Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shootings 4 ijured in daylight drive by shooting - Stop & Search

374 replies

Abigail69 · 14/01/2023 17:24

AIBU to demand greater powers for police to carry out more stop and searchers?

IMO, stop and search at an officer's discretion without fear of being accused of unfairness eytc should be supported by the majority of people that are lawful.

As long as the police were being honest/fair and doing their job , polite and explained their reasons, I w=uold never have a problem. I may be ticked of if I got stopped two/three times in a couple of weeks but there are certain times of the day/night and areas that need to be targeted

Their si no question that stop and searching reduce crime as gradually those carrying weapons will decrease. Even now, the trouble makers hide their weapons/drugs in prams, roadside bins, parks etc and collect them when needed but many do still carry a weapon/drugs both etc.

When there is a fight for whatever reason, if not one is carrying a weapon, almost certain the person/s will not get seriously injured or worse.

Stop and search of cars is high yielding as when some are stopped for using the phone and trying to drive, I think i read quiet often they are not fully road legal eg, not have a full licence/banned, no insurance, mot etc

As I said, if I got stopped I may get miffed but if the officer was nice/professional and explained etc, I'd accept it. (My parents are not from the uk) (I am aware that like any profession, there are mistakes when this happens they need to be fully investigated by an independent body.)

Today, just read this - see link below - I hope the victims make a full and speedy recovery and the suspects caught and then sent to prison for a long time.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11635423/Four-people-including-seven-year-old-girl-injured-shooting-outside-funeral-London.html

OP posts:
OddsocksinmyDocs · 14/01/2023 21:30

Going by your apparent logic, all women are murderers because some women have murdered... You can't generalise all police officers because of the actions of somd.

Pumperthepumper · 14/01/2023 21:32

OddsocksinmyDocs · 14/01/2023 21:30

Going by your apparent logic, all women are murderers because some women have murdered... You can't generalise all police officers because of the actions of somd.

Surely we should be holding police officers to a higher standard than the general public though? Where was the outrage and call for change from the MET police after Sarah Everard was murdered? There was none - just snivelling about bad apples. It’s sickening.

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/01/2023 21:33

OddsocksinmyDocs · 14/01/2023 21:30

Going by your apparent logic, all women are murderers because some women have murdered... You can't generalise all police officers because of the actions of somd.

I honestly can't be bothered.

S&S doesn't work, doesn't fly with community policing, increased mistrust of the police when used in the past and again, doesn't work.

Many things do work, I've talked about them on this thread. Do them.

Florenz · 14/01/2023 21:34

Quveas · 14/01/2023 19:51

Dear God. So the police know in advance, without evidence, who the criminals are, and those people have no human rights. That isn't justice. It's a police state

Of course people know who the criminals are. They're the ones with criminal records. The vast majority of offences are committed by repeat offenders.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 14/01/2023 21:35

Yeah.. no.

Admittedly I’m one of those pesky Americans who don’t believe in overreaching gov’t. But even as someone who is generally pro-police I would fight hard against this. I like my liberty, and rights that protect from unreasonable search and seizure.

That being said, it’s your country and your laws, knock yourself out. But you don’t seem to be getting too much agreement here for your idea.

GirloutofAfrica · 14/01/2023 21:38

I am black an support s&s, yes there are race issues etc. But when I worked in South London we seemed to have at least 3-4 BLACK yp being referred to our services for knife related injuries or crimes. Without tougher policing and better use mapping it's our communities that suffer!

ClivePowermax · 14/01/2023 21:41

Oh, my sweet summer child. I wish I lived in your universe, OP.

Xenopus · 14/01/2023 21:42

NeverDropYourMooncup · 14/01/2023 19:14

The mathematics behind Stop and Search were fundamentally flawed.

If I collar 2000 middleaged women who own cats on a rainy Thursday morning in January and discover that 200 of them are somewhat grumpy and single, but approach 150 women in their twenties at a family dog walk event on a sunny Saturday afternoon in June and find that 130 are in a good mood, married and don't own cats, the S&S logic dictates that women who own cats are more likely to be grumpy and single than women who own dogs. If I didn't like middleaged women or cats, that confirms my bias, so I'll stop right there; younger women who own dogs are nicer and more likely to have a husband. From that, the inference is that if I am looking for more grumpy woman, I look at cat owners.

