Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

is dp reasonable to not want to continue dating because I won’t take off my bra?

264 replies

ReeseRose · 09/10/2023 10:36

namechanged for obvious reasons and going to try and keep this short. I lost a lot of weight some years ago now, it was a couple years before I met dp (I guess my boyfriend but that sounds extremely juvenile) who I have been with for 6 months but known for almost 2 years. I had abdominal skin removed before we started dating and honestly I am definitely still full of imperfections and my boobs are very deflated (I’m in my 20s so it’s definitely a big insecurity) so I have always kept a bra on. He’s never been a fan of that but tries to be understanding the thing is, he’s made it worse by always complimenting them in a bra/clothes like they obviously look completely different to if they weren’t and I don’t think he understands how bad they may look and therefore it’s making it even worse for me. I will honestly have them lifted (no implants) soon but he’s going on about how he doesn’t actually think it’s necessary based on “how they look in a bra” WELL NO SHIT. I just don’t want the self esteem crush of getting them out and him agreeing with me or something. Plus; it would just make me feel uncomfortable. Am I being unreasonable though? Like is this a dealbreaker to most men? I think he should just accept it how it is because I don’t see how it’s the biggest deal in the world, especially when lingerie is known to be attractive and perfectly reasonable to wear in the bedroom.

OP posts:
TemporarilyshyAF · 09/10/2023 11:23

He can leave for any reason and if this is because not being naked in bed makes him feel not trusted or whatever that's fine. Please don't let this affect your self esteem more. It is an impasse that you're both entitled not to be happy with. What is he like in terms of being understanding, compassionate, wise and caring apart from the bra issue? Your self consciousness is very heightened and he hasn't been very reassuring that it's not about how they look, it's about being close to you and now he's made it all a big thing. You've made huge physical changes and mental ones are following. If this man isn't quite understanding of that in his approach (not that I don't get his view) then he may not be quite the one for you. No shame in that.

If you think he is great for you in every other way but you've tripped over each other's feet on the bra subject then it may be worth discussing again and seeing if you can really hear each other but if he is simply not listening and you have shut down on it then I'm not sure it's worth it after 6 months. Don't undo your hard work on yourself.

Mamma2017 · 09/10/2023 11:26

Malificent1 · 09/10/2023 10:58

The responses on this thread! My god. Bottom line, your body, your choice.

Any dickhead telling me he was going to break up with me because he couldn’t see my tits would be dropped so fast his head would spin. What a prince.

This!!! These posters saying he’s entitled to see you without your bra on- no he is not! Yes he’s entitled to leave of course he is but OP any man that leaves for that reason-as in can’t show understanding & compassion towards you and wants to dump you because he can’t see your tits- isn’t worth being with anyway.

margotrose · 09/10/2023 11:27

Neither of you are unreasonable.

He wants a relationship where he can be more intimate and wants to see his partner naked - that's totally valid.

You're not comfortable with that right now and feel as though he's pressuring you - that's valid too.

Unfortunately your points of view just don't match which may well be a dealbreaker and that's okay. You won't be compatible with everyone you date/

Roughashouses · 09/10/2023 11:29

Yes, it's unreasonable of him to try and emotionally blackmail you into doing something you're not comfortable with. He sounds revolting.

RenegadeMrs · 09/10/2023 11:30

Eh. I don't think either of your stances are unresonable. I understand what it is like to be uncomfortable in my body after its undergone some big changes. But I also think I would not be happy with someone who wasn't happy to be naked round me. It speaks to trust and intamacy. After all, this isn't some random on the street wanting to see you, it's your partner.

I think that if neither of you can get past your own perspectives and find accpetance or a compromise you probably need to split.

OneTC · 09/10/2023 11:32

How much of ourselves we choose to show to anyone is our own choice and ours alone. If someone can't live with that that's on them.

Although I can understand wanting to be completely naked and intimate with someone I cannot understand wanting to remove something from them that gave them comfort for whatever reason.

