Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

is dp reasonable to not want to continue dating because I won’t take off my bra?

264 replies

ReeseRose · 09/10/2023 10:36

namechanged for obvious reasons and going to try and keep this short. I lost a lot of weight some years ago now, it was a couple years before I met dp (I guess my boyfriend but that sounds extremely juvenile) who I have been with for 6 months but known for almost 2 years. I had abdominal skin removed before we started dating and honestly I am definitely still full of imperfections and my boobs are very deflated (I’m in my 20s so it’s definitely a big insecurity) so I have always kept a bra on. He’s never been a fan of that but tries to be understanding the thing is, he’s made it worse by always complimenting them in a bra/clothes like they obviously look completely different to if they weren’t and I don’t think he understands how bad they may look and therefore it’s making it even worse for me. I will honestly have them lifted (no implants) soon but he’s going on about how he doesn’t actually think it’s necessary based on “how they look in a bra” WELL NO SHIT. I just don’t want the self esteem crush of getting them out and him agreeing with me or something. Plus; it would just make me feel uncomfortable. Am I being unreasonable though? Like is this a dealbreaker to most men? I think he should just accept it how it is because I don’t see how it’s the biggest deal in the world, especially when lingerie is known to be attractive and perfectly reasonable to wear in the bedroom.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
5128gap · 12/10/2023 07:25

Carpediemmakeitcount · 12/10/2023 00:37

Get to the point what are you really trying to say because your post sounds dangerous.

I'm not sure how I can make myself clearer. Perhaps if you specify what exactly you feel endangered by?

Alwayswildatheart · 12/10/2023 00:41

Congratulations OP on your amazing weight loss. So sorry. You are not being unreasonable at all.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 12/10/2023 00:37

5128gap · 11/10/2023 14:10

He 'said he feels hard done by'
He 'seems annoyed I'm not comfortable'
He 'feels as my partner he should get to see them now'
He's 'making a big deal...throwing in about leaving...'
Sounds a lot less like a mature man 'protecting boundaries' and 'stating his intent' than a guy who thinks he's being denied his due rights to a woman's body, so is playing his face and threatening to leave ('throwing it in' note, not actually doing it!) until she changes her mind.

Get to the point what are you really trying to say because your post sounds dangerous.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 12/10/2023 00:34

AliceOlive · 10/10/2023 17:35

She’s telling him how she feels about taking her bra off. Not how he would feel about it.

She would not be comfortable doing this even if he liked what he saw. How can you not understand this? Our experience of sex and physical intimacy isn’t all about how a man feels.

Simple answer is find one that does because you and the op can't change how another person feels be it man or woman. You find someone who will put up with you and will be understanding. Why would you be with someone who makes you feel uncomfortable. I don't get it.

Mari9999 · 11/10/2023 23:40

It is offensive and disrespectful to real victims of abuse and coercion to have these terms tossed around as if they are just so many buzz words to be applied to any behavior where there is a difference of opinion or not unreasonable expectation.

5128gap · 11/10/2023 14:10

He 'said he feels hard done by'
He 'seems annoyed I'm not comfortable'
He 'feels as my partner he should get to see them now'
He's 'making a big deal...throwing in about leaving...'
Sounds a lot less like a mature man 'protecting boundaries' and 'stating his intent' than a guy who thinks he's being denied his due rights to a woman's body, so is playing his face and threatening to leave ('throwing it in' note, not actually doing it!) until she changes her mind.

BrightGreenMoonBuggy · 11/10/2023 14:09

Being very realistic, if you’ve lost 15/16 stone you will have loose skin / stretch marks / scars in places which he’s already seen so I genuinely can’t imagine for a moment that he’s going to expect wonderful perky implant-style breasts. It should be obvious that your breasts won’t be full. Same with any silly bloke who thinks post-breastfeeding boobs should still defy gravity. I truly think he’s already totally comfortable with the way you look and just wants you to feel comfortable with him too. I don’t think your breasts will horrify him or cause him to end things - It just sounds like he wants you to not feel worried that he won’t accept you. Chat to him about this so he understands exactly what the nature of the issue is. His reaction then will be the one to go by. Having a partner who loves your body no matter what it’s been through - good, bad, injury, operation - is what everyone deserves really.

svccld · 11/10/2023 13:51

No question it's unreasonable to the OP but objectively, taking a bra off when intimate with a partner is not on the same level as as underaged girl being coerced into sex.

And whilst op confirmed her partner has said he'll leave the relationship, nowhere has she said he's "threatened". There is a big difference between "take off your bra or we're over" and "I want to to feel comfortable with me and if you don't there's no way forward". We don't know how the partner has expressed this but op hasn't used the word threaten and has said he's been understanding.

So the answer remains, no he's not unreasonable to leave the relationship (in his 20's and only a matter of months in) if it's not working for him. But yes he does need to leave

5128gap · 11/10/2023 13:24

svccld · 11/10/2023 13:06

Those are vastly different sets of circumstances @5128gap. OP said herself her boyfriend has tried to be understanding.

