Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have gone off sick as manager made the job impossible

130 replies

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 18:30

I am a social worker with older people. I live in a fairly large town and the team cover a large area with substantial rural areas. However the vast majority of our clients live in the town centre.

I do not drive. This is not due to a disability. I’ve tried everything (PLEASE don’t offer me driving advice 😂) and have made peace with the fact driving isn’t for me. I hated every minute of driving lessons and never got anywhere despite trying many things. I am very happy being a non-driver and don’t feel the need to try to learn now.
I was honest about this in my interview over 12 years ago. Lovely manager had no issue with this as most clients are in the town centre and the town centre has excellent transport links.
I have happily worked in this job for 12 years now. I get given cases based in the town centre and go via walk or electric bike. If it’s raining I will take the bus.
Crucial I think is that clients in rural areas are given to the social workers who live in those areas just for convenience and practicality really. So NO ONE is having to travel longer on account of me. Infact most social workers say they hate the town centre work as they need to find parking and get stuck in traffic so are happy I cover this area.

The original manager left and two years ago a new one came along who seemed nice enough. I informed my manager I was pregnant three months ago. Since then (it may not be related but it’s a coincidence if not) my cases have been getting further and further from the town centre.
I have had an few allocations I can’t get to at all as they are not accessible by public transport and actually dangerous to travel there on a bike or bus (no phone signal and no pavement).
the others would just take me so long it would mean I’d not be able to do my job effectively.
When I queried this I was told to get another worker to give me a lift. It would not be fair to ask them to be my chauffeur.

I have spoken to my union and as the town centre allocations was an informal arrangement with my previous manager and not an official term of my contract (darn should have got that in writing). I basically have no powers to do anything.
I don’t need to visit places that are dangerous without a car but they can make me go somewhere that’s accessible even if it would take all day. If they want to be twats.
My work contract says I need to be able to travel anywhere within the county. It doesn’t say car essential but essentially I’d need to be able to get to any client.
We don’t have duty or emergency work in my role.

Realising I physically can’t do my job anymore I got signed off sick for stress until the start of my maternity leave.

I am lucky I am highly employable so can find social worker jobs easily. There are hospitals where a car is not needed. I will use the end of my maternity to get one of these jobs. I will return to my old job for 3 months to keep my pay.
It’s a shame as I loved working there and I worked there very successfully for 12 years. I had a total of 3 DAYS sick days in 13 years and was a good worker.
I recently got married and I think they think I will be off on repeated maternity leave so best get me out now.
Everyone of my colleagues is appalled and so upset. Their support has been amazing.

So AIBU to have gone off sick? Probably am aren’t I? But I don’t think I had much choice.

OP posts:
VerveClique · 04/06/2023 18:57

You need to make a flexible working request and specifically request Town centre allocations.

This will clear things up one way or another for both you and your employer.

Please don't tie this to your pregnancy.

chimchimina · 04/06/2023 18:57

But why should they tell you in a formal meeting, if it wasn't under a policy such as flexible working? It was an informal agreement...

chimchimina · 04/06/2023 18:58

As the PP states you need to make a flexible working request.

Trees6 · 04/06/2023 18:59

I can see both sides tbh. It’s annoying when people go on the sick as a reaction to change. But….. I will say that the new more rural cases arriving shortly after your pregnancy announcement looks mightily suspicious.

Looking for a new role next year is a sensible idea. Draw a line under this one.

Good luck with the birth.

Rainn21 · 04/06/2023 18:59

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 18:42

Nonesense. 17 years of successful working in the job might suggest otherwise. I’ve been a social worker 17 years and worked as a hospital and school social worker prior to this and 12 happy years in this role.

Many jobs don’t require any travel at all. Even in community roles in a large city you can easily get by in adult service via public transport.

😊

But you’re now off sick with stress because you can’t physically reach some of your caseload without a car. So it may not have been a given up until this point but now it is.

JustGeorgie · 04/06/2023 18:59

Bluebells1970 · 04/06/2023 18:46

What about your clients, OP?

Who is looking after them while you're throwing a hissy...

Don't think she's bothered tbh!

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:00

Trees6 · 04/06/2023 18:59

I can see both sides tbh. It’s annoying when people go on the sick as a reaction to change. But….. I will say that the new more rural cases arriving shortly after your pregnancy announcement looks mightily suspicious.

Looking for a new role next year is a sensible idea. Draw a line under this one.

Good luck with the birth.

First rural case literally came a day after informing them. First in 12 years.

OP posts:
PositiveParasite · 04/06/2023 19:00

Could you have grounds for a constructive dismissal claim? Your previous years of successful responsibility for the town centre cases seems like good enough evidence, what else could a tribunal infer from this sudden change?

It reads as if you are being deliberately forced out. I’m not surprised you are signed off with stress related issues.

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:00

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:00

First rural case literally came a day after informing them. First in 12 years.

I’m not even asking for opinions on whether this change is due to pregnancy as I already know. It’s obvious.

OP posts:
Xiaoxiong · 04/06/2023 19:01

I am actually going to differ from many of the other posters to say that if you had an implied change to your contract that was relied upon by you and your employers over many years (ie. That you only went to service users in the town centre where you didn't have to drive) this may actually have changed that contrary clause in your contract by use and custom.

If all your colleagues knew about this practice, it was applied equally (ie, they weren't made to do the town centres because they knew you did it, you weren't made to do out of town because they did it etc) there is a chance that the clause in your contracts requiring you to cover a wider area out of town and them to cover the inner city areas doesn't apply any longer thanks to the many years of different practice and custom.

