Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What can I take on walks that may help if a dog attacks us.

502 replies

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 06/06/2023 20:39

I've noticed that some very nasty dogs are being walked on our usual local walks around a pretty village.

With the recent spate of attacks and my suspicions of the owners, is there anything that could help in the event of an attack eg high pitched noise like rape alarm.
? What do you do if a dog goes for the child or yourself?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
WiddlinDiddlin · 11/06/2023 14:27

Mmm... ah, but the Titchmarsh interview with Cesar was a DELIGHT.

Lots of trainers/behaviourists contacted Titchmarsh before the interview was filmed, filled him on in the details - it appears Alan really does not like bullies.

Cesar was doing the 'tour the chat shows to promote my book/show' thing and all the shows were pretty light hearted, fluffy stuff, where he could talk a bit of guff, flash his brilliant smile and laugh at the ineptitude of dog owners (usually woman, the man is an absolute sexist misogynistic pig)... promote his gig and off.

He was therefore, thoroughly and absolutely, unprepared for Titchmarsh to push him over his methods, particularly hitting, pinning, shock collars...

It was really well planned, they even had another trainer (Steve Mann I think) in the wings, in case Cesar stormed off and they needed a quick fill in 'doggy content'...

But nope, he didn't stomp off, he DID pretend he didn't understand English enough to try to deflect some questions (that is one of his stock responses if someone gets pushy with the awkward questions) - then was pushed into an off script description of how he did use positive reinforcement too - only what he described was bizarre - using a parrot that would bite the dog (or the dog was scared of it), to teach the dog not to do something to the owner... (IIRC!)..

Titchmarsh absolutely fucking destroyed him, revealed him for the total cunt he is and made him look VERY stupid.

Apparently Cesar was FURIOUS afterwards and his team/entourage had a heck of a job getting him back on his bus and out of it. A lot of 'you can't air this...' but at the time, it was filmed only a short while before being aired giggle so it went out pretty much exactly as it went down!

oakleaffy · 11/06/2023 18:24

WiddlinDiddlin · 11/06/2023 04:31

I think it won't surprise you to know Graeme used to be a salesman...

Mm, I have the (sometimes dubious, there are things I'd often rather not know!) benefit of several 'insider' friends working in tv here and in the US.

Cesars practice is to take a dog off the owners for upwards of 2/3 hours before bringing the owners back in - this is whether working with them 1 to 1 or actually for filming (though he did very little training in the US before being on TV. His training background in Mexico was in training protection dogs to bite people...

Both the 'tssst' and the little backward kicky thing he does with his heel are heavily conditioned with whatever aversive the owners already use or he feels suitable - hence the rather extreme reaction! Say 'tsst' or nudge an unconditioned dog like that and 9 times out of 10 you will get mild surprise and confusion or nothing at all!

He also used to offer to swap people dogs he could not fix (though they'd be labelled 'not suitable for the family' of course...) for one of his pack... That pack was just whatever pound dogs would tolerate the communal living conditions they were kept in without huge fights breaking out.

Many did not tolerate those conditions... but in any case, he actually dumped several 'packs' when he moved facilities, leaving local rescues/dog people to sort that out.

The man has got away with near murder tbh, as he has friends in verrrrrry high places (or had, anyway) - the time he set a dog loose, on a pair of young and terrified pigs, knowing that dog had already killed a pig, and that aired on TV... wow. Animal Control actually investigated that and tried to bring a cruelty case but... suddenly... poof, it alllll disappeared.

Hey ho! I digress and it is bedtime. I've spent 8 hours today helping nice people with on the whole, suitable dogs, set their puppies up for a happy, safe life (some of them were even asking for help BEFORE they got a puppy... so things are improving, there is good out there too! :) )

That’s appalling..
I tried the “PSSSTTT” just now on a dog and got this reaction- Curiosity.
Nothing more.

It’s alarming what goes on behind the scenes.

Terrible behaviour by Milan in my opinion.

What can I take on walks that may help if a dog attacks us.
oakleaffy · 11/06/2023 18:30

@WiddlinDiddlin It’s heartening that potential owners are asking for help Before getting a puppy.

