Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Waterboarding in top public school

124 replies

Jumblymother · 20/12/2022 00:21

Theres a whiff in Kent amongst year 11s…..
3 or 4 very sporty boys were caught at a top public school waterboarding another child. School expelled them yet they magically and mysteriously all found places at a local highly selective state school which is above PAN.
After hearing that, how do you explain to that to your own 16 year old son?
It’s not just tittle tattle, I witnessed a staff member of the public school being asked about it. They acknowledged it happened but immediately cut the conversation dead and moved away from the people talking about it.
How did the boys get places at an over subscribed state school after being expelled for torture?
Like I said, there’s a whiff….

OP posts:
FancyFanny · 20/12/2022 09:37

SnowlayRoundabout · 20/12/2022 09:30

Most of these super selectives will snap up GCSE year kids expelled from top privates because 6 months before exams, they are likely to get top grades and will boost the school performance.

Unlikely. The chances of the selective schools doing the same GCSE syllabuses for the same exam boards at the same pace and in the same order as the public schools are, realistically, nil.

Why? There really aren't many exams boards and the GCSE exams are all sat at the same time whether public or state- and actually, top grammar schools often have higher achieving pupils than private schools.

Getoff · 20/12/2022 09:39

As I said upthread, this is an issue for the police and for SS. What’s going on in the children’s home lives to turn them into such sadists?

I assumed (perhaps wrongly) that the private school was a boarding school. In that case, if my experience is relevant, their "home life" is being at school in a lord-of-the-flies scenario where the biggest boys are in charge, and adults supervision is rare outside of classrooms and sports coaching. Their parents will just be strangers they see in the holidays.

Every boarding school thread I've ever seen on here, 95% of (presumably) mothers say schools aren't like this any more. I'm reminded of the scene in "Another Country" where one character says something like "if only parents knew what goes on", to which the reply is "the fathers know."

Tigofigo · 20/12/2022 09:40

Another reason why selective state schools shouldn't exist

Why not contact the school and ask them OP? You could do a FOI request.

Sugargliderwombat · 20/12/2022 09:41

School admissions go through the local authority - headteachers don't have the power to do what you are suggesting.

MilkyYay · 20/12/2022 09:41

Unlikely. The chances of the selective schools doing the same GCSE syllabuses for the same exam boards at the same pace and in the same order as the public schools are, realistically, nil.

Top privates will have covered all the syllabus by dec year 11. There's a huge amount of overlap between exam boards in subjects like maths, science, geography, english language & MFL. These kids will have been exceptionally well prepared for subjects with specific texts/themes like english and history and are still likely to out perform the averages.

Greatly · 20/12/2022 09:42

Getoff · 20/12/2022 09:39

As I said upthread, this is an issue for the police and for SS. What’s going on in the children’s home lives to turn them into such sadists?

I assumed (perhaps wrongly) that the private school was a boarding school. In that case, if my experience is relevant, their "home life" is being at school in a lord-of-the-flies scenario where the biggest boys are in charge, and adults supervision is rare outside of classrooms and sports coaching. Their parents will just be strangers they see in the holidays.

Every boarding school thread I've ever seen on here, 95% of (presumably) mothers say schools aren't like this any more. I'm reminded of the scene in "Another Country" where one character says something like "if only parents knew what goes on", to which the reply is "the fathers know."

Oh fgs 😂

Getoff · 20/12/2022 09:43

What’s going on in the children’s home lives to turn them into such sadists?

I lost track of the point I was trying to make in my last post. The point was supposed to be that in a boarding school, boys may be being raised by other boys, not their families.

Tigofigo · 20/12/2022 09:45

Sugargliderwombat · 20/12/2022 09:41

School admissions go through the local authority - headteachers don't have the power to do what you are suggesting.

I'm not sure this is the case for academies.

edwinbear · 20/12/2022 09:53

OP you don’t actually know the facts though do you. The only facts you know are that a) some children have been expelled b) they’ve been able to join a local state school. Everything else is just gossip.

Itstoocoldoutthere · 20/12/2022 09:58

I think the public vs state school debate here is completely unfounded. Equally bad bullying, including bog washing, also happens regularly in state schools. It is not a new thing either as I was bullied badly in my selective state grammar back in the 1970s. It was happening in my DCs state schools in the 1990s and 2000s so YABU.

KimberleyClark · 20/12/2022 10:01

Except that at public boarding schools pupils are more vulnerable simply because they are there all the time.

SnowlayRoundabout · 20/12/2022 10:03

FancyFanny · 20/12/2022 09:37

Why? There really aren't many exams boards and the GCSE exams are all sat at the same time whether public or state- and actually, top grammar schools often have higher achieving pupils than private schools.

Because, say, exam board A sets the Tudors and Stuarts for history GCSE and exam board B does the 20th century. Board A sets Macbeth, Eliot, Lawrence and Amis for English Lit, Board B sets Romeo and Juliet, Hardy, Fitzgerald and Atwood. If both schools choose board B, the first one nevertheless covers those authors in a different order from the second one. School A offers science as three different GCSEs, school B offers it as two. And so on.

gourmetperle · 20/12/2022 10:56

If you are talking about actual waterboarding why on earth weren't the police involved?! That is really awful.

thinkponk48 · 20/12/2022 10:58

There is every chance it's just a story. Don't get too worked up

Legoninjago1 · 20/12/2022 11:12

Getoff · 20/12/2022 09:43

What’s going on in the children’s home lives to turn them into such sadists?

