Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have gone off sick as manager made the job impossible

130 replies

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 18:30

I am a social worker with older people. I live in a fairly large town and the team cover a large area with substantial rural areas. However the vast majority of our clients live in the town centre.

I do not drive. This is not due to a disability. I’ve tried everything (PLEASE don’t offer me driving advice 😂) and have made peace with the fact driving isn’t for me. I hated every minute of driving lessons and never got anywhere despite trying many things. I am very happy being a non-driver and don’t feel the need to try to learn now.
I was honest about this in my interview over 12 years ago. Lovely manager had no issue with this as most clients are in the town centre and the town centre has excellent transport links.
I have happily worked in this job for 12 years now. I get given cases based in the town centre and go via walk or electric bike. If it’s raining I will take the bus.
Crucial I think is that clients in rural areas are given to the social workers who live in those areas just for convenience and practicality really. So NO ONE is having to travel longer on account of me. Infact most social workers say they hate the town centre work as they need to find parking and get stuck in traffic so are happy I cover this area.

The original manager left and two years ago a new one came along who seemed nice enough. I informed my manager I was pregnant three months ago. Since then (it may not be related but it’s a coincidence if not) my cases have been getting further and further from the town centre.
I have had an few allocations I can’t get to at all as they are not accessible by public transport and actually dangerous to travel there on a bike or bus (no phone signal and no pavement).
the others would just take me so long it would mean I’d not be able to do my job effectively.
When I queried this I was told to get another worker to give me a lift. It would not be fair to ask them to be my chauffeur.

I have spoken to my union and as the town centre allocations was an informal arrangement with my previous manager and not an official term of my contract (darn should have got that in writing). I basically have no powers to do anything.
I don’t need to visit places that are dangerous without a car but they can make me go somewhere that’s accessible even if it would take all day. If they want to be twats.
My work contract says I need to be able to travel anywhere within the county. It doesn’t say car essential but essentially I’d need to be able to get to any client.
We don’t have duty or emergency work in my role.

Realising I physically can’t do my job anymore I got signed off sick for stress until the start of my maternity leave.

I am lucky I am highly employable so can find social worker jobs easily. There are hospitals where a car is not needed. I will use the end of my maternity to get one of these jobs. I will return to my old job for 3 months to keep my pay.
It’s a shame as I loved working there and I worked there very successfully for 12 years. I had a total of 3 DAYS sick days in 13 years and was a good worker.
I recently got married and I think they think I will be off on repeated maternity leave so best get me out now.
Everyone of my colleagues is appalled and so upset. Their support has been amazing.

So AIBU to have gone off sick? Probably am aren’t I? But I don’t think I had much choice.

OP posts:
Pawpatrollermum · 04/06/2023 21:05

I’m a long standing social worker in children and families so a bit different to you.

However, I’m really struggling to see how you can’t get deal with crisis in social work? Even if they’re your own long-standing allocated cases - surely there is some crisis/responding work you undertake?

randomuser2019 · 04/06/2023 21:18

This reply has been withdrawn

Removed at poster's request due to privacy concerns.

TheCreamTeaWasFromMe · 04/06/2023 21:40

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/06/2023 20:23

How can places not be covered by taxis? Taxis will surely go anywhere?
I would do what she has told you and ask a colleague for lifts to these visits, and CC her into the emails when you ask them. You can even ask her! Then document how it isn't working to get you there or you colleagues can ask for less caseloads on account of you driving them.
You can also get an occupational health assessment if your pregnancy makes cycling unsafe etc

Welcome to rural living!! The village that my Dad lives in has a bus service that runs twice a day - once out in the morning, once back at about 5.30pm. There used to be a cabbie (singular) but he retired.

If you want to book a taxi you have to ring the firm in the big town 20 minutes away. But they will charge you their travel fare. I had to book a taxi for my Dad to go to a hospital appointment as I couldn't get off work to take him. I had to pay the fare cost from the town to my Dad's, the cost of the fare to the hospital, then the cost of the journey back from the hospital, and finally the cost of the taxi's journey back to his base in the town. And to get them to agree to go to him I had to pay the full 4x fare cost in advance.

If you haven't lived rurally, then driving is a complete necessity as it's incredibly difficult and expensive to get about otherwise, and it's not always a case of not being able to afford a taxi - sometimes actually getting one is impossible!

Primrosesanddaisies · 04/06/2023 21:43

I think it would be very worthwhile to get half an hour with an employment law specialist. Sometimes, terms of an employment contract can be implied (not written down) even if this is not what your job description states. So for 12 years, it has become custom and practice that you work in a certain location. I don't think a new manager can come along and just change that. Ultimately only a tribunal can decide but rather than get comments from random people based on what they think, find out from someone who has actual legal knowledge. Personally I think you have a strong case - 12 years is a very long time but sometimes it is better to say goodbye and start afresh somewhere else, especially as you have an idea that your new manager is a bit difficult. Good luck!