If you and potentially your colleagues wanted to fight it you could talk to an employment lawyer or to your union rep about it.

Theskyoutsideisblue · 04/06/2023 19:03

You are being managed out.v unfair. But driving is a life skill.

WateryDoom · 04/06/2023 19:05

I live in a fairly large town and the team cover a large area with substantial rural areas.

Given this, I think it's obvious that you need to be able to get to clients. If your team covers substantial rural areas then you weren't really suitable for the job in the first place if you were going to pick and choose your clients.

chimchimina · 04/06/2023 19:05

I don't think she's being "managed out." If it's anything like the social work teams I oversee, there's a massive recruitment crisis in social work, plus an unprecedented demand since covid. Most social work teams have waiting lists plus staff vacancies. All team members need to pull their weight.

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:08

WateryDoom · 04/06/2023 19:05

I live in a fairly large town and the team cover a large area with substantial rural areas.

Given this, I think it's obvious that you need to be able to get to clients. If your team covers substantial rural areas then you weren't really suitable for the job in the first place if you were going to pick and choose your clients.

I’m not the only person on the team with adjustments.
some actively prefer not to drive in the town centre, some have specifically requested the rural areas as they live near, some need to be back for childcare so need to have visits that get them back for 5pm etc.

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 04/06/2023 19:09

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:00

I’m not even asking for opinions on whether this change is due to pregnancy as I already know. It’s obvious.

I don't think you're being unreasonable.

I had a somewhat similar situation, though not pregnancy related. But a new manager who made big & detrimental changes to our working conditions with no consultation or discussion whatsoever. They may think they can just do that but the end result was a lot of the team resigning within a short period, or going off sick with stress.
Sometimes when it feels impossible to be heard, people vote with their feet. And you had the added stress of being pregnant so I think it's fair enough that you put your own/baby's health first. You're working in a caring profession and have the right to expect that your employer will show some empathy & concern for your wellbeing.

Babyroobs · 04/06/2023 19:09

You've had an informal agreement for years and have been very lucky to have this. Sorry but I think YABU to go off sick because you can't meet the terms of your contract. You need to look for another job. I have to regularly visit older people in their homes as part of my job. Others in my team refuse to go miles out into the county, one doesn't drive etc so I get dumped with the lot city and county. How are you going to manage returning to work nd needing to drop a baby off at nursery etc on public transport or is that not going to be an issue?

Babyroobs · 04/06/2023 19:11

WateryDoom · 04/06/2023 19:05

I live in a fairly large town and the team cover a large area with substantial rural areas.

Given this, I think it's obvious that you need to be able to get to clients. If your team covers substantial rural areas then you weren't really suitable for the job in the first place if you were going to pick and choose your clients.

Exactly this. Surely there will be times when a county colleague is off sick and their cases need to be covered at short notice yet you wouldn't be able to do that.

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:13

chimchimina · 04/06/2023 19:05

I don't think she's being "managed out." If it's anything like the social work teams I oversee, there's a massive recruitment crisis in social work, plus an unprecedented demand since covid. Most social work teams have waiting lists plus staff vacancies. All team members need to pull their weight.

I can pull your weight on the town centre. I’m far less effective outside of it.
you’re right about the recruitment crisis though. Might be why it would have been a good idea not to force a perfectly good, long-standing social worker out of the job.
I will find it far easier to get another job than they will to recruit someone else.
They just want me gone 😂
I realise this and won’t fight leaving as I don’t want to be where I’m not wanted.
I’ve never had any issues about my practice raised, won awards for my practice in fact. Had the lowest sick leave of everyone.
Their loss. Someone else will appreciate me. 😊

OP posts:
GoodChat · 04/06/2023 19:13

First rural case literally came a day after informing them. First in 12 years.

You could probably fight this on the grounds of maternity discrimination rather than change in terms.

It might be worth calling Pregnant Then Screwed tomorrow.

GoodChat · 04/06/2023 19:14

Also, they should have done a risk assessment and established its not safe for you to be walking down roads with no footpaths when pregnant

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 04/06/2023 19:14

I’m completely with your new manager on this. I don’t think your previously manager effectively managed the team and you’ve all got away with things on your terms rather than what is really right for your service users. You’ve been very lucky and I think you’re completely taking the piss now to have been signed off sick, basically you’re just stroppy you’re no longer getting your own way and trying anyway to make this out to be discrimination / their fault and not being self aware quite how fortunate you’ve had it. I’m sure no other social work team in your county works that way.

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:15

Babyroobs · 04/06/2023 19:11

Exactly this. Surely there will be times when a county colleague is off sick and their cases need to be covered at short notice yet you wouldn't be able to do that.

This actually never happened as we don’t do duty or emergency work. We have another team for that. If the colleague would be off sick the case would be completely reallocated or kept on hold until they’re back (managers decision what was needed).

OP posts:
Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:18

GoodChat · 04/06/2023 19:14

Also, they should have done a risk assessment and established its not safe for you to be walking down roads with no footpaths when pregnant

yup. That’s another issue.

OP posts:
wankerseverywhere · 04/06/2023 19:20

What a piss-take. I cannot quite believe that we have a system that allows it. If you had an ounce of integrity you'd have resigned and then got yourself another job where your lack of driving wasn't an issue. What with how highly employable you are and seeing as there are so many SW jobs completely doable on public transport.

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:20

Rayannn · 04/06/2023 19:18

yup. That’s another issue.

My Union did say this was unacceptable of them

OP posts: