Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask about Jehovah's Witnesses?

375 replies

cecilyyb · 02/02/2023 22:40

There's a Kingdom Hall right at the end of my street. Always extremely busy a couple of nights a week and open everyday I've gone past.

I'm intrigued at what happens in there. It gives off cult vibes but I could be wrong.

Does anybody know what happens during these meetings? Can non JW attend or is that usually not accepted?

I did use to work with a JW but she never spoke much about her religion, all I really knew was that she didn't partake in celebrations.

Interested to hear experiences on here Smile

OP posts:
Pencase · 07/02/2023 05:44

ChilliBandit · 06/02/2023 22:46

It doesn’t sound like @Stoptherideiwannagetoff interrogated anyone to me. I read it as if they were carrying out some sort of debrief/investigation.

No need to interrogate the parents - if the medical professionals agreed to withhold treatment, they should be the ones who are questioned to ensure they acted within the law. Questioning the parent’s was totally unwarranted

MeetPi · 07/02/2023 05:57

cecilyyb · 02/02/2023 22:46

@BankOfDave funny you say that, cos on more than on occasion we have also received a hand written letter through the post. Assuming it's from somebody who goes to the Kingdom Hall

I received one today! The address on the envelope was hand-written; the flyer inside was not. Should I complain?Wink

ChilliBandit · 07/02/2023 08:27

Pencase · 07/02/2023 05:39

I’d quite like to be euthanised when my time comes - but society has decided I don’t have that choice. When the time comes I will not be battling to live till I’m 95, if my only choice it to refuse medical intervention you think I shouldn’t be allowed that either - you sound very extreme.

I have no idea how you’ve got that from my post?? I am fully supportive of voluntary euthanasia, which is not a preventable or suspicious death. Making decisions on behalf of another adult is not voluntary euthanasia.

Not sure how pointing out that trying to better understand someone’s beliefs to think of ways around preventable deaths make me extreme.

So any preventable or suspicious death should not be investigated because the family are religious? Now that would be extreme.

ChilliBandit · 07/02/2023 08:33

Pencase · 07/02/2023 05:44

No need to interrogate the parents - if the medical professionals agreed to withhold treatment, they should be the ones who are questioned to ensure they acted within the law. Questioning the parent’s was totally unwarranted

What if the adult child wasn’t a JW but the parents are? Is it still ok then to let the JW parents beliefs override vital medical treatment of the child who unable to consent in that moment? How terrifying for anyone who has left the religion. Sorry probably too ‘extreme’ a scenario for you 🙄🙄

newnamethanks · 07/02/2023 08:35

Everyone Else Burns. Channel 4. Try it there first if you find this kind of surrender of self attractive.

Blossomtoes · 07/02/2023 08:43

ChilliBandit · 07/02/2023 08:33

What if the adult child wasn’t a JW but the parents are? Is it still ok then to let the JW parents beliefs override vital medical treatment of the child who unable to consent in that moment? How terrifying for anyone who has left the religion. Sorry probably too ‘extreme’ a scenario for you 🙄🙄

If the adult child had left the religion their parents wouldn’t be speaking to them, let alone making clinical decisions on their behalf.

Pencase · 07/02/2023 08:54

Blossomtoes · 07/02/2023 08:43

If the adult child had left the religion their parents wouldn’t be speaking to them, let alone making clinical decisions on their behalf.

This is not true - my Mil's friend has a son who has left the JWs she is still in regular contact with him, I asked her about it and she said some families end up in that place but there's no requirement to not speak to your child. She felt quite strongly that you had a duty to your child.

Blossomtoes · 07/02/2023 09:04

My mum felt the same @Penrose, most don’t though. And she’d never have made clinical decisions on my behalf.

Pencase · 07/02/2023 13:04

Blossomtoes · 07/02/2023 09:04

My mum felt the same @Penrose, most don’t though. And she’d never have made clinical decisions on my behalf.

My mil displays Christmas cards, came to my dh’s 50th birthday celebration. Has never once mentioned my 9 pint blood transfusion following childbirth. She has never talked about religion to my kids - respects my view that they should be brought up atheist. She didn’t want the option of blood transfusion when she had surgery and we respected her POV. Ds is gay but he doesn’t want mil to know - he just doesn’t see the need - it’s not her business - or anyone else’s as far as he’s concerned. My dcs love their grandmother - her being JW is such a non- issue.

