Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have gone off sick as manager made the job impossible

130 replies

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 18:30

I am a social worker with older people. I live in a fairly large town and the team cover a large area with substantial rural areas. However the vast majority of our clients live in the town centre.

I do not drive. This is not due to a disability. I’ve tried everything (PLEASE don’t offer me driving advice 😂) and have made peace with the fact driving isn’t for me. I hated every minute of driving lessons and never got anywhere despite trying many things. I am very happy being a non-driver and don’t feel the need to try to learn now.
I was honest about this in my interview over 12 years ago. Lovely manager had no issue with this as most clients are in the town centre and the town centre has excellent transport links.
I have happily worked in this job for 12 years now. I get given cases based in the town centre and go via walk or electric bike. If it’s raining I will take the bus.
Crucial I think is that clients in rural areas are given to the social workers who live in those areas just for convenience and practicality really. So NO ONE is having to travel longer on account of me. Infact most social workers say they hate the town centre work as they need to find parking and get stuck in traffic so are happy I cover this area.

The original manager left and two years ago a new one came along who seemed nice enough. I informed my manager I was pregnant three months ago. Since then (it may not be related but it’s a coincidence if not) my cases have been getting further and further from the town centre.
I have had an few allocations I can’t get to at all as they are not accessible by public transport and actually dangerous to travel there on a bike or bus (no phone signal and no pavement).
the others would just take me so long it would mean I’d not be able to do my job effectively.
When I queried this I was told to get another worker to give me a lift. It would not be fair to ask them to be my chauffeur.

I have spoken to my union and as the town centre allocations was an informal arrangement with my previous manager and not an official term of my contract (darn should have got that in writing). I basically have no powers to do anything.
I don’t need to visit places that are dangerous without a car but they can make me go somewhere that’s accessible even if it would take all day. If they want to be twats.
My work contract says I need to be able to travel anywhere within the county. It doesn’t say car essential but essentially I’d need to be able to get to any client.
We don’t have duty or emergency work in my role.

Realising I physically can’t do my job anymore I got signed off sick for stress until the start of my maternity leave.

I am lucky I am highly employable so can find social worker jobs easily. There are hospitals where a car is not needed. I will use the end of my maternity to get one of these jobs. I will return to my old job for 3 months to keep my pay.
It’s a shame as I loved working there and I worked there very successfully for 12 years. I had a total of 3 DAYS sick days in 13 years and was a good worker.
I recently got married and I think they think I will be off on repeated maternity leave so best get me out now.
Everyone of my colleagues is appalled and so upset. Their support has been amazing.

So AIBU to have gone off sick? Probably am aren’t I? But I don’t think I had much choice.

OP posts:
Fossie · 04/06/2023 20:08

It surely makes no sense to send people all over the place from a logistical point of view. What a waste of extra travel time. Do others now have to do city centre visits? They can’t be happy. Surely a sensible manager wants to get the best from their team? I hope he/she can justify losing you when there are staff shortages.

gemsgv · 04/06/2023 20:10

I'd say, you have a job that requires driving but you have managed to get around this because your last manager let you have the jobs that didn't need to be driven to. You've done well to get 12 years out of that.

If I was given certain jobs at work because someone else didn't drive, I would not be happy at all.

DataNotLore · 04/06/2023 20:15

TheHoover · 04/06/2023 19:41

I agree with everything that @VerveClique said.
Why arent you approaching this as an issue to which you and your employer mutually have to find a solution? Why did you go to your union with a ‘they can’t do this to me can they’ question rather than ask them to help negotiate a better arrangement?

The posts suggesting you don’t give a fig about your clients are a tad harsh but possibly fair because you don’t seem to be seeing things from all sides, just your own.

This is what unions are for

DataNotLore · 04/06/2023 20:18

Xiaoxiong · 04/06/2023 19:01

I am actually going to differ from many of the other posters to say that if you had an implied change to your contract that was relied upon by you and your employers over many years (ie. That you only went to service users in the town centre where you didn't have to drive) this may actually have changed that contrary clause in your contract by use and custom.

If all your colleagues knew about this practice, it was applied equally (ie, they weren't made to do the town centres because they knew you did it, you weren't made to do out of town because they did it etc) there is a chance that the clause in your contracts requiring you to cover a wider area out of town and them to cover the inner city areas doesn't apply any longer thanks to the many years of different practice and custom.

If you and potentially your colleagues wanted to fight it you could talk to an employment lawyer or to your union rep about it.

This is possibly right.

Speak to your union and get proper advice.

