Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have toddler in ft nursery even though I don’t have to?

275 replies

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 05:05

Initially I went back to work when ds was 9 months and he started nursery FT, up until he was 19 months. Then I got work to agree to three days a week. He still does this.

I don’t want to go back ft - I have another child now. Equally though it doesn’t seem that things are working well having ds home with me/us 4 days a week. I know this is partly our fault but he just doesn’t eat. Nursery he eats everything. Breakfast, snack, hot lunch, pudding, tea. Home he barely touches anything. Today after refusing two breakfasts he finally ate a banana after a lot of persuasion, had a biscuit at a toddler group and an apple, refused lunch and then had maybe three mouthfuls of macaroni cheese. He then demands yoghurt and biscuits. He has been awake half the night and I’m sure it’s hunger related.

I know people will say he won’t starve and I’m not so sure! He might not starve but he doesn’t eat anything near enough and this affects behaviour and sleep. So - AIBU to have him in nursery FT? It’s expensive but worth it for peace of mind.

OP posts:
Manthide · 08/10/2023 21:08

I can understand how tired and frustrated you are. Dd1 was an awful sleeper and eater and until she was about 3 or 4 I felt like a zombie. Thankfully dd2 (19 months younger) was a great eater (until she was about 3) and a great sleeper. With dd1 I reduced the amount of milk she was having and that helped a lot. Dd2 was a bit more stubborn- she'd make her self sick if she didn't like something and every day there seemed to be something else she didn't like. Eventually I took a step back, decided she wouldn't starve herself and stopped giving her 'extras'. I would put a small amount of the food she didn't like on her plate and I'd take it away after a reasonable time. Dd1 was still given extras and I used to tell dd2 that she wasn't getting any as she mustn't be hungry as she hadn't eaten her lunch/dinner. It took about 3 days and since then she was fine. This approach is probably not fashionable now - dd2 is 30 - but I was at my wits end!

Drames78 · 08/10/2023 21:25

I don't know if you will read this as you are clearly fed up with the preaching in this thread and I can see why.

No advice here. Your children aren't necessarily anything like mine.

Just here to say my eldest (now 16) was challenging. Especially with food. I was pretty convinced her hated me. I felt like a crap parent. Argued with husband over parenting. Sleep deprivation didn't help.

Eldest was with a child minder 3 days a week. If I could have put him in for the other two I would have but she didn't have space (and to be honest I think he exhausted her too).

The ONLY thing that saved us was I was leant a trainee nursery nurse on placement by the local college. She came one day a week and helped look after the baby (and played with the eldest one who thought she was amazing).

Nothing else helped. He just grew up. Turned into a nice kid (despite me). Fussed about food, declared her was vegetarian at 9 (no I couldn't 'put my foot down' he just wouldn't have ate). He was skinny. I worried. He's now 6 ft 1. Still skinny. Started to go to gym and now isn't veggie because suddenly meat is important for muscles!

Little sister is fine. She was a sling baby. Always eldests biggest fan. Easiest going child on earth. Partly through some 'neglect' (yep call SS).

I've finally forgiven myself for being a 'crap parent'. I've realised I kept them and me alive and they grew into decent kids so clearly what I did wasn't all bad.

I know you aren't a bad parent. Bad parents don't ever consider if they are good or bad. They don't care. You clearly do. It'll be ok. Whatever you do It'll be OK one day.

l2222 · 08/10/2023 21:52

You can get through this. Do what you think is right for your child and family now - you can change your mind at any time.

Take each day at a time until you can get more sleep but I echo some of the other comments, please go to the doctor and discuss post natal depression - most people that have it don’t realise it, it just casts a horrible shadow over your life and you’ll look for and find blame elsewhere.

Sundownmemories · 08/10/2023 22:17

Honestly it sounds like you’re overwhelmed and need to make life easier for
yourself.
You’ve just had your second baby, at 3 months you’re in the trenches. You’re sleep deprived, feeling guilty that your eldests life has been turned upside down, annoyed that your husband isn’t having to deal with this all day everyday because he’s at work while you’re at home on maternity leave.
Life is hard right now. It’s ok to admit you’re overwhelmed taking care of a newborn and 3 year old every day on very little sleep. I’ve been there.
All I will say, you’ve got to do what you’ve got to do. If you need your eldest in nursery full
time right now to make life more manageable then do it. Don’t feel guilty or justify it. Do what you need to do to get through this difficult phase. Reasses when you feel ready.

MumtoSENprincess · 08/10/2023 22:23

I have read most of this thread and I am wondering whether your DS (and maybe your DH) could be on the autistic spectrum? I know several parents of children with autism and some of their children have real problems with eating and sleep. If your DS is autistic, much of the usual advice about fussy eating won't work eg if they are hungry enough they will eat.

