Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask about Jehovah's Witnesses?

375 replies

cecilyyb · 02/02/2023 22:40

There's a Kingdom Hall right at the end of my street. Always extremely busy a couple of nights a week and open everyday I've gone past.

I'm intrigued at what happens in there. It gives off cult vibes but I could be wrong.

Does anybody know what happens during these meetings? Can non JW attend or is that usually not accepted?

I did use to work with a JW but she never spoke much about her religion, all I really knew was that she didn't partake in celebrations.

Interested to hear experiences on here Smile

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 15:33

Blossomtoes · 03/02/2023 12:06

You mean like Catholic hcps who won’t treat or care for women having terminations.

Going back a fairly long time here - late 1980’s. Our family GP was RC and irefused to refer a relative for advice on continuing a pregnancy, even though she had a disability which not only could be passed on, but posed very serious risks for my relative herself. We eventually had to go private to get the right advice and she chose to terminate. The GP didn’t want to discuss anything but the ‘situation as it stands’ as she kept referring to it. We made a complaint and changed GP. So I agree with both of you. If you have deeply held religious convictions you shouldn’t be in a job where it compromises them at someone else’s’ expense.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 15:36

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ.

Well said.

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 15:40

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 11:35

My experience is different to yours so this never happened, is that your point?

No, I think the difference is that your experience came after leaving the church - a very different thing, and a big thing for a JW. Having said that, once an ex member has been shunned am I right in thinking there should be no contact at all ? So not only nasty but hypocritical.

LieutenantRipley · 03/02/2023 16:16

It's a misogynistic, controlling, manipulative, isolating cult. I was raised a Jehovah's Witness - my whole family were. Luckily not anymore. Horrifying impact on lives. If anyone is in any doubt about the inner machinations of this religion, I highly recommend reading 'Crisis of Conscience' by Raymond Franz, a former member of the JW governing body. I read this after I left the religion and it was extremely helpful and eye-opening. (Incidentally, if I'd read it before I left, I would've been disciplined for reading apostate material. Critical thinking, questioning or holding any views that might not conform to what the governing body is telling you is met with swift punitive measures. Think state media-type control.)

IcedPurple · 03/02/2023 16:26

ChilliBandit · 02/02/2023 23:05

I thought JW were targeted by the Nazis and put in camps so that confuses me. Unless they didn’t want their children to learn that?

They were.

JW have been persecuted in many places, but Nazi Germany was the worst. They were offered freedom in return for renouncing their beliefs, but almost none chose to do so.

Blossomtoes · 03/02/2023 16:27

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 15:40

No, I think the difference is that your experience came after leaving the church - a very different thing, and a big thing for a JW. Having said that, once an ex member has been shunned am I right in thinking there should be no contact at all ? So not only nasty but hypocritical.

It wasn’t true in my case. I walked away. My mum remained and she treated me no differently after I left. It was decades later that she died and I had to interact with them to organise her funeral. An elder and his wife who had known me since I was a child came to my house and we drank tea and cried as we discussed the funeral. The service was exactly what they respectfully agreed with me and the kindness I experienced from a number of them on the day was heartwarming and comforting.

I’m very willing to listen to the experience of any former JW and fully appreciate that different people will have been treated in different ways but I have to be honest about how I was treated and it was impeccable.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/02/2023 16:30

You have to understand their beliefs. It’s not cruel - they believe that leaving the church means you are turning your back on God and won't achieve the Kingdom of Heaven, and it’s met with sadness

Out of interest, since when did "sadness" involve turning your back on someone - and worse, insisting that others in the wider family should do the same thing?

I agree that shunning isn't exclusive to JWs, but I'm not sure the word sadness is appropriate here, when "pique", "resentment" and even "spite" may well be more accurate

IcedPurple · 03/02/2023 16:49

clarabellabunting · 03/02/2023 10:45

Only those who were baptised are shunned, which is why my DH is glad he was never baptised, or else he'd have close family members who would not now be allowed to speak to him.

