Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What can I take on walks that may help if a dog attacks us.

502 replies

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 06/06/2023 20:39

I've noticed that some very nasty dogs are being walked on our usual local walks around a pretty village.

With the recent spate of attacks and my suspicions of the owners, is there anything that could help in the event of an attack eg high pitched noise like rape alarm.
? What do you do if a dog goes for the child or yourself?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
Emotionalsupportviper · 09/06/2023 10:09

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 09/06/2023 09:57

@Emotionalsupportviper

Rottweilers absolutely terrify me but I do appreciate that they can be good pets

Good breeding, proper socialisation, effective training and being sensible with them where there are children - like with any dog (though, of course they are much larger than many dogs) They do tend to be fairly placid - or at least all the ones I've known have been.

Trouble now with every breed is that people get the dog because they like the look of it, or they've watched 101 Dalmations or Marley and Me and think that dogs are just like people in fur coats - they aren't.

There were fewer dog attacks in the past not only because there were fewer dogs but because most people chose a dog for a reason, and a lot of dogs had jobs - you want a guard dog, you get a GSD, treat it as a dog (not a baby) and train it properly; you want a herder, you get a border collie, train it and work it, you want a ratter - jack russell, as border or GSD etc

A lot of dogs become aggressive because they are so bored and under-exercised (and lonely) that they quite literally go mad.

Don't pick a breed because it's pretty, or you've seen it dancing at Crufts on the telly, or you want to be able to look like you are "controlling' huge dog. (Not unless you intend to fulfil its mental and emotional needs as well as feed your own fantasies.)

WisherWood · 09/06/2023 10:45

I think kennels should euthanise them automatically if they end up there. In the streets they should be muzzled and leashed, and if they aren't then they should be taken for euthanasia and the owner fined. If people insist on keeping them, they should all be neutered. (TBH, they should all be euthanised, but we won't see that happen.)

The thing with bigger dogs is that their life expectancies aren't great. So you could insist on muzzling in public and ban breeding, and the problem would be gone within 10 to 15 years. OK yes, I know there are complexities, but it could be done.

And I'd take a Rottweiler or a Dobermann any day of the week but not a bully. You'd actually be better off with a wolf. At least they haven't been mucked around by humans. Well they have, that's how we got dogs, but you know what I mean.

Roughashouses · 09/06/2023 10:47

We're so lucky to such a large amount of experts on MN.

spring78 · 09/06/2023 11:51

SheSeIIsSeaShells · 09/06/2023 09:42

@Emotionalsupportviper "Dogs such as GSDs, Dobermann Pinschers, Rottweilers, Staffies etc, properly and responsibly bred, properly trained using reward methods rather than brutalising punishment, and neverencouraged to chase or attack other animals (and certainly not people) can prove to be reliable family pets."

Key word, can. Also, often don't though. That's the problem. And there is often no telling when a dog may snap. If you follow the reports of dog attacks where they are more common than here (namely, the US), there are multiple examples of dogs being raised by people who purport to know what they are doing, work as vets or vet nurses, or in animal rights, and still the dog turns and kills or maims, often the owner.

I don't think most people who aren't drug dealers own these for protection. They own them because they are deluded fools who think they are lion tamers, or they fell.for the sob story and have a saviour complex.
Even if they were for protection, I'd rather risk getting attacked by a human than getting mauled to death by a land shark.

I own 2 of the named breeds and a frenchie. I am not a drug dealer or use them for protection.
They are loved family pets (4 children) and amazing manners - it is down to training and the environment

oakleaffy · 09/06/2023 12:10

spring78 · 09/06/2023 11:51

I own 2 of the named breeds and a frenchie. I am not a drug dealer or use them for protection.
They are loved family pets (4 children) and amazing manners - it is down to training and the environment

But definitely genetics, too.

Greyhounds are hardwired to chase.
Spaniels to flush or retrieve game.
Border Collies to herd.{The Einstiens of the dog world}

A lot is genetic. These types were/are bred to fight or bait other dogs or bulls.

Guide dog types- they go for tractable natures and intelligence- and breed their own- Genes are so important in any dog.

miniegg3 · 09/06/2023 12:18

On amazon you can get something that looks like a torch buy gives off a really high pitched noise that dogs hate that's supposed to scare them off. It was about a tenner..

