Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have toddler in ft nursery even though I don’t have to?

275 replies

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 05:05

Initially I went back to work when ds was 9 months and he started nursery FT, up until he was 19 months. Then I got work to agree to three days a week. He still does this.

I don’t want to go back ft - I have another child now. Equally though it doesn’t seem that things are working well having ds home with me/us 4 days a week. I know this is partly our fault but he just doesn’t eat. Nursery he eats everything. Breakfast, snack, hot lunch, pudding, tea. Home he barely touches anything. Today after refusing two breakfasts he finally ate a banana after a lot of persuasion, had a biscuit at a toddler group and an apple, refused lunch and then had maybe three mouthfuls of macaroni cheese. He then demands yoghurt and biscuits. He has been awake half the night and I’m sure it’s hunger related.

I know people will say he won’t starve and I’m not so sure! He might not starve but he doesn’t eat anything near enough and this affects behaviour and sleep. So - AIBU to have him in nursery FT? It’s expensive but worth it for peace of mind.

OP posts:
Hercisback · 06/10/2023 07:08

Nice and awful homes don't let you see boundaries.

Your kid will appear a nice home but probably be awful to teach.

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 07:08

Of course.

OP posts:
Hercisback · 06/10/2023 07:09

Tell DH to move out. Until you take it really seriously, he won't.

Muststopeating · 06/10/2023 07:09

I had 3 babies in 4 years and I totally get the exhaustion and did not find the toddler years fun. My youngest is now 2 and it WILL get easier (in terms of lack of sleep at least). There will be so many days that you feel all you can give is survival parenting.

What about compromising, why don't you put him in for 4 days a week and start there.

In the meantime... will he eat plain yoghurt? If so, give it to him after every meal? It's healthy enough without too much sugar (none added) that it's guilt free but will fill his tummy a bit more than biscuits.

Also what kind of biscuits... a digestive will have more fibre (wholegrain) and thus be more filling than a custard cream. Nairns also do chocolate chip oatcakes... could you try him on something like that. At least it's some goodness?

Also, when he's demanding biscuits etc can you give him a choice. You can have this thing or this thing. He will scream and shout and get cross. But I find with my 2 year old that if she is kicking off because something is wrong with 'the thing's that if I remove said thing for a minute or 2 she will then accept it as she realises that it's the broken cracker or no crackers etc? There is a tantrum but its relatively short lived.

You are not a rubbish parent, not at all. But nursery or no nursery you will need to figure out how to introduce boundaries or eating will be the least of your worries in the longer term. Instead of saying I can't or trying to tackle the whole issue try little changes at a time. You will get there if you can find even a little bit of extra energy. (Oh and your DH needs to realise this is more important than his biscuit fix).

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 07:09

Nope won’t eat plain yoghurt. Only the petit frous (?) ones, I think that is how it is spelled!

OP posts:
Mumsanetta · 06/10/2023 07:10

@NurseryFT you sound very much on the edge, a big hug to you. You have a 3 month old and a DH who doesn’t seem to be helping your DS’ eating habits. You and your DH need to be on the same team but you seem to feel as though this is not possible. Can you show your DH this thread? It might help him understand how you feel and how changes to his own eating habits (such as eating biscuits out of sight and not buying him ice cream) might help.

Quitelikeacatslife · 06/10/2023 07:10

You said DH bribes him with junk to get him in car seat , that's what I meant.
It sounds like you are the one around all day, so your DH really needs to back you up. It's no use just saying but he won't . Does he really really not communicate with you at all?
Maybe buy a little table and chairs like they have at nursery, you need to model what they do there, I can guarantee they do not chase them round with a spoon, stop that right now.
I have family who are incredibly tense over food with their kids, but they can't see how stressed they are , I absolutely guarantee that their kids eat better when we all sit down and talk about something else, even put tv on, just don't hover

mikado1 · 06/10/2023 07:14

I'd be telling dh that this is going to ruin your respect and regard for him... it certainly would for me anyway. It's really unfair and its clear you're at the end of your tether from trying with him (DH).

You don't need to control your ds, so take that off your conscience but you are the guide and the leader in terms of food provided. I remember reading to act as if you're an uninvested waitress lol! Deliver the food and take it away when finished. My youngest dc is a very 'discerning' eater 😉 but I just keep offering and don't substitute, now 8.

hedgehogsunflower · 06/10/2023 07:15

OP I think you need to go a bit easier on yourself. You’ve got a newborn and a 2 year old, I remember that stage and it is really tough.

If you can afford 4/5 days of nursery for a bit and it takes the pressure off, why not try it. You can always drop down again.