You might like to Google ARFID, which is extreme food refusal. Even if your son doesn't actually have it, there will be useful advice. My DD is a fussy eater and has the same meals every day but it works for her so we have gone with that.

Also, when I have seen programmes about anorexia and eating disorders, they say to forget about 'healthy foods' - if the child is not eating, any food is OK. It's very stressful having a child who doesn't eat, so I hope you are able to find some answers.

WickedWitchOfTheEast87 · 09/10/2023 00:17

@NurseryFT I have read all your posts and I hope this doesn't seem harsh because I can feel your frustration, exhaustion and hopelessness in all of them.

You have come across as dismissive and defensive of some posters advice. I'm a former nursery worker and your problems are not uncommon I've had many parents talk with me about their kids eating habits. Some children do go through a fussy stage, others do so because they know their parents will give in. Believe me in the long run that is not a good route to go because the older your son gets the worse his behaviour will get.

I feel every sympathy for you because frankly your DH sounds like a useless lazy twat and you sound ground down and unmotivated because of his utter lack of consistency and you trying to put down clear and consistent guidance and boundaries alone is undermining your efforts so now you're in a why bother mindset.

I think your ds is behaving this way because he's simply pushing boundaries as he senses your lack of control, stress and frustration, along with the lack of concistency and attempts at discipline which has no confidence behind it. Then throw in your dh using treats as a bribe and not supporting you and leaving you to do all the work your son is learning that he can do what he wants as he has no consequences. Also with a new baby getting all the attention is a big change even for young children. I also think your sons behaviour is hyped up because he's had a lot of surgary treats so it makes it worse.

Have you spoken to the nursery staff or ds key worker about this? Could you maybe tell them exactly what is going on at home and ask if both you and dh can come in for a meeting and could they maybe spell it out to DH that if he carries on doing nothing the impact on your son's development will not be good. Sometimes it takes an outsider to see the issue and hit the message home. Or is there someone else like a friend or family that will tell your dh straight and light a fire up his arse!

curaçao · 09/10/2023 03:03

Sorry if i have missed it op, but iwhat centiles is your ds on for height and weight

Wishbone436 · 09/10/2023 06:37

honestLet h isn’t going to be more reasonable when he starts school. Nursery & school can only do so much. I mean this in the nicest way possible but if you feel it’s down to your parenting you need to work on that, ask for outside support if you need it. It not gets harder the older they get. The last thing u want when baby gets older is 2 kids that you can’t parent. You need to set the framework

Frazzledmum123 · 09/10/2023 07:02

@NurseryFT please stop saying you are a shit parent, you really aren't. Overwhelmed maybe at the moment yes but not shit. A shit parent wouldn't be worried about anything and there is a lot of love coming through your posts
Firstly ignore all the bi*chy people, people love a good self indulgent 'I'm so much better than you' post on here! And don't compare yourself to others as you really don't see everything. I had a friend ask my why I'm always so calm in the mornings at school and Ive honestly never been so surprised - I am the very opposite of calm and its something I've often cried about to myself as I'm worried my stressiness is really bad for the kids. But she only sees me after I've dropped them at school so yes, I'm much calmer then.
Put him in nursery the extra days if you can afford it. It doesn't have to be forever but it will be one less thing on your mental load right now and a less stressed you is better for him too. His behaviour is normal too for his age, especially with a new sibling. Doesn't mean you are doing anything wrong, my best friend has just gone through the exact same thing with her child and mine went through a stage of almighty temper tantrums (I mean MEGA style). She is now the sweetest, best behaved kid there is so it isn't you.
And don't rule out PND please. You may just be exhausted but it may be more, just keep that in mind and if things get worse, speak to your gp or health worker about how you are feeling. I did and my HW was fantastic

LolaSmiles · 09/10/2023 07:26

What you did say is that I have explained I can’t do some things: one of those things is pretend my youngest isn’t here.To spend really effective time with the first without the baby every day is not possible unless I put her eg in the garage
I haven't said anything about pretending the baby isn't there either.

People with a range of parenting experiences are trying to help, people are telling you over and over that you're not a rubbish parent, and that you sound exhausted and overwhelmed.

It's hard to see what you want from this thread because it doesn't seem to be help, or advice, or ideas for things to try, or any suggestions about going up stream to work out the root of the behaviour, or suggestions to speak to the GP about how you're feeling, or advice to speak to different professionals for help and advice, or anything regarding DH's undermining, or anything else practical.