Jellyx · 04/06/2023 21:53

I don't think I could have gone off sick unless I was genuinely unwell and had expressed to my manager that the lack of safe travel was making me unwell.

I do think that the council need to change their hiring policy so that a driving license is essential.

I work in social work and some workers have openly said they don't want to get their license so they don't have to travel far away for foster care placements..

Blogswife · 04/06/2023 21:56

As you have been working under these conditions for 12 years your working arrangements may have become “Custom & Practice “-
“ an unwritten and implied contract term that relates to an unofficial practice within an industry or organisation that has become accepted as the norm”

If this is the case your employer would have difficulty changing your contract / working arrangements without consultation.
This must be very stressful for you , especially as you are now being expected to take risks to get to the rural locations. I’m surprised that your employer is putting your safety at risk knowing your situation and being aware of your pregnancy
If you contact Citizens Advice or ACAS they should be able to advise you on the best way forward - certainly sounds like discrimination !

VerveClique · 04/06/2023 22:06

The thing is OP, I have explained to you how you address this.

What do you want? For things to go back to how they were? Or you 'get your day in court'?

I know I'm a stranger on the Internet but I have given you good advice.

Follow the steps I've set out and it neat just be able to resolve it.

There's nothing stopping you going to an employment lawyer at a later date.

If you are in Union, contact them NOW and request support in this.

Bring incredulous is not going to get you anywhere. I know you're upset but in most cases the best thing you can do when you're pregnant is hold onto a god job... you're going to need it.

IME there are very few managers that are both organised enough and or ignorant/hard-faced enough to make a significant change to your working arrangements BECAUSE of your pregnancy the day after you've announced it.

This is unfortunate, upsetting and inconvenient. But it's worth trying very hard to resolve it amicably IME.

SquishyGloopyBum · 05/06/2023 06:35

You'd be better off posting on employment matters than in aibu.

But it sounds like your manager has taken issue. I think you need a meeting with her- document it all. Then complain higher up if necessary.

pilates · 05/06/2023 06:54

I think you need to take your grievances higher before being signed off sick. Also there will be extra pressure on your work colleagues.

SchoolShenanigans · 05/06/2023 07:07

They've handled it wrong. They shouldn't have suddenly given you work they know you can't do.

BUT you're wrong when you say your role doesnt require driving - it does. You can only not drive because others do drive. You can only be allocated the centre because others seemingly don't mind that.

I wonder if they've changed it because other people are starting to feel hard done by and want the jobs to be evenly allocated. Perhaps your colleagues didn't feel able to complain to the old manager as they allowed you to do it, but they've been asking the newer manager for work to be more fairly allocated.

I used to work in a similar setting and we had a few walkers. We couldn't manage them out but we wanted to. They did substantially fewer visits every shift and were an absolute pain to plan around.

You say yourself, working in a school or hospital is well suited to someone who's doesn't drive - so do that.

A community based social working role really isn't suitable for a non-driver who can never work rurally.

TheKobayashiMaru · 05/06/2023 07:18

Not sure why you posted in AIBU, you clearly think you are not.

daisychain01 · 05/06/2023 07:23

PositiveParasite · 04/06/2023 19:00

Could you have grounds for a constructive dismissal claim? Your previous years of successful responsibility for the town centre cases seems like good enough evidence, what else could a tribunal infer from this sudden change?

It reads as if you are being deliberately forced out. I’m not surprised you are signed off with stress related issues.

For this to stand any chance of CD, the OP will need to try to resolve the matter starting informally, then formally, with her Manager via the grievance process. If that doesn't work, then she will need to resign immediately citing Constructive Dismissal and forfeit any notice period plus employer enhanced Mat Pay, due to having been put into an impossible position by said Manager. The degree to which a Tribunal would deem the client locations to be impossible for the OP to service will depend on their assessment of why the OP is incapable of reaching said locations, including taking account of any maternity based risks. This needs to be lodged with Tribunal within the time limit of 3 months.

In short it wouldn't be an easy thing for the OP to undertake, not least of when she is just about to have a baby.

Theunamedcat · 05/06/2023 07:30

Throwncrumbs · 04/06/2023 20:29

You and your GP are way out of line discussing clients/patients of his… absolutely not on!

They are allowed to discuss things in general terms they are not gossiping

MRex · 05/06/2023 07:37

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 18:50

Yes my work pay full pay for maternity related sickness

You are incorrect. You must work in the 15th week before the birth for the SMP portion: https://www.gov.uk/employers-maternity-pay-leave/eligibility-and-proof-of-pregnancy#:~:text=Statutory%20Maternity%20Pay%20(%20SMP%20),you%20proof%20they're%20pregnant. Unless you have passed that point, you'll need to apply for maternity allowance instead.