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2023 15:26

Blossomtoes · 06/02/2023 22:25

Their doctrine is quite contradictory i.e. there is a finite number of places in paradise but they all go there?

They believe there will be 144,000 places in heaven with an infinite number of people living in paradise on earth.

I’m absolutely horrified that you would interrogate a newly bereaved mother @Stoptherideiwannagetoff. Why on earth made you think that was remotely appropriate?

I wondered that too. Given that the child who died the ‘preventable’ death was an adult, and would have made the decision on refusing any treatment herself, why would anyone quiz the mother about it ?

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2023 15:36

ChilliBandit · 07/02/2023 08:33

What if the adult child wasn’t a JW but the parents are? Is it still ok then to let the JW parents beliefs override vital medical treatment of the child who unable to consent in that moment? How terrifying for anyone who has left the religion. Sorry probably too ‘extreme’ a scenario for you 🙄🙄

They don’t. If someone isn’t capable of consent at the time they need emergency or vital treatment, and their wishes have not been made clear, then the medics take over and give the necessary treatment. If the person is under age -a child - they would simply obtain a court order and treat them. I’d consider this a kind of ‘get out of jail free card’ for JW parents because when they withhold consent, they pretty much know their child will be treated under a court order anyway. And I do wonder how many JW parents would hold out until their child passed away if not. But many people are missing the issue here. Consent is key. If a JW gives consent to a prohibited procedure such as a blood transfusion, they will be held responsible and must take the consequences. If they are not capable of consent at the time the treatment is given, or have been overruled with a court order, they are not responsible for that.

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2023 15:46

newnamethanks · 07/02/2023 08:35

Everyone Else Burns. Channel 4. Try it there first if you find this kind of surrender of self attractive.

The series doesn’t present a realistic view because it’s based on elements of other religions besides JWs. The problem I think people have with this, is that if they haven’t experienced all encompassing faith for themselves they can’t understand it. I’m not JW myself but a close relative is, and a couple of my friends are. For them, there is a distinct difference in what is Godly and what is worldly. Breaking what they consider to be God’s laws result in the loss of the Kingdom of God. Your life is given over completely to God and self doesn’t matter. Everything you did before conversion to JW you can repent. But you can’t repent breaking God’s laws after that, because knowing is accepting and obeying. For me, it goes against everything Christ teaches about God given free will and forgiveness, but I’m prepared to accept that not having that kind of faith, I’m not in a position to understand.

ChilliBandit · 07/02/2023 15:49

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2023 15:36

They don’t. If someone isn’t capable of consent at the time they need emergency or vital treatment, and their wishes have not been made clear, then the medics take over and give the necessary treatment. If the person is under age -a child - they would simply obtain a court order and treat them. I’d consider this a kind of ‘get out of jail free card’ for JW parents because when they withhold consent, they pretty much know their child will be treated under a court order anyway. And I do wonder how many JW parents would hold out until their child passed away if not. But many people are missing the issue here. Consent is key. If a JW gives consent to a prohibited procedure such as a blood transfusion, they will be held responsible and must take the consequences. If they are not capable of consent at the time the treatment is given, or have been overruled with a court order, they are not responsible for that.

I was talking about an adult child in this situation following on from what someone else said but I appreciate I did not make that clear. I still think forcing a hospital to have to spend time and money to obtain a court order to save your child who needs life saving treatment is unforgivable however. I wonder what happens in countries which may not have the same set up with courts vs religious freedoms etc.

I don’t care particularly about adult JW refusing blood transfusions although I would question whether someone raised in the faith is really making a free decision but I appreciate that could apply to most things in life for everyone.

I thought in situations where an adult person was unable to consent (ie they are unconscious), their family would be consulted on treatment? I am happy if that is not the case and the medics just do what they can to save you.

