Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask about Jehovah's Witnesses?

375 replies

cecilyyb · 02/02/2023 22:40

There's a Kingdom Hall right at the end of my street. Always extremely busy a couple of nights a week and open everyday I've gone past.

I'm intrigued at what happens in there. It gives off cult vibes but I could be wrong.

Does anybody know what happens during these meetings? Can non JW attend or is that usually not accepted?

I did use to work with a JW but she never spoke much about her religion, all I really knew was that she didn't partake in celebrations.

Interested to hear experiences on here Smile

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 08:49

Prescottdanni123 · 03/02/2023 07:53

Its a cult. They don't sit in a candle lit circle chanting while a figure in robes speaks in Latin and sacrifices animals but it is still a cult.

Parents would prefer to let their kids die of blood loss than give them a transfusion. Thankfully, hospitals have permission to overrule them in these cases.

It’s a sect, not a cult. And it’s absolutely not true that parents ‘prefer’ to let children die of blood loss. Somewhere upthread I’ve described why they don’t allow blood transfusions, and why they are answerable to God if they do. And hospitals do not have permission to overrule parents, or any other JW’s wishes, without an independent court order, unless in an emergency. Consent is the issue, and there are exceptions. Children are minors and unable to make decisions for themselves, so in practice the parents and the child would be forgiven, as the transfusion was given without consent. There is also ‘forgiveness’ for want of a better word for other members who receive a transfusion without consent in other circumstances, such as an emergency where they are unable to communicate their wishes or are deemed as not having capacity to do so and are overruled.

I should point out that I am not a JW, but have a family member who is, and they don’t push their beliefs on anyone else, but will engage if asked. I think in an age when we are being asked to be tolerant of all kinds of things, being tolerant of someone’s beliefs should be fundamental. JW’s are not well understood by those who have little contact with them, and some of the comments in this thread bear that out.

Wdib78 · 03/02/2023 08:54

My mother grew up in a JW household, forced to go door knocking with her sister every week, she hated it, was done with it all as soon as she married my dad.
Her older brother revealed to her some years ago that his father is their grandfather because he had been raping their mother till she was into her 30s, got her pregnant then applied to the marriage bureau to get her married off,forced her to marry a,man that beat her regularly, the Kingdom Hall knew about this and said "you'll get your reward in heaven".
Definitely a cult, stay the fuck away.

Eranzer · 03/02/2023 08:56

@Rosscameasdoody I've had much contact with them. They are not 'misunderstood'. My mum was disfellowshipped because she was sexually abused in her teens, my dad was also as a late teen and then my lovely grandma (dads mum) was shunned completely because they found out she'd still been in contact with and looking after her teenage!! son.
There IS misinformation on this thread, none of it has a better reality though.

You couldn't pay me to be tolerant of JW.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:03

Ultraninja · 03/02/2023 08:22

My friend has just "woken up" and left the JW. She's now shunned by all of the people she knew through the church, and the majority of her JW family. Lovely people until they are faced with something like someone losing their faith, then very, very cruel.

You have to understand their beliefs. It’s not cruel - they believe that leaving the church means you are turning your back on God and won't achieve the Kingdom of Heaven, and it’s met with sadness. They are shunned, as followers of other religions are shunned for leaving the faith - it’s not peculiar to JW’s

niceduvet · 03/02/2023 09:05

If you're interested in Christianity, I'd go to a lively mainstream bible-based Christian church eg Baptist, Methodist, Anglican etc. I'd try a few and see where you feel most comfortable. I'd steer clear of the JWs as you're likely to be literally knocking on doors for the rest of your life and they are a (large) cult in essence.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:06

Eranzer · 03/02/2023 08:56

@Rosscameasdoody I've had much contact with them. They are not 'misunderstood'. My mum was disfellowshipped because she was sexually abused in her teens, my dad was also as a late teen and then my lovely grandma (dads mum) was shunned completely because they found out she'd still been in contact with and looking after her teenage!! son.
There IS misinformation on this thread, none of it has a better reality though.

You couldn't pay me to be tolerant of JW.

Not getting into arguments because this thread has the potential to turn ugly. Only posting from my own experience, and obviously you have yours.

Myhydrangeachangedcolour · 03/02/2023 09:09

This sounds a bit odd but does anyone know if it’s correct that JWs can’t eat duck?!

My best friend was raised JW but left, moved country and forced herself to forget most of the teachings. Suddenly the other day (eating a Chinese) said she had never been allowed duck as a child because they don’t eat it… she was racking her brain but couldn’t remember why?!

They were allowed meat generally so not a vegetarian thing, specifically a duck issue.

We can’t find anything on line about it and she doesn’t speak to her JW family so can’t ask them.

niceduvet · 03/02/2023 09:10

... or sect. Whatever, I'd steer very clear of the JW church. The shunning of family members for leaving the faith is particularly cruel. True Christians would never do this.

fireflown · 03/02/2023 09:12

I think in an age when we are being asked to be tolerant of all kinds of things, being tolerant of someone’s beliefs should be fundamental

Why should anyone be tolerant of someone who refuses to let their child have life-saving medical treatment?

fireflown · 03/02/2023 09:12

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:03

You have to understand their beliefs. It’s not cruel - they believe that leaving the church means you are turning your back on God and won't achieve the Kingdom of Heaven, and it’s met with sadness. They are shunned, as followers of other religions are shunned for leaving the faith - it’s not peculiar to JW’s

Shunning your own family is absolutely cruel. That other faiths might do it doesn't make it not cruel.

lifeinthehills · 03/02/2023 09:13

Myhydrangeachangedcolour · 03/02/2023 09:09

This sounds a bit odd but does anyone know if it’s correct that JWs can’t eat duck?!