I am so grateful to the experienced woman at RSPCA who paired us with the lovely Lurcher.

She says she watches people( CCTV) as they go around the kennels and sees how they react to the dogs.

I had no idea we were being observed!

An experienced person can be so helpful and save much trouble IF the potential owner takes on board what trainer or advisor says.

Emotionalsupportviper · 11/06/2023 18:51

WiddlinDiddlin · 11/06/2023 14:27

Mmm... ah, but the Titchmarsh interview with Cesar was a DELIGHT.

Lots of trainers/behaviourists contacted Titchmarsh before the interview was filmed, filled him on in the details - it appears Alan really does not like bullies.

Cesar was doing the 'tour the chat shows to promote my book/show' thing and all the shows were pretty light hearted, fluffy stuff, where he could talk a bit of guff, flash his brilliant smile and laugh at the ineptitude of dog owners (usually woman, the man is an absolute sexist misogynistic pig)... promote his gig and off.

He was therefore, thoroughly and absolutely, unprepared for Titchmarsh to push him over his methods, particularly hitting, pinning, shock collars...

It was really well planned, they even had another trainer (Steve Mann I think) in the wings, in case Cesar stormed off and they needed a quick fill in 'doggy content'...

But nope, he didn't stomp off, he DID pretend he didn't understand English enough to try to deflect some questions (that is one of his stock responses if someone gets pushy with the awkward questions) - then was pushed into an off script description of how he did use positive reinforcement too - only what he described was bizarre - using a parrot that would bite the dog (or the dog was scared of it), to teach the dog not to do something to the owner... (IIRC!)..

Titchmarsh absolutely fucking destroyed him, revealed him for the total cunt he is and made him look VERY stupid.

Apparently Cesar was FURIOUS afterwards and his team/entourage had a heck of a job getting him back on his bus and out of it. A lot of 'you can't air this...' but at the time, it was filmed only a short while before being aired giggle so it went out pretty much exactly as it went down!

On the basis of this post I have fallen in love with Alan and if all my eggs weren't dried up I would want to have his babies.

123wdcd · 11/06/2023 22:27

Cesar Millan had numerous lawsuits related to alleged attacks by one of his pit bulls against both people and dogs.

Training and socialisation is obviously essential for all dogs. For training to be effective it is going to have to work with a dogs natural instincts; a malinois will be trained for protection work and a border collie for herding, or at least for a dog with these instincts to be safe and stable. Nobody is going to use a retriever as a sheep dog or a collie to retrieve birds, as many of their inherent breed traits cannot be overcome. Pit bull mixes or descendants (XL Bullies) are very powerful dogs with strong instincts (something must have triggered... ...just snapped... ...it was the victim's fault...). How can these dogs be effectively trained when their breed instinct is to fight?

oakleaffy · 11/06/2023 22:27

Emotionalsupportviper · 11/06/2023 18:51

On the basis of this post I have fallen in love with Alan and if all my eggs weren't dried up I would want to have his babies.

Oh my goodness- I will have to look at that interview-
Just hope it’s online.

I remember Milan being bitten by Holly a yellow Labrador-
He then allegedly kept Holly as a pet.

I wasn’t aware Alan Tichmarsh was a dog person- Good for him for challenging cruel , coercive training methods.

oakleaffy · 11/06/2023 22:35

123wdcd · 11/06/2023 22:27

Cesar Millan had numerous lawsuits related to alleged attacks by one of his pit bulls against both people and dogs.

Training and socialisation is obviously essential for all dogs. For training to be effective it is going to have to work with a dogs natural instincts; a malinois will be trained for protection work and a border collie for herding, or at least for a dog with these instincts to be safe and stable. Nobody is going to use a retriever as a sheep dog or a collie to retrieve birds, as many of their inherent breed traits cannot be overcome. Pit bull mixes or descendants (XL Bullies) are very powerful dogs with strong instincts (something must have triggered... ...just snapped... ...it was the victim's fault...). How can these dogs be effectively trained when their breed instinct is to fight?

