Skiggles2018 · 25/10/2023 21:29

YABU to see you wanting to be with baby is more important than him wanting more time with baby.
However if you’re the one willing to cut back then that’s fair but make it cutting back enough so you can both feel like you’re getting some extra time.

I think you may also find part time contracts for teachers can be tough to find - usually they’re given to teachers who have been in a school for a while (unless you’re lucky to spot a job share come up because someone in a school is dropping to part time).

I am a teacher so I know the workload is crazy and I honestly don’t know how full time parents do it and have a work life balance. However it does start to get easier when they’re sleeping better, getting less illnesses than the initial constant nursery sickness.
I can definitely see why you want to go part time, as the job is tough if it’s not you’re all. But you can’t see you as part time more important than your partner getting two full days off with baby. Trust me you’ll want him there at the weekend to tag in and give each other breaks, lie ins and so if baby is up in the night you can share the load (if one has work then the other needs to do the night wakes).

Snowdayplease · 25/10/2023 21:37

FosterMommy13 · 25/10/2023 17:28

Doesn’t seem fair at all that you get extra time with the baby because you’re his mummy…..your DP is his daddy! Neither are more important plus you get all your maternity leave with baby whereas DP will miss out on that. YABU 100% in my opinion and really unfair :-(

Ask the small baby which parent they'd prefer.

FosterMommy13 · 25/10/2023 21:40

Snowdayplease · 25/10/2023 21:37

Ask the small baby which parent they'd prefer.

How do you mean sorry? I’ve not understood your reply to my comment :-/

Snowdayplease · 25/10/2023 21:40

Do you genuinely need that much money - two full time salaries that both pay (reasonably) well?
It seems odd he was onboard with you dropping a day's pay to help your mum but not your child. I'm guessing if he's a 45 minute commute he won't be the one doing drop offs and pick ups?
But at least he will he around for all the evenings that you need to work.

Snowdayplease · 25/10/2023 21:41

Fostermummy13 I was suggesting that most small infants would prefer to be cared by the person who has been caring for them for the last year, ie their primary carer, which is almost always the woman.
If breastfeeding there are even more reasons for them to want their mum to be on hand!

FosterMommy13 · 25/10/2023 21:46

Snowdayplease · 25/10/2023 21:41

Fostermummy13 I was suggesting that most small infants would prefer to be cared by the person who has been caring for them for the last year, ie their primary carer, which is almost always the woman.
If breastfeeding there are even more reasons for them to want their mum to be on hand!

Edited

Ahh ok, I understand now. I do get that reason. I think maybe it was just how OP worded her post - it came across very much to me that she was thinking she as mummy was more important than him as daddy.
I don’t think little one would suffer in anyway during the time with daddy though so I still think when the time comes, it’s only fair for both to have the same time and not to expect dad to miss out when it could be equal :-)

Whyohwhywyoming · 25/10/2023 22:42

Springforward1 · 25/10/2023 16:12

In my experience the vast majority of fathers are delighted when mum takes the lead in parenting & the vast majority of mothers are happy with this . My DH is a brilliant father & when ours were children they loved us equally & still do as young adults. When they were sick it was mummy they cried for. All perfectly normal when its a mother & father situation. It's not a competition.

Yes this. I don’t know why so many people are pretending that mothers and fathers have the same roles when they just don’t. Which is not to say dads are not important / loved / loving. But it’s not the same.