Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have toddler in ft nursery even though I don’t have to?

275 replies

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 05:05

Initially I went back to work when ds was 9 months and he started nursery FT, up until he was 19 months. Then I got work to agree to three days a week. He still does this.

I don’t want to go back ft - I have another child now. Equally though it doesn’t seem that things are working well having ds home with me/us 4 days a week. I know this is partly our fault but he just doesn’t eat. Nursery he eats everything. Breakfast, snack, hot lunch, pudding, tea. Home he barely touches anything. Today after refusing two breakfasts he finally ate a banana after a lot of persuasion, had a biscuit at a toddler group and an apple, refused lunch and then had maybe three mouthfuls of macaroni cheese. He then demands yoghurt and biscuits. He has been awake half the night and I’m sure it’s hunger related.

I know people will say he won’t starve and I’m not so sure! He might not starve but he doesn’t eat anything near enough and this affects behaviour and sleep. So - AIBU to have him in nursery FT? It’s expensive but worth it for peace of mind.

OP posts:
NurseryFT · 08/10/2023 20:07

And you think yours was one of them?

You think comparing having a second child to having an affair is helpful?

You think endless long posts after I have repeated that I’m not really seeking advice is helpful?

The thing is, you’re wanting to poke and prod so you can then have a row. It’s a well established MN game, and it’s tedious as hell.

There is a lot I do right as a parent. One thing is recognising what works. As I’ve said, if I say my boundary is no climbing on the table and I repeatedly take my 2 year old down,
we’ll be there hours, no one won anything. If I ignore and I walk away, over in minutes. That’s common sense. So no, not a hard boundary as I’ve no way of enforcing it. OTOH, not kicking or hurting the baby is a hard boundary as I can enforce that. With me?

Today I got up with my toddler and baby, gave breakfast, cleaned up, read books, drew pictures. We went for a long autumn walk and ended up at the park. Had home cooked healthy dinner, bath and bed, stories, love, bumped knees kissed, toys reassembled. I don’t think I’m too terrible, but I doubt myself all the time because I care so much. But a bad day doesn’t of course define me any more than your exceptionally nasty post defines you I am sure. But I do have massive mum guilt re trying to meet the needs of two lovely little people.

OP posts:
FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 08/10/2023 20:09

The less time you spend with very young children, the harder it is when you spend time with them. They are a whole lot easier if you spend every waking minute with them. It's too 'bitty' otherwise, and you can never really be consistent, because your consistency will clash with nursery's consistency, and your child won't have a clue what's what - and then he'll use the very limited means at his disposal to express his confusion and frustration (i.e. not eating).

You need to spend more time with him, not less.

Babyboomtastic · 08/10/2023 20:09

NurseryFT · 08/10/2023 19:46

I think I’ve explained that I was really exceptionally tired at the start of this thread and struggling with perspective as a result. No one needs to be giving me paragraphs of tired old advice - it’s easy to feel like a shit parent when you’re worn out. Only the extremely arrogant and there are a few of you would not question themselves and doubt themselves and feel they aren’t enough for their child or children, I think.

You seen to think that we are all bright eyed and bushy tailed idealists or something. Lots of us as ridiculously tired and burned out too. That's why we understand your frustration. We've been there or still are there. We also recognise how kids can change and become challenging after a sibling comes along because it happened to us too.

No one is saying you are a bad parent except you. On the contrary, people have said you are a good mum, you just dont believe it.

No one has said you shouldn't have had a second child, only that you need to look at things from your toddlers perspective.

Feeling like you can only be a decent parent to one at a time is just part of having two children, especially in the first 2 years.

Virtually every child eats better in childcare than at home. That doesn't mean it's a better place for them necessarily.

A young child is hard. 2 is VERY hard.

NurseryFT · 08/10/2023 20:12

Of all the ridiculous posts on this thread, being flagged to SS for - good question, for what? Confused

I think when people post those sorts of things it is either to try and scare a poster into ‘compliance’ and to ‘agree’ they are wrong or they don’t have a clue what SS actually do and deal with.