It will get easier 💐

spitefulandbadgrammar · 06/10/2023 07:16

You’re not a shit parent, you’ve got a preschooler and a 3 month old baby, and your DH is undermining something quite fundamental: all of that is HARD, as is sleep deprivation.

FWIW I had my 3yo in nursery 4 days a week while I was on maternity leave, as that was her routine anyway. The day I had the pair of them home, I HATED it. She’s also fussy!

I wouldn’t provide a snack at night as that sets a precedent, but I do sometimes still offer a cup of warm milk to DD if she wakes and says she’s hungry: it’s rare this happens, and when it does, it settles her.

You can’t change DH but you can change you. Clear the house of ice cream, biscuits, etc. Make sure there’s filling stuff available for DS like Greek yoghurt, porridge, peanut butter toast. If DH whinges or restocks his junk, at least put it all in one place out of sight of DS. Hold firm even when you’re exhausted.

After we moved house, moving cities and nurseries, and had a baby, DD went through a phase of only eating ham sandwiches, from inside a cardboard moving box. She called it her quiet box. Two months of ham sandwiches at home, and a vitamin pill; varied diet at nursery. We let her, while always offering a varied diet. Food can easily turn into a battleground, and it’s the one area of their lives they can control. I don’t think your DS is saying “take me out of nursery”, I think he’s saying “help, why is there a baby and why is mummy tired and why sometimes yes ice cream from daddy and sometimes no and the rules are different”. Nursery sets boundaries. At home, he’s got nothing, so he’s putting the control in place by saying “fine, I won’t eat”.

If it helps, I ate nothing but jammy toast til I was about 10, then later on as an adult got a job as a food writer. I don’t have scurvy or rickets; DS will be fine.

BertieBotts · 06/10/2023 07:17

People will jump on me, but has your DH looked at the possibility of ADHD? The lack of consistency and jumping to fix every little thing and instantly reactive, all without being controlling/hostile sounds very familiar to me (I have ADHD).

It does also run in families so it's possible that your DS might have it too, which would cause the lack of response to any normal discipline techniques. It's way too early to think about that though and the main issue there is probably simply that those typical techniques assume a background of safety and stability.

For example, I used to find that my eldest was absolutely impossible with daily routine tasks like getting dressed etc. While there were some ADHD issues at play the biggest problem was that I wasn't getting him to do it every single day. With DS2 I thought he was an easier child but as he's got older he's had similar issues to DS1 in many areas - but the home areas where DH has had consistency that I lacked the first time around have been easier. It makes a huge difference.

Quitelikeacatslife · 06/10/2023 07:17

I was thinking, does he have favourite tv show? Can you put that on at mealtime and he sits at little table to watch it and eat but don't let him watch it any other time , it might be a bit like training him to associate good with something pleasurable? , he could help you get his food together , tiny plate of grapes crackers cheese yogurt etc, whatever he likes out of the healthy choices you offer him
You can wean him off this habit later and separate the food

BertieBotts · 06/10/2023 07:18

BTW I think the nursery is fine. I have my 2yo in nursery. About to drop him down to finishing at 2 instead of 4, but he absolutely loves it and gets so much from it.

Nagado · 06/10/2023 07:18

It strikes me that you’re actually a pretty good parent and it’s your DH who is being a bit rubbish and who is making your life so much harder by undermining everything you’re doing.

Yes, you could put him in nursery full time and it would ensure he was eating, but do you want to solve the problem or hide it? Hiding it would definitely be easier in the short term but it’s not going to help you long term when he realises that your DH does negotiate with terrorists and that he can use this to his advantage. And what will happen when the baby starts to copy what he sees his big brother doing? It’s short term gain for long term pain.

You say you’ve gone through this with your DH loads of times; how does he respond? Does he agree with you but then ignore everything you’ve said? Or does he think that he’s doing the right thing? I think you need help getting your DH onside first, before tackling your DS. If you made an appointment with a child nutritionist, would he listen? Or would he still give in for an easy life?

Nicole1111 · 06/10/2023 07:18

Yes going somewhere full time with boundaries where he eats more regularly rather than being at home starving and unsettled is likely to be better in the short term. That said in a couple of years you’ll have a school age child you can’t control and then down the line a teenager you can’t control. You can’t just hope the passage of time resolves things. Do a parenting course, ask nursery what they’re doing that you’re not that you need to implement at home and speak to your hv about managing picky eating. If your dh isn’t listening to you get a professional such as someone from nursery or the hv to speak to him. Yes it’ll be hard work with a baby too but it’ll be a lot easier than the alternative of years and years and years of battles.

