Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What can I take on walks that may help if a dog attacks us.

502 replies

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 06/06/2023 20:39

I've noticed that some very nasty dogs are being walked on our usual local walks around a pretty village.

With the recent spate of attacks and my suspicions of the owners, is there anything that could help in the event of an attack eg high pitched noise like rape alarm.
? What do you do if a dog goes for the child or yourself?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 09/06/2023 19:27

@Emotionalsupportviper again i agree I wouldn't leave any breed alone with a small child at all.

A and e do say the dog bites come from the beloved family pet who wouldn't want normally hurt a fly until... Whoops they do!!

The difference being a nasty bite from rhe tea cup yorkie to the animal bred to maim something.

OP posts:
ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 09/06/2023 19:29

@Verv.. Thank you I will add them to list ww have of protection on here.

Being serious for a moment I dint think they would be liscsnded to carry arms in the UK so again wood they be an good with bare hands?

OP posts:
123wdcd · 09/06/2023 22:03

CrossBun · 09/06/2023 17:26

Dogs such as GSDs, Dobermann Pinschers, Rottweilers, Staffies etc,

Nope you slipped Staffies in there. Others all fine (with training/ supervision). They were bred as fighting dogs originally from bull dogs although I accept they’re separate from pit bulls. I think Staffies are still a bit of an unknown quantity.

Unfortunately I agree. There are nice staffordshire bull terriers, but irresponsible breeding has started to create many that are more like pit bulls (or pit mixes labelled as Staffies/Special Staffies). Rather than moving away from their fighting origins, there has been this push for larger, menacing status symbol dogs and weapons/fighters for those seeking to get around BSl. Adding to the danger, they are pushed as 'Nanny Dogs', when bull breeds were never used this way (https://www.battersea.org.uk/pet-advice/dog-advice/finding-right-dog-you/staffies). In the US pit bulls get described as 'Nanny Dogs' FFS (https://blog.dogsbite.org/2010/05/1909-fatality-john-p-colbys-fighting.html). I cannot comprehend how a type of fighting dog that has maimed and killed hundreds of children in the US can be portrayed as some sort of gentle and sensible Lassie equivalent.

1909 Dog Bite Fatality: John P. Colby's Fighting Pit Bull Kills Nephew - DogsBite Blog

John P. Colby and son Louis (1922), Colby's Pincher (top) and Colby's Twister. View Archive Article Newburyport, MA - While researching fatal pit bull attacks of the early to mid 1900s, we came across the most damaging fatal attack the … Continue readi...

https://blog.dogsbite.org/2010/05/1909-fatality-john-p-colbys-fighting.html

MrsWhy · 10/06/2023 07:16

I think this all a little extreme. Most reported dog incidents are by dogs known to the victims. Dog don't mistake a child for a squirrel or a bunny! They have a fight or flight mode so don't try a match aggression with aggression, stay calm and give clear commands
If the worse does happen grab the collar and twist

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/06/2023 09:02

123wdcd · 09/06/2023 22:03

Unfortunately I agree. There are nice staffordshire bull terriers, but irresponsible breeding has started to create many that are more like pit bulls (or pit mixes labelled as Staffies/Special Staffies). Rather than moving away from their fighting origins, there has been this push for larger, menacing status symbol dogs and weapons/fighters for those seeking to get around BSl. Adding to the danger, they are pushed as 'Nanny Dogs', when bull breeds were never used this way (https://www.battersea.org.uk/pet-advice/dog-advice/finding-right-dog-you/staffies). In the US pit bulls get described as 'Nanny Dogs' FFS (https://blog.dogsbite.org/2010/05/1909-fatality-john-p-colbys-fighting.html). I cannot comprehend how a type of fighting dog that has maimed and killed hundreds of children in the US can be portrayed as some sort of gentle and sensible Lassie equivalent.

Yes - I totally agree, which is why I emphasise good breeding etc from dogs with good temperament as well as health. Again, it is another good breed spoiled because unscrupulous, greedy breeders see a way to make a quick buck.

Most reported dog incidents are by dogs known to the victims

Very true @MrsWhy , but we are seeing a very disturbing increase in the number of attacks on non-family members and outside of the home (ie dog isn't responding to a perceived threat to its territory). The number of home attacks is increasing as well and this is almost all down to these very dangerous breeds.

I don't know why any ordinary family would want one - and I certainly do't know why anyone in their right mind would re-home one of these into a house where there are children, elderly people or anyone else who may be even slightly vulnerable, even if those people were just occasional visitors.

Had that poor girl in the video not managed to regain her feet she could very easily have been killed rather than "just" injured. She was a fit young woman, thank heavens - if those dogs had attacked anyone with a disability, or who was small or weak it could have been an even more terrible story.

123wdcd · 10/06/2023 09:10

MrsWhy · 10/06/2023 07:16

I think this all a little extreme. Most reported dog incidents are by dogs known to the victims. Dog don't mistake a child for a squirrel or a bunny! They have a fight or flight mode so don't try a match aggression with aggression, stay calm and give clear commands
If the worse does happen grab the collar and twist

That is true of normal dog types @MrsWhy With pit bull descendants increasingly owned in the UK in the form of XL bullies, causing catastrophic injuries and with the police sometimes having to shoot the dog to stop the attack. We risk more horrific attacks, both where these dogs are kept in homes where there are children and unrelated people are targeted as prey.

This US doctor describes the change they have seen: https://eu.cincinnati.com/story/opinion/contributors/2014/06/29/doctor-says-ban-pit-bulls/11709481/

"When I started my career, the most common dog-bite injuries were from German shepherds and occasionally retrievers. These injuries were almost always provoked, such as food-related or stepping on the dog, and in almost every instance, the dog reacted with a single snap and release – essentially a warning shot. There were no pack attacks. Starting about 25 years ago, my colleagues and I started to see disturbingly different types of injuries. Instead of a warning bite, we saw wounds where the flesh was torn from the victim. There were multiple bite wounds covering many different anatomical sites. The attacks were generally unprovoked, persistent and often involved more than one dog. In every instance the dog involved was a pit bull or a pit bull mix."

What can I take on walks that may help if a dog attacks us.
What can I take on walks that may help if a dog attacks us.
oakleaffy · 10/06/2023 12:29

123wdcd · 10/06/2023 09:10

That is true of normal dog types @MrsWhy With pit bull descendants increasingly owned in the UK in the form of XL bullies, causing catastrophic injuries and with the police sometimes having to shoot the dog to stop the attack. We risk more horrific attacks, both where these dogs are kept in homes where there are children and unrelated people are targeted as prey.

This US doctor describes the change they have seen: https://eu.cincinnati.com/story/opinion/contributors/2014/06/29/doctor-says-ban-pit-bulls/11709481/

"When I started my career, the most common dog-bite injuries were from German shepherds and occasionally retrievers. These injuries were almost always provoked, such as food-related or stepping on the dog, and in almost every instance, the dog reacted with a single snap and release – essentially a warning shot. There were no pack attacks. Starting about 25 years ago, my colleagues and I started to see disturbingly different types of injuries. Instead of a warning bite, we saw wounds where the flesh was torn from the victim. There were multiple bite wounds covering many different anatomical sites. The attacks were generally unprovoked, persistent and often involved more than one dog. In every instance the dog involved was a pit bull or a pit bull mix."

@123wdcd That is horrific what the Doctor says.
And that every one of these catastrophic wounds was from a pit or pit mix {XL Bullies}

When Pit owners say ''It's the owner, not the breed'', they are denying the powerful effect genes have on dogs.

A fighting bred dog has the potential to want to 'Worry' and kill other dogs/people or animals.

'Normal' dogs do a 'Snatch' bite and release- Even GSD's.

