Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask about Jehovah's Witnesses?

375 replies

cecilyyb · 02/02/2023 22:40

There's a Kingdom Hall right at the end of my street. Always extremely busy a couple of nights a week and open everyday I've gone past.

I'm intrigued at what happens in there. It gives off cult vibes but I could be wrong.

Does anybody know what happens during these meetings? Can non JW attend or is that usually not accepted?

I did use to work with a JW but she never spoke much about her religion, all I really knew was that she didn't partake in celebrations.

Interested to hear experiences on here Smile

OP posts:
otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:00

What I could never understand, was how they got away with it?
Can you imagine the uproar if a Muslim community refused for their dc to learn about other religions and the holocaust in a mainstream school?
It would be all over the front of the bloody daily mail!!

Pearfacebanana · 02/02/2023 23:01

I have family who are JW. I'm not.

What happens at the meetings? Think church service with really bad electric piano music in a building normally resembling a community centre.

Are they cult like? Still unsure. Some are but not everyone. I know a minister and he is one of the most laid back people I know. His wife however is far more uptight about it.

Do they deny the holocaust? Not as far as I'm aware. I always understood them to be quite sympathetic to Jews so I can't see this myself and certainly my grandparents (who were quite hardcore) would not have said this.

Do they take things literally? Yes.

ChilliBandit · 02/02/2023 23:03

JudgeRudy · 02/02/2023 22:50

I attended a PREVENT training workshop. Included in risk factors for radicalisation was religion and cults (amongst many others).
I asked what the difference was and was given answers like "Well The Moonies is a cult but Catholisism is a religion"...yes but what's the difference? Why is attending a Christian Church seen as wholesome but if I'm a Scientologist it's because I've been brainwashed.
Amongst people I've spoken with JW seems to be hovering on the line. Personally I don't differentiate.

It’s an interesting question and I have no skin in the game as such being an atheist but for me it’s about control. The Catholic Church don’t care so much if you walk away, it won’t stop your family from speaking to you or seeing you ever again. It has teachings and expectations of its congregation but the consequences of not following them are your own burden to bear really, there is a lot more room for interpretation. I know Catholics who use contraception, have sex outside of marriage or eat meat on a Friday for example and still happily attend church and are part of their religious community. Tithing is more optional. I feel like cults tend to exert a lot more control over their members’ lives, and expect a lot more both in time and money in my opinion. Shunning is a big indicator, as is the amount of time and money JW are expected to give.

XenoBitch · 02/02/2023 23:03

cecilyyb · 02/02/2023 22:59

Surely most are born into JW and nobody would choose to become part of it themselves out of choice?

My mum's side were JW... long standing as far as I gather, but my mum didn't stick with it, and neither did some of her siblings. My mum believes in God and Heaven etc, but is not a JW.

PMAmostofthetime · 02/02/2023 23:03

@cecilyyb

In the evenings they have services like a church, they sing have speakers etc but like Sunday service is you have ever been.
some nights
they have children's parties ( as they don't celebrate birthdays) so they have them so the children don't miss out.

They are open in the day for community work ( their community) so they may be supporting a family in crisis and donating food, physical support etc

Some of the ladies also meet to clean the Kingdom Hall.

The reason they don't have blood transfusions is because they believe your soul is in your blood and if you had a transfusion you would no longer be you.
Medical developments mean there is artificial blood now that they will accept as their blood knits with it.

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:04

Pearfacebanana · 02/02/2023 23:01

I have family who are JW. I'm not.

What happens at the meetings? Think church service with really bad electric piano music in a building normally resembling a community centre.

Are they cult like? Still unsure. Some are but not everyone. I know a minister and he is one of the most laid back people I know. His wife however is far more uptight about it.

Do they deny the holocaust? Not as far as I'm aware. I always understood them to be quite sympathetic to Jews so I can't see this myself and certainly my grandparents (who were quite hardcore) would not have said this.

Do they take things literally? Yes.