TeamRR · 07/02/2023 15:55

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2023 15:36

They don’t. If someone isn’t capable of consent at the time they need emergency or vital treatment, and their wishes have not been made clear, then the medics take over and give the necessary treatment. If the person is under age -a child - they would simply obtain a court order and treat them. I’d consider this a kind of ‘get out of jail free card’ for JW parents because when they withhold consent, they pretty much know their child will be treated under a court order anyway. And I do wonder how many JW parents would hold out until their child passed away if not. But many people are missing the issue here. Consent is key. If a JW gives consent to a prohibited procedure such as a blood transfusion, they will be held responsible and must take the consequences. If they are not capable of consent at the time the treatment is given, or have been overruled with a court order, they are not responsible for that.

Getting a court order takes time, and in that time the child could die or sustain lasting damage, in which case their blood is on their parents hand. If someone's religion is more important to them than their child's life, they shouldn't have children.

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2023 17:20

ChilliBandit · 07/02/2023 15:49

I was talking about an adult child in this situation following on from what someone else said but I appreciate I did not make that clear. I still think forcing a hospital to have to spend time and money to obtain a court order to save your child who needs life saving treatment is unforgivable however. I wonder what happens in countries which may not have the same set up with courts vs religious freedoms etc.

I don’t care particularly about adult JW refusing blood transfusions although I would question whether someone raised in the faith is really making a free decision but I appreciate that could apply to most things in life for everyone.

I thought in situations where an adult person was unable to consent (ie they are unconscious), their family would be consulted on treatment? I am happy if that is not the case and the medics just do what they can to save you.

I agree with you on the court order thing, plus they take time to obtain, although I would have thought they can be fast tracked where necessary. I don’t actually think it is a ‘free’ decision either - it would be constrained by your own religious convictions and with everything they believe at stake, there would be pressure from other members of the church. This is where I think JWs version of Christianity is completely at odds with the teachings of Christ on free will, and forgiveness. Also very much at odds with the Jewish faith which teaches that there are situations where commandments can be broken if life is genuinely at risk - they believe that God intended man to live by the commandments, not to die by them.

My understanding of UK law is that if a person is unable to consent to emergency or vital treatment, doctors would consult with the patients’ family to find out if there is an advance directive or whether someone has a lasting power of attorney for the patient. In the absence of these, they would be able to go ahead with any necessary treatment. I think end of life treatment is different. When my husband was on life support, the doctors consulted with myself and my family when it came time to end things, and we consented. I was reliably informed that if we hadn’t, they would eventually have sought a court order to end life support as there was no prospect of recovery. It’s difficult stuff isn’t it ?

Rosscameasdoody · 07/02/2023 17:24

TeamRR · 07/02/2023 15:55

Getting a court order takes time, and in that time the child could die or sustain lasting damage, in which case their blood is on their parents hand. If someone's religion is more important to them than their child's life, they shouldn't have children.

Wouldn’t disagree, but again I don’t hold that level of conviction in any faith, so it’s difficult for me to understand those who do. I can only speak from conversations with relatives and friends who are JWs (and there’s a LOT of disagreement) to the fact that to them obedience of God’s law as they interpret it is paramount to everything - even earthly life itself.

WetLettuce2 · 09/02/2023 00:04

@Rosscameasdoody ‘Everything you did before conversion to JW you can repent. But you can’t repent breaking God’s laws after that, because knowing is accepting and obeying‘.

Not correct - the model prayer includes asking for forgiveness of sins, as all imperfect humans including JWs make mistakes.

Rosscameasdoody · 09/02/2023 14:52

WetLettuce2 · 09/02/2023 00:04

@Rosscameasdoody ‘Everything you did before conversion to JW you can repent. But you can’t repent breaking God’s laws after that, because knowing is accepting and obeying‘.

Not correct - the model prayer includes asking for forgiveness of sins, as all imperfect humans including JWs make mistakes.

Slightly out of context. I was referring to the issue of a blood transfusion, consented to in the knowledge that it’s against Gods’ law. I am under the impression that consent to such a procedure is not something a JW can repent of, as it actually damages their relationship with Jehovah. Happy to be corrected if I’m wrong though.

CuppaAndABiccie · 03/03/2023 22:17

Sorry, this is quite lengthy, but really just the tip of the iceberg….