Agree with dogs having innate drives .

Pits and pit mixes on you tube seem to “ Just flip “

There is an horrific video where a Pitbull is attacking its male owner -It’s roaring is beyond hideous
Police tazed it so the owner could get away, then shot it dead.
They seem to turn for no apparent reason
Plenty of videos of them attacking online
Children, other dogs- random passers by.

Often when the dog is shot, the owner doesn’t seem to care much- They let the dogs stray and cause trouble.

123wdcd · 11/06/2023 22:38

@oakleaffy The lack of pain response from pit bulls/bull breeds is also terrifying. Most dogs would take off if they heard a gun shot, yet there are accounts of pit bulls being shot multiple times before an attack ends with the dog dying.

oakleaffy · 11/06/2023 23:01

Emotionalsupportviper · 11/06/2023 18:51

On the basis of this post I have fallen in love with Alan and if all my eggs weren't dried up I would want to have his babies.

It is online!
Titchmarsh is superb!..Very calm and keeps to the point.

Here..

Alan Titchmarsh Brands Dog Whisperer Cesar Millan 'BABARIC'

During his show Alan Titchmarsh interview Millan outspoken.Durante il suo show Alan Titchmarsh intervista Millan senza peli sulla lingua.ATTENZIONE: (ATTIVAT...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0I6JavkIaUE

oakleaffy · 11/06/2023 23:02

123wdcd · 11/06/2023 22:38

@oakleaffy The lack of pain response from pit bulls/bull breeds is also terrifying. Most dogs would take off if they heard a gun shot, yet there are accounts of pit bulls being shot multiple times before an attack ends with the dog dying.

Sadly this is the case. They seem to have a very high pain threshold, unlike the more sensitive breeds/types.

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/06/2023 06:22

oakleaffy · 11/06/2023 23:02

Sadly this is the case. They seem to have a very high pain threshold, unlike the more sensitive breeds/types.

Nothing distracts them either, Even when they are "got off", if they escape they will return to the same victim almost all of the time. Most dogs, even if they are carried along in the excitement of a fight, once the animals are separated will calm down enough to make them safe (though will remain in a heightened state, and more likely to attack again in the next few days).

This is true predator behaviour - other people may get bitten, but it will be in the melee, rather than them being deliberately targetted.

Thank you, for the video, @oakleaffy.

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/06/2023 06:26

Watching the video now - I am very disappointed to read the comments. So many people conned by Milan's surface charm and "cheeky chappie" persona.

I feel so sorry for their dogs.

WisherWood · 12/06/2023 10:41

Sadly this is the case. They seem to have a very high pain threshold, unlike the more sensitive breeds/types.

It's not necessarily just that it's a high threshold. It's also that when they feel pain, it tends to heighten the attack rather than stop it. It is key to trying to stop an attack - just hitting the dog will not work and might make the attack worse.

WisherWood · 12/06/2023 10:42

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/06/2023 06:26

Watching the video now - I am very disappointed to read the comments. So many people conned by Milan's surface charm and "cheeky chappie" persona.

I feel so sorry for their dogs.

Well how do you think we got Johnson as PM? People fall for this shit.

MovinGroovinBarbie · 12/06/2023 16:31

Tbf, lots of dogs were bred to kill. Daschunds to kill badgers, terriers to kill rats, and lots of other breeds used to guard against humans (so often exhibiting human aggression tendencies as opposed to just being dog aggressive).

The problem with bullies is their extreme strength and the fact that almost every owner is a chav who chose that breed to look hard.

WiddlinDiddlin · 12/06/2023 18:13

People think pitbulls, ambulls etc are really tough thuggish breeds ... they aren't they are actually REALLY really sensitive, over sensitive if anything..

They have a really high pain threshold and full on play style, no real understanding of personal space...

When they DO get hurt, or finally realise someone is objecting/being aggressive toward them etc... they over-react, and they don't forget either so next time are far more likely to react offensively, aggressively, than defensively/passively. Then, when they do... (again this is linked to breeding and training/handling as well), they tend to be no holds barred, full on.

