Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask about Jehovah's Witnesses?

375 replies

cecilyyb · 02/02/2023 22:40

There's a Kingdom Hall right at the end of my street. Always extremely busy a couple of nights a week and open everyday I've gone past.

I'm intrigued at what happens in there. It gives off cult vibes but I could be wrong.

Does anybody know what happens during these meetings? Can non JW attend or is that usually not accepted?

I did use to work with a JW but she never spoke much about her religion, all I really knew was that she didn't partake in celebrations.

Interested to hear experiences on here Smile

OP posts:
fireflown · 03/02/2023 09:50

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:48

JW’s do not ‘let’ their children die for religious beliefs - as explained upthread.

If a child needs a transfusion and their parents don't let them have one, how is that not letting them die?

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:55

fireflown · 03/02/2023 09:12

I think in an age when we are being asked to be tolerant of all kinds of things, being tolerant of someone’s beliefs should be fundamental

Why should anyone be tolerant of someone who refuses to let their child have life-saving medical treatment?

They don’t - children are minors and can’t give consent, and the hospital will take it out of their hands and get a court order for treatment. JW parents know this, and they also know that they and their children will be forgiven for receiving a blood transfusion that they did not consent to. Consent is the key.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:56

fireflown · 03/02/2023 09:50

If a child needs a transfusion and their parents don't let them have one, how is that not letting them die?

Already answered this.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:59

niceduvet · 03/02/2023 09:10

... or sect. Whatever, I'd steer very clear of the JW church. The shunning of family members for leaving the faith is particularly cruel. True Christians would never do this.

Born again Christians do something similar - a lot of pressure brought to bear on those leaving the faith.

fireflown · 03/02/2023 10:02

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:55

They don’t - children are minors and can’t give consent, and the hospital will take it out of their hands and get a court order for treatment. JW parents know this, and they also know that they and their children will be forgiven for receiving a blood transfusion that they did not consent to. Consent is the key.

Getting a court order takes time, by which point it may be too late.

purpleme12 · 03/02/2023 10:06

For someone saying they're not defending the belief of shunning, they sure sound like they're defending it

TooTiredToWork · 03/02/2023 10:15

news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/shropshire/7337333.stm

Imagine being the staff looking after this mother. She died shortly after birth after refusing a blood transfusion. I can’t imagine the stress of being in the position of knowing what needs to be done, and can quite easily be done, yet being prevented from doing it

A terrible tragedy for the woman, her family and the staff involved

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 10:15

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:03

You have to understand their beliefs. It’s not cruel - they believe that leaving the church means you are turning your back on God and won't achieve the Kingdom of Heaven, and it’s met with sadness. They are shunned, as followers of other religions are shunned for leaving the faith - it’s not peculiar to JW’s

Which other religions shun members? I can’t think of any?

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 10:19

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:48

JW’s do not ‘let’ their children die for religious beliefs - as explained upthread.

If the state didn’t step in and override them, JW children would absolutely die for need of a blood transfusion if no alternative treatment was available. Why else would the matter need to continually go to court?

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 10:22

Nat6999 · 03/02/2023 04:31

Some of my mum's neighbours are Jehovas Witnesses, they often have gatherings at their house before going on the knock, we are all black balled after my mum lost her temper when they tried knocking at her door for the third time in a week. If you don't want them to call again, tell them you are a Catholic, that is what I did when they knocked at mine, they couldn't get away fast enough & have never been back again.

JWs don’t believe Christ died on the cross, but a simple stake and they consider the cross to be a manufactured religious symbol. They also believe in one God, not the holy trinity as in traditional Christianity. If I understand correctly - and don’t quote me because I’m not sure - they believe God created Jesus, who is actually the Archangel Michael. They don’t believe Christ died for the sins of man, or that he was resurrected - they believe we pay for our own sins when we die. Pretty much goes against everything Catholicism and traditional Christianity in general teaches. Catholics can easily dismiss JW’s because they can trace their teachings to the apostles - JW translators were not fluent in Hebrew or Greek and the Catholic faith believes their translations are misguided self-serving. Not surprising then, that faced with the words ‘no thank you I have my priest’ they won’t hang about !!

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 10:23

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:59

Born again Christians do something similar - a lot of pressure brought to bear on those leaving the faith.

Now I know a LOT of born again Christians- not out of choice. I am also not a fan of theirs, but none of them practises organised, congregation wide shunning like the JWs. If so half my family wouldn’t speak to me, (now that would be a blessing). You seem very keen to sweep away the more unsavoury parts of JWs.

badgergirly · 03/02/2023 10:27

If you want to get rid of them all you have to say is " sorry, can't stop and chat, I'm just off to give blood "

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 10:28

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 10:19

If the state didn’t step in and override them, JW children would absolutely die for need of a blood transfusion if no alternative treatment was available. Why else would the matter need to continually go to court?