Do you seriously think SS would be interested in ‘Hi, this mum we have only got to bed at midnight and got woken up at 4 with a couple of wake ups in between. She seems a bit stressed and upset because she thinks her son isn’t eating enough and so she’s considering sending him to nursery five days a week for a bit to try to get him to eat more as he eats better at nursery.’

I mean - yeah, grounds for immediate child protection plan, that Confused

OP posts:
Sennelier1 · 08/10/2023 20:12

I think putting your son in nursery full time would give you all some welcome breathing space. Being a big brother to a new sibling is a lot of work! I think being at home full time in the week- ends and then spending the evenings together on weekdays is enough right now 😊 This solution maybe shouldn't be permanent, but could you try this for a few months? By then the baby will start reacting to big brother, making life at home more interesting 😊

NurseryFT · 08/10/2023 20:13

no one has said you shouldn’t have had a second child have another look. I do honestly think the thread is best wrapping up. There is nothing good coming of it at all.

OP posts:
Rosieroo20 · 08/10/2023 20:18

Sending you lots of positivity,it's so difficult when you feel you are doing a pants job as a mum and I can't imagine how difficult things are for you.I have a 3 year old who sounds just like yours I just don't have the new baby but if I did I think I would be in a mental asylum.
Nursery is the best idea if they are good my daughter goes 4 mornings a week and 1 full day.
She loves it.
Her eating is not great but I try to not let it get me down,she barely eats traditional meals,she dislikes meat and prefers things like beans on toast.I too have to feed her or she wouldn't eat.
I take comfort in the fact nutritionly we could survive on sandwiches and bananas.
We did cut the sugar down but I do find it hard to refuse treats.
Boundaries are not my thing as I just don't have the patience and don't believe they would work with her.
Be kind to yourself, do you have any family support?my husband is pants too,I have to do the bedtime routine as she just plays him up.it is what is tho.
He will grow out of it just like my daughter.
We live in hope.
Seriously they do.this is my 2nd merry go round as I have 2 older grown up children and they turned out well and my son was extremely hard work when he was a toddler.

Sbera · 08/10/2023 20:22

@NurseryFT
just to offer some kindness

No you ANBU to pop your son in nursery for more days to help you through the most traumatic time of having a newborn whilst raising a toddler. (I found it horrific and wondered why on earth I had f**ked it all up having number 2)

I had a horrific eldest toddler. He was awful. A biter, non sleeper, non eater you name it, he tested me beyond belief. And when the baby came, this behaviour amplified beyond belief. So I can empathise.

You can’t always thrive and it sounds like right you you just need to survive. So you do what you can to do that. If that’s FT nursery fill your boots.

However, now I’m through the other side with two teenagers (who for the most part are reasonable human beings who don’t go round biting people) just some of my own hindsight which you can take or leave as you wish.

Putting in time now will pay dividends so if you go down the FT nursery route, if you feel you can, put the effort in at the weekend for those dreaded boundaries (said in jest and hoping for a smile). Less effort as only two days a week but he will learn that mum (and dad) mean business.

Secondly, have you considered shipping the baby out and paying for one day care for them so you get a dedicated day for toddler? I did this when little one was 6 months and was game changing. Again just an idea.

And for what it’s worth, The very fact you’re trying to find a solution means you are no longer in the shit parent camp!

PinkMoscatoLover · 08/10/2023 20:26

@Sjh15 yeah this certainly works for me. I don’t take the children out of their cots or put the light on. I simply give them a light snack with some water and they usually go back to sleep within 10 mins!

NurseryFT · 08/10/2023 20:28

It isn’t about effort. I don’t actually wish to be rude but do I sound like I can’t be bothered, just a bit too lazy?

OP posts:
PureAmazonian · 08/10/2023 20:31

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 06:52

Oh he would I’m sure but I don’t think that’s great really, he’s then getting used to filling up in the night.

I don't understand why you have this boundary that you stick too but not the others? If you aren't willing to give him toast in the night, what about giving him 'supper' toast and warm milk to go to bed with?