This leads to dogs tolerating all sorts of shit.... riiiiiiiight up until they don't and never will again, and often as a result of both breeding and prior learning, show few warning signs.

And that adds up to 'dogs that turn without warning' - it isn't really true, the warning signs were there... but you'd have to have observed a hell of a lot of a specific dog's behaviour to see how you get to a particular point/incident.

Emotionalsupportviper · 12/06/2023 18:16

WisherWood · 12/06/2023 10:41

Sadly this is the case. They seem to have a very high pain threshold, unlike the more sensitive breeds/types.

It's not necessarily just that it's a high threshold. It's also that when they feel pain, it tends to heighten the attack rather than stop it. It is key to trying to stop an attack - just hitting the dog will not work and might make the attack worse.

Exactly!

Trying to beat them away from their victims just intensifies it as they feel under attack.

MovinGroovinBarbie · 12/06/2023 21:08

oakleaffy · 10/06/2023 12:29

@123wdcd That is horrific what the Doctor says.
And that every one of these catastrophic wounds was from a pit or pit mix {XL Bullies}

When Pit owners say ''It's the owner, not the breed'', they are denying the powerful effect genes have on dogs.

A fighting bred dog has the potential to want to 'Worry' and kill other dogs/people or animals.

'Normal' dogs do a 'Snatch' bite and release- Even GSD's.

One can occasionally get 'Rogue' dogs- a woman that we used to live near always had aggressive dogs, and they weren't 'Known' aggressive breeds, {One was a Golden Retriever that mauled a postwoman's hand so severely she needed surgery} but her ownership seemed to bring out the very worst in the dogs she owned.

Someone like that with a Pit Bull or XL Bully would be very dangerous.

She was always shouty -abrasive and screaming at the dogs.

Someone with a sighthound made a Picachu ''Surprised face'' when the gentle dog they were with caught and dispatched a squirrel on a walk.

But that has been hardwired into sighthounds- to catch and dispatch small game and 'Vermin' {Rats, mice &c} - They don't need teaching- it's innate.

As it is with Bull breeds to have the potential for attacking.

@WiddlinDiddlin Who is the Daily Mail 'Expert'?
The only one I can think it might be is Roger Mugford - I did refer to his books years ago with my first dog, but he didn't suggest anything untoward that I can remember- {Books from Library}- I do remember that he was the person who 'Invented' the Halti for pulling dogs, and he spoke out against prong collars {I do agree with him there}.

What is the Expert suggesting re the recent spate of XL /Pit attacks?

Tbf, though, fighting pit bulls that displayed aggression towards humans were usually put down or retired. The owners needed to be able to separate them once one dog had 'won'.

These fighting dogs would've been less likely to bite a human than the many species of dogs that we're specifically encouraged to chase away intruders. It's mainly the chavvy types of owners you see and the fact that when these dogs do attack they cause serious damage.

lovetakemedowntothestreets · 12/06/2023 22:59

As always, a mix of good and terrible advice. I have been involved in a few dog attacks, one very serious. My takeaways:

Blunt force won't work. These dogs are bred to ignore it. Seen one take a few decent whacks with a baton to no effect. So poles etc are out.

It is legal in this country to carry a non locking knife with a blade of less than three inches. Get one. You need to be able to open it one handed - spyderco is a solid bet. You want a blade that is stiff so it won't just fold. Most pocket knifes have little nail slots near the top to open, this will be useless in the second or two you have so it needs a hole allowing you to open with a thumb.

Put a lanyard on the pocket knife. When you situational awareness is peaked, lanyard goes round wrist and thumb opens knife in pocket. When these things go, you are likely to lose grip of a knife. The lanyard will keep it with you.

Situational awareness is key. Have your kit ready to go before an attack.

I saw bite back used both during an attack and as a preventative sprayed on trousers. It can have some effect, I wouldn't rely on it though. (I still carry a can)

You get attacked, there is no real planning it. You will get bitten. Bites are excruciating, XL Bullies and their ilk latch on and tear.