I read that Serena William was baptised into the JW last month. She was raised in the faith but not baptised as they don't believe in child baptism. I wonder if she deliberately waited until her tennis career was over, as the JW frown on competitive sport? Her husband is also not a JW and their daughter was born before they were married, so in many ways her lifestyle would not have been compatible with a fully 'signed up' member of the JW. But that is what she is now.

Genevieva · 03/02/2023 16:52

We have had Jehovah Witnesses visit occasionally. The trouble is that if you are too nice to them they think you might be a potential recruit. The first one was a simple chap and only stopped coming after brining one of his more senior church members to our house. At that point we politely but firmly made it clear that we were not interested. The second was a young Mum. She understood that we were not open to conversion, but we had a really interesting chat about what caused her to convert and about the community she had found. She was very normal and family focussed. It made me realise that they are not really a cult. They are just different and a minority.

winningeasy · 03/02/2023 17:08

There's a new black comedy on channel 4 called Everyone Else Burns which I imagine is based on the JW lifestyle

Pinotpleasure · 03/02/2023 17:22

I used to live in Singapore. The religion of Jehovah’s Witnesses has been banned there for decades, as is the Unification Church (aka the ‘Moonies’).

The Singapore government banned JW’s in 1972 on the grounds that ‘the church was prejudicial to public welfare and order because:

1.JW’s objected to National Service (in which all Singaporean males and sons of permanent residents must participate),

2.Reciting the national pledge (all Singaporean public school pupils recite it daily and everyone else at major national events).

3.Refusing to sing the National Anthem.

There is also the view that Singaporean citizens must be prepared to defend their country in the incidence of an attack from a foreign power and therefore why should JWs and Moonies benefit from the potential sacrifice of their fellow citizens if they’re not prepared to do so themselves?.

LindyLou2020 · 03/02/2023 17:36

@cecilyyb

You opened the thread by wondering what happens at JW meetings.
My late mum came to the UK in her early 20's, just after WW2, from another European country, and at that time knew very little English.
She eventually became fluent, but there were many malapropisms along the way.
I grew up thinking JWs must have wonderful, fun times at meetings, as my mum referred to them as Jovial Witnesses.........

LastOfTheChristmasWine · 03/02/2023 17:47

winningeasy · 03/02/2023 17:08

There's a new black comedy on channel 4 called Everyone Else Burns which I imagine is based on the JW lifestyle

I've watched it, it's fairly funny. Bit of a mixture of JW and Mormon beliefs (e.g. the group depicted don't drink coffee or alcohol, which is a Mormon thing not a JW thing).

Apostasy is a film made by a man who was raised JW and starring Siobhan Finneran. Worth a watch if you're interested in these things.

Pearfacebanana · 03/02/2023 18:09

There is a lot of confusion on this thread and I believe there are different strands of JW. I had a leaflet through my door from an entirely separate JW organisation to the main one. I asked my mum and aunt who were brought up in the faith and they had no idea who it was, so there are definitely off shoots.

I disagree with the shunning. My mum isn't shunned and they are very welcoming at weddings etc.

One thing that does bother me though was how they treated my Nan after 60+ years in the congregation when she got Alzheimer's. No help or support or interest even. This did make me question their "Christian" values.

WickedSerious · 03/02/2023 18:12

BankOfDave · 02/02/2023 22:45

Last year I think it was, I received a very neat handwritten letter through the post. Apparently that’s a thing/common.

Couldn’t believe how long it would take to do that plus postage costs etc. must be a v well funded organisation.

We've had a few of these,the first one arrived during lockdown.

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 18:14

Rosscameasdoody · 03/02/2023 15:40

No, I think the difference is that your experience came after leaving the church - a very different thing, and a big thing for a JW. Having said that, once an ex member has been shunned am I right in thinking there should be no contact at all ? So not only nasty but hypocritical.

I’ve never left any church? I was remarking on how you said another posters situation couldn’t have happened because it wasn’t your experience.

Pearfacebanana · 03/02/2023 18:15

Ps also a JW would never say church!