It does sound like you're being "managed out" aka being bullied into constructive dismissal.

Lots of people spouting pseudo outraged nonsense on this thread.

Orbitsound · 04/06/2023 20:18

I half wondered if this was my colleague!

She argues she's pulling her weight whilst being completely inflexible too and had a tantrum then went off long term sick.

She essentially cherry picked clients in a certain geographical area, the rest of us are expected to do that area as well as all of the others.

usererror99 · 04/06/2023 20:18

I don't get why you are signing yourself off sick though? If you don't like the terms of your job then leave rather than put pressure on your boss and colleagues not to mention the cost to the company to cover your work just because you don't like where they are sending you?

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 04/06/2023 20:18

Tbh I think a job which involves travel to clients should have stipulated a car driver on the job description. Using public transport must eat into a lot of your work time and be costly.

If it were me I would keep going with driving lessons even if it took the rest of my life 🤷‍♀️

DataNotLore · 04/06/2023 20:19

Fossie · 04/06/2023 20:08

It surely makes no sense to send people all over the place from a logistical point of view. What a waste of extra travel time. Do others now have to do city centre visits? They can’t be happy. Surely a sensible manager wants to get the best from their team? I hope he/she can justify losing you when there are staff shortages.

Good point.

Babyroobs · 04/06/2023 20:20

Orbitsound · 04/06/2023 20:18

I half wondered if this was my colleague!

She argues she's pulling her weight whilst being completely inflexible too and had a tantrum then went off long term sick.

She essentially cherry picked clients in a certain geographical area, the rest of us are expected to do that area as well as all of the others.

Exactly the same in my workplace ! I decided I'd had enough recently and have found a new role !

cartalena · 04/06/2023 20:20

I work in a SW team exact same demographic only we work 3c model so pick up our own cases without being allocated them.

Nine times out of ten we pick them based on geographical unless it's urgent. Suits us all to work the area nearer to us.

I'd be fine with you being a non driver on out team as we could work with that as we work as a team!

I think they're treating you appallingly.

DataNotLore · 04/06/2023 20:21

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 04/06/2023 20:18

Tbh I think a job which involves travel to clients should have stipulated a car driver on the job description. Using public transport must eat into a lot of your work time and be costly.

If it were me I would keep going with driving lessons even if it took the rest of my life 🤷‍♀️

What would be the point in that?

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/06/2023 20:23

How can places not be covered by taxis? Taxis will surely go anywhere?
I would do what she has told you and ask a colleague for lifts to these visits, and CC her into the emails when you ask them. You can even ask her! Then document how it isn't working to get you there or you colleagues can ask for less caseloads on account of you driving them.
You can also get an occupational health assessment if your pregnancy makes cycling unsafe etc

Throwncrumbs · 04/06/2023 20:24

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 18:50

Yes my work pay full pay for maternity related sickness

How is you not being able to travel to clients ‘maternity related sick pay’ ?

Orbitsound · 04/06/2023 20:25

Fossie · 04/06/2023 20:08

It surely makes no sense to send people all over the place from a logistical point of view. What a waste of extra travel time. Do others now have to do city centre visits? They can’t be happy. Surely a sensible manager wants to get the best from their team? I hope he/she can justify losing you when there are staff shortages.

But people have caseloads so sometimes the person with capacity to take a new case isn't the closest. It's client based work so their need trumps whether or not a new client is close to my house or not.

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 20:28

cartalena · 04/06/2023 20:20

I work in a SW team exact same demographic only we work 3c model so pick up our own cases without being allocated them.

Nine times out of ten we pick them based on geographical unless it's urgent. Suits us all to work the area nearer to us.

I'd be fine with you being a non driver on out team as we could work with that as we work as a team!

I think they're treating you appallingly.

Thank you.
literally all my colleagues have been nothing but amazing and are appalled. All have individually contacted me to say they had no issue with me and all want me to stay in the job.
Infact they were happy as I was doing the cases car drivers hated.

OP posts:
steff13 · 04/06/2023 20:28

everythingisgoingup · 04/06/2023 19:46

Surely this is discrimination under the Equality Act 2010 on the grounds of Maternity/pregnancy?

Is it worth going to CAB for legal advice?

If her contract says she has to be able to travel anywhere within her county and that's what they're asking her to do then how is that discrimination?

Throwncrumbs · 04/06/2023 20:29

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:39

Yes. The GP was horrified! Couldn’t believe it. I’ve been a social worker for his clients and he thought they were mad!