I'm really confused why you didn't address this with HR and senior management? You've run off "sick" when you aren't sick, you have logistical issues. Offer to take a taxi, then if they decline you say "Oh unfortunately I can't get to that location". Or ask.your manager to arrange the colleague for a lift. Make the manager come up with the travel plan and implement it.

Statutory Maternity Pay and Leave: employer guide

Employer guide to Statutory Maternity Pay (SMP) and Leave - rates, eligibility, notice period, form SMP1, recover statutory pay

https://www.gov.uk/employers-maternity-pay-leave/eligibility-and-proof-of-pregnancy#:~:text=Statutory%20Maternity%20Pay%20(%20SMP%20),you%20proof%20they're%20pregnant.

Giggorata · 05/06/2023 07:45

As a SW manager, I would not have employed anyone who couldn’t drive.
It would have been stated on the contract too, as an essential requirement.

Having said that, after a team merger, I inherited a social worker who couldn’t drive. Her team had previously operated only in the town centre.
It meant that everyone else either had to make adjustments around her, giving lifts and allocating only local service users, or her taking hours and sometimes all day, getting to someone on public transport or in different towns.

It was a pain, she did less than everyone else and It wasn't an effective use of the time of a hard pressed team.
It also carried the danger of losing the essential car allowance for that team member, thereby impacting the team's budget. Once lost, it was almost impossible to reinstate, should the person leave, due to the red tape.

Cases to allocate came in thick and fast, so there wasn’t the opportunity to allocate only nearby cases to her, even if it had been fair to do so.
Which it wasn't.

Remotecontrolatmyside · 05/06/2023 07:48

You are being completely unreasonable

towriteyoumustlive · 05/06/2023 07:54

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:32

It’s interesting that 64% on the poll say I’m not being unreasonable but the comments are mainly negative.

The YANBU bit is suddenly having your job changed when you said you were pregnant. That's not on.

But going on long term sick rather than making more effort to challenge this will get you negative comments. I would have requested a meeting with the manager and pushed for their reasoning in writing as this was potentially an unfair dismiss case.

bluebird3 · 05/06/2023 07:57

YANBU - they're trying to manage you out so you're responding in the way that you need to based on the situation they've put you in.

VerveClique · 05/06/2023 08:12

What @daisychain01 says is correct.

Zezet · 05/06/2023 08:13

The original arrangment sounds pretty unreasonable, however you had it for 12 years successfully so who are we to judge.

That they changed it for your pregnancy is appalling and gives you 60% YANBU votes.

But to sign off sick when you are clearly not is, well, fraud. As reflected by the comments here and the one third YABU.

You are further unreasonable by coming here and asking for advice with no apparent intention other than being proven right.

HAF1119 · 05/06/2023 08:23

You'll find a company who treat their employees better :)

I don't drive and have some limitations in place due to this but nothing which prevents me doing a good job.

When pregnant my company had numerous meetings to check with me that I was managing things effectively and if anything needed to be done to keep me comfortable and safe during pregnancy. Didn't really need any adjustments but they certainly didn't make things harder with no notice the second I got pregnant. For me that's the crux - they have tried to stay within your contract but effectively make your job non manageable and increase your stress as soon as you got pregnant, I wouldn't want to work for anyone who did that.

Cornflakes44 · 05/06/2023 09:13

It’s irrelevant whether you should or shouldn’t be able to drive in your role. You’ve been doing it for 12 years without being able to. If they are to change your role that substantially, even if it was a casual arrangement (but not that casual if it’s lasted that long) they should discuss it with you first. Not just land it on you. Give you a chance to propose an alternative etc. If it’s not in your contract then technical/ legally they can behave like this, but it’s shitty practice and unfair. I’m surprised so many people are siding with your boss. I wonder if it happened to them if they’d feel the same.

LlynTegid · 05/06/2023 09:16

I think your union have let you down in their advice. What you have (or had) is an implied term of contract in my opinion. Discussed at interview, the reality for over 10 years, and even better in that it benefits others.

Scalottia · 05/06/2023 09:39

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:20

My Union did say this was unacceptable of them

Of course they did 🙄

YABU to go off 'sick'. And you not being able to drive shouldn't be the employer's problem.

Does nobody have any resilience anymore?

GoodChat · 05/06/2023 10:16

And you not being able to drive shouldn't be the employer's problem.

It's not the employer's problem but there's been a compromise that suits everyone for the last 12 years (including two years which the new manager has been happy with) which has only suddenly become an issue now that the OP has informed them of her pregnancy.