Probably a better shot than trying to strangle them 🤣

Ylvamoon · 09/06/2023 12:18

Roughashouses · 09/06/2023 10:47

We're so lucky to such a large amount of experts on MN.

😉

Excited Celebration GIF by Slanted Studios
miniegg3 · 09/06/2023 12:22

Innefier Anti Barking Device Ultrasonic Dog Deterrent Handheld Dog Repeller Trainer Waterproof Mini Dog Bark Control Device Rechargeable with 3 in 1 Bark Control Tool with LED Flashlight amzn.eu/d/7dzrtcn

oakleaffy · 09/06/2023 12:41

miniegg3 · 09/06/2023 12:18

On amazon you can get something that looks like a torch buy gives off a really high pitched noise that dogs hate that's supposed to scare them off. It was about a tenner..

Probably a better shot than trying to strangle them 🤣

The reviews on that device are dire.

In the suddenness of a dog attacking a child {Friends two young children were attacked by an English Bull Terrier as they were walking on a pavement- it's so silent and fast.
That dog was beaten off by a heavy chain by its 18 yr old owner, but the risk is hitting the baby or toddler.

Also, hitting often doesn't work. {Some frightening videos on you tube where innocent children {or pets} are targeted by these dogs-

We need a way to defend our children ,pets and horses from aggressive dogs

miniegg3 · 09/06/2023 12:49

They're all 5 star reviews 🤷‍♀️ I have one for training purposes and they work fine

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/06/2023 13:18

That device is NOT going to stop a dog hell bent on attacking you.

It may stop a 'friendly but rude' dog - it also may really piss off a 'curious, haven't yet decided how I feel about you' dog and when it says it doesn't cause pain... um, how do you think it works?

It emits an ultrasonic pitch so high that it fucking hurts. Using pain to control dogs is proven to be a risky strategy - even the manufacturers of shock collars say that deploying a shock when a dog approaches (another dog or person) is likely to make the situation worse and trigger an aggressive response.

oakleaffy · 09/06/2023 13:20

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/06/2023 10:09

Good breeding, proper socialisation, effective training and being sensible with them where there are children - like with any dog (though, of course they are much larger than many dogs) They do tend to be fairly placid - or at least all the ones I've known have been.

Trouble now with every breed is that people get the dog because they like the look of it, or they've watched 101 Dalmations or Marley and Me and think that dogs are just like people in fur coats - they aren't.

There were fewer dog attacks in the past not only because there were fewer dogs but because most people chose a dog for a reason, and a lot of dogs had jobs - you want a guard dog, you get a GSD, treat it as a dog (not a baby) and train it properly; you want a herder, you get a border collie, train it and work it, you want a ratter - jack russell, as border or GSD etc

A lot of dogs become aggressive because they are so bored and under-exercised (and lonely) that they quite literally go mad.

Don't pick a breed because it's pretty, or you've seen it dancing at Crufts on the telly, or you want to be able to look like you are "controlling' huge dog. (Not unless you intend to fulfil its mental and emotional needs as well as feed your own fantasies.)

So true about people getting a dog because they think it's pretty or 'Intelligent'..Or fulfils a fantasy about looking 'Tough'

When ''One man and his dog'' used to be on TV, there was a spate of people buying Border Collies. Phil Drabble used to say ''They aren't suited to a family home- they are workers'.

There are definitely 'Trends' in dog ownership - But too often people don't think 'Does our lifestyle suit the dog we want to get?'

'Wolf dogs' were a trend years ago- Every mass market film with a dog in it spurs a spate of buying that type of dog.

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/06/2023 13:26

There are 'experts' everywhere. The 'britains leading expert'... in the Mail... is easily into his 70's and hasn't been hands on with dogs for donkeys years, is qualified only by the organisation he set up himself and is widely regarded by actual experts as little more than a pain in the arse...

But if it says he's an expert in the papers, welllllll... (they have just copied what he says on his own website about himself).

We have a HUGE problem with the modern belief that we are 'entitled' to have whatever it is we want. If we want a puppy, we shall have a puppy - oh, the fact we work all day, live somewhere wholly unsuited to dog ownership, want a insert unsuitable breed... all irrelevant apparently.

