Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?

402 replies

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:42

Hello
I have two dcs, one born in 19/7/2020 and the other in 2/9/2022.
First dc is due to enter Reception in Sept 2024 at 4 +2 months due to state cut off, and the second will be due in Sept 2027 at 5 yo.

I feel like it is unfair for dc1 to be expected to act/ achieve at a level of 3 years ahead of dc2 when she is practically only 2 years older than dc2. Dc1 has ASD while dc2 is very likely NT, which adds to that.

I am considering a deferral for dc1 mainly because of this reason, which DH thinks is ridiculous.

Any ideas on whether I should defer dc1?

For some context both dcs are academically bright, but dc1 is really babyish compared to other 3 yo and dc2 seems more mature than other 1yo.

OP posts:
Ownedby2kidsandadog · 26/09/2023 21:49

That’s incorrect information.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?
K4tM · 26/09/2023 21:51

My son was a July baby (26/7) and was held back from starting school until Jan when his contemporaries from nursery started in Sept. He/we found it frustrating for him to be left behind in nursery. My daughter, also a summer baby (22/6) had to start in Sept which was perhaps a little soon for her. But it has evened out over the years and now they’re both fine and we scarcely remember.

WillowCraft · 26/09/2023 22:09

It sounds as though your older child would benefit from a delayed entry without doubt. The reason being the social side and ASD. She may well come on a lot during that extra year.

However I think you are wrong in the way you are comparing your children. You are the only one comparing them in this way - they'll be be 2 or 3 years apart at school, no one is going to be thinking about the fact that the older one wasn't achieving the same level 3 years ago when they are teaching the younger one. The one with ASD is going to have a very different experience from her sister with or without a delayed entry - you can't undo the condition or make her equal to her sister.
Additionally children all develop at different rates. Just because some other one year olds aren't as good as talking as yours, that doesn't mean other children won't catch up and surpass in the next year or so. As long as your children are happy they will achieve their best.

Pumpernickel27 · 26/09/2023 22:18

I wouldn't, because (I believe) if you defer a year your child has to then start school from year one, and reception is structured differently (lots of play based learning, designed to ease children into school) and so I think it would be more detrimental to miss out on reception and go straight to year one.

AussiUnHomme · 26/09/2023 22:21

You've already got labels for your kids, the poor things...

JRM17 · 26/09/2023 22:31

Why would u defer a mid July baby. The cut off is 1st Sep. I went all the way through school with a boy who's BD is 31st Aug, you're talking about making a decision without even giving you child a chance

Jemjems89 · 26/09/2023 22:34

My eldest is May born and has ASD and social/communication difficulties, also likes to be in his own world. We didn't defer as actually the kids "levels" are so varied. Actually my son was ready for reception and learnt all the tricky words and phonics faster than a lot of other children. But socially, and with speech/communication, he's way behind and actually his 3 year old brother with ASD is actually about the same level as him and socially more advanced and will be starting school in September as he's December born. Yet, I think my youngest is going to really struggle with school and with the learning and I won't be able to defer his place because he's one of the older ones.
You can get everyone's opinions but actually, only you know your child and whether she'd be able to cope with school or not. If you talk to the school SENCO, once she starts reception, it might be if she's really struggling they can keep her back a year, or even just add in extra support for her.

trainboundfornowhere · 26/09/2023 22:45

If your eldest is in nursery then talk to the nursery staff as they will see it all the time so will be in a good position to offer advice.

floquinho12 · 26/09/2023 22:58

We have deferred our son and was thr best decision we have made.
One extra year of play has made a wonderful of goodness for him.
Specially starting year1 now!

floquinho12 · 26/09/2023 23:01

How does it make sense that kids born in July and August finish Reception at still being 4yo and the Compulsory School age is 5?

In Scotland kids born from April only go to school thr following year.

4 is SO different from 5. At 4 they are still toddlers.

Lasvegas · 26/09/2023 23:05

My birthday is 1 sept and my sister was born 11 months and 11 days after me. So we ended up in same school year. I was the oldest and she was one of the youngest.