Branleuse · 09/10/2023 11:32

how close are you to realistically getting the boob job you want.
i had massively sagging boobs after breastfeeding and weight fluctuation. I used to be so massively preoccupied with it and felt ashamed and deformed.
i ended up getting an uplift and implants for shape, and I think it really was important for my confidence. I used to actually seriously hate them. It was upsetting me with such frequency. Its meant that I rarely think about them anymore or if i do, its positive.
I consider it reconstructive surgery. Nobody would be judgy if someone had a reconstruction after a mastectomy, or got a broken nose fixed, so i dont know why people try and discourage breast surgery for this reason. Counselling might be helpful too, but i dont see the point in going through all youve been through with weight loss, to have to now live with all the extra skin must be hard.

MCOut · 09/10/2023 11:32

I lost 25kg and while I love being smaller and still have a way to go I hate my breasts. There is absolutely nothing wrong with being self-conscious about it. Similarly getting cosmetic surgery after huge weight loss is normal. Some of the comments here are absolutely ridiculous, even the smallest and fittest amongst us will get body conscious from time to time.

OP this is not the man for you. He is at liberty to make whatever decisions he wants, but this shows you he prioritises his gratification over your feelings. I guarantee you with the right man eventually you will be less self-conscious about it without being pressurised.

fivenonrouses · 09/10/2023 11:33

DragonDoor · 09/10/2023 11:10

That’s a horrible ultimatum for him to have given you, especially as he knows you are insecure about that part of your body.

Either he really doesn’t care about how you feel, or doesn’t have the ability to feel empathy. He is only interested in his own gratification.

This is such a red flag. Don’t spend anymore of your time with a man like this.

Posters who have said you are being unreasonable are being absurd. It’s your body, he doesn’t have a right to it.

People are not saying she is unreasonable not to remove her bras for him.
People are saying she is unreasonable not to remove her bras for him and expect him to still want to be in a relationship.

He doesn't have a right to it, but she, on the other hand, isn't entitled to a relationship with him.
If x,y,z reasons OP doesn't want to do something, she's 100% in her right not to.
If x,y,z reasons are dealbreakers for him he's perfectly reasonable to walk away..

For me personally, I'd consider the whole thing too much trouble for a relationship of just 6 months and just end it with him and start over again once I was more confident in the way I looked (after the surgery or whatever).

beastlyslumber · 09/10/2023 11:34

Congratulations on your incredible weight loss, OP. That's such an achievement! You should be really proud of yourself.

As for your boyfriend - ugh. I'd just dump him to be honest. He clearly doesn't understand, and he's threatening you that he'll leave unless he sees your boobs - this is unacceptable. You deserve someone who accepts you as you are and would never put pressure on you to feel uncomfortable, especially sexually.

Throw this one back and find a nice man who doesn't mind taking things at your pace.

5128gap · 09/10/2023 11:34

Ignore people trying to pathologise what they don't understand OP. You don't need to have self esteem issues requiring therapy to be self conscious about looking very different in clothes to without. I get it completely.
And yes it would be absolutely lovely to be able to throw your inhibitions (and bra!) out of the window to empower yourself. However, sex is not an endurance test where you have a duty to overcome your self consciousness for the greater good. Its supposed to be fun and relaxed and comfortable. If you need a bra on to enjoy it, he should respect that.
I imagine that he doesn't understand and sees you as holding back on him, or imagines that he will be able to completely change your views with his reassurance. You need to explain that there's nothing psychologically wrong with you that he can fix, that you're entitled to share your body with him how you see fit, and within your comfort zone, and that he takes it or leaves it.

Pinkdelight3 · 09/10/2023 11:36

I think the people reducing this to him being an arse because he 'can't see her tits' are over-simplifying somewhat. It's clearly impacting their relationship in bigger ways e.g.

tries to be understanding the thing is, he’s made it worse by always complimenting them in a bra/clothes like they obviously look completely different to if they weren’t and I don’t think he understands how bad they may look and therefore it’s making it even worse for me.