Verv · 09/06/2023 13:37

oakleaffy · 09/06/2023 13:20

So true about people getting a dog because they think it's pretty or 'Intelligent'..Or fulfils a fantasy about looking 'Tough'

When ''One man and his dog'' used to be on TV, there was a spate of people buying Border Collies. Phil Drabble used to say ''They aren't suited to a family home- they are workers'.

There are definitely 'Trends' in dog ownership - But too often people don't think 'Does our lifestyle suit the dog we want to get?'

'Wolf dogs' were a trend years ago- Every mass market film with a dog in it spurs a spate of buying that type of dog.

Yes, and an increase in huskies for rehoming.

WisherWood · 09/06/2023 13:46

If you're trying to work out someone's expertise, watch out for them talking about alpha dogs. That stuff was debunked 30 years ago. They might actually be OK trainers if they're observant, but if so, they'll be doing the right things for the wrong reasons.

FlameGrilledSquirrel · 09/06/2023 13:56

Saw a Bully type dog the other day. Seemed extremely friendly and appeared well trained but if it turns there is absolutely no way you are stopping it regardless of what app you are using. Dogs have been bred for a purpose whether it be a companion, a herder or a weapon. We need to stop pretending otherwise and start treating them accordingly. It's insane that people can walk around with some of these dogs with impunity.

Also, before people take on board some of the suggestions about what to carry, please have a quick google on the laws surrounding the carrying of offensive weapons.

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/06/2023 14:44

WisherWood · 09/06/2023 10:45

I think kennels should euthanise them automatically if they end up there. In the streets they should be muzzled and leashed, and if they aren't then they should be taken for euthanasia and the owner fined. If people insist on keeping them, they should all be neutered. (TBH, they should all be euthanised, but we won't see that happen.)

The thing with bigger dogs is that their life expectancies aren't great. So you could insist on muzzling in public and ban breeding, and the problem would be gone within 10 to 15 years. OK yes, I know there are complexities, but it could be done.

And I'd take a Rottweiler or a Dobermann any day of the week but not a bully. You'd actually be better off with a wolf. At least they haven't been mucked around by humans. Well they have, that's how we got dogs, but you know what I mean.

They aren't the sort of dogs with a lifespan of 8 years or so, like a great dane or a Bernese - they can live a good 12 years. I would LOVE to think they would be extinct within 10-15 years, but it's a pipe dream, unfortunately.

I agree with your final paragraph - I'd rather share the house with a wolf. Their feral instincts make them reluctant to engage in any form of fighting or killing unless they are hungry or otherwise desperate (few wild animals will fight if they don't need to - the risk of injury and subsequent death from starvation/ infection is too great). Keep it well fed and don't poke it with a stick and you'd probably be ok.

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/06/2023 14:51

WisherWood · 09/06/2023 13:46

If you're trying to work out someone's expertise, watch out for them talking about alpha dogs. That stuff was debunked 30 years ago. They might actually be OK trainers if they're observant, but if so, they'll be doing the right things for the wrong reasons.

And if anybody suggests you "Alpha roll" your dog to let it know who's boss - for God's sake, don't!

You could end up very badly bitten, and it doesn't teach a dog anything except not to trust you.

Verv · 09/06/2023 15:13

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 06/06/2023 20:39

I've noticed that some very nasty dogs are being walked on our usual local walks around a pretty village.

With the recent spate of attacks and my suspicions of the owners, is there anything that could help in the event of an attack eg high pitched noise like rape alarm.
? What do you do if a dog goes for the child or yourself?

You could hire The Expendables.

123wdcd · 09/06/2023 15:55

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/06/2023 10:09

Good breeding, proper socialisation, effective training and being sensible with them where there are children - like with any dog (though, of course they are much larger than many dogs) They do tend to be fairly placid - or at least all the ones I've known have been.

Trouble now with every breed is that people get the dog because they like the look of it, or they've watched 101 Dalmations or Marley and Me and think that dogs are just like people in fur coats - they aren't.

There were fewer dog attacks in the past not only because there were fewer dogs but because most people chose a dog for a reason, and a lot of dogs had jobs - you want a guard dog, you get a GSD, treat it as a dog (not a baby) and train it properly; you want a herder, you get a border collie, train it and work it, you want a ratter - jack russell, as border or GSD etc

A lot of dogs become aggressive because they are so bored and under-exercised (and lonely) that they quite literally go mad.