Sbera · 08/10/2023 20:32

Sorry if the word effort offended. You don’t sound lazy at all. Was genuinely trying to be kind and offer a different view point.

I know how tricky it can be.

Cactusprick · 08/10/2023 20:33

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 06:30

I don’t really care if it’s a cop out. I just want my child to be healthy and in a routine for the next 2 years. When he’s at school he’ll be older and hopefully a bit more reasonable. And if not at least he’s had a good healthy 2 years.

Oh that’s sad.
You had children for a reason. Don’t send him off away from his brother 5 days a week if he’s already out the house for 3!
You can never get this time back with him.
That bond those siblings will be making at these ages will be invaluable. Don’t reduce that opportunity for the sake an essentially 24 months. That time will fly and I wouldn’t want to regret not spending as much of it with my 3 as possible. Making memories and forming the most special bonds.

NurseryFT · 08/10/2023 20:41

Because to be honest to me that isn’t a boundary, it’s common sense. I certainly don’t mean that offensively to the poster in question as if it works for her that is great but it would be most unlikely to hear. Not feeding ds in the middle of the night and claiming that is a boundary is more like not eating something I don’t like myself and then saying well my boundary is I don’t eat sprouts - unless we’re saying living our lives is a boundary! Probably Smile

@Sbera I am not offended but equally your post was not helpful and did insinuate, intentionally or otherwise, that any difficulties with ds are because of not wishing to put in the effort when in fact the opposite is true. But however much or little effort something is, it is pointless if it does not work. That’s what is key here. It isn’t the amount of effort, it’s the effectiveness of the action.

OP posts:
NurseryFT · 08/10/2023 20:42

*here!!

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 08/10/2023 20:43

Sometimes I can’t Lola. What do you want me to say, that I can put my baby in the garage? That I can Sit DH Down and all will be well?
I've not said anything about putting baby in the garage though.

I'm acknowledging that there's a lot of posters on here who will also have their own really difficult patches with their children and they'll also have gone through trial and error and exhaustion and feeling rubbish during those hard times. Many will have had new babies with toddlers and been there when their first child finds the adjustment difficult, and some will have larger families and done that transition several times with different children with different temperaments.

In the thick of it it's really easy to feel like we're not good enough or that it feels hopeless trying something else, but there's two choices we all have to make:

Option 1: go through the trial and error to find what works for your child, try different approaches (but actually give them long enough to embed before changing), realise some things might work for one child but not yours, and what works for yours might not work for another. Use childcare as required, full or part time, but stay committed to finding what works for your child at home because in the long run it's better for everyone. This will create a secure environment where everyone can thrive.

Option 2: say nothing works, nothing is going to change, accept partner actively undermining any attempts to improve the situation, don't do anything to change the situation or give up any changes if they don't work instantly, take the easy route out and hope that childcare will sort the worst of it out, then school will deal with it, and then by teen years it's luck how they'll be. This is more likely to be an insecure environment where a child doesn't thrive and the parents are miserable.

Some threads are car wrecks but there's a lot of posters trying to help on this one.

NurseryFT · 08/10/2023 20:46

You didn’t say anything about putting the baby in the garage no.

What you did say is that I have explained I can’t do some things: one of those things is pretend my youngest isn’t here. To spend really effective time with the first without the baby every day is not possible unless I put her eg in the garage.

I think I have answered the rest of your post elsewhere but these long posts giving me advice I don’t want and haven’t asked for then berating me for saying they aren’t helpful, really aren’t helpful to anyone.

OP posts:
GeeMum21 · 08/10/2023 20:47

I really feel your pain with the not eating. I have a 2.5 year old and for a good month or so it seemed he would hardly touch a single meal I give him (but would eat absolutely everything he'd given at nursery). But we recently visited relatives for a long weekend and there were no snacks on offer at all between meals, and he's now eating every meal. I know how easy it is to give in (I also have a 4 month old who is very needy/clingy and cries anytime she is put down so is exhausting battling with a toddler), and most of the time previously I'd be so worried about him going hungry that I'd let him have whatever he wanted to make sure he was eating something. Now I have been much more consistent not letting him snack other than a little bit of fruit here and there and he is SOOO much better and I wish I'd realised it a lot sooner.
Good luck! X

Sbera · 08/10/2023 20:48

@NurseryFT Then I apologise for insinuating (completely unintentionally) that you do not wish to put the effort in. It’s a genuine apology.

