Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?

402 replies

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:42

Hello
I have two dcs, one born in 19/7/2020 and the other in 2/9/2022.
First dc is due to enter Reception in Sept 2024 at 4 +2 months due to state cut off, and the second will be due in Sept 2027 at 5 yo.

I feel like it is unfair for dc1 to be expected to act/ achieve at a level of 3 years ahead of dc2 when she is practically only 2 years older than dc2. Dc1 has ASD while dc2 is very likely NT, which adds to that.

I am considering a deferral for dc1 mainly because of this reason, which DH thinks is ridiculous.

Any ideas on whether I should defer dc1?

For some context both dcs are academically bright, but dc1 is really babyish compared to other 3 yo and dc2 seems more mature than other 1yo.

OP posts:
fionamadcat · 27/09/2023 18:35

My ds was oldest in his year, dd was youngest in her year. We deferred ds because it was right for him. We had the option to defer dd but didn’t as she was ready for school. Every child is different, make the decision based on what is right for each individual.
We are in Scotland so different system but they are now 21 and 19 and I would absolutely say now we made the right decision for each of them.

Gettingolderandgrumpier60 · 27/09/2023 18:36

Most LAs/schools will not defer a child’s admission to school, even in cases when child has substantial SEN. However, children do not legally have to attend school until their 5th birthday so you can decide to defer their admission but you will find your child does start school they will be put straight into Year 1 and will have missed the whole of their Reception year, which is a crucial year. Even if you manage to find a school that will allow this, you have to then coordinate with secondary school as they would also have to take child out of chronological year as it causes issues with formal exams. (For context, I am a recently retired primary head who has dealt with cases like this.)

Zeezee82 · 27/09/2023 18:38

I did. No issues academically or verbally. DS1 would have coped as the youngest but has thrived as the oldest. DS2 has started at 4 years + 2 months. They were just completely different children.
You know what is best for your child. Don’t be swayed by the “I did fine” or “rules is rules” argument.
The only person this ultimately affects is your child.

NalafromtheLionKing · 27/09/2023 18:39

My DS (secondary school) has a late June bday and just got the highest achievement points in his year group (not deferred) so 🤷‍♀️

Lovely17 · 27/09/2023 18:39

my birthday is 31/08 and I was the youngest in my class, I was great during school & didn’t need any extra help, I didn’t fall behind with work etc.

my ds who’s birthday is 30/08 has just started nursery seems so much younger than the September born 4 year olds in his class… i didn’t even know deferring was a thing, i think he would maybe benefit from that as he’s got speech delay… x

DoughBallss · 27/09/2023 18:39

I have a June 2020 girl who just started nursery at the primary school she will be going to. Absolutely thriving…loves it

RockyReef · 27/09/2023 18:46

I would say YABU as you seem to be basing your decision primarily on the perceived unfairness between your two children. We were in the same situation with DS1 and DS2, except more extreme (beginning of August & end of September birthdays). DS1 is the youngest in his year at secondary, and DS2 is the second oldest in his class in year 5, they are only just over 2 years in age difference but are 3 school years apart. Both very academic and sporty, DS1 goes to a selective school, DS2 goes to a small local school but will go to the same secondary. It never even crossed our minds to defer DS1’s entry to reception as he was clever and seemed ready. He was (and is) shy and we suspect he has what used to be called Asperger’s but together we have decided not to seek a diagnosis for now. He has flourished at school right through, despite being less mature than some of the other children when he started (in fairness some of the oldest children were the least mature though!), and is very social and popular even though he can be shy and quirky! He is sporty which has helped massively, both in making friends and in his own confidence. DS2 does have an easier ride if everything - he is as NT as they come, a cheery extrovert who is in G&T programmes for academics and sports. But him being how he is doesn’t affect what’s best for our eldest, and didn’t factor in our decision making. Reception is a big change for all children and I wouldn’t say that my almost 5 year old was any less tired at the end of the days than my just-turned 4 year old. He does have an advantage in sports as he is physically taller and stronger but that soon evens out and my smaller eldest makes up in skill what he lacks in height. I think the key thing is to support their development individually. If you feel it’s best to defer your eldest then do so, but not because it will make it fairer for her compared to your youngest. The teachers are used to a range of children in terms of age, maturity and intelligence so they don’t expect them all to achieve the same standards or behaviour immediately, and there will be children younger than your daughter in her class without a doubt.

Thirtyandflailing · 27/09/2023 18:50

I was an august baby so was one of the youngest and I had cousins born in September and October so they was the oldest and I got better SATs and GCSEs even though I was younger. I would only consider deferring if you really don’t think they would cope but tbh kids starting school/nursery always adapt because there’s always going to be younger and older kids

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 27/09/2023 18:52

I was the oldest in my year at school, but due to them changing the cut off dates I was the youngest when I started with the year above and had to stay down when they moved on to be with my own year group.