Remember a dog is just property. People come above property. This is important, because you need to try and kill the dog. Hit it with the knife wherever you can. To target an area whilst having one latched on would take amazing coolness. Just hit them wherever, head if possible.

That's pretty much it. If the dog is attacking, you can use reasonable force same as if you were attacked by a person. A fighting dog is a risk factor. Presence of children is a risk factor. The owner will probably be aggressive, angry and may go for you as well. Worth considering, if some idiot wraps up your free arm to prevent you harming their precious pibbles then that's a whole other issue.

At the end of the day, they are just property. There are a few offences that could be thrown your way, most of it summary only. If some 7 stone monstrosity is attacking you, they won't stick. Even if they did, the mitigating alone would get you fairly clear.

oakleaffy · 13/06/2023 00:42

lovetakemedowntothestreets · 12/06/2023 22:59

As always, a mix of good and terrible advice. I have been involved in a few dog attacks, one very serious. My takeaways:

Blunt force won't work. These dogs are bred to ignore it. Seen one take a few decent whacks with a baton to no effect. So poles etc are out.

It is legal in this country to carry a non locking knife with a blade of less than three inches. Get one. You need to be able to open it one handed - spyderco is a solid bet. You want a blade that is stiff so it won't just fold. Most pocket knifes have little nail slots near the top to open, this will be useless in the second or two you have so it needs a hole allowing you to open with a thumb.

Put a lanyard on the pocket knife. When you situational awareness is peaked, lanyard goes round wrist and thumb opens knife in pocket. When these things go, you are likely to lose grip of a knife. The lanyard will keep it with you.

Situational awareness is key. Have your kit ready to go before an attack.

I saw bite back used both during an attack and as a preventative sprayed on trousers. It can have some effect, I wouldn't rely on it though. (I still carry a can)

You get attacked, there is no real planning it. You will get bitten. Bites are excruciating, XL Bullies and their ilk latch on and tear.

Remember a dog is just property. People come above property. This is important, because you need to try and kill the dog. Hit it with the knife wherever you can. To target an area whilst having one latched on would take amazing coolness. Just hit them wherever, head if possible.

That's pretty much it. If the dog is attacking, you can use reasonable force same as if you were attacked by a person. A fighting dog is a risk factor. Presence of children is a risk factor. The owner will probably be aggressive, angry and may go for you as well. Worth considering, if some idiot wraps up your free arm to prevent you harming their precious pibbles then that's a whole other issue.

At the end of the day, they are just property. There are a few offences that could be thrown your way, most of it summary only. If some 7 stone monstrosity is attacking you, they won't stick. Even if they did, the mitigating alone would get you fairly clear.

Robert Cabral released a video yesterday about how to prevent dog on dog attacks from these man made monstrosities. {Pitbulls &XL Bully types}

He points out the mistakes people make trying to get these dogs to ''Release''

It's a very{VERY} hard video to watch, th but the only things that will get one to release is sharp steel {like you say} or a noose {a slip lead literally being held so hard the dog goes unconscious.{Otherwise when you release, the dog will bite again}

He says so many times in his videos that bad genes are to blame.

He has worked with shelter dogs in USA and says they are not like other dogs.

Dog Fight Mistakes Breakdown

I see so many videos of dog attacks on other dogs and people struggle with what to do. In this LIVE I will give my advice on your best chances of breaking u...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rHVyMHTb6l4

user1477391263 · 13/06/2023 00:50

WiddlinDiddlin · 12/06/2023 18:13

People think pitbulls, ambulls etc are really tough thuggish breeds ... they aren't they are actually REALLY really sensitive, over sensitive if anything..

They have a really high pain threshold and full on play style, no real understanding of personal space...

When they DO get hurt, or finally realise someone is objecting/being aggressive toward them etc... they over-react, and they don't forget either so next time are far more likely to react offensively, aggressively, than defensively/passively. Then, when they do... (again this is linked to breeding and training/handling as well), they tend to be no holds barred, full on.

This leads to dogs tolerating all sorts of shit.... riiiiiiiight up until they don't and never will again, and often as a result of both breeding and prior learning, show few warning signs.