It's become this thing the OP is understandably very sensitive about and he's trying to be sensitive about it and making it worse, so it becomes more of thing and so on. It's not 'show me your tits or I'll go'. Even the comment about him never getting to see how she actually looks feels more like when men lament that a DP won't be seen without make-up on. It's a mode of being with your DP that isn't happening in this situation and won't happen even after surgery. Which is OP's absolute prerogative, but it's sad for both her and DP if it's otherwise a good relationship, and she has framed it that way regardless of how some are taking it.

AliciaJohnson · 09/10/2023 11:37

Congratulations on the weight loss - that's a fantastic achievement.

I honestly wouldn't worry about what your boobs look like. There is far more to intimacy than what your body physically looks like. That's probably what's bothering your DP - he wants to be intimate (as in be genuinely intimate, not as in 'have sex') but you aren't confident enough with that. My DP and I are far from physically perfect, but I'd be quite upset if he refused to take his shirt off because he's overweight (which he is) and didn't want me to see his stomach.

So I don't think your DP is being unreasonable for ending it as you can't give him the intimacy he wants, but I suppose you're not being unreasonable either, given that you can't overcome this hang-up. If I were you, I'd just celebrate no longer being overweight, even if it means you've got saggy boobs.

LodiDodi · 09/10/2023 11:37

Do what you want to do OP, if that means covering your boobs then do so. If it's such a huge issue for him then the relationship probably won't last anyway. I'm sorry you're suffering because of this, it isn't fair especially considering how hard you must have worked to become a healthier weight. I hope that you can be happier in yourself, however that looks for you.

Daffodil18 · 09/10/2023 11:38

I understand your point of view however even if he agrees with you, if he is loving and supportive then he will be there for you, because you’ve said you are going to have surgery on them anyway.

JaxiiTaxii · 09/10/2023 11:39

Anyone who blackmails someone into doing something through threats of leaving unless you do what they want is IMO abusive. It's your body, it's not a democracy where he gets a say, it's a dictatorship and only you get to chose.

BUT I can understand that it would hurt that someone you love won't share themselves with you because they're scared of your reaction. It's pretty much saying you think they're shallow and only want you for your appearance.

Only you can sift through which of these apply to your boyfriend, but IMO anyone who would throw away a loving, supportive, otherwise healthy relationship because their partner has an isolated issue with one body part which affects nothing except seeing that body part naked, is an idiot.

Fionaville · 09/10/2023 11:41

I get everything you've said OP. Honestly though, I think you should just go for it and get your boobs out for him. You are denying him the chance to show that he loves every part of you. What's the worst that can happen? He's disgusted by your boobs and can't bring himself to stay in a relationship with you? I really don't think that's going to happen. But so what if it did? You are disgusted in your own boobs and think that they are a relationship breaker.
Or he'll agree that you need surgery? Again, so what? You already think you do and plan to anyway.
Just give him the chance to show that he loves every part of you. He might be hurt that you think hes so shallow. And skin to skin contact is so much better than wearing underwear to bed.

fivenonrouses · 09/10/2023 11:41

JaxiiTaxii · 09/10/2023 11:39

Anyone who blackmails someone into doing something through threats of leaving unless you do what they want is IMO abusive. It's your body, it's not a democracy where he gets a say, it's a dictatorship and only you get to chose.

BUT I can understand that it would hurt that someone you love won't share themselves with you because they're scared of your reaction. It's pretty much saying you think they're shallow and only want you for your appearance.

Only you can sift through which of these apply to your boyfriend, but IMO anyone who would throw away a loving, supportive, otherwise healthy relationship because their partner has an isolated issue with one body part which affects nothing except seeing that body part naked, is an idiot.

Forcing someone to stay in a relationship and expecting them to handle the burden of whatever you have been through in the past, to me, is abusive.

At 6 months imo you'll still testing the waters.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 09/10/2023 11:41

ReeseRose · 09/10/2023 11:07

I’m hoping the breast lift will honestly be done next year, I’m saving still. He has said he gets it will be temporary but feels hard done by that even when that’s done and he can see those, he will never have seen my “actual boobs” I’ve told him I’m only having them lifted and they are no different to calling what I have not my actual boobs either considering all the skin and he just seems annoyed that I’m not comfortable to show them now

I think any man who gets annoyed at not being able to see their partner's body parts, particularly after pressuring them about a part that they are uncomfortable about, is not a man to stay with.