As I said, I'm happy to be corrected but in my previous school our jw children were taken out when the holocaust was being introduced/taught.
They also had absolutely nothing to do with dress up, fundraising days eg Red Nose Day etc
Again, totally baffling?

ChilliBandit · 02/02/2023 23:05

I thought JW were targeted by the Nazis and put in camps so that confuses me. Unless they didn’t want their children to learn that?

Blossomtoes · 02/02/2023 23:09

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:04

As I said, I'm happy to be corrected but in my previous school our jw children were taken out when the holocaust was being introduced/taught.
They also had absolutely nothing to do with dress up, fundraising days eg Red Nose Day etc
Again, totally baffling?

Let me correct you then. Unless they’ve changed out of all recognition in the last few years, they’re not holocaust deniers and they allow their children to learn about it. JWs were as persecuted as Jews by the Nazis.

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:09

ChilliBandit · 02/02/2023 23:05

I thought JW were targeted by the Nazis and put in camps so that confuses me. Unless they didn’t want their children to learn that?

Possibly?
As I said before, I'm happy to be corrected. I'd actually like to be wrong about this as I never understood why they weren't included.

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:12

@Blossomtoes
Can you give me any plausible explanation why parents would insist they didn't attend any learning about it?
This issue aside, refusing to allow your children to learn about other religions etc is massively offensive/unacceptable.

PMAmostofthetime · 02/02/2023 23:12

cecilyyb · 02/02/2023 22:58

@otherwayup Bloody hell that's awful. I don't understand how anybody could deny the holocaust Confused

Quite the opposite actually.

JW was also targeted during the Holocaust.

I have friends who are JW and took the time to try and understand their way of life. It's not a way I'd choose to live however they have good principles such as no lying, no cheating erc that they live to the book by.

Some of their ways I'd consider old fashioned.

Chaperones to date, women/ girls have to wear dresses/skirts to the Kingdom Hall.
Elders ( people who are seen as superior in the religion) are all male. No same sex relationships.

However they help and support anyone in their congregation and refer to each other as brothers and sisters and no one will go without.

Anyone is welcome to a meeting. The bible says to spread gods word-
So the letters are instead of the days they used to knock doors that stopped post- covid. They accept all other religions and other people choices like same sex marriage just do not practice it themselves.

JudgeRudy · 02/02/2023 23:12

They do recruit....elderly widows, broken single mums, mentally ill......the vulnerable.......they pick you up, and really welcome you into the fold. That's step one of radicalisation...making you feel valued. This moves onto belonging, then a sense of duty to the cause.

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:16

@PMAmostofthetime
Really? If they accept other peoples religions, sexuality why on earth do their children spend so much time out of the classroom?!
Our jw children couldn't even come into our harvest festival assembly.

PMAmostofthetime · 02/02/2023 23:16

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:00

What I could never understand, was how they got away with it?
Can you imagine the uproar if a Muslim community refused for their dc to learn about other religions and the holocaust in a mainstream school?
It would be all over the front of the bloody daily mail!!

Exactly this happened at my school.

All JW children and All Muslim children were pulled from RE lessons and Assembly's.

We had to have 'talks' or 'updates' so they could attend twice a week in their place.

ChilliBandit · 02/02/2023 23:16

@JudgeRudy - yes I once read about their targeting of women’s shelters for new recruits.

Also sex abuse but what religion/cult hasn’t got that.

ToBeOrNotToBee · 02/02/2023 23:18

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 22:57

It's a cult. And a pretty messed up, nasty one too.

I worked in education for many decades and one of worst aspects of my job, was being expected to assist jw families poison their children's minds.

I had to take them out of the classroom for so much important learning.
They weren't allowed to learn about other religions, cultural festivals etc and most sickening, Year 6 jw children weren't included in the learning about the holocaust.
Yep, they are apparently holocaust deniers? Although I'm happy to be corrected, they certainly are in my neck of the woods!
Sickening.

Jehovah Witnesses were targeted by the Nazis and killed in the holocaust too.

How disgusting of you to now claim they are holocaust deniers.

I can assure you, JW are very aware of the holocaust.