I was much happier being the youngest. Also by the time I was in y11 I was thoroughly sick of school and really gave up. I felt I was nearly 17 and should have left before that. I did much worse than I would have if I had left the year before.

just another perspective. Someone always has to be the youngest. I do think where will it end with the deferrals, but you know your child. But in a way I’d rather they took a bit longer to settle into primary at aged 4/5 than massively resent being held back and the oldest at almost 17 and give up.

Gettingolderandgrumpier60 · 27/09/2023 18:55

Gettingolderandgrumpier60 · 27/09/2023 18:36

Most LAs/schools will not defer a child’s admission to school, even in cases when child has substantial SEN. However, children do not legally have to attend school until their 5th birthday so you can decide to defer their admission but you will find your child does start school they will be put straight into Year 1 and will have missed the whole of their Reception year, which is a crucial year. Even if you manage to find a school that will allow this, you have to then coordinate with secondary school as they would also have to take child out of chronological year as it causes issues with formal exams. (For context, I am a recently retired primary head who has dealt with cases like this.)

This comment refers to schools in north of England. May have difference practice abroad. Also, I have DC with August birthday and, although he seemed a little ‘immature’ in comparison to his class, this ‘gap’ soon disappeared and he achieved above average KS1 SATs.

celticprincess · 27/09/2023 19:22

Both my children are august born. Both are extremely bright. Both were also fairly young for their age. One was diagnosed autistic at 10. Both have been perfectly fine in the actual year group. I did consider deferring at one point however was told that deferring reception meant they would start straight into y1 with the class they deferred from. Not sure if this is still the case. But felt that would leave them at even more disadvantage. They did both go to the pre school attached to the main school (private though) and the preschool and reception share continuous provision space. What they found hard from starting pre school at just turning 3 was that there were friendship groups already established from the older kids that had done 2 terms already. There were a lot of summer born kids in one of my daughters classes and the pre school teacher said it was harder work than usual.

However both have done well academically. One got greater depth in her sats. The other missed sats due to Covid but is now embarking on GCSEs and is is higher middle sets and some top sets.

If you think they are bright then don’t defer. When my youngest was in pre school it was clear she was very bright and even the teacher had to restrain herself from giving her reception level work as she would have had to repeat it the following year. But she was more than capable.

On another note there was a family in the class from Poland and they start school later there. Her eldest didn’t settle so they pulled her out with the plan to start her on y2 (if I recall but could have been later or earlier) at the age she would be in Poland. This failed miserably as the child was unable to fit in after being home so much longer so the family ended up choosing to home educate. Not sure if they persisted a bit more in the reception days then the child might have eventually settled.

rennieroo · 27/09/2023 19:36

My cousins (siblings) were 11 months apart, eldest September, youngest August so both in the same school year. Youngest was always more sociable and in higher sets. Nothing to do with date of birth, just personality

Tamuchly · 27/09/2023 19:42

I know of a child held back because his older brother didn’t have a great start to school (both summer born). Unfortunately the younger brother didn’t really need this delay so is currently sitting in a Year 2 class bored because he is capable of so much more. Children are individuals, even when they have the same parents and upbringing, and should be treated accordingly. The gap between autumn and summer born feels huge in the Reception year but by Year 6 it’s much smaller and by Year 11 it’s almost non-existent. If we hold all the summer born children back then what about the spring born children?

WotsitsMadeIn1927 · 27/09/2023 20:21

My eldest was born at the end of August, making him the youngest in his year group by almost a year. He excelled in all his subjects.

Decide whether your child is ready for school, rather than comparing expectations between children due to their ages.

trainboundfornowhere · 27/09/2023 20:23

My parents chose not to defer me and I’m a July born but due to my DF job meaning my parents moved from England to Scotland I completed reception in England and hated it. I then moved to year 1 in England but during the Easter holidays we moved countries and I moved schools completing primary 1 in Scotland. In England I was one of the youngest in my year but in Scotland I was in the middle age wise. I managed but was in the lower groups academically though I did pass all my exams at standard grade (GCSES) with nothing lower than a C grade.

Hoppysue · 27/09/2023 20:55

I’d be very wary about deferring…. Depending on the education authority you are under… the rules for transferring to secondary school vary… eg some authorities expect children to rejoin their correct year group.

Janeycarrie · 27/09/2023 20:58

Most of Europe don’t start formal school till 6 or 7 and if you lived in Scotland she wouldn’t start till the next year because the youngest here is 4 and 6 months and many people defer for their children at this age. I think just 4 is too young, you will be giving her a much bigger advantage by going to school later both socially and emotionally never mind being more ready academically.