You are missing the point. The state does step in and override them - it’s the law. Children have to be protected because they are minors and can’t give consent themselves. The parents know this, know that their children will get the treatment they need, and know that they will be forgiven because they didn’t give consent - the hospital took consent out of their hands.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 10:29

badgergirly · 03/02/2023 10:27

If you want to get rid of them all you have to say is " sorry, can't stop and chat, I'm just off to give blood "

Nope. JW’s are allowed to donate blood if they want to - they just can’t receive donated blood, or even store their own for transfusion.

badgergirly · 03/02/2023 10:30

@Rosscameasdoody it works for me, I use that line everytime and they disappear very quickly.

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 10:31

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 10:28

You are missing the point. The state does step in and override them - it’s the law. Children have to be protected because they are minors and can’t give consent themselves. The parents know this, know that their children will get the treatment they need, and know that they will be forgiven because they didn’t give consent - the hospital took consent out of their hands.

No you are missing the point. JW would let their children die, the state just won’t allow it. A religion does not get a get out of jail free card on an abhorrent part of their beliefs because the state steps in to stop the worse from happening. It doesn’t absolve JW of guilt by then shifting responsibility to the state. It also prolongs a child’s suffering whilst the hospital has to spend time and money faffing about with a court order.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 10:36

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 10:23

Now I know a LOT of born again Christians- not out of choice. I am also not a fan of theirs, but none of them practises organised, congregation wide shunning like the JWs. If so half my family wouldn’t speak to me, (now that would be a blessing). You seem very keen to sweep away the more unsavoury parts of JWs.

No, not at all, Not a JW, and not a fan of them or their practices. Just trying to bring a bit of perspective. Discussed many aspects of it with a JW family member and we disagree a lot but there are nuances that are missed. And I have had a particularly unpleasant experience with born again Christians trying to extricate a friend from their clutches, and you’re right, it’s not organised shunning in the sense that JW’s or the Amish practice it, because they’re not such a closed community. But they do bring pressure to bear, and it’s very difficult to deal with.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 03/02/2023 10:36

I think as a religion they likely rely on the fact that parents never actually get to make that choice.

because I’d bet there are a good number that would ultimately change their mind and agree if they didn’t have that knowledge that ultimately the state will step in.

That ultimate is never really challenged, which given falling numbers is a good thing for the religious big wigs

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 10:38

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 10:31

No you are missing the point. JW would let their children die, the state just won’t allow it. A religion does not get a get out of jail free card on an abhorrent part of their beliefs because the state steps in to stop the worse from happening. It doesn’t absolve JW of guilt by then shifting responsibility to the state. It also prolongs a child’s suffering whilst the hospital has to spend time and money faffing about with a court order.

Consent is the key. We’ll have to agree to disagree on this one.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 10:39

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 03/02/2023 10:36

I think as a religion they likely rely on the fact that parents never actually get to make that choice.

because I’d bet there are a good number that would ultimately change their mind and agree if they didn’t have that knowledge that ultimately the state will step in.

That ultimate is never really challenged, which given falling numbers is a good thing for the religious big wigs

Yes, this. You said it better than me, thank you.

Msmumm · 03/02/2023 10:41

I know a lady who left the religion. When she lost her baby at 28 weeks she was contacted by one of the elders to tell her that it was her own fault and had she not left her baby would probably still be alive.
Absolutely delightful religion.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 10:43

Msmumm · 03/02/2023 10:41

I know a lady who left the religion. When she lost her baby at 28 weeks she was contacted by one of the elders to tell her that it was her own fault and had she not left her baby would probably still be alive.
Absolutely delightful religion.

Hypocritical too. If she left the religion she would have been shunned - means no contact. At all.

clarabellabunting · 03/02/2023 10:45

Only those who were baptised are shunned, which is why my DH is glad he was never baptised, or else he'd have close family members who would not now be allowed to speak to him.

clarabellabunting · 03/02/2023 10:45

Shunned for leaving, I should say.

Abhannmor · 03/02/2023 10:59

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 10:22

JWs don’t believe Christ died on the cross, but a simple stake and they consider the cross to be a manufactured religious symbol. They also believe in one God, not the holy trinity as in traditional Christianity. If I understand correctly - and don’t quote me because I’m not sure - they believe God created Jesus, who is actually the Archangel Michael. They don’t believe Christ died for the sins of man, or that he was resurrected - they believe we pay for our own sins when we die. Pretty much goes against everything Catholicism and traditional Christianity in general teaches. Catholics can easily dismiss JW’s because they can trace their teachings to the apostles - JW translators were not fluent in Hebrew or Greek and the Catholic faith believes their translations are misguided self-serving. Not surprising then, that faced with the words ‘no thank you I have my priest’ they won’t hang about !!

Another important JW belief is that in death we are asleep. There's no past life review or meeting deceased loved ones. Just a dreamless sleep til the Day of Judgement. Based on a line in the Book of Ecclesiastes.

The JWs who call on me are lovely people. I live in a small town ( pop 1600) in County Cork. One day a JW lady from Devon came calling. She told me she lives in an even more remote place about 10 miles away up in the mountains.

'You have relations there I suppose ' I asked.
'No ' she seemed surprised at this.

'What on earth brought you there?"
' The church sent us'

That is some power! I quite liked getting the handwritten letters in Covid lockdown tbh. Nobody writes to me anymore 😭