I got sucked into this in the late 70s as an 18 year old, coming from a pretty loveless background - and thus very vulnerable to the love-bombing you automatically get as a newbie.

Things may have changed now, but certainly back then you couldn’t just ‘join’ - you had to have an individual bible study with a JW (along with going to meetings) and one of the first thing that should have been more of a red flag, was that you were/are warned off from listening to any opposing view or research which puts them in a bad light - it’s described as Satan speaking through ‘apostates’ (anyone who’s left the JWs, and subsequently telling it how it is!).

You are not allowed to have friends or socialise with non-JWs - and so after a while, one’s entire social and family network ends up being 100% other JWs. Whilst they don’t ‘christen’ infants, they do encourage young people to make the lifetime commitment of becoming baptised, and once baptised, they’ve really got you!

All this is key to them having a hold over you, as if you try and leave, or you break one of their rules on any number of things, then you can be ‘disfellowshipped’, which means you must be completely shunned by all JWs….until you see the error of your ways and come grovelling back.

Interestingly, Norway have just removed their religious status (crucially the massive tax benefits granted to various religions) based on the shunning practice, and the incredibly damaging effect this has on young people/children.

There is also currently a worldwide scandal concerning the covering up of child sexual abuse within congregations - and almost complete resistance to reporting to ‘secular authorities’ ie the police. Google the Australian Royal Commission and JWS for the full story there - not to mention literally hundreds of court cases in the USA underway right now, where adult male offenders are routinely believed over the word of frightened and vulnerable children because of the ‘two witness rule’ - ie if the act wasn’t witnessed by others, then the child must be lying….and the abuser can carry on doing what they’re doing for years to come.

The organisation has 8 (well, 9 at the moment - but that’s another story!) old American men who make up ‘the governing body’ who are basically a conduit from god - so all doctrine and direction comes from them. This is a misogynistic religion where women play second fiddle to men in all aspects, and are not permitted to teach in any religious capacity.

Further education for teenagers is actively discouraged, and instead JWs are encouraged to work in low level ‘humble’ jobs, so they can devote time to evangelising. People tend to marry young, as sex outside of marriage is forbidden. Homosexuality is also an absolute no no, which means if you’re gay your choices are to live your life as a lie, or be shunned.

So in summary, this is most definitely a cult. The JWs themselves are not necessarily bad people, BUT, as they are not permitted to use any kind of critical thinking, they are generally unaware of all the CSA scandals unfolding around the world, or the growing awareness of the psychological damage caused by shunning (as just recognised by Norway).

They have a massive persecution complex, and criticism is deemed ‘proof’ that the end of the world is imminent, when all except for JWs will be destroyed by god….and then JWs only will get to live in an on-earth paradise.

Please please OP, do your research before getting drawn in! A good source of information I’d suggest is Lloyd Evans on YouTube. He’s an ex JW ‘elder’ who left just over a decade ago, and has great insight into the internal workings of the organisation 👍

CuppaAndABiccie · 03/03/2023 22:34

Nat6999 · 03/02/2023 04:31

Some of my mum's neighbours are Jehovas Witnesses, they often have gatherings at their house before going on the knock, we are all black balled after my mum lost her temper when they tried knocking at her door for the third time in a week. If you don't want them to call again, tell them you are a Catholic, that is what I did when they knocked at mine, they couldn't get away fast enough & have never been back again.

Better still, tell them you’re an ‘apostate’ - that’s like kryptonite to superman to them! 😄

WetLettuce2 · 04/03/2023 10:37

@CuppaAndABiccie

‘This is a misogynistic religion where women play second fiddle to men in all aspects, and are not permitted to teach in any religious capacity’ - definitely not true, many, if not most, of the JWs who knock on doors teaching the bible are women.

‘when all except for JWs will be destroyed by god….and then JWs only will get to live in an on-earth paradise’ - also definitely not true and not something that is in the bible, nor something that they teach.

NandorsFamilar · 04/03/2023 11:00

They also refuse to vote as 'god is in charge and we cannot vote for anyone as its not god' (paraphrased).
In Australia it is mandatory to vote and JWs have to claim religious exemption.

