Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Waterboarding in top public school

124 replies

Jumblymother · 20/12/2022 00:21

Theres a whiff in Kent amongst year 11s…..
3 or 4 very sporty boys were caught at a top public school waterboarding another child. School expelled them yet they magically and mysteriously all found places at a local highly selective state school which is above PAN.
After hearing that, how do you explain to that to your own 16 year old son?
It’s not just tittle tattle, I witnessed a staff member of the public school being asked about it. They acknowledged it happened but immediately cut the conversation dead and moved away from the people talking about it.
How did the boys get places at an over subscribed state school after being expelled for torture?
Like I said, there’s a whiff….

OP posts:
FancyFanny · 20/12/2022 12:45

What would you like to happen to these boys then?

AussiUnHomme · 20/12/2022 13:00

Gosh OP you do sound awfully bitter, given you have no real information apart from conjecture and gossip.

Jumblymother · 20/12/2022 13:04

@FancyFanny Good question which I don’t really know the answer to.

Thats why I thought -AIBU?

If it were one child then I would have thought - I’m glad the public school expelled them but they are a child and need an education to need to go somewhere.

But it was a group of them that found places in one school which is over subscribed. That’s my point.

OP posts:
Needtoseethatbiggerpicture · 20/12/2022 13:22

Is it your child who has been waterboarded, OP? I am struggling to understand why you are so.angry about this. There was likely room in year 11 for all the reasons already discussed. Trying to complete their GCSEs now will be a nightmare, regardless of the calibre of school they have entered. They have been excluded for their behaviour in their other school. Presumably, the police have been involved. What else do you want to to happen?

Elleherd · 20/12/2022 14:45

Please don't call things waterboarding if they're not. I actually suffered it repeatedly as a child. (though I didn't know it had a name) It left me with a damaged gag reflex, damaged lungs and a suspicion of some brain damage. I'm still paying decades later.
Yes private schools tend to have good relationships with other private schools and selective and grammer schools. It's part of a private schools remit to ensure that children they (for whatever reasons) no longer want, go to reasonable education and aren't just chucked out. These days state schools do the same with managed moves etc.
We long ago realised that the quickest way to turn kids who've done something bad or stupid into failures, drop outs, or suicides, is to apply punishments that they can't really recover from and will effect them very long term if not for life.

I should think the school that's taken them is glad of some well educated (little bastards that need watching) transfers that will do reasonably well in exams.

It's the way it goes, and you'd be better off teaching your son that imo.

Jumblymother · 20/12/2022 17:26

@Elleherd - when did I say that I wanted the perpetrators to be given a punishment that they wouldn’t recover from?

My AIBU was how did an over subscribed school suddenly have place for 3 or 4 places when others are on a waiting list to join?

I said waterboarding because I meant that word. I know what it means.

Thats why it was so horrific.

I am truly sorry that you experienced it and have suffered life long trauma from it.

Thats my point.

There are independent colleges (once upon a time called Crammers) where children received care and great education. But there wasn’t the prestige of another top school with all the trips and exciting bits. Children still went on to good universities and careers (I know - I have a couple of good friends this happened to). If the parents of the children I’m talking about were paying 40K for a place at the original school - they can probably afford other options other than their child going to a school where others are on a waiting list.

Finishing your education at an Independent College said something to the rest of the student population. But it is still an education where a child can get qualifications.

Others have explained that that there may be spaces as others don’t want to move mid GCSEs but please don’t suggest that I wanted any child to become without hope or suicidal. That is not what I wrote.

OP posts:
Greatly · 20/12/2022 17:30

Why are you so invested??

Greatly · 20/12/2022 17:31

Is your ds on the waiting list? Presumably he must be in which case I can understand that you are pissed off but seriously, you need to let it go.

Jumblymother · 20/12/2022 18:02

@greatly I’m invested because it’s hard enough raising teenagers not to be idiots (particularly in front of their mates).

Yes I am the boring parent who challenges banter.

Maybe I’m wrong in being seriously frustrated by the inequalities in the state education system.

I think any parent should be invested in all teenagers seeing that there are long term consequences for bullying and worse.

OP posts:
edwinbear · 20/12/2022 18:08

You don't know that these boys didn't meet the entry requirements though OP. If they've come from a selective independent school, there is every likelihood they will have. For all you know, they sat for Y7, passed, and declined for a private offer.

edwinbear · 20/12/2022 18:13

And in terms of being annoyed that private school kids are taking up places in state school when their parents can afford to pay. Wait until Labour introduce VAT on school fees. There will be c.90,000 private school kids moving out of private schools and taking up spaces in the state system.