One can occasionally get 'Rogue' dogs- a woman that we used to live near always had aggressive dogs, and they weren't 'Known' aggressive breeds, {One was a Golden Retriever that mauled a postwoman's hand so severely she needed surgery} but her ownership seemed to bring out the very worst in the dogs she owned.

Someone like that with a Pit Bull or XL Bully would be very dangerous.

She was always shouty -abrasive and screaming at the dogs.

Someone with a sighthound made a Picachu ''Surprised face'' when the gentle dog they were with caught and dispatched a squirrel on a walk.

But that has been hardwired into sighthounds- to catch and dispatch small game and 'Vermin' {Rats, mice &c} - They don't need teaching- it's innate.

As it is with Bull breeds to have the potential for attacking.

@WiddlinDiddlin Who is the Daily Mail 'Expert'?
The only one I can think it might be is Roger Mugford - I did refer to his books years ago with my first dog, but he didn't suggest anything untoward that I can remember- {Books from Library}- I do remember that he was the person who 'Invented' the Halti for pulling dogs, and he spoke out against prong collars {I do agree with him there}.

What is the Expert suggesting re the recent spate of XL /Pit attacks?

oakleaffy · 10/06/2023 12:38

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/06/2023 09:02

Yes - I totally agree, which is why I emphasise good breeding etc from dogs with good temperament as well as health. Again, it is another good breed spoiled because unscrupulous, greedy breeders see a way to make a quick buck.

Most reported dog incidents are by dogs known to the victims

Very true @MrsWhy , but we are seeing a very disturbing increase in the number of attacks on non-family members and outside of the home (ie dog isn't responding to a perceived threat to its territory). The number of home attacks is increasing as well and this is almost all down to these very dangerous breeds.

I don't know why any ordinary family would want one - and I certainly do't know why anyone in their right mind would re-home one of these into a house where there are children, elderly people or anyone else who may be even slightly vulnerable, even if those people were just occasional visitors.

Had that poor girl in the video not managed to regain her feet she could very easily have been killed rather than "just" injured. She was a fit young woman, thank heavens - if those dogs had attacked anyone with a disability, or who was small or weak it could have been an even more terrible story.

How that young woman escaped was a literal Miracle.

It was terrifying to see that footage.

The owner of those dogs {Three...ye Gods} had zero control of any of them- and he told the woman to 'Run'?

Her screams, while absolutely natural, probably geed up those dogs to bite and worry at her even more.

I hope the owner is caught, and those dogs euthanised.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 10/06/2023 13:23

On the back of this thread I've wandered down an internet rabbit hole . Starting with "XL Bullies for sale" they command a huge price .
Sad to see how many of the parents are ear-cropped but some are imported .

The same names come up which took me onto a breeder of Bully Type/Pit Bull type in the USA ( PitBulls are not an illegal breed there ) again huge prices ($10,000+) and they can ship the puppies across the world for a fee.
And arrange ear-cropping for you so that's a weight off your mind eh? Hmm
These dogs are HUGE (and IMO fucking ugly , no nice way to gild the lily .

Lots of football and sports stars are buying them.

Even on some of the UK sites , the dogs are advertised like a heavyweight boxer fight promotion. Head and chest of the dogs, the kennel name and a background of flames /explosions .

I live in East London and I've seen some bloody huge dogs round here , thankfully at a distance ,but recent news items (the man in Limehouse where the Police shot his dogs and the woman in Stepney Green attacked by the three offlead bullies )
These dogs are so wide barrelled and squat legged , they look like they'll collapse with the bulk.
The puppies are quite cute , I can see why people are attracted to the pups .

Adverts , photographed with children tangled up with the dogs (to show how great they are with kiddies ) . Even when the dogs are asleep they are patting them.etc, Erm what happened to never disturb a sleeping dog (even if its for your InstaPhoto)

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/06/2023 13:28

oakleaffy · 10/06/2023 12:38

How that young woman escaped was a literal Miracle.