PMAmostofthetime · 02/02/2023 23:18

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:16

@PMAmostofthetime
Really? If they accept other peoples religions, sexuality why on earth do their children spend so much time out of the classroom?!
Our jw children couldn't even come into our harvest festival assembly.

They accept it but don't participate or practice it , the same way Christian's accept Muslims but do not participate in Eid

Pericombobulations · 02/02/2023 23:20

Another person who had JW grandparents. I dont have good feelings towards the JW.

At my grandparents party one year there was a JW tolder running around, and my gran told us that he was ill but could be cured but as the treatment went against the JW ethos, they all (including his parents) would rather he died of it.

I heard her call any child born out of wedlock a bastard, and that included her first born great grand child.

She stayed in hospital with a broken hip, refusing a hip replacement until they could do it without blood transfusions. She was in months.

When my grandpa died, she told me off for crying at his funeral, because we should be happy he was now with Jehovah. He had war medals from WWII, she made him give them away and didnt let him talk about it.

She used to quote sections of their Bible, which my RC father would tell her were wrong, and she checked and the JW version of the Bible was often different to the Kng James version.

Birthdays, Christmas and Easter were never celebrated. Nor Mothers Day. They refused to go in any other church to celebrate a wedding, Christening or funeral. They missed several of her own grand childrens weddings due to this.

I also remember that in her last months, the JW tried to get her to change her will to leave a significantly larger portion of her money to them. Luckily she was stopped from signing it, particularly as she was no longer of sound mind to make that change. Her original will stood, which did include money to JW, just not as much as they wanted.

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:22

@ToBeOrNotToBee
Absolutely no need to call me disgusting.

As I have said, I'm happy (and would be somewhat relieved) to be corrected.
But still no explanation as to why jw children were removed from holocaust learning?
I'm simply sharing my experience and pondering why on earth this ever happened!!

ToBeOrNotToBee · 02/02/2023 23:26

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:22

@ToBeOrNotToBee
Absolutely no need to call me disgusting.

As I have said, I'm happy (and would be somewhat relieved) to be corrected.
But still no explanation as to why jw children were removed from holocaust learning?
I'm simply sharing my experience and pondering why on earth this ever happened!!

Because JW are very sensitive of govt interest, interference and of non-believers discussing their beliefs which invariably will contain alot of untruths and alot of hostility, as you have just proven with your holocaust denier claim.

They prefer to tell their children in their own time without the aspertions of ignorant people like yourself.

Blossomtoes · 02/02/2023 23:28

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:12

@Blossomtoes
Can you give me any plausible explanation why parents would insist they didn't attend any learning about it?
This issue aside, refusing to allow your children to learn about other religions etc is massively offensive/unacceptable.

My speculation is that those parents were misguided or had misunderstood something. As far as I know it’s not a requirement of the faith. I learned comparative religion at school, the only thing I was withdrawn from was acts of worship.

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:30

@ToBeOrNotToBee
You honestly believe that?

So, for example, JW children aren't allowed to attend sex ed lessons because their parents will, in their own time, do a wonderful job of explaining homosexuality to their dc?

purpleme12 · 02/02/2023 23:32

This thread is really quite fascinating hearing about people's experiences.
2 people did try to get me and my child to come and pray/have family time.I was tempted cos they were so lovely and I don't have a lot in my life at the minute. I don't think my child would have the patience though!

Blossomtoes · 02/02/2023 23:32

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:30

@ToBeOrNotToBee
You honestly believe that?

So, for example, JW children aren't allowed to attend sex ed lessons because their parents will, in their own time, do a wonderful job of explaining homosexuality to their dc?

They will explain homosexuality in the context of their faith which will obviously not be the case in the classroom. I don’t understand why you have such a problem with that.

ParrotsAteThemAll · 02/02/2023 23:33

Alannahxx · 02/02/2023 22:42

It's a cult. And one that kills people. ( have watched as a hcp as someone died due to refusing blood)

Same here, it’s heart breaking the lengths these cult members will go to.