I don't think it helps the op nor victims of coercion to think of this situation as coercive.

They're only 'vastly different' because people are imposing their own subjective views of what is a reasonable request. The request is unreasonable to the OP and her refusal should be respected. He needs to either leave her,or stay and accept it not keep cajoling persuading and threatening.

svccld · 11/10/2023 13:06

Those are vastly different sets of circumstances @5128gap. OP said herself her boyfriend has tried to be understanding.

I don't think it helps the op nor victims of coercion to think of this situation as coercive.

Stravaig · 11/10/2023 10:19

I don't see that you can 'threaten to leave' someone you've only been dating for 6 months. Dating is by nature an ongoing discovery, an experimental sharing of time, only for as long as it suits both people. You simply decide not to continue, because it is no longer fun, interesting, rewarding, healthy.

Foisting a fairytale happy-ever-after onto every date/every kind of relationship is the problem, instead of just discovering what is really there.

5128gap · 11/10/2023 10:11

Mari9999 · 10/10/2023 22:34

@saffronsoup
Saying that you are unwilling to remain in a relationship if xyz does not happen is neither coercive or threatening. It is just a clear statement of your boundaries. Just as the OP saying that she would leave a relationship in which her lover expected to see her naked. That too is just a clear statement of her boundaries. Neither is exerting force or threat. No one is entitled to relationship, a relationship requires mutual agreement to begin and on going mutual agreement to be sustained.

The exiting partner is not taking anything that belongs to the other party; they are only removing their person and their presence.

Its not that simple. If it was, there would be no such thing as coercion would there? Everything would simply be a 'statement of intent' and 'boundaries'.
People persuade other people to do all manner of things under threat of leaving them. From the 15 year old threatening to dump his girlfriend if she doesn't have sex, to the spouses who threaten divorce if their partner doesn't lose weight.
Wanting to see your girlfriend bra less is no more your 'boundary' than wanting her to dress in leather or wash your pants. You're not defending something of yours, you're requesting something from her, to move into her territory if you like, around which she may have erected a boundary.

Mari9999 · 10/10/2023 22:34

@saffronsoup
Saying that you are unwilling to remain in a relationship if xyz does not happen is neither coercive or threatening. It is just a clear statement of your boundaries. Just as the OP saying that she would leave a relationship in which her lover expected to see her naked. That too is just a clear statement of her boundaries. Neither is exerting force or threat. No one is entitled to relationship, a relationship requires mutual agreement to begin and on going mutual agreement to be sustained.

The exiting partner is not taking anything that belongs to the other party; they are only removing their person and their presence.

Americano75 · 10/10/2023 18:19

I totally get how you feel OP, I had a mastectomy and reconstruction some years ago and no one but my husband is allowed to see. If I had decided from day one that he wouldn't ever see me without a bra again then he have respected my decision.

They're your breasts, your boundaries. Don't be pressured into anything you're not comfortable with.

AliceOlive · 10/10/2023 17:35

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 10/10/2023 15:11

He's not coercing her though.

He's simply said that he wants to end the relationship.

Someone can end a relationship for any damn reason they want.

She HAS made his mind up for him.

He hasn't demanded she does anything. I also wouldn't want to be with someone who tells me how I would feel about something. I wouldn't demand they let me experience the thing so I can make my own mind up, but I wouldn't want someone dictating how I will feel about something, especially someone I love and I would choose to end the relationship too.

She’s telling him how she feels about taking her bra off. Not how he would feel about it.

She would not be comfortable doing this even if he liked what he saw. How can you not understand this? Our experience of sex and physical intimacy isn’t all about how a man feels.

Mamma2017 · 10/10/2023 17:26

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 10/10/2023 15:11

He's not coercing her though.

He's simply said that he wants to end the relationship.

Someone can end a relationship for any damn reason they want.

She HAS made his mind up for him.

He hasn't demanded she does anything. I also wouldn't want to be with someone who tells me how I would feel about something. I wouldn't demand they let me experience the thing so I can make my own mind up, but I wouldn't want someone dictating how I will feel about something, especially someone I love and I would choose to end the relationship too.

Her not wanting to remove her bra because of her own deep insecurity and dislike of her body IS NOT equal to her “dictating” how he will feel about it. At all. It’s about how she feels about it-there’s no dictating her on her part whatsoever-she simply doesn’t want to take her bra off.

saffronsoup · 10/10/2023 16:28

5128gap · 10/10/2023 15:24

If he wants to end the relationship because he only wants sex with bra less women, or he feels there's 'mistrust' or 'self esteem issues' or whatever else people imagine might be behind it, well, I'm sure he can find the door.
But no, instead of just walking through it, he's sticking around continuing the relationship and threatening to walk if the OP doesn't take her bra off. Its the threat that's coercive not ending the relationship.

It is also called communication. Telling each other how you feel is an important part of a relationship. If he just walked out the door and never told her what was concerning or bothering him - that woul dbe far worse.