It was terrifying to see that footage.

The owner of those dogs {Three...ye Gods} had zero control of any of them- and he told the woman to 'Run'?

Her screams, while absolutely natural, probably geed up those dogs to bite and worry at her even more.

I hope the owner is caught, and those dogs euthanised.

I thought at first he was shouting "Run", but on listening again I thought he might have been shouting "Rocco" - calling the dog. Not sure which.

I agree - dogs need to be euthanised (and owner needs a prison sentence).

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 10/06/2023 13:33

oakleaffy · 10/06/2023 12:38

How that young woman escaped was a literal Miracle.

It was terrifying to see that footage.

The owner of those dogs {Three...ye Gods} had zero control of any of them- and he told the woman to 'Run'?

Her screams, while absolutely natural, probably geed up those dogs to bite and worry at her even more.

I hope the owner is caught, and those dogs euthanised.

The woman was possibly saved from further injury as she was wearing a thick fleece which one of the dogs (the brown dog ? Rocco) had hold of . Even after a boot in the ribs from the bloke , it hung in grimly ,
And , I think he did the Bulldog Wheelbarrow at one point (which did nought)

Utterly terrifying to watch that video and that he thinks walking three offlead, unmuzzled powerful dogs in a park area is a good idea Shock

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 10/06/2023 13:40

Ah just saw not Stepney Green , it's Lambeth

Hopefully there wasn't a second attack in Stepney Green that got the news report confused .

oakleaffy · 10/06/2023 13:48

Emotionalsupportviper · 10/06/2023 13:28

I thought at first he was shouting "Run", but on listening again I thought he might have been shouting "Rocco" - calling the dog. Not sure which.

I agree - dogs need to be euthanised (and owner needs a prison sentence).

@Emotionalsupportviper I thought I heard “ Run “ then definitely “ Rocco”- The woman appeared to be targeted for no apparent reason.

Yesterday on a walk I saw ( and my dog saw) a dog with aggressive body language.

It was off lead but muzzled.

The owner calling out “It’s a Rescyoo” as if that makes a jot of bloody difference!

There are enough nice non aggressive dogs to adopt ~ but at least the bloke had it muzzled.

It was definitely not good with other dogs.

Rainbowsandfairies · 10/06/2023 13:50

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 09/06/2023 09:08

@Emotionalsupportviper

They are weapons and this is the part missed by some. It was explained very clearly in yesterday's article that I can't link.

They are causing much pain and suffering and they should not be brought into existence. We don't need to them.

For people who do feel safer with a more aggressive dog, there are better more rounded dog breeds out there.

Totally agree! My 5 year old leapt into my arms as a crazy dog circled us and kept trying to jump on us!! Owner had no control, she said " sorry, I didn't think anyone would be here!!" It was 9.30 on a Sat morning in the woods near our house ( with rope swings) so definitely meant for kids!! Owner said " she's a lock down dog!!" And.....that means it's OK then. My daughter is nearly 9 and still absolutely terrified 😨 of dogs!!!!

Rainbowsandfairies · 10/06/2023 13:52

miniegg3 · 09/06/2023 12:18

On amazon you can get something that looks like a torch buy gives off a really high pitched noise that dogs hate that's supposed to scare them off. It was about a tenner..

Probably a better shot than trying to strangle them 🤣

Brilliant I'll get 1 as my 8 year old got a massive fright when she was 6 ( see my above posts)

oakleaffy · 10/06/2023 14:00

Rainbowsandfairies · 10/06/2023 13:50

Totally agree! My 5 year old leapt into my arms as a crazy dog circled us and kept trying to jump on us!! Owner had no control, she said " sorry, I didn't think anyone would be here!!" It was 9.30 on a Sat morning in the woods near our house ( with rope swings) so definitely meant for kids!! Owner said " she's a lock down dog!!" And.....that means it's OK then. My daughter is nearly 9 and still absolutely terrified 😨 of dogs!!!!