Rcc67 · 27/09/2023 21:05

I always regretted sending my DC to school at 4yrs old! Wasn’t ready for it and would have benefited from a further year at nursery. I was a young naive mum and just done what the system said you do. If you don’t think your DC is ready then wait another year x

ImInACage · 27/09/2023 21:18

MrsRaspberry · 27/09/2023 09:49

@ImInACage where am i spreading misinformation as fact? My comment stated "as far as I am aware" and where is it illegal to skip Reception year? Reception class is non compulsory for a start off so skipping it is not illegal. Hence why in my area if you defer your kids a year they begin their schooling from year 1 keeping in line with their school age group

I didn't say that skipping reception was illegal, I said that it's not lawful for an admissions board to have a blanket policy regarding summer norms. By law, each case has to be looked at and assessed in order to make a decision based on the needs of each individual child. What they categorically cannot do it's have a policy that all children who wish to defer will go into year one. That is not legal, as it goes against government legislation.

Good grief there are some I'll informed people on here, it's so frustrating to see the same misinformation repeated over and over.

WeightoftheWorld · 27/09/2023 21:23

Gettingolderandgrumpier60 · 27/09/2023 18:55

This comment refers to schools in north of England. May have difference practice abroad. Also, I have DC with August birthday and, although he seemed a little ‘immature’ in comparison to his class, this ‘gap’ soon disappeared and he achieved above average KS1 SATs.

This is not accurate. I'm in the North of England, and had absolutely no difficulty with a range of schools agreeing to my DC starting in reception at 5.

It's great that your DC's gap disappeared, but statistically, on average, it doesn't.

ImInACage · 27/09/2023 21:23

Hoppysue · 27/09/2023 20:55

I’d be very wary about deferring…. Depending on the education authority you are under… the rules for transferring to secondary school vary… eg some authorities expect children to rejoin their correct year group.

Again, this would be an unlawful blanket policy. each secondary admission board would have to make a decision based on the child's needs, taking into account that they had always been with that cohort. Not one of the 20+ heads I spoke to regarding my DS's transfer to high school had a problem with him staying with his cohort, before I'd submitted any evidence. Most said that they would never make a child miss a year.

Zeezee82 · 27/09/2023 22:07

I found that most LAs were under-educated in the area, rather than against it. We span 3. One was apathetic, one clueless and one pro-choice

2IT · 27/09/2023 22:15

Oldest DC has just started reception, she is one of the eldest in her year. She is struggling emotionally with it and chooses to stay close to the teacher a lot.
She is bright with an interest in letters and numbers but socially prefers adult company, was the same at pre school.
Yet some of the August born babies in their class are confident and enjoy socialising.
I feel there is a lot of emphasis put on age when actually each child is individual. Just because you defer them a year doesn’t necessarily mean they will socially be more mature or even academically. They could simple be how they are now just older.
The constant referral to each child being at a certain age level is slightly troublesome. In a lot of reception years the setting will start to group them depending on ability so they will be learning with others at the same level regardless.
My youngest DC will be about middle for their year, they are clever but prefer to mess around rather than learn unlike my eldest at their age. This is just their personality not a reflection of when their bday is…..

Elvis1956 · 27/09/2023 22:43

I can only speak from personal experience of my own time at school. I was a very shy, timid child but started school at 4 and 1/4 because back in the 1970s headmasters had a lot more say. Dad was a greengrocer making a delivery to the school and the head said I needed to start next term.
It was the best thing to ever happen to me. I had time to adapt, to learn and be ahead of my peirs when they joined and things levelled out.
I grew in confidence, believed I was actually clever (although every iq test scored me at dead average and I have taken dozens)
It meant I got good o levels and whilst I failed at a level(mainly through laziness and partly because mum died 1/2 way through) I got a good job. Worked hard and now will retire this year at 55....thank you Mr Sykes!

crowisland · 27/09/2023 22:46
  1. as a matter of urgency, you need to get your asd daughter to a qualified therapist ASAP! I've seen kids with very noticeable asd get lots of excellent therapy (including equine therapy) and their lives were turned around. Have become loving, productive and brilliant adults.
  2. Best friend's son was premature, youngest in class, and it's a key factor that has destroyed his and his parents' lives. He's 25 now. Drugs, crime, no moral compass, two babies. He never got the academic attention he needed (despite being in a good primary), and he always thought he was 'thick' and there was something wrong and inferior about himself. Also had dyslexia that was not dealt with. The therapeutic interventions were too little, too late. They tried to defer, but the local educational authority refused--even though his 40 week birth date SHOULD have landed him in the following year. I've watched this tragedy since he was born. Heartbreaking.
  3. you are the only advocate for your child--you know her best, and trust yourself! good luck