Even though I've only spoken to 150 and found that 20 are irritable; Grumpy older Cat owners = 10%, Grumpy younger dog owners = 13%, the S&S justification is that 200 grumpy single women with cats outweighs 20 grumpy married women with dogs even though I deliberately didn't look at the other 1800 because that would have fucked up my assumptions from being a misogynistic ailurophobe. I'm therefore expecting cat owners to be grumpy and I'm more abrupt with the next ones I meet and piss them off with my attitude. Which confirms my prejudice against them. So I'm ruder to the next ones, who have learned that researchers are dickheads to cat owners, so are more hostile, etc, etc...

You can't find what you don't look for - and Stop and Search was the ultimate fuck up in terms of not looking.

I love this post 😊

Voice0fReason · 14/01/2023 22:05

I tend to think that all of the people claiming that they wouldn't mind being stopped and searched are imagining a polite police officer asking to pat them down, search their bag then let them go on their way in 2 minutes. And that this only happens once or twice in their lifetime.

The reality of stop & search is very different to that. If you look a certain way, you will be stopped constantly. That will lead to ill-feeling within those communities and greater suspicion.

And of course, S&S is just ineffective.
It's a terrible idea.

Abigail69 · 14/01/2023 22:17

Endlesssummer2022 · 14/01/2023 20:24

OP was written by someone who is confident they or their children would not be targeted by ‘stop and search’ which doesn’t even work and just causes bad feeling and more distrust. Look at what happened to that poor child they strip searched at school leaving her with mental health problems.

However, if OP were willing to allow herself and her children to be stopped daily and frisked going about their business then I may be more in favour of it.

Some people are always in favour of reducing other people civil liberties. Similar to the men who wish to restrict women’s rights as it doesn’t impact them.

I'm in favour odfusing S&S for the good of all. No one in their right mind wants to be forced to be S&S within the law but ask yourself, what is the alternative?

I rather be S&S than hear daily news regarding real people often young people being maimed and worse.

Accept the fact that no one lives in a perfect world along with the fact that the UK is better than most countries and I have been to several countries in my travels and if I had a free choice to live where I wanted to, it would be England/London.

What is the alternative -m just ask the loved ones of those injured or worse.

OP posts:
Abigail69 · 14/01/2023 22:19

ClivePowermax · 14/01/2023 21:41

Oh, my sweet summer child. I wish I lived in your universe, OP.

Do not "wish" but act proactively via your actions and speech and challenge the wrongs and accept what may not be perfect but a driver of good.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 14/01/2023 23:13

Do not "wish" but act proactively via your actions and speech and challenge the wrongs and accept what may not be perfect but a driver of good.

Great. What have you done to address disaffected youth in cities, social inequality, racism, education outcomes and addiction.

Because I've spent my life addressing all of them and I don't believe more S&S is the answer.

Ruffpuff · 14/01/2023 23:42

Officers have been given updated training (including highlighting unconscious bias) and there have been changes to policy in recent years meaning S&S procedures should improve. There are sufficient existing powers with s&s, more aren’t really needed. I can imagine it’s not nice to be searched, however officer do get people to lean in certain ways, e.g. widened stance/leaning forward for their own safety.

Even with enhanced S&S powers, they’re never going to be able to identify everyone with a weapon unfortunately.

Kinnorafron · 15/01/2023 00:02

I rather be S&S than hear daily news regarding real people often young people being maimed and worse.
A totally false dichotomy - daily stop and search for you won't stop that, there is actual data that proves it doesn't.