Plenty of people have said, me included, that if you need to use full time nursery then do, just don't rely on nursery to fix everything when there's no change at home because it won't work long term. It would probably help you see the wood from the trees if you spoke to the GP or a health visitor about how you're feeling because you can't pour from and empty jug.

crew2022 · 09/10/2023 07:58

Why not go for 4 days in nursery so you will have a day with just the baby. Then you only have the weekend and one week day to get through?
I would think about
a) you are doing your best and right now that's good enough
b) try to not make food a big deal. If he doesn't eat what you offer just remove it and do an activity. Try again later on.
C) suggest your husband swaps junk food for a small treat like playing with a special toy when ds gets in the car for him
d) generally try and cut out food as a reward and start swapping it for other high value treats like a toy, a book, a trip to the park etc
e) if things go wrong one day then accept it's another day tomorrow!
Things will get better

GracePalmer33 · 09/10/2023 08:19

To be honest I really don't think there's anything wrong with him being in nursery full time. You also have a 3 month old baby to look after. Im assuming you're on maternity leave so your job right now is to look after the newborn- if you were working your job then he'd be in nursery so I don't think it's any different. If you're struggling then better to do what you can so you can at least look after your baby well in the day. He sounds like he enjoys nursery and many parents have their 3 year olds in nursery full time and don't bat an eyelid? I'm surprised at some of the comments on this thread tbh.

In a few weeks im about to have a newborn and a one year old and can't afford to put my one year old in nursery for even 1 day a week and im absolutely terrified !!!

Hufflepods · 09/10/2023 08:33

Most of the comments on this thread are ridiculous and so patronising.
OP you have a 3 month old too, do whatever suits!

It isn't uncommon to have keep your first child in nursery while on mat leave with a second, there's nothing wrong with it. It doesn't mean you don't love your children, or you can't parent, or whatever anyone else wants to try to make you feel bad about.

I'm on mat leave in a few weeks and my toddler will stay in FT nursery. No guilt whatsoever.

xSilverandcoldx · 09/10/2023 08:53

How is your son's development generally? Has he hit all of his developmental milestones etc?

My eldest was a nightmare toddler and literally nothing I tried helped her behaviour. I put it down to new baby and us being crap at parenting, but it turns out she has ASD and ADHD.

I don't think people believed me when I said none of the parenting strategies worked but they literally didn't. They couldn't as her brain is wired differently. Now that we know we use other methods that DO work and she is a much more settled child.

I'm not trying to scare you, and I might be way off but it's something to think about.

Jem2468 · 09/10/2023 12:02

Hey,
I with you it's tough juggling!

Speaking from my own experience we had struggles with my first DD when a new sibling came along (also DD). My eldest was 3. Around that time first DD started preschool but also started acting up with her behaviour which can happen in many ways.

After doing some reading I realised that you felt pushed out with some of my attention being diverted to the new baby which was only made worse by her starting preschool. Probably jealousy because she was at preschool while I was home with the new baby.

Children often don't know how to articulate their feelings as they don't have the emotional vocabulary to do so but will certainly do it in other ways.

It made it much easier to understand from her point of view by thinking how would I feel if my husband came home with a "new wife".

From that point I spent alot of time trying to include her as much as possible by involving her in bathtime, nappy changing etc and slowly it worked. It also took alot of me reassuring her.

Hope this helps in some way.

Tiggerbabe2 · 09/10/2023 16:12

Why on earth did you have a 2nd child!??
You seem unwilling to make any effort to actually parent your child and appear to think that saying 'oh I'm a bad parent' makes it ok.

NurseryFT · 09/10/2023 16:16

If every day was like the day when I posted this I probably wouldn’t have!

OP posts:
clarehhh · 09/10/2023 17:12

Are you doing something else when he eats? Sit with him, keep anxiety out of your voice. If you can't eat a meal at least sit with a cup of tea. Max 15 mins too. At nursery he eats because he can't do anything else. No option to get down. Encourage him to try food from your plate too.

Mck1987 · 09/10/2023 20:47

Put your child in FT nursery. Think about this again when your youngest sleeps in chunks longer than 8 hours. (I kept my daughter in full time nursery for my whole maternity leave and felt absolutely no guilt).

Pixie3683 · 09/10/2023 20:55

Firstly, it sounds from your latest msg that your post was made at an exceptionally low point and I hope you’ve had a better day today ❤️

Secondly, as others have said no crap parent reaches out for help on a decision they are struggling with. You are juggling an awful lot atm and with little to no support from what I can understand. This is sooooooo draining and soul destroying. I defy any mum here to say they haven’t had a time when they’ve truly believed they’re the worst parent in the world - just trust me when I tell you, you are not!

