Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?

402 replies

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:42

Hello
I have two dcs, one born in 19/7/2020 and the other in 2/9/2022.
First dc is due to enter Reception in Sept 2024 at 4 +2 months due to state cut off, and the second will be due in Sept 2027 at 5 yo.

I feel like it is unfair for dc1 to be expected to act/ achieve at a level of 3 years ahead of dc2 when she is practically only 2 years older than dc2. Dc1 has ASD while dc2 is very likely NT, which adds to that.

I am considering a deferral for dc1 mainly because of this reason, which DH thinks is ridiculous.

Any ideas on whether I should defer dc1?

For some context both dcs are academically bright, but dc1 is really babyish compared to other 3 yo and dc2 seems more mature than other 1yo.

OP posts:
Highfivemum · 26/09/2023 19:11

You have to look at each child as individual. I didn’t defer my aug DC as they were ready. One of the mums who I met in hospital did and it was the worse thing. Her DS got bored in nursery/playgroup and started misbehaving. His behaviour went backwards. She regrets it.

MonchichiMonchichi · 26/09/2023 19:19

My daughter is Summerborn and we made the decision for her to start Reception a year later at Compulsory School Age at the age of 5.The Department for Education says that these children should not have to miss either Year 6 or Year 7 in order to transition into secondary school. We have just had approval from 6 secondary schools to allow us to apply for a Year 7 out of year group place next year. Which means that she will transition to secondary with her adopted cohort.

Best decision we ever made, back when she was four.

mangokiwi · 26/09/2023 19:21

I haven’t read the whole thread so this might have been mentioned already.
Deferring a year does have its benefits but can cause a problem with sports teams particularly if they want to compete at a higher level (county etc) as they will have to join the year above.

HerRoyalStressHead · 26/09/2023 19:30

No I wouldn't defer.

I have an NT 9 year old December born girl and a ND 8 year old August born boy. They're year 5 and 4 now.

I wouldn't have dreamt of deferring my son because he's autistic and because he's the youngest. Someone has to be the youngest and there are bound to be undiagnosed neurodiverse children too. I was an August born undiagnosed autistic and did amazing in school.
Likewise for DS, he's absolutely smashing school.
DD on the other hand struggles with spelling and writing, is physically a lot smaller than her peers due to short stature, barely speaks due to selective mutism and is academically at a level more suited to her brothers level or younger.
Does this mean she should be deferred despite technically being one of the oldest in the class? Some kids are going to find it more difficult than others. There's nothing that you can do to change that so why take away her educational opportunities?

leighh88 · 26/09/2023 19:38

Mine is 29th July so she will be the youngest in the year, i did read up on deferring but decided against it, mainly for the reasons; if i defered her she is not guaranteed to start in reception whete im from, it is each individual schools choice, so i didnt want to take the risk of her starting in year one, knowing that all the children in her class have had a year to get to know each other and make friends in reception class.

Leasa12 · 26/09/2023 19:39

I have 2 kids very similar to this my eldest was more than ready for school at only 4. My youngest started at 5 she is first week of sept too and that suited her she was far to immature at 4 she struggled at 5 to be honest. My eldest is doing her GCSE this year and is very academic and is predicted top grades I know it would have been unfair to hold her back a year.

trainboundfornowhere · 26/09/2023 19:40

I am in Scotland so the school cutoff is a different point in the year. They start school in August and those born in March will be 5 and a half and those in February 4 and a half when starting school in August. My DSis year for example were born between March 1985 and February 1986. My DSis was born in February and DB in late December which meant my parents had the option to defer both of them.

They sent my sister at the right time and while she managed academically she was emotionally immature so had few friends to begin with though she caught up within a couple of years. They deferred my brother and he managed fairly middle of the road academically and had a good group of friends. He is still friends with them today but his two best friends were also deferred by their parents.

HikingforScenery · 26/09/2023 19:43

Do it. Those who’ve done it have said nothing but good things

Somuchgoo · 26/09/2023 19:49

leighh88 · 26/09/2023 19:38

Mine is 29th July so she will be the youngest in the year, i did read up on deferring but decided against it, mainly for the reasons; if i defered her she is not guaranteed to start in reception whete im from, it is each individual schools choice, so i didnt want to take the risk of her starting in year one, knowing that all the children in her class have had a year to get to know each other and make friends in reception class.