MarshaMelrose · 20/12/2022 18:30

Why would there be a waiting list to join year 11 half way though the last academic year. Surely everyone's settled in their schools? But I guess a child with no school would take precedence over a child who just would like to transfer.

timefortinsel · 20/12/2022 18:49

OP, how do you know for a fact that there was / is a waiting list at this point in Year 11? What child would choose to move school at that point? They are probably doing their GCSE mocks! They literally have a term left before study leave, etc.

What I am saying is that there may well be waiting lists for Years 7, 8 and 9 - maybe even a waiting list for joining Year 10 (though to a much lesser extent). But who would be in s waiting list for mid Year 11? To join a school at Xmas Year 11 would only happen for those for whom there is no other option - ie. expelled from somewhere else.

Put it this way, even if my child was being severely bullied at this point Year 11, I would just home or remote school for the Spring term. I certainly wouldn't try to push them into another school just for a term. The disruption would not be worth it.

weRone · 20/12/2022 18:58

what baffles me most is that the boys (3 or 4 of them) were all transferred together. I thought the bully group should have been split up. What private school was it OP?

Ericaequites · 20/12/2022 19:44

Big washing is not cute. It is assault, and should lead to immediate expulsion with prejudice when proven.

Ericaequites · 20/12/2022 19:48

Across the pond, some students are far more equal than others at private schools. A bribe/donation can cover much bad behavior.

Keyansier · 20/12/2022 20:27

Ericaequites · 20/12/2022 19:48

Across the pond, some students are far more equal than others at private schools. A bribe/donation can cover much bad behavior.

Gladyou mentioned this - it was something I wanted to say in my other posts but forgot. Compared to day schools: Boarding schools- you are either at the very top, or you're not. Hierarchy isn't stacked similar in the same way in a school where you can go home and spend time with your family each night. Dorms are the WORST. No escape. I genuinely think (I'm including myself in this) that guys who were sent to boarding schools are a little tapped from it in their heads (through no fault of their own).

Greatly · 20/12/2022 21:34

Jumblymother · 20/12/2022 18:02

@greatly I’m invested because it’s hard enough raising teenagers not to be idiots (particularly in front of their mates).

Yes I am the boring parent who challenges banter.

Maybe I’m wrong in being seriously frustrated by the inequalities in the state education system.

I think any parent should be invested in all teenagers seeing that there are long term consequences for bullying and worse.

Really? I have absolutely zero clue about any drama in any other school than my dds. The idea I should be invested in a bunch of random teenagers at schools that have nothing to do with me is laughable.

Elleherd · 20/12/2022 22:28

Jumblymother
I said waterboarding because I meant that word. I know what it means.
Fair play to you. I apologise for assuming otherwise when you didn't pick up on the question earlier.
It's really disturbing to hear of kids doing this. I'm not suggesting what was assumed, (shoving someone's head down the bog and flushing) isn't horrible and serious bullying, but it is possible for it to be spontaneous stupidity following old so called traditions (of bullying) whereas actual waterboarding requires more planning on the part of those doing it and isn't to the best of my knowledge considered anyone's tradition. I can understand your disbelief that they can do that and appear to be easily educationally accommodated despite it.

I hope the police were brought in. It wasn't really understood when I was child, but even then it was seen as an extreme, dangerous and weird thing to do, and a reason to take a child away, but nowadays it has a name and is rightly understood as intended torture and associated for most with extreme regimes attempting to extract information by using it.

Kent seems to have very different education systems, but what I do know is if the receiving school is an academy the rules are very different, and I wouldn't be that surprised to find the private school had agreed to pay the other school for these boys education which might get around all sorts of things perfectly legally.
Certainly that's where I'd be looking if I was trying to understand what was going on, and I'd be looking at what the previous relationship between the schools (if any) was if I wanted to follow it all up.
I hope the child it was done to is as ok as they can be. Sad

Elleherd · 20/12/2022 22:33

Ps no intention to suggest YOU wanted any child to become without hope or suicidal. Just that we as a society had moved on from a model of punishment in education and expulsion that often lead to it.

mummytoalfie07 · 29/05/2023 22:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

alfie2019 · 29/05/2023 22:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

mummytoalfie07 · 29/05/2023 23:01

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

alfie2019 · 29/05/2023 23:05

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page