My mother tried to get my sister put back a school year but couldn’t- this was in the mid 70’s.
it was terrible as we were such different characters, we never got on and still don’t in middle age.

PollyPut · 26/09/2023 23:09

If you defer then what happens when they get to secondary school and try to enter external competitions (maths/sport/other events)? They are too old for the correct yeargroup - are they still eligible or will they be excluded?

floquinho12 · 26/09/2023 23:09

Ultimately it is the parents decision.
They only approval you need to get is to start at Reception.
What borough are you? Some boroughs are much easier than others.
Join the group Summerborns Admissions, lots of information and families sharing their own stories.

From our experience what we can tell is 4 is MUCH different than 5. Our son has changed completely from one year to another. At 4 he was pretty much a toddler still. And also, similar do your DC1 he would have finished Reception still being a 4yo! Makes absolutely no sense when Compulsory School Age is 5.

People saying you would be depriving your DC1 from education have no idea what they are talking.
You would only be given her an extra year of play. Kid would do the whole school years anyway.

Enjoy your babies. They are only little once.

PollyPut · 26/09/2023 23:10

Also - have you understood how applications into year 1 work in your area? Would you be certain to get the school you want if you apply a year late? Or will all the year 1 spaces have been taken in reception?

PollyPut · 26/09/2023 23:20

And have you considered how DC1 will feel starting school when all the others have already been there a year and made friends?

I would be starting DC1 in reception

76evie · 26/09/2023 23:30

My youngest is an august baby, sent them to reception at 4 years and couple of weeks. No problems, academically or from emotionally mature/immature aspect. If anything the girl in the class that was born 1st September, was the one that always seemed to be too grown up, so she would have probably thrived more if she had been allowed to start school the year before, couple days after turning 4 instead of 5.

However you know your child best.

I think they could be some resentment when they are older, teenage years, if you do defer them starting for a year.

Pleaseme · 26/09/2023 23:30

I deferred my middle child. Honestly I felt that he could do with an extra year of nursery to socially mature. He is the eldest in his class but next class up has the previous years deferrals so he'd of been the youngest with people up to 13 months older than him. I got an extra year of school nursery funding and he joined the school with them (didn't miss out on a year or anything).

It's pretty easy for him and has perhaps coasted a bit but I think he'd of struggled a lot being younger. Already a younger sibling he was constantly chasing to catch up so it was quite nice for him to feel confident that he had this.

Gmary20 · 26/09/2023 23:46

If she's bright there's no reason to defer her. Children young in the year do sometimes find it harder, but they catch up and if they are bright often it doesn't make any difference (I'm a teacher for context). If she's kept back a year when she's older her peers will tease her and it will be embarrassing for her. Plus, I don't think your actually allowed to defer school entry if there is no good reason... plus if she's bon in July there will be several children younger than her in her class, and in general girls mature before boys anyway so she will already have a head start against many of the boys in her class even if they are older.

Geordiebabe85 · 27/09/2023 06:24

My DD was 3 at end of August and will start a week after her 4th birthday. I'm a primary teacher. We won't defer.
From my experience summer babies struggle for the first few years but generally by y6 are at age related standard.
Check the school you want to use too. Some head teachers would want to put her straight into y1 when she starts a year later. However, some are much more flexible. But don't just assume.

claireandbabe · 27/09/2023 06:27

Deferring won't mean DC starts a year late in Reception. They will go straight into Y1 having missed all that socialisation and practical learning in the last year of EYFS. Schools have managed the huge gap in children born at different times of the year forever. It is very difficult comparing our own Ch to others as you can't be objective.

Ellen1990 · 27/09/2023 06:30

I was the youngest 31/08
I could read before I went to school, if my mum had held me back I’d have been devastated. I was all top groups etc… BUT in reception I had to be put on half days, I kept falling asleep halfway through the day, it was just too much.
Ask your child if they want to go to school but don’t make it sound scary, take them to visit etc let them decide themselves

Covetthee · 27/09/2023 06:36

claireandbabe · 27/09/2023 06:27

Deferring won't mean DC starts a year late in Reception. They will go straight into Y1 having missed all that socialisation and practical learning in the last year of EYFS. Schools have managed the huge gap in children born at different times of the year forever. It is very difficult comparing our own Ch to others as you can't be objective.