Moobae · 15/01/2023 01:32

Abigail69 · 14/01/2023 17:39

No but I'm not white and have experience first hand around 30 years ago rudness. However, I now feel that times have changed and with the advent of mobile phones/cams/cctv and police officers wearing cams, it is the way forward

When me and my OH got stopped, unfairly in our view as we did not breach a red light - the officer was having none of it and we stayed calm and soon understood it was no good arguing. We complained to the chief of please in a cnocse manner and explained the facts and that the officer may have not had a good angle view and gussed. We were sent an apology. IMO, if we argued and argued the officer would have called up backup etc. Even when we went down with the papers to the police station, the cahp at the front desk, at best lacked skills but the man/woman at the top saw through this, It should not have happened and I hear you but I'm fed up with the street crime/etc.

You are aware camera footage often gets “lost” when you make complaints about incidents.?

SnowyPetals · 15/01/2023 01:56

So as far as I am concerned It is perfectly fine for the police to target the demographic that is more likely to be in these gangs.

And therein lies the destruction that S&S does to community relations. Bet this poster doesn't have many young black men in their family, that they would be "perfectly fine" with being searched several times a week.

ClivePowermax · 15/01/2023 02:16

Do not "wish" but act proactively via your actions and speech and challenge the wrongs and accept what may not be perfect but a driver of good

I spend my working life doing just that, thank you. And a good portion of my non-work life, too. I live and work in the real world. Stop and search is not a "driver of good." If you truly believe it is, and you're entitled to, then you're naive at best. I hope the bubble never bursts for you.

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/01/2023 02:19

SnowyPetals · 15/01/2023 01:56

So as far as I am concerned It is perfectly fine for the police to target the demographic that is more likely to be in these gangs.

And therein lies the destruction that S&S does to community relations. Bet this poster doesn't have many young black men in their family, that they would be "perfectly fine" with being searched several times a week.

And the irony is that the young black men who are just going about their business have both a harder time with the police AND a harder time with the young men involved in trouble than OP and her family. It's very hard to keep your education on track, keep your nose clean and be successful if there's social and economic inequality all around you.

As well as the fact that youthful indiscretions are more likely to turn into criminal convictions if you are in the wrong demographic. You only have to read the cocaine/cannabis threads on here to see that the whole of MN would have a criminal record if middle class, white women were S&S regularly. Turning a kid with a bit of temporary recreational use of drugs into a criminal. When MC white kids are free to go off to university, take a shit ton of drugs, get good jobs, still do a line or two of blow on the weekends and slag off the drug problem in their trendy bit of London with a glass of lovely Semillon in their hand. While feeling desperately urban chic and edgy.

That turned into a rant...

JamSandle · 15/01/2023 02:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh shut up. Do you think no white person in the world has been subject to police brutality....not in say...Russia for example?

Eyerollcentral · 15/01/2023 02:29

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/01/2023 17:31

Are you black?

Because having lived through the shit that was various police forces in the UK in the recent past, I wouldn't trust them as far as I could throw them.

Young black men around my way in living memory were sewing their pockets shut so they couldn't be planted and being beaten up in the back of vans for talking back.

No thanks.

Yes @Abigail69 I agree with @MrsTerryPratchett. It’s a dangerous game giving police yet more powers. I grew up in Belfast during the troubles and enhanced police powers meant harassment of people in Catholic/republican communities was relentless You cannot understand that unless you have lived. History shows time and again that minority communities will be disproportionately targeted. You sound but naive I am afraid to say.

mathanxiety · 15/01/2023 02:30

Yeah, because stop and search has always worked really well wherever it's been tried, with no adverse effects whatsoever....

Hmm
mathanxiety · 15/01/2023 02:31

YYY @Simonjt

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/01/2023 02:32

Good example @Eyerollcentral

And yes, much too easy to abuse.

Eyerollcentral · 15/01/2023 02:32

SharonEllis · 14/01/2023 17:45

They already have adequate stop & search powers if they have information. S&S on basis of poor intelligence just causes huge community conflict & makes it harder for the police to do their job. Policing depends on trust. The problem isnt lack of S&S its lack of quality police officers & resources to do their job

Totally agree with this post

mathanxiety · 15/01/2023 02:36

@Florenz

So how do you get started on a criminal record?

Swipe left for the next trending thread