I actually think YOU should end it with HIM.

Kisskiss · 09/10/2023 11:42

ReeseRose · 09/10/2023 10:42

I think it’s unreasonable to comment that my self esteem issues are extreme. It’s difficult losing so much weight and being left in a body of a 90 year old lady in your 20s. It doesn’t mean I’m just a walking anxiety ridden person who can’t function in their body because of how I feel. Counselling isn’t going to change the fact I have boobs of a 90 year old in my 20s and I’m pretty confident most people wouldn’t exactly be jumping at the idea of someone seeing them and clearly never being able to find them sexy. It just is what it is.

yes, he has said if it continues like this, he doesn’t think the relationship can continue

If he’s serious about wanting to dump you because you won’t take your bra off then it’s a massive red flag and you should dump him now. He’s showing very little empathy and support for your reasons tbh

1month · 09/10/2023 11:42

I completely understand where you’re coming from and I think some posters don’t understand what boobs look like after a massive weight loss or after BF multiple kids.

But I also understand where he’s coming from as I would feel upset that I couldn’t see my DP naked and would feel that him being so uncomfortable around me means that’s he’s not as into me as I am off him.

If it was me I would compromise.
Tell him you aren’t going to take your bra off when you have sex, else you won’t be able to enjoy the sex but you don’t mind taking it off in front of him when you’re getting changed etc.

He just wants you to be open and comfortable around him, which is fair enough but unless someone has ever been insecure about something they can’t ever understand how you truly feel.

ThinWomansBrain · 09/10/2023 11:46

Wow, huge congratulations on losing so much weight.

It makes me feel so sad that you are still adversely affected by your body image, but I hope that you get to a place where you feel more comfortable with your body.

Niinja · 09/10/2023 11:49

I think it's ok for you to split up over this. But your future together would not look any brighter if you took off your bra for him. Giving in to blackmail is never a solid foundation for a relationship.

YANBU to draw your own boundaries and keep private whatever parts of your body you wish. He is free to decide that touching naked boobs is a non-negotiable for him and therefore you're not the right person for him. What is not OK is this blackmail thing - show them to me or else.

Cosycardigans · 09/10/2023 11:49

I'm on your side OP. Imagine if the man had a life changing scar somewhere which he kept covered up and OP was saying she would leave the relationship, if he didn't show her before surgery to improve it, next year.

PyramusandThisbe · 09/10/2023 11:49

1month · 09/10/2023 11:42

I completely understand where you’re coming from and I think some posters don’t understand what boobs look like after a massive weight loss or after BF multiple kids.

But I also understand where he’s coming from as I would feel upset that I couldn’t see my DP naked and would feel that him being so uncomfortable around me means that’s he’s not as into me as I am off him.

If it was me I would compromise.
Tell him you aren’t going to take your bra off when you have sex, else you won’t be able to enjoy the sex but you don’t mind taking it off in front of him when you’re getting changed etc.

He just wants you to be open and comfortable around him, which is fair enough but unless someone has ever been insecure about something they can’t ever understand how you truly feel.

I perfectly understand how the OP feels, but it's her boyfriend's choice whether he wants to deal with this level of insecurity/body issues etc in a fairly new relationship.

I think it’s unreasonable to comment that my self esteem issues are extreme. It’s difficult losing so much weight and being left in a body of a 90 year old lady in your 20s. It doesn’t mean I’m just a walking anxiety ridden person who can’t function in their body because of how I feel. Counselling isn’t going to change the fact I have boobs of a 90 year old in my 20s and I’m pretty confident most people wouldn’t exactly be jumping at the idea of someone seeing them and clearly never being able to find them sexy. It just is what it is.

yes, he has said if it continues like this, he doesn’t think the relationship can continue

Not unreasonable for you to feel any of this, but he has a perfect right to decide that this isn't something he wants to deal with.

I certainly wouldn't have wanted to deal with significant body issues in a new relationship in my 20s. It would be a different matter in a longterm relationship where I already loved and was committed to the person.