That’s completely unacceptable.
Always an excuse with these owners.
If it’s “ Rescue” a “ Puppy” or “ Lockdown “ keep it on a lead and or muzzled til it is reliable around children or other people or dogs.

carrying a heavy Blackthorn stick can be a deterrent- If the owners see you have a heavy stick they are more likely to try and call their dog off.

( Or try to!).

WiddlinDiddlin · 10/06/2023 14:10

@oakleaffy Stan Rawlinson, he's well into old age and hasn't actually worked with 'type' dogs much at all and not for a verrrrrrrrry long time. Some of what he comes out with is sense but then... he has a history of leaning rather heavily on other peoples work/words/opinions... and then passing them off as his own.

oakleaffy · 10/06/2023 15:13

WiddlinDiddlin · 10/06/2023 14:10

@oakleaffy Stan Rawlinson, he's well into old age and hasn't actually worked with 'type' dogs much at all and not for a verrrrrrrrry long time. Some of what he comes out with is sense but then... he has a history of leaning rather heavily on other peoples work/words/opinions... and then passing them off as his own.

Thanks, I will Google him.

Trends in dog training could me and go- I was shocked to see in some old books that “pinning down a dog” that challenges you was a suggested action, Or standing astride it, and lifting the forelegs off the ground-
Plus punishment with “ A rolled up newspaper 🗞 “

Then there was Woodhouse with her beastly choke chains that people often put on incorrectly-

There is a male trainer on TV ( I don’t watch much TV) but he charges a small fortune to visit people- hundreds of pounds for a four hour visit.

On you tube there is Robert Cabral who seems to deal a lot with Malinois and Bull Breeds-
Even he says some dogs are far too dangerous to be pets.

Also that there is nothing wrong with choosing a “ Nice” dog over a problem.

Some people have a saviour complex and want the really problem dog- but do themselves or the dog any favours.

WisherWood · 10/06/2023 16:46

The owner of those dogs {Three...ye Gods} had zero control of any of them- and he told the woman to 'Run'?

He was calling the dog Rocco but I also thought he was actually saying 'don't run', which makes more sense. You're not going to outrun a dog, you just invoke their instinct to chase.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 10/06/2023 18:13

There is a male trainer on TV ( I don’t watch much TV) but he charges a small fortune to visit people- hundreds of pounds for a four hour visit.

Graeme Hall?

I know Ceaser Milan is not well recieved but some of his training policies like work before food /most dogs are underexercised/ always leave and enter the house before yor dog .....to me they make sense . But others claim he uses "Pack Theory" and other outdated and unpalateable methods .

Barbara Woodhouse was another one who had some good points - getting the dog to pay attention to you . The command "Sit" . But the choke chain which was often too lightweight and fitted wrong , they had to be heavy enough to release again. You could see them in use and often painful response to pulling .

WiddlinDiddlin · 10/06/2023 21:07

All sensible, educated trainers will advice consistency, exercise, meeting a dogs needs - the fact that the likes of Cesar, Graeme etc occasionally hit on those things does not make them decent trainers or in any way good at what they do...

Dogs can have food for free (I mean, they should, food, air, water, basic rights innit!), you can let them go in the door before you, if they're well trained, needs met, exercised appropriately etc it will not cause your dog to take over the world!

Cesar set the training world back 40 years with his alpha rolls, force based methods and his magical 'tssst' (in fact a conditioned response, developed after several hours off camera pairing that sound with a sharp jerk to a cheesewire like slip collar, prong collar or shock collar, so not actually magic at all!).

Graeme is self-certified, member of a 'pay to join' organisation that just asks that you confirm you've trained x number of dogs for x hours, pay the fee and you too can be a Master Dog Trainer.

What they both have in common is a very confident, apparently charming manner (but look closely they are actually really rather rude to their clients on tv, belittling, sneering, laughing at them, and far FAR worse with women of course...) but underlying it - they are both domineering bullies!