AnotherPidgey · 03/02/2023 18:57

There are JWs in my extended family.
I've been along to meetings in my childhood. The mid-week bible readings were pretty dry, the Sunday worship is prayer and Bible based; I don't recall hymns, but it was a long time ago. The funeral I went to was heavy on Bible content and didn't feel very personal about their life.

There have been a lot of family issues. It's a close knit community which is fine if all is hunkydory and everyone follows the rules. The younger teen family members that drifted away without baptism didn't face wider bother. One family member "married well" at a young age to some one else of JW roots. Neither were baptised. No support from the JWs when he turned out to be a violent abuser. The baptised family member that commited the sin of cohabiting found themself shunned by the community, which affected them going about their daily business in the local area. Family relationships were soured although not completely shunned. The long-established family member has had health issues and the blood transfusion beliefs have compromised optimum medical care. When they were seriously ill in hospital, the Elders were intrusive and unsupportive.

In contrast DH has had no consequence to drifting away from his mainstream church or parting from its official policies. We attend a different denomination of church and if we go, people are pleased to see us. If we haven't been for a while, there's no bother and people are just warmly pleased to see us if we see them in passing.

The scale of shunning is very different to the typical MN NC. Normal NC is people at their limits, breaking contact with abusive, damaging people and trying to avoid them. It's specific. Shunning extends through the whole community, family, friends.
I don't find shunning very compatible with the teachings of the New Testement.

PrincessConstance · 03/02/2023 19:10

Dp says shunning is for baptized members who are disfellowshipped and refuse to repent. Adultery, fornication, drugs, apostasy.
He describes/compares this has been removed and barred from a nightclub.

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 19:21

PrincessConstance · 03/02/2023 19:10

Dp says shunning is for baptized members who are disfellowshipped and refuse to repent. Adultery, fornication, drugs, apostasy.
He describes/compares this has been removed and barred from a nightclub.

That analogy would only work if his family and friends lived in the nightclub he was barred from entering and even when they left the nightclub they still had zero contact with him.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/02/2023 19:27

A side issue, I know, but these "handwritten letters" - are they really handwritten, or copied and then perhaps signed in a different coloured ink?

I'd always assumed it was the latter, but now you've all got me wondering ...

OtherOtter · 03/02/2023 19:44

Dh grew up with a JW mother - he tells no stories of awful childhoods. He decided not to get baptised because after reading the bible he found too many inconsistencies and decided it wasn't for him. His sisters also decided not to pursue it. Mil respected my decision to bring my kids up as atheists - we always spent their birthdays at her house, there was never an atmosphere - the kids knew she had religious beliefs that meant she didn't celebrate birthdays but she was happy for them to do so. People send her Christmas cards - she displays them, they are sent with good intent. Her religion brings her a lot of comfort and we respect her right to access it and worship when she needs to. Imo there are load mouth extremists in every religion - I grew up Catholic and it can be quite extreme, even though most people who follow it are not - you never hear about people like my MIL, they quietly get on with doing things. She's too old now to go around the doors but we did wish she wouldn't as she often met very angry people but that was what she saw as her duty.

PrincessConstance · 03/02/2023 19:48

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 19:21

That analogy would only work if his family and friends lived in the nightclub he was barred from entering and even when they left the nightclub they still had zero contact with him.

The idea is, people are removed who do not behave in the manner set by their governing body.
He left and has had no issues, although he wasn't dipped and he's not being apostatizing.

ChilliBandit · 03/02/2023 20:24

PrincessConstance · 03/02/2023 19:48

The idea is, people are removed who do not behave in the manner set by their governing body.
He left and has had no issues, although he wasn't dipped and he's not being apostatizing.

But in many JW congregations they don’t just get asked leave the congregation, they are then shunned by their family and friends.

Blossomtoes · 03/02/2023 20:27

Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/02/2023 19:27

A side issue, I know, but these "handwritten letters" - are they really handwritten, or copied and then perhaps signed in a different coloured ink?

I'd always assumed it was the latter, but now you've all got me wondering ...

They’re really handwritten.

Swipe left for the next trending thread