You get a yes/no from the schools before you have to make a final decision so this situation shouldn't arise. The only way it would would be if you got none of your school choices, but you can get around that by ensuring at least one is an undersubscribed school.

We had our 3 'yesses' lined up early enough that we have certainty.

If you've changed your mind about wanting to delay that's fine, but I just wanted to let you know that you don't have anything to worry about in that front.

WeightoftheWorld · 26/09/2023 19:49

Ladyoftheknight · 26/09/2023 19:00

This is the most mental thing I've ever read. OP, give your head a really good wobble for your childrens sake. Your children are normal children, they are different from each other and are much more resilient than you are allowing them to be. You're also not the first person to ever be a parent, or a parent to possbly ND children.

You have asked for advice, we have told you your idea is mad, bad and not based on fact or good reasoning. Speak to some professionals so you can hear it from them too.

Surely the reams of research, readily available via Google, showing that summer born children who start school in their usual cohort in England, have statistically on average worse outcomes across a whole range of measures - from phonics screening test results, to mental health as teenagers, to GCSE results, to Oxbridge applicants - is 'fact' and 'good reasoning'?

Hocuspocusnonsense · 26/09/2023 19:49

I deferred my April born because she wasn’t emotionally ready. She had crippling separation anxiety and hated being away from me and home. She started school at 5yrs 4 months and it was 100% the right decision. She has made friends and sits in the middle when it comes to academic achievement. She isn’t ahead of the class or bored.

JustAnotherCheeseburger · 26/09/2023 19:50

My daughter has a late August birthday and we didn't defer because she was socially okay in her year group and working at expected levels in nursery.

A couple of potential things to be aware of...

  • she struggled to read in primary and she would have found it hard being the eldest in the year and also with a very low reading age. She wouldn't have liked realising that children a year younger than her were reading better than her and possibly would have made it a bigger issue for her.
  • socially she's a much better fit with her current peers. She finds the immature boys annoying, of course if she was the eldest in they year, the boys would be a whole year younger!
  • we were also concerned that she might need to jump a year at the start of secondary and we weren't prepared to risk that.

Now she's studying for her GCSEs, I'm pleased we didn't defer. She has a lovely group of friends her own age and is on track for good results. She's dyslexic which is why reading was hard, nothing to do with her age. The only slight hiccup I see is that she'll be the last to turn 18 and therefore the last to get ID.

beyourownchampion · 26/09/2023 20:02

I have two DDs at secondary, one is the eldest in year 9, the other is the youngest in year 8. Both are top sets and the fact that my youngest is an August baby seems to make no difference academically even though she looks absolutely tiny compared with her peers. Personally, I wouldn’t delay , if a child is struggling, school with make adjustments and give extra support if needed.

Ladyoftheknight · 26/09/2023 20:03

WeightoftheWorld · 26/09/2023 19:49

Surely the reams of research, readily available via Google, showing that summer born children who start school in their usual cohort in England, have statistically on average worse outcomes across a whole range of measures - from phonics screening test results, to mental health as teenagers, to GCSE results, to Oxbridge applicants - is 'fact' and 'good reasoning'?

But OP doesn't seem worried about that, they're convinced their child is a genius at 1 and the other a baby. That they know exactly how their children will be treated in the 'wrong' year. No one can read at 1, OP is deluded to believe their child is that developed, which is what is influencing their decision here.

Mumtryingtolivethedream · 26/09/2023 20:17

I think by deferring her and having her put with younger ones will potentially hold her back if anything with older ones she has the potential to fly as the others will bring her on and eventually it will all even out the others in the class won't all be September October never born many will be spring and summer so she won't be the only July child. At first the age gap will show but that will slowly disappear

Inspiredpumpkin2 · 26/09/2023 20:47

When I enquired with my LEA about deferring my DD born 30/8 I was told there wouldn’t be much benefit as she would miss reception and have to start school in year 1. Meaning the rest of the class will have already been there a year and formed friendships and routines. It also meant that the normal admission process wouldn’t apply and we would be stuck with whatever school had a space in the year group and that might not necessarily be local.

givemeasunnyday · 26/09/2023 20:57

I was the youngest in my year at school - there were kids in the year below who were older than me (not in the UK), and it never bothered me. What does it matter?