Yearsyonder · 06/10/2023 07:20

I understand where you're coming from. I developed a phrases that I would say to my child when they were shouting/screaming/kicking off for something.

'No, no more biscuits etc. And I will not be moved on this.' Said with firmness and finality, but kindly.

It was actually more for me than my daughter. It was to convince ME that I wouldn't be moved. It didn't take long for her to come to understand that I wouldn't be moved. Whining, shouting etc massively reduced once I had become firm in my boundaries.

So decide your boundary, state it, hold it firmly and don't be moved, despite the storm.

Keep a connection with him when he's kicking off, quietly state you know he's angry and wants a biscuit but that he won't be having one. And wait for the storm to pass. Eventually there'll be fewer storms.

Once you reduce the biscuits the food consumption at dinner will increase naturally.

WannabeMathematician · 06/10/2023 07:21

@NurseryFT Could you go up to full time for a month or so? Just to get your barings and build up your mental reserves? I had a friend whose child didn’t eat like you described and it nearly finished her marriage it got so bad. It’s the near constant stress. The went to a dietitian who said they had to hide fats in everything just to get his calorie intake up.

NoSquirrels · 06/10/2023 07:28

I know the ‘correct’ answer is we sit down and work it out but we’ve tried so …

Does your DH agree with you in principle that the eating habits/giving in to bribe with junk is an issue? Is it that he agrees but struggles to maintain agreed boundaries?

Or does he not agree it’s a problem at all?

Is he usually inflexible about things like food - does he acknowledge his own eating habits aren’t great?

Just trying to establish where the problem really lies.

hoglets · 06/10/2023 07:31

i think YABU. A 19 months old won't benefit from a full time nursery place developmentally/socially. It appears he is in full time as you struggle to parent him effectively and decided the easy option is nursery due to his eating issues. I think you need to crack the eating at home. I think it's a bizarre reason for putting a toddler into nursery full time when you only need 3.

DillyDallyingAllDay · 06/10/2023 07:32

Have you considered taking him out of nursery altogether? Maybe a few weeks of having him home full time; DH could parent and he'd naturally learn to enforce boundaries.
It would be the equivalent of throwing you all in the deep end; DS wouldn't be eating well 3 days a week so he'd have to eat half decently 5 days a week to remain not hungry. You and your family need a drastic change to re-set. I assume you're on maternity leave; DH needs to take some parental leave and DS needs leave from nursery to enable you all, as a family to figure out your boundaries. DS will soon learn and if DH is behaving like a child, maybe snacks/treats need to not be bought?

NoSquirrels · 06/10/2023 07:37

Food can easily turn into a battleground, and it’s the one area of their lives they can control. I don’t think your DS is saying “take me out of nursery”, I think he’s saying “help, why is there a baby and why is mummy tired and why sometimes yes ice cream from daddy and sometimes no and the rules are different”. Nursery sets boundaries. At home, he’s got nothing, so he’s putting the control in place by saying “fine, I won’t eat”.
I’d agree this is the crux of it. Lots of change, food is a way to get control. And that removing power struggles from food is really really hard but also completely vital.

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 07:41

I’d lose my mind if he was home all the time. More to the point though we’d lose his space and I am going back to work next year. Anyway I do think nursery is the best lace for him for now and we can hopefully work on issues when he’s in a proper routine.

OP posts:
Lovethatforyouhun · 06/10/2023 07:49

.

Mouthulcer · 06/10/2023 08:11

If DS likes nursery, definitely up to 5 days a week at nursery to give yourself a breather. I didnt struggle that much with parenting but still kept my eldest in nursery when my second was a newborn. I only had both of them one day a week and although lovely, it was exhausting so I was glad I didn't have to do it everyday.

But please do work on things the days your eldest is at home. Bribing with food needs to stop today, he's still young enough for things to change but won't be for much longer. It will be hard, but you can do it. Talk to your health visitor, they are here to help with exactly this sort of thing and can probably help you with small, practical steps so it doesn't seem so overwhelming

GoodlifeGlow · 06/10/2023 08:30

Your attitude to this is odd, you have a problem with your child and you just want to push it onto someone else and not make any changes yourself.

This is your child who you need to look after and give the best start in life. You say you are a teacher? Well if you are not equipped with the skills to parent, learn! Do what other active, involved parents do, read the books learn about child psychology. Then teach your husband the strategies you’ve learnt so you can both be consistent.

I get you have a baby, but that doesn’t mean giving up on the one you have because they aren’t behaving how you think they should. Most of this behaviour is probably related to having a new baby in the house. You need to address the issues at home.