Their lives are very restricted. And they shun anyone who leaves, so a whole support network disappears in a single swoop

follyfoot37 · 04/03/2023 11:03

cecilyyb · 02/02/2023 22:43

@Alannahxx Yeah I heard about them not accepting blood transfusions. What is the reason for this?

Why don't you do some on-line research or go to a library instead of garnering biased 'cult!, cult!, cult!' responses you will get here

PrincessConstance · 04/03/2023 11:12

CuppaAndABiccie · 03/03/2023 22:17

Sorry, this is quite lengthy, but really just the tip of the iceberg….

I got sucked into this in the late 70s as an 18 year old, coming from a pretty loveless background - and thus very vulnerable to the love-bombing you automatically get as a newbie.

Things may have changed now, but certainly back then you couldn’t just ‘join’ - you had to have an individual bible study with a JW (along with going to meetings) and one of the first thing that should have been more of a red flag, was that you were/are warned off from listening to any opposing view or research which puts them in a bad light - it’s described as Satan speaking through ‘apostates’ (anyone who’s left the JWs, and subsequently telling it how it is!).

You are not allowed to have friends or socialise with non-JWs - and so after a while, one’s entire social and family network ends up being 100% other JWs. Whilst they don’t ‘christen’ infants, they do encourage young people to make the lifetime commitment of becoming baptised, and once baptised, they’ve really got you!

All this is key to them having a hold over you, as if you try and leave, or you break one of their rules on any number of things, then you can be ‘disfellowshipped’, which means you must be completely shunned by all JWs….until you see the error of your ways and come grovelling back.

Interestingly, Norway have just removed their religious status (crucially the massive tax benefits granted to various religions) based on the shunning practice, and the incredibly damaging effect this has on young people/children.

There is also currently a worldwide scandal concerning the covering up of child sexual abuse within congregations - and almost complete resistance to reporting to ‘secular authorities’ ie the police. Google the Australian Royal Commission and JWS for the full story there - not to mention literally hundreds of court cases in the USA underway right now, where adult male offenders are routinely believed over the word of frightened and vulnerable children because of the ‘two witness rule’ - ie if the act wasn’t witnessed by others, then the child must be lying….and the abuser can carry on doing what they’re doing for years to come.

The organisation has 8 (well, 9 at the moment - but that’s another story!) old American men who make up ‘the governing body’ who are basically a conduit from god - so all doctrine and direction comes from them. This is a misogynistic religion where women play second fiddle to men in all aspects, and are not permitted to teach in any religious capacity.

Further education for teenagers is actively discouraged, and instead JWs are encouraged to work in low level ‘humble’ jobs, so they can devote time to evangelising. People tend to marry young, as sex outside of marriage is forbidden. Homosexuality is also an absolute no no, which means if you’re gay your choices are to live your life as a lie, or be shunned.

So in summary, this is most definitely a cult. The JWs themselves are not necessarily bad people, BUT, as they are not permitted to use any kind of critical thinking, they are generally unaware of all the CSA scandals unfolding around the world, or the growing awareness of the psychological damage caused by shunning (as just recognised by Norway).

They have a massive persecution complex, and criticism is deemed ‘proof’ that the end of the world is imminent, when all except for JWs will be destroyed by god….and then JWs only will get to live in an on-earth paradise.

Please please OP, do your research before getting drawn in! A good source of information I’d suggest is Lloyd Evans on YouTube. He’s an ex JW ‘elder’ who left just over a decade ago, and has great insight into the internal workings of the organisation 👍

Isn't Lloyd Evans the chap who has been lambasting witnesses online for yrs, taking donations?
Only for Mr. Evans to be found using these donations to fund visits to prostitutes abroad.🙄😂
Sounds like a fine upstanding member of the 'World'.

Oxterguff · 04/03/2023 13:54

It’s clearly a cult and I can’t believe that there are people here seriously criticising others for saying that. The organisation is dangerous, I have seen direct evidence of it destroying families. There have been countless child abuse cases and cover ups and they prey on vulnerable people. They came to my door once and told asked them to justify the recent cover up of an elder who had been jailed for multiple counts of rape and child abuse. They haven’t been back since!