emziecy · 26/09/2023 20:57

You should of course do what you think is right for your child but you might be overthinking this. I have 3 sons, October, March and June. All went from school nursery to reception to Y1 etc in September. Oldest is 33, other 2 are 16 and 17 (still at school, although abroad in local non English speaking state school.) All have done absolutely fine and their birth month and the exact age they started nursery/reception has never made any difference to their achievements. I am also a Primary teacher. Teachers are very qualified and experienced in differentiating for children's abilities and individual needs. Please trust us, we want the best outcome for every child in our care x

Stoptheworldiwanttogetoff · 26/09/2023 21:12

Surely if your concern about her development is mainly her level of maturity this will be helped more by going to school where she will be surrounded by older and more mature kids rather than staying in nursery with younger immature kids. I think particularly with your daughters advanced academic ability I would not be deferring as PP have said this will likely lead to her being bored in class and possibly end up being ostracised by her class mates for being a clever clogs or know-it-all. Kids can be cruel and can latch on to any reason to pick on another kids. Plus, it’s almost a year away and they can change so much in that amount of time. My DC (also a July baby due to start next September) has only just started playing with other kids at nursery so you may find that over the coming months you see a change in her anyway.

Samlewis96 · 26/09/2023 21:13

caban · 26/09/2023 11:00

I'd 100% defer.

I have an older August born and a younger September born, and the September born had a hugely easier time.

My summer born did fine, managed, was ok but it was totally different to thriving and sailing through early school, always being one of the oldest, biggest, most articulate, most confident.

There's a reason why Autumn borns are statistically more likely to be on sports teams, get speaking roles in plays and do better in their exams.

Summer borns have a disadvantage and Autumn borns have an advantage. Some able Summer borns will succeed despite the disadvantage which is obviously great, but not sure why anyone would choose not to give their child an advantage if they have the opportunity.

Doesn't always work that way. I was born late Aug ( and also 6 weeks prem) From the moment I went to school I excelled. By the end of the first term I'd read all the infants books and by year 2 had ploughed through the juniorscstuff also. I had no issues making friends. My brother on the other hand was born early Oct. He struggled gor 3 years and couldn't read at all until he was nearly 7. No SEN just not ready.

Horatiosmum · 26/09/2023 21:33

The school system knows how to juggle the age range as it happens every year, your situation is not unique.

My oldest DS was born 24/9 and his younger brother (by 2 years) was born other 14/7 so similar ages to yours in relation to starting school.

Our oldest turned 5 in the second week of starting reception and was ready for school. Our youngest had just turned 4 and was really still a toddler.

The youngest wasn't fully potty trained when he started Reception, he is very young for his age too but he is loving school, the school are nurturing and they have children with these age gaps every year. He is doing really well and better than his brother did when he was in Reception yet his brother was almost a year older than him when he was there.

Don't hold your child back, if you have concerns speak to the school they deal with this every year.

My youngest is now in year 1 and is better at reading than his older brother!

Zanatdy · 26/09/2023 21:34

I don’t think it’s necessary if your DD is bright already. By the time they are in secondary they are all on a level playing field. My son is mid August, came out with all 9’s in GCSE and 3 A stars at A level. Holding him back a year would have achieved nothing.

Sophsky · 26/09/2023 21:38

If your main concern is social difficulty due to ASD, how will another year growing older with even younger and less socially capable children going to help her?

emziecy · 26/09/2023 21:39

As a teacher I would never recommend skipping reception and going straight into Y1, or any year unless they are exceptionally mature in terms of social skills and gifted all round. I teach Y2 abroad and half my class have come straight from reception into Y2 and just don't have the basic social and academic skills learnt in Y1. The other half are actually Y3 age but have come from countries where formal schooling is not compulsary until age 7, and also do not have the English language ability to access the curriculum. As a teacher I think for social and emotional reasons young children should stay with their chronological peers unless there are exceptional reasons not to. Part of a teacher's job is to differentiate for every child, and to support as needed for different abilities. However this is much easier said than done 😞

TheRealShatParp · 26/09/2023 21:45

Hello OP,
just because they’re siblings does not make it more unfair than 2 unrelated children with the same birthdays.
I have a summer born child (august) and it did cross my mind that she will be behind the older children academically, but it’s my understanding that deferring children just excuses them from reception. So if you defer your child they’ll skip reception and wait until the next year and go straight into year one. Perhaps I’m wrong.