Yes it does.

when you defer, you just defer their reception year to the following year. Otherwise there would be no need to defer if they will still have been in the same class at their older peers.

hence all the talk of being the oldest in the class rather than the youngest.

Suzi2806 · 27/09/2023 06:39

Why would she go straight into year 1? She can start reception at Csa age 5.

Muthaofcats · 27/09/2023 06:55

I think you are being given an unfairly hard time for the ‘conparison’ element of your post; I think I get what you mean - it’s inevitable that you’ll see how much easier being older in the year makes the experience for your oldest child, so of course you are going to be aware of how different that might be for your youngest and worry that they will be at a disadvantage.

Statistically they ARE at a disadvantage so I think it’s wholly reasonable to be looking at the options available to you to correct that disadvantage - it’s precisely why the option for summer borns exists, because the government recognised the impact of starting school at just turned 4 and as the youngest in the class, so made it possible for parents to avoid that by allowing the option to start reception at 5 instead.

Its only in recent years that children started going to reception at just 4. It used to be staged based on birth month. This change was more to do with funding (once the 30 hours were introduced, schools altered entry ages in order to benefit from the 30 hours funding) and economics (getting women back into work). There is not evidence to support starting formal education at just 4 is beneficial for children. There are, however, a wealth of studies showing the benefits of being older when you start.

I would ignore all the anecdotes that say ‘my august born started at 4 and now they are prime minister and a doctor and a lawyer etc’ and look at objective data instead . What do the studies say about suicide rates for summer borns, risk of severe bullying, chances of being mislabelled as SEN, chances of getting into a Russel group Uni? Etc etc

Next, look at your own instincts: there is a reason you are contemplating it for your youngest, ultimately you should be guided by this rather than other people’s opinion because they don’t know your family.

It is also necessary to identify that a lot of the responses will come from a perspective of NOT having taken advantage of the summer born guidance (either because they didn’t know about it, or were pressured to follow the status quo) and will then naturally be defensive about this and need to justify their decision by being very much against those that did. I always pause and ask myself why on Earth someone could be reacting so strongly about a decision for my child, usually the only justification for such a strong response is their own anxiety / guilt driving their approach.

I have friends who benefited from how much easier it has been for their autumn born eldest so felt even more confident they needed to give their summer born youngest the same opportunity, that makes perfect sense. You can only know the difference when you have a child born in each month and see for yourself the difference in their experience.

Finally, mumsnet seems to be made up of a large proportion of the people who do not delay start, so be prepared to see the majority of replies here falling into the ‘defensive/guilty/self justification’ category. For a more informed perspective do look up the flexible school admissions for summer borns group on facebook. Of course on there you will find more of an echo chamber as those people tend to be more well informed about the option and did go for it and so naturally likely to be biased the other way. But a combo of the misinformed ignorant opinions and the informed opinions should help you come to your own….

it is helpful though to read all the ignorant comments as if you do go for a delayed start for your summer born, you will need to be prepared to accept that there will be lots of people with an opinion and you’ll have to be ok with that. It took me some getting used to, but then I remembered it’s like with all of parenting, how you choose to feed your kid, what car seat you use etc - ultimately other peoples opinions about your parenting are not what matters so trust your own knowledge of your kids and focus on objective facts in deciding what is right for you.

good luck !

Muthaofcats · 27/09/2023 07:00

Please don’t ‘let them decide for themselves’, they are currently 3. They have no idea what they would be deciding for themselves. They haven’t a true concept of what school means. I had a friend who sent her summer born because they said they wanted to go, and he was still wetting himself in reception, gets bullied and is now on a special intervention because he can’t fluently read (which you need to be able to do by year 1) . If he was starting reception this year with my just turned 5 year old he would actually seem advanced, as he is a bright kid, but now is labelled as one of the struggling kids which must be horrible for his confidence and breaks my heart. His mum says she wished she hadn’t asked him and the nursery and had done more reading about it.