Don't pick a breed because it's pretty, or you've seen it dancing at Crufts on the telly, or you want to be able to look like you are "controlling' huge dog. (Not unless you intend to fulfil its mental and emotional needs as well as feed your own fantasies.)

This is very true. There was a Channung Tatum film released in 2022 called DOG, starring a beautiful Malinois. Hoping there will not be a spate of irresponsible Malinois breeding and then these dogs getting abandoned as they leave the puppy stage. Very few people can accommodate the needs of these, as it is a huge exercise and training commitment.

Plus, for herding get a border collie, for guarding get a GSD... so what do people want to do with bull breeds that have a natural instinct to fight and kill.

WisherWood · 09/06/2023 16:47

I agree with your final paragraph - I'd rather share the house with a wolf. Their feral instincts make them reluctant to engage in any form of fighting or killing unless they are hungry or otherwise desperate (few wild animals will fight if they don't need to - the risk of injury and subsequent death from starvation/ infection is too great). Keep it well fed and don't poke it with a stick and you'd probably be ok.

They come with their own risks though - I recommend Mark Rowland's The Philosopher and the Wolf, if you don't know it already. Chance of attack is limited but their levels of destruction when their owner isn't around are off the scale.

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/06/2023 16:51

The ship has sailed already on the Mali trend unfortunately.

More and more people totally unsuited to them, wanting them - cannot get from a reputable breeder because reputable breeders won't sell to wannabe hardmen - so they're buying from disreputable breeders, exporters, 'buy your half trained teenage maligator/dutch herder/doberman' here types..

The modern sports bred mali is also a billion miles away from the working type of even 20 years ago, a dog that with plenty to do and a job could still be a family pet in the 'sensible owner' sense anyway.

Even the well bred ones really need to be housed, handled and managed in a way most pet dog owners cannot achieve.

CrossBun · 09/06/2023 17:26

Dogs such as GSDs, Dobermann Pinschers, Rottweilers, Staffies etc,

Nope you slipped Staffies in there. Others all fine (with training/ supervision). They were bred as fighting dogs originally from bull dogs although I accept they’re separate from pit bulls. I think Staffies are still a bit of an unknown quantity.

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/06/2023 18:05

WisherWood · 09/06/2023 16:47

I agree with your final paragraph - I'd rather share the house with a wolf. Their feral instincts make them reluctant to engage in any form of fighting or killing unless they are hungry or otherwise desperate (few wild animals will fight if they don't need to - the risk of injury and subsequent death from starvation/ infection is too great). Keep it well fed and don't poke it with a stick and you'd probably be ok.

They come with their own risks though - I recommend Mark Rowland's The Philosopher and the Wolf, if you don't know it already. Chance of attack is limited but their levels of destruction when their owner isn't around are off the scale.

I have spaniels - haven't had a matching pair of socks or a dry set of clothes for eight years.

I daresay I'd learn to live with shredded curtains and de-stuffed furniture as well. 😂

I understand they can't be housetrained, though - I'd find that difficult to cope with.

Thank you for the tip off re: the book - just bunged it into my Amazon basket.

Emotionalsupportviper · 09/06/2023 18:09

WiddlinDiddlin · 09/06/2023 16:51

The ship has sailed already on the Mali trend unfortunately.

More and more people totally unsuited to them, wanting them - cannot get from a reputable breeder because reputable breeders won't sell to wannabe hardmen - so they're buying from disreputable breeders, exporters, 'buy your half trained teenage maligator/dutch herder/doberman' here types..

The modern sports bred mali is also a billion miles away from the working type of even 20 years ago, a dog that with plenty to do and a job could still be a family pet in the 'sensible owner' sense anyway.

Even the well bred ones really need to be housed, handled and managed in a way most pet dog owners cannot achieve.

Heartbreaking - they are such beautiful dogs.

Nope you slipped Staffies in there. Others all fine (with training/ supervision). They were bred as fighting dogs originally from bull dogs although I accept they’re separate from pit bulls. I think Staffies are still a bit of an unknown quantity.

I've had four staffies - properly bred and handled they are wonderful dogs. I wouldn't leave one alone with a small child, but that's because I wouldn't leave any dog alone with a small child. As house dogs they have very steady temperaments and are very affectionate (though can be destructive if they get bored - and they're very greedy, but so are spaniels!)