What they also have in common ... is a huge number of normal, every day, run of the mill trainers, like I was (I don't do in person training any more, health put paid to that), mopping up the wake of dog related messes they leave behind.

They charge HUGE fees, in Graemes case, three to four times the industry standard for a home visit, training, report and work to get on with and follow up support...

Trainers doing this often offer lifetime support - if anyone does that, RUN, because no decent trainer can offer that for a flat fee. It's not possible, so what really happens is, you pay the trainer £800, they come out, give you stuff to do, you do it, it goes tits up very fast and oh... you can't actually get in touch again, they're busy, they'll call back, ..... and ghosted.

Barbara woodhouse did good in that she brought pet dog training to pet dog owners - prior to her and also John Rogerson, it was for working dogs, pet dogs were really not trained by professionals, and not well trained by owners.

However her methods were to cause the dog to fear her more than anything else, to achieve 'respect' - I think we all realise now that fear is not respect, and respect is earned, not forced.

If anyone is looking for a trainer, theres a lot of professional organisations out there..

I would go with:

PACT
APDT
IMDT
APBC
ABTC

A trainer should be a member of a professional organisation that requires members adhere to a code of conduct you can look at.

That prof. org. should require members complete a certain amount of CPD hours each year or every two years, that is of a certain standard/quality (they will specify to members what that is. For mine, it had to be accepted by the ABTC as science based and usually through one of their recognised organisations, ABTC being an umbrella organisation that has many member orgs under them.)

They should also assess trainers in person, actually training dogs they have not met before, as well as a written exam covering theory, business practice, safety etc.

They should be insured.

If you have all that and you get a duff trainer, you have comeback - but owners HAVE to report to a professional organisation themselves they cannot get someone else to do it - the number of times I had people ask if I could report other trainers... and we can't. Professional organisations will ONLY take first hand reports of poor training, poor practice, dangerous stuff, prohibited methods etc, from the client of that trainer.

Many people won't report as they feel conned, silly, guilty etc etc.

oakleaffy · 10/06/2023 21:41

@WiddlinDiddlin If people only chose dogs that were well suited to them personality wise, there would also be far fewer problems with dogs.
RSPCA chose my first dog for me- She really wasn’t what I had in mind - I wanted big adult male!
But they chose extremely well- we had almost 12 yrs together.
( A very quiet sensitive young female Collie Lurcher)
I do like quiet, sensitive ones, an overbearing. Barky bumptious dog would be hell for me .

Trainers seem largely to train the human .

I wasn’t aware that Caesar paired his Pssshtt!! With jags from a sharp slip collar.

Agreed, these men are nearly all Uber confident and bossy.

Robert Cabral seems ok, but I haven’t the insider’s take on him.

He seems calm and sensible.

( Graeme was the hugely expensive person!
many hundreds for four hrs!)

WiddlinDiddlin · 11/06/2023 04:31

I think it won't surprise you to know Graeme used to be a salesman...

Mm, I have the (sometimes dubious, there are things I'd often rather not know!) benefit of several 'insider' friends working in tv here and in the US.

Cesars practice is to take a dog off the owners for upwards of 2/3 hours before bringing the owners back in - this is whether working with them 1 to 1 or actually for filming (though he did very little training in the US before being on TV. His training background in Mexico was in training protection dogs to bite people...

Both the 'tssst' and the little backward kicky thing he does with his heel are heavily conditioned with whatever aversive the owners already use or he feels suitable - hence the rather extreme reaction! Say 'tsst' or nudge an unconditioned dog like that and 9 times out of 10 you will get mild surprise and confusion or nothing at all!

He also used to offer to swap people dogs he could not fix (though they'd be labelled 'not suitable for the family' of course...) for one of his pack... That pack was just whatever pound dogs would tolerate the communal living conditions they were kept in without huge fights breaking out.