I lost track of the point I was trying to make in my last post. The point was supposed to be that in a boarding school, boys may be being raised by other boys, not their families.

Well I'll add my voice to the 95% you mentioned earlier. They're nothing like they any more.
Moreover, nobody has said this is a boarding school. In fact, it is highly unlikely to be given the story is that all the boys then bought their way into the same selective state school in the same area.
Sounds all a bit far fetched to me.

Jumblymother · 20/12/2022 11:16

This is it.

How did they have spaces for a group?

But I suppose AIBU for being furious that this has all been hushed up? The member of staff from the public school was terrified when asked about it at a social gathering. Terrified because the staff had been warned by the school.

I want to call it out. The privilege that some are born into means that they can damage another human being and move with their mates to another prestigious school.

What does it teach their peers?

It may be that life is like that and it’s a life lesson but so are a great many other things that are now seen by society as wholly wrong.

Kent County Council fail a lot of children when it comes to children so why have they been able to make these louts a priority over other more vulnerable children who need appropriate schooling?

If we teach teenagers that they can just move on to another prestigious after such cruel behaviour, then what are we teaching the leaders of tomorrow?

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 20/12/2022 11:21

That’s horrific but unsurprising.

Having worked in independent schools and also having my children attend them, I’m absolutely aghast at the level of bullying pupils are allowed to get away with.

The schools shit themselves in case the bullies and their siblings are pulled out. So if you’re being bullied by a rich family or a family with multiple siblings, you’re absolutely screwed.

RegularNameChangerVersion21 · 20/12/2022 11:47

The private school is naturally going to cover it up because it's going to put any parent off paying a fortune to send their child there. I'd at least be satisfied they expelled the culprits.

Most prestigous grammar schools have a very strict and transparent admissions process which is open to scrutiny. It's obviously not a fair system but I don't think it's open to overt cheating in the way you're suggesting. If anything private schools have more power to reject a student due to their behaviour record than a state school.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 20/12/2022 11:52

If anything private schools have more power to reject a student due to their behaviour record than a state school.

They definitely have more power but it doesn’t mean they do especially if they have too much to lose financially.

FancyFanny · 20/12/2022 12:02

So what you want OP, is that these teenagers, having been expelled from their private school, are only allowed to go to schools that are low in the league tables? It makes no sense. When a child is permanently excluded from a state school, the LA will allocate them a place in another school- they don't choose the new school for them based on it's performance- they don't punish children by sending them to worst school in the area...

RegularNameChangerVersion21 · 20/12/2022 12:05

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 20/12/2022 11:52

If anything private schools have more power to reject a student due to their behaviour record than a state school.

They definitely have more power but it doesn’t mean they do especially if they have too much to lose financially.

True. I imagine it depends on the school and historically they've certainly tolerated or even encouraged horific behaviour.

Greatly · 20/12/2022 12:05

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 20/12/2022 11:52

If anything private schools have more power to reject a student due to their behaviour record than a state school.

They definitely have more power but it doesn’t mean they do especially if they have too much to lose financially.

They tend to take the other families money into account as well. If bad behaviour is impacting many paying students then they tend to get chucked out.

FancyFanny · 20/12/2022 12:13

why have they been able to make these louts a priority over other more vulnerable children who need appropriate schooling?

But are there really vulnerable children who now don't have an appropriate school place because of this? Not likely.

Jumblymother · 20/12/2022 12:20

No. He was offered a place at the state school and we turned it down.

I’m not spreading tittle tattle due to sour grapes.

I want all of the children who want a place at that school to have an equal chance if they meet the entry requirements.

It matters to everyone with 16 year olds who are trying to bring them up to see other people as equal independent of their family’s resources and want my kids to feel strong enough to challenge those are privileged and bully.

Like it or not, there is still a toxic air of ‘boys will be boys’…. Especially if you’re good at things like sport and raise the profile of the school.

I AM NOT implying any money has ever changed hands for bribery…..

More wonder if this is a case of the old boys network…..

OP posts:
Legoninjago1 · 20/12/2022 12:33

Jumblymother · 20/12/2022 12:20

No. He was offered a place at the state school and we turned it down.

I’m not spreading tittle tattle due to sour grapes.

I want all of the children who want a place at that school to have an equal chance if they meet the entry requirements.

It matters to everyone with 16 year olds who are trying to bring them up to see other people as equal independent of their family’s resources and want my kids to feel strong enough to challenge those are privileged and bully.

Like it or not, there is still a toxic air of ‘boys will be boys’…. Especially if you’re good at things like sport and raise the profile of the school.

I AM NOT implying any money has ever changed hands for bribery…..

More wonder if this is a case of the old boys network…..

Meaning what though? The old boys of this local public school now work in the admissions office at Kent County Council and are doing these lads' dads a favour? Is your 16 yr old DS really interested/ bothered by the fact that these boys all allegedly got into a state school which you claim offered him a place which you then turned down?