As I said, you can take or leave my thoughts. And I’m sorry I couldn’t be more helpful.

For what’s it worth though, I answered your original question of AIBU with a “No you aren’t”

If you see no help in me answering the question then I’m out. And I hope things become easier for you soon whatever you decide to do.

Cactusprick · 08/10/2023 20:50

NurseryFT · 08/10/2023 19:54

Sorry, I stopped reading at boundaries.

Bloody hell, I suggest you stop posting to be honest.
You’re coming across dreadfully rude and passively aggressive.
Crack on how you like. Your poor son.

BacktoIrelandMaybe · 08/10/2023 20:52

Hi OP, hope you're okay. I think 5 days of nursery is fine if it gets you through this hard phase of young baby and tricky toddler. This is survival zone and whatever gets you through feeling reasonably okay in yourself and getting as much sleep as possible is the thing to do. You can always reassess later when you'll hopefully be feeling stronger. If your DH is the problem maybe he can be the one to get up with your son at night while you handle night wakings with the baby? Maybe if there is some 'pain' for your DH he will become more mindful. Best of luck to you, you sound like a really caring mum xx

NurseryFT · 08/10/2023 20:52

Well, I did try to wrap the thread up a while back! @Sbera i honestly don’t want to be overly moody or for want of a better word a dick here, but it was this

Putting in time now will pay dividends so if you go down the FT nursery route, if you feel you can, put the effort in at the weekend for those dreaded boundaries (said in jest and hoping for a smile). Less effort as only two days a week but he will learn that mum (and dad) mean business I responded to. I do out in time - a lot of time, and effort. And I have mentioned once or twice that I am not finding the boundary talk helpful - or amusing, to be honest. That is MY boundary, which is being ignored.

@GeeMum21 he isn’t really asking for snacks to be honest - unless dad comes in munching crisps, then just takes them 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
WhatIThinkAboutThis · 08/10/2023 20:55

Okay, other people have provided useful comments on changes to make etc. But can I just say I had my second when my first was 2.5 and it was SO hard. Maybe I was just unprepared for how big a change it would be but honestly, that first 6 months was insanely difficult.

Please don't beat yourself up for your parenting when you have such a young baby at home. The first year where they start off with no routine then start getting into a routine that then changes every month or so is absolute chaos and I genuinely believe the uncertainty and changeability of it causes upset and stress to the entire household.

It will get better. Once baby is into a reliable 2 nap day you will be able to use one nap to rest and the other to get stuff done. Baby transitioning to 1 nap is the game changer.

Along with this, I imagine your 3 month old is still waking in the night? The night wakings are tough enough the first time round, when you have to get up and parent a toddler the next day they're absolute killers. Again, it will get better. Once baby sleeps through the night you will feel like a new person.

Honestly, my advice would be to just serve safe foods that you know your son will eat for the next 6 months, then commit to cracking it in the new year when you're feeling more ready. Better weather is also good for cracking fussy eating cause you can picnic outside and just let the kids pick at the healthy foods you lay out for them whilst they play.

NurseryFT · 08/10/2023 20:57

safe foods your son will eat that would be chocolate fingers and quavers, thanks to dad 🤣

Not sure if people are just replying to the OP now but really we’re all good. Just a stressful day when I started the thread, and it was what like 5am?

OP posts:
Mumoftwosweetboys · 08/10/2023 20:57

I haven't read the full thread so sorry if others have said this but could he be being difficult with food because of the arrival of the baby? My son was 3 when my second baby arrived and he played up a bit for a couple of months not particularly with food but other things. This could be his way of getting attention.

Swipe left for the next trending thread