You and your GP are way out of line discussing clients/patients of his… absolutely not on!

MichelleScarn · 04/06/2023 20:32

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/06/2023 20:23

How can places not be covered by taxis? Taxis will surely go anywhere?
I would do what she has told you and ask a colleague for lifts to these visits, and CC her into the emails when you ask them. You can even ask her! Then document how it isn't working to get you there or you colleagues can ask for less caseloads on account of you driving them.
You can also get an occupational health assessment if your pregnancy makes cycling unsafe etc

Are you suggesting getting the colleagues into trouble for not agreeing to be the OPs taxi service?!

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 20:35

DataNotLore · 04/06/2023 20:19

Good point.

Yes. Which is why I know the ONLY reason is to manage me out and force me to resign by making the job impossible.
it makes no managerial or logical sense.

OP posts:
Throwncrumbs · 04/06/2023 20:36

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:08

I’m not the only person on the team with adjustments.
some actively prefer not to drive in the town centre, some have specifically requested the rural areas as they live near, some need to be back for childcare so need to have visits that get them back for 5pm etc.

Jesus, now it’s other peoples child care….does any one want to actually see clients/ do the work they are paid for in your office. You are not paid to pick and choose which jobs you want to do whether it’s in the town centre or not, and definitely so that you can be on time to pick kids up if you finish at 5 it’s 5 not before so you can pick up kids. No wonder the new manager has made changes, he’s probably cottoned in to the piss taking that’s going on!

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 20:36

Throwncrumbs · 04/06/2023 20:29

You and your GP are way out of line discussing clients/patients of his… absolutely not on!

We were discussing them at all. He’s just aware I’m their social worker. 😂

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 04/06/2023 20:39

Throwncrumbs · 04/06/2023 20:36

Jesus, now it’s other peoples child care….does any one want to actually see clients/ do the work they are paid for in your office. You are not paid to pick and choose which jobs you want to do whether it’s in the town centre or not, and definitely so that you can be on time to pick kids up if you finish at 5 it’s 5 not before so you can pick up kids. No wonder the new manager has made changes, he’s probably cottoned in to the piss taking that’s going on!

Maybe they have to allow some flexibility to keep staff though. Especially when these professions are not hugely well paid.

keeponandonandon · 04/06/2023 20:48

chimchimina · 04/06/2023 18:48

Im a social work manager in adults and agree with a previous poster; you really need to be able to drive. Im surprised you don't need to do any urgent or duty work too.

And it doesn't sound like you need to be " off sick with stress" tbh. It takes the piss out of all those people who are really burned out or have mental health issues.

I agree, also OPs colleagues having to pick up the slack.

It is an absolute given that you need to drive as a social worker unless you are in London. I had a worker who didn't have a car, it took 3 hours for them to do a 30 minute journey - not really good enough Use of social work time.

DontSetYourselfOnFireToKeepOthersWarm · 04/06/2023 20:49

Throwncrumbs · 04/06/2023 20:36

Jesus, now it’s other peoples child care….does any one want to actually see clients/ do the work they are paid for in your office. You are not paid to pick and choose which jobs you want to do whether it’s in the town centre or not, and definitely so that you can be on time to pick kids up if you finish at 5 it’s 5 not before so you can pick up kids. No wonder the new manager has made changes, he’s probably cottoned in to the piss taking that’s going on!

Why can’t employees just shut up and do what they’re told rather than trying to strike some mutually beneficial agreement that has a positive impact on their work/life balance.After all we have people queuing up to do these kind of jobs………

namechanger563 · 04/06/2023 21:02

I personally would contact ACAS and your union again and claim Custom and Practice applies and the allocation of your work is now an implied term within your contract.

Work has been allocated in this way by successive managers without any performance issues or negative impact to the team. It is reasonable to assume this is now an implied term due to custom and practice.

From ACAS:

Custom and practice
'Custom and practice' terms are often left unwritten. This type of term could become part of the employment contract when it's:
• 'notorious' – this means the term is generally well-known in the business or industry, usually over a long period of time
• reasonable
• certain
If an employer wants to prevent something becoming an implied term, they should put it in writing. This will make it an express term and help to avoid misunderstandings.
Example of a term which might be considered implied through custom and practice
An employee might expect a bonus of £100 at the end of the year if their employer has paid that annually for the last 10 years, to everyone in their team.
To prevent misunderstandings, the employer could state in the contract that getting an end of year bonus:
• depends on the business's profits in the latest financial year
• is paid at the employer's discretion

Swipe left for the next trending thread