And that adds up to 'dogs that turn without warning' - it isn't really true, the warning signs were there... but you'd have to have observed a hell of a lot of a specific dog's behaviour to see how you get to a particular point/incident.

People think pitbulls, ambulls etc are really tough thuggish breeds ... they aren't they are actually REALLY really sensitive, over sensitive if anything..

Er, they were bred to be fighting dogs. How and why would someone breed a fighting dog to be sensitive to pain?

The solution to these vile animals is to euthanize the fuckers.

WiddlinDiddlin · 13/06/2023 05:33

This is exactly my point.

I don't mean sensitive as in pain threshold, they do have really high pain thresholds.

They're very sensitive to owner mood, to wanting to please an owner, they learn very fast, they have no impulse control, poor ability to cope with frustration, a desperate need to appease owners (much of the leaping, jumping, boisterous attempts at play you often see these dogs doing is 'act the fool to deflect trouble' behaviour)..

It generally takes a while before they realise someone is a threat, trying to hurt them, (dog or human)... once they DO though... that lesson is learned and applied to everyone, terrier mentality 'get in there first before they can get you'.

People mistake fear behaviour in some breeds as confidence - some breeds will run away, hide, cower or tremble or turn to a person for help.

Some breeds have been bred to bite, to lunge and bark and create an aggressive display (German Shepherds, Dobermans, as well as terriers).

Many of these huge thug-dogs are stressed to the max and terrified and it goes wholly unrecognised and with genetics that tells them to use aggression first, to grab something and not let go so it can't get them back... plus their size, that makes for extreme danger.

Oakleaffy - Cabral talks some sense but he's another in the 'I like to use shock/prong/pain to train' camp... for those able to extract the sense from the bullshit, theres some useful ideas... unfortunately, most folk can't do that.

Cabral has videos on youtube about training bite sport/protection work.

I think thats really dangerous - the three dogs who attacked the woman in Lambeth, they were playing, with her as their tug toy.

The fact that the attack stopped when she pulled off her top, and the dog holding her arm 'won' her top suggests that the owner had messed about with teaching that dog protection work. If the dog had been attacking out of fear or anger or predatory drive... that wouldn't be the case. But play or trained 'play' which is what bite sports are... mm.

We need to make training a dog to be a weapon, an offence. If you have a guard dog, you need a licence for that and the dog has to be on a lead, not loose.

But you can have a pet dog and teach it to attack people, and that is legal!

Emotionalsupportviper · 15/06/2023 09:06

Many of these huge thug-dogs are stressed to the max and terrified and it goes wholly unrecognised and with genetics that tells them to use aggression first, to grab something and not let go so it can't get them back... plus their size, that makes for extreme danger.

Agree - and fear-aggressive dogs are the most dangerous because they are the least stable

The fact that the attack stopped when she pulled off her top, and the dog holding her arm 'won' her top suggests that the owner had messed about with teaching that dog protection work.

I hadn't realise that she had effectively given them a "trophy". Interesting. As you say, they will most likely have been encouraged to "attack" as a game.

I'd advise never, ever playing a game like this with even the tiniest of dogs. Over-excitement can cause even the sweetest-natured animal to bite.

And never, ever encourage a large or heavy dog to jump up at anyone - the weight and force alone can do damage, even without any aggressive intent.

@lovetakemedowntothestreets - very interesting post, thank you. Sounds like good, practical (and legal) advice.

Emotionalsupportviper · 15/06/2023 09:09

Just checking @lovetakemedowntothestreets - you are in the UK, aren't you?

Chipsahoy · 15/06/2023 09:12

My dh has been raised around large dog breeds. He spotted a family members distressed (older pup) Doberman getting very angry and he was able to pin him as he went to bite someone. He has a scar on his hand from putting his hand around his jaw and pushing him to the ground. He knew what to do after years and years of dog handling.
I have pinned my gsd pup when she was being a little monkey. And I tell ya at 7 months old that was not easy.

You cannot fight a large dog. You just can’t.