Many did not tolerate those conditions... but in any case, he actually dumped several 'packs' when he moved facilities, leaving local rescues/dog people to sort that out.

The man has got away with near murder tbh, as he has friends in verrrrrry high places (or had, anyway) - the time he set a dog loose, on a pair of young and terrified pigs, knowing that dog had already killed a pig, and that aired on TV... wow. Animal Control actually investigated that and tried to bring a cruelty case but... suddenly... poof, it alllll disappeared.

Hey ho! I digress and it is bedtime. I've spent 8 hours today helping nice people with on the whole, suitable dogs, set their puppies up for a happy, safe life (some of them were even asking for help BEFORE they got a puppy... so things are improving, there is good out there too! :) )

GSD20 · 11/06/2023 06:36

@WiddlinDiddlin completely agree that training needs to be much more strictly regulated. I have a MA in behaviour but don’t work as a behaviourist (work in a related field but not as a trainer) because I can’t be bothered to compete with people with next to 0 qualifications but a huge social media presence. Or even worse X has had a dog for 30 years so know better types.

Another thing wrong with the dog industry really. The whole thing needs an overhaul!

Emotionalsupportviper · 11/06/2023 08:05

WiddlinDiddlin · 11/06/2023 04:31

I think it won't surprise you to know Graeme used to be a salesman...

Mm, I have the (sometimes dubious, there are things I'd often rather not know!) benefit of several 'insider' friends working in tv here and in the US.

Cesars practice is to take a dog off the owners for upwards of 2/3 hours before bringing the owners back in - this is whether working with them 1 to 1 or actually for filming (though he did very little training in the US before being on TV. His training background in Mexico was in training protection dogs to bite people...

Both the 'tssst' and the little backward kicky thing he does with his heel are heavily conditioned with whatever aversive the owners already use or he feels suitable - hence the rather extreme reaction! Say 'tsst' or nudge an unconditioned dog like that and 9 times out of 10 you will get mild surprise and confusion or nothing at all!

He also used to offer to swap people dogs he could not fix (though they'd be labelled 'not suitable for the family' of course...) for one of his pack... That pack was just whatever pound dogs would tolerate the communal living conditions they were kept in without huge fights breaking out.

Many did not tolerate those conditions... but in any case, he actually dumped several 'packs' when he moved facilities, leaving local rescues/dog people to sort that out.

The man has got away with near murder tbh, as he has friends in verrrrrry high places (or had, anyway) - the time he set a dog loose, on a pair of young and terrified pigs, knowing that dog had already killed a pig, and that aired on TV... wow. Animal Control actually investigated that and tried to bring a cruelty case but... suddenly... poof, it alllll disappeared.

Hey ho! I digress and it is bedtime. I've spent 8 hours today helping nice people with on the whole, suitable dogs, set their puppies up for a happy, safe life (some of them were even asking for help BEFORE they got a puppy... so things are improving, there is good out there too! :) )

Excellent post - thank you.

I can't stand Cesar Milan, though I've had loads of people recommend him. A lot of his methods are dangerous, never mind ineffective. And I recall one video where he deliberately intimidated and taunted an elderly dog with her food bowl until she finally bit him (which was what he had wanted) and he could then "discipline" her. (He's an absolute bar-steward!)

I also hated that the dogs he "failed" with were taken to his "dog ranch" where they lived out the rest of their (probably short, stressed) lives away from their families in an alien environment, and with packs of dogs they had never met before and would likely been terrified of. Obviously they all "settled perfectly" and were "happy" and their idiot owners were free to get another dog to ruin without having a euthanised dog on their conscience. God alone knows what happened on the "ranch" - how many dogs were killed by others, how many died of stress and loneliness, how many even starved or died of thirst, because I don't believe for a moment that those animals were properly and individually looked after.

The more I learn about him, the worse he gets.

I bliddy HATE him!

Swipe left for the next trending thread