There is nothing wrong with voicing opinions or feelings and communicating in a relationship about what aspects are working for you or not working for you. He is being a mature adult. If she is adament that no, he will never see or touch her breasts - they are off limits to him. He can now choose what to do with that information and he can let her know that he doesn't feel that is healthy and likely means this isn't a relationship he can stay in.

5128gap · 10/10/2023 15:24

If he wants to end the relationship because he only wants sex with bra less women, or he feels there's 'mistrust' or 'self esteem issues' or whatever else people imagine might be behind it, well, I'm sure he can find the door.
But no, instead of just walking through it, he's sticking around continuing the relationship and threatening to walk if the OP doesn't take her bra off. Its the threat that's coercive not ending the relationship.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 10/10/2023 15:11

Mamma2017 · 09/10/2023 15:08

How can a person get something so wrong and backwards. Are you for real? It’s not up to her to make his mind up for him?? Hang on. How have you got her not taking her bra off because she doesn’t want to -because of the way SHE feels about HER breasts- translating as she is making his mind up for him?? It’s nothing to do with how he will feel seeing her breasts- it’s everything about how SHE feels showing her breasts! Regardless of his reaction.
She is not “making his mind up for him” at all… she does not want to show her breasts because of how SHE feels about them!
.
He is crossing her boundaries trying to coerce her into doing something she doesn’t feel comfortable by threatening to leave. Regardless of his potential reaction she shouldn’t be made to do something she doesn’t want to do. Simple as. It’s nothing to do with not trusting him it’s to do with not being comfortable regardless of his reaction-she just doesn’t want to take her bra off. Her personal choice it is an extremely sensitive issue to her and if he cared about her and loved her he would respect that.

He's not coercing her though.

He's simply said that he wants to end the relationship.

Someone can end a relationship for any damn reason they want.

She HAS made his mind up for him.

He hasn't demanded she does anything. I also wouldn't want to be with someone who tells me how I would feel about something. I wouldn't demand they let me experience the thing so I can make my own mind up, but I wouldn't want someone dictating how I will feel about something, especially someone I love and I would choose to end the relationship too.

AliceOlive · 10/10/2023 14:56

Justwrong68 · 10/10/2023 14:09

I tend to agree here. But I'm of the personality that likes to rip the bandaid off as fast as possible

I feel the opposite. Rather have someone leave me for not doing something that I don’t want to do. Rather than leaving me after I did something for them that I didn’t want to do and which made me extremely uncomfortable.

We all have limits and boundaries. A loving partner doesn’t push them for their own sexual gratification.

Bangwam1 · 10/10/2023 14:49

I know how it is, in the same situation, I hate not having a bra on. It’s easy for people to say just love yourself when they haven’t experienced it. It’s soul destroying to put that work in, lose weight and feel even uglier.

I'm trying this, hoping it works with consistency and other exercise. But if I need to get a doctor, I will because living hating yourself is just not worth it. I completely get you x

As for your partner, if he is the one he will be patient with you.

How to lift Sagging Breast

Disclaimer: The Content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical.advice.Bad posture forces your breasts to sit in an unnatural position fo...

https://youtu.be/UzbRKM7dNGk?si=tThjcUSNvrEgfTDs

Justwrong68 · 10/10/2023 14:09

neilyoungismyhero · 09/10/2023 17:48

If you don't take it off he's going to leave you.
If you do take it off you think he will be horrified and leave you. You might as well get it over with and let them loose and say you wanted it you've got it mate..now what? See what happens.
It's your choice though.
Congratulations on the weightless that's awesome.

I tend to agree here. But I'm of the personality that likes to rip the bandaid off as fast as possible

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 10/10/2023 00:23

You’re not at all unreasonable for not wanting to bare yourself. Your right. But also your responsibility. You don’t get to call him unreasonable for not wanting to accept the consequences of YOUR choice. He doesn’t have to accept them. You do. It’s your choice.

Deathbyfluffy · 10/10/2023 00:11

Willyoujustbequiet · 09/10/2023 10:47

Honestly the majority of men couldn't give a shit what they look like.

Man here - I agree.
Far more interested in the person themselves than what their boobs look like!

Mari9999 · 10/10/2023 00:01

It is a real disservice to women to suggest that partners who have different feelings or expectations are necessarily abusive or coercive if they say that they will end a relationship because of this or that.

In this situation , the partner seems to be saying he wants to see his partner naked. The OP has her reasons for saying no. It is well with the range of normal expectations to want to see one' s lover naked.

In this case , it is also within the OP 's right to say that she can't or won't do that. Neither of them are being abusive or coercive. Both are responding in ways that are normal for them. People end relationships for all kinds of reasons. Anything that leaves you feeling unhappy or unsatisfied is a valid reason for ending a relationship. Relationships are not meant to be captive in nature. Healthy relationships are meant to be positive and satisfying.

In this relationship there is something that is preventing both parties from being satisfied. Neither is wrong and both parties have a right to feel satisfied.

Maybe, they will.be able to work through this,.but if not neither should be made to feel that they are abusive or that they are being abused. These are just people whose expectations and insecurities are preventing them from having a comfortable relationship.