Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Waterboarding in top public school

124 replies

Jumblymother · 20/12/2022 00:21

Theres a whiff in Kent amongst year 11s…..
3 or 4 very sporty boys were caught at a top public school waterboarding another child. School expelled them yet they magically and mysteriously all found places at a local highly selective state school which is above PAN.
After hearing that, how do you explain to that to your own 16 year old son?
It’s not just tittle tattle, I witnessed a staff member of the public school being asked about it. They acknowledged it happened but immediately cut the conversation dead and moved away from the people talking about it.
How did the boys get places at an over subscribed state school after being expelled for torture?
Like I said, there’s a whiff….

OP posts:
meditrina · 20/12/2022 08:58

anexcellentwoman · 20/12/2022 08:33

I just don't believe a Local Authority school would absorb four new students in these circumstances. If you think rules are being broken ask for clarification on the admissions policy. Go to your local councillors and ask that they investigate a possible breach of the school's admissions policy. Report a breach of the school's admissions policy to Ofsted . The school's admissions policy will be on its website and the school would not dare breach it for fear of someone reporting it.

If indeed it is full in the relevant year group, OP also needs to know if all local schools are also full in that year group.

If they are, then FAP would have been used. No breach of the rules in those circs

oakleaffy · 20/12/2022 08:59

VioletLemon · 20/12/2022 00:26

That sounds horrific and I'm glad these entitled little shits have been expelled. Hope investigation happens as there are bound to have been a long lead up. The victims will need help. Sadly money is no substitute for actually parenting your kids and not outsourcing that to a private boarding/day school. Some of these kids have worse attachment disorders and low resilience than inner city schemes.

Agreed.
One of the top public schools in England {Friend's brother was a scholarship day boy there when we were kids}
A boarder left out of an upper window fracturing two ankles.
Chalk graffiti said ''Do better, next time {Name of victim}''
Terrible bullying.
Also a very sporty school.

oakleaffy · 20/12/2022 09:00

Edit: Leapt, not left.

KimberleyClark · 20/12/2022 09:00

If it was the actual torture definition of waterboarding they should have been charged with a criminal