My best friend was raised JW but left, moved country and forced herself to forget most of the teachings. Suddenly the other day (eating a Chinese) said she had never been allowed duck as a child because they don’t eat it… she was racking her brain but couldn’t remember why?!

They were allowed meat generally so not a vegetarian thing, specifically a duck issue.

We can’t find anything on line about it and she doesn’t speak to her JW family so can’t ask them.

JWs can eat duck.

purpleleotard2 · 03/02/2023 09:15

I just feel sorry for any person who 'Believes' in a religion / cult.

They are all being duped in some way. Rational thought cannot shift their 'belief' as the fairy stories they are told are more important to them.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 03/02/2023 09:20

All I know is that they’re a bloody nuisance, coming to the door after they’ve repeatedly been asked - politely - not to. And once, at my DPs house, after nobody answered the door (we were all in the garden) they had the nerve to come uninvited round into the garden - ‘Oh, we heard the children, so we thought…’
My DF gave them very short shrift, I can tell you.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:30

There is something in the Jewish faith called Pikuach Nefesh - literally means watching over a soul. The Talmud allows for the commandments to be broken to save a life. It interprets the commandments - although laws given by God - as something to live by, not to die by, because only God can give life and take it away. The Jewish faith also dictates that blood not be ingested as it contains life given by God - hence the draining of blood from animals before they are used as meat, etc. The difference is that where there is genuine risk to life, it can be disregarded along with other commandments to preserve that life. So where someone needs life saving surgery they would have it, where they are starving they would be allowed to eat non Kosher foods, a doctor would be allowed to break the Sabbath to save a life - that kind of thing. Interesting how the same biblical passages can be interpreted differently.

HoodieBell · 03/02/2023 09:31

@Rosscameasdoody Shunning is cruel and it is a trademark of a cult. www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/06/the-seven-signs-youre-in-a-cult/361400/

TooTiredToWork · 03/02/2023 09:31

Sarahcoggles · 03/02/2023 08:36

Tell me about the blood recycling

There are a few techniques we used to reduce blood usage. We try to minimise use of donated blood because it is a scarce resource and there are (rare) risks

One is pre-donation. You give a unit of your blood pre op. It is stored and given back to you at the time of surgery. In the meantime your body should have made more red cells to replace your donation.

The more common is cell-salvage. Here we suction the blood lost at surgery, wash and spin it and give the red cells back to you at the same time. I use it quite a lot in maternity for caesarean sections. It is not suitable in all surgeries or patients. Both of these are acceptable to some but not all JWs

For planned surgery we will try and make sure any anaemia is correct by giving iron pre-op, as an iv infusion if needed.

Non of these techniques however eliminate the need for blood transfusion. There are other components of blood other than red cells such as clotting factors or platelets we may need to transfuse. It is disingenuous of the Watchtower Society to suggest that modern techniques mean blood transfusions are rarely needed any more

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:32

purpleleotard2 · 03/02/2023 09:15

I just feel sorry for any person who 'Believes' in a religion / cult.

They are all being duped in some way. Rational thought cannot shift their 'belief' as the fairy stories they are told are more important to them.

They would probably argue that you are the one in need of sympathy because you regard faith as a fairy story !!

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:33

HoodieBell · 03/02/2023 09:31

@Rosscameasdoody Shunning is cruel and it is a trademark of a cult. www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/06/the-seven-signs-youre-in-a-cult/361400/

So you’d regard Amish communities as a cult ?

HoodieBell · 03/02/2023 09:35

@Rosscameasdoody Yes. The Amish are an obvious cult. Well, more a collection of cults.

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 09:38

@MinceandMash - Christian Scientists (the religious group not scientists who are Christian) shun modern medicine and followers and children have died because of it. Not saying that justifies the JWs! But another religion to add to your list of people who let children die for religious beliefs.

Rubyupbeat · 03/02/2023 09:39

@otherwayup
Jehovahs witnesses are definitely not holocaust deniers. They were in the camps alongside Jews, gypsies and certain other religions.

Blossomtoes · 03/02/2023 09:44

Blueuggboots · 03/02/2023 07:09

They believe their place in heaven will be affected by the number of people they convert, hence the pushy nature on doorsteps.

It's a horrible religion that breaks up families. Steer well clear.

They don’t believe they’re going to heaven so how does that work? As for the shock at “shunning”, how many people on MN are no contract with their families? And how many are urged to do it?

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:46

fireflown · 03/02/2023 09:12

Shunning your own family is absolutely cruel. That other faiths might do it doesn't make it not cruel.

But again, if you are not of that faith how can you judge ? You’re coming at it from a different point of view. I’m not particularly defending or condemning it - just pointing out the difference. Faiths that adopt shunning tend to keep to their own faith communities - such as the Amish for example. They live by their own faith rules, one of which is that if you leave the faith, you are no longer a part of the community - that’s what shunning is. You know this from the start so it’s obviously designed to make you think carefully before taking the decision to leave the faith.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 09:48

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 09:38

@MinceandMash - Christian Scientists (the religious group not scientists who are Christian) shun modern medicine and followers and children have died because of it. Not saying that justifies the JWs! But another religion to add to your list of people who let children die for religious beliefs.

JW’s do not ‘let’ their children die for religious beliefs - as explained upthread.

fireflown · 03/02/2023 09:48

You know this from the start so it’s obviously designed to make you think carefully before taking the decision to leave the faith.

It's made to pressure and emotionally blackmail you into not leaving.