Lastly, apologies if someone has already suggested this (I read the first 5 pages of replies before jumping to the end), but could the money be spent on having a nanny come and help you at home with both children for those extra 2 days, rather than relying on nursery? A fellow grown up to tag team with, especially one experienced with very young children could give you the respite you need, help set up a routine and some boundaries in the home and also help build your confidence.

Mostlyoblivious · 09/10/2023 22:46

Pedisure drinks (milkshakes). Ocado sell them. Toddler will think it’s another treat, get the calories, hopefully sleep, you hopefully sleep, husband hopefully works out when not to eat crap in front of toddler and then reframe from there.

fed is best (junk or not)

Gemst199 · 10/10/2023 06:09

HuGs! You are a good mum, you care so much about your little one you are willing to sacrifice to make his life better. You know you need to change, but you are exhausted and overwhelmed with the new baby and that's normal and ok.
You sound like you need some help and support - do you have family or friend close by who you could come over and help with housework, or watch the kids while you nap?
Your nursery may have a family support worker who can help you come up with a plan. If not, reach out to your health visitor for support.
It's scary to talk to a professional when you know it's not going well but they are there to help you!

Bearcub101 · 10/10/2023 07:03

I hear you! Had ds (now at uni) went through this ‘phase’ when that age. Meal times turned into a battle. Ate lovely at nursery but we struggled at home. Both dp and I were on the same page, all sat at the table for meals
together (dp started early and finished work at lunchtime) but we still struggled and so we asked our health visitor for help.

Sorry if this has been suggested many times (it’s a long thread!) but do you make meal times ‘fun’? This is what the HV suggested to us and it helped loads. I can only say this helped us.

When ds wasn’t eating well we’d make finger food, sit with their teddy’s and take it in turns. One for Teddy, one for mummy one for ds. Lots of small sandwiches cut into shapes (believe me I never want to see another cheese spread sandwich in my life!). Playing kitchen and serving lunch out of their play saucepans and and onto their plates. I used to even do finger painting, when eating (I used to spoon feed ds for this!). Reading a book when eating. I’ve even bathed and spoon feed them 🤦‍♀️. In my defence all I was concerned about was that he would starve! It was anything so he ate food!

But gradually we decreased the play, and the eating naturally increased. It worked. Within a few months, he sat down at the table, with toddler cutlery and ate all his meals. Never had problems after that few months.

I think with ds he were afraid of missing out on playing, so wouldn’t want to eat. When he learnt that playing was still going to be there, it helped him to eat. He developed really good sleep patterns then too, as he was content when he went to bed.

Please don’t take the easy option of extra days at nursery. Ds maybe feeling a little pushed out with the baby, he may actually need more time with you.

BusyZoo · 10/10/2023 20:02

NurseryFT I’ve signed up to mumsnet just to say that I’m sure you’re not bad at parenting, you’re just really really tired from having a newborn baby and a toddler! Kids often eat more a nursery because of the peer pressure. And some days they are more hungry than others. And three is the exact age a lot of fussy eating begins. Just cos they’re three and testing out their autonomy.

So I reckon if he’s happy at daycare send him for more days, remove the stress and settle into life with two kids. Then when you feel a bit more yourself down the track you’ll be better able to deal with and you can take him out again if you want to. And just try to reduce the biscuits. Try the ones made for babies that are lower in sugar, or the ones shaped like animals which are smaller, or a rusk which lasts ages, or a rich tea which is plainer. Or see if you can get him into fruit toast or low sugar jam sandwiches or different fruits which would fill him up more / be natural sugars at least. Good luck x

69Pineapples69 · 11/10/2023 06:06

Sorry op, but you sound like you've given up on yourself. You absolutely can do this. But you have to decide to do it. You say you can do things the easy way, but that's not what's best for your child. I think you need a meeting with ds's key worker and manager and see if they can help you manage the eating. You say DH won't listen, so you make him listen. Have that talk again that you said was pointless and DH doesn't listen, and make it clear to him this is what you are doing and if he doesn't support you in parenting your children then he can get lost. It's never going to work if you don't work as a team. As an early years teacher with three of my own, I can promise you putting him in nursery might seem easy now but it will not do you any favours in the long run. Sitting there saying "I'm a shit parent" is not going to change your sons eating habits. It's a cop out. And repetition with boundaries DOES work, some children just need more reminding. What do you think we do at nursery? You think all the children listen all the time? No! repitition, Makaton sign language, firm voice and above all distraction. If a child is climbing on something they shouldn't they are telling you they need to climb. Take them somewhere they can do that, or make it safe for them to climb somewhere. Don't give up op, but also stop being so hard on yourself
I don't think you sound like a shit parent, otherwise you wouldn't be on here expressing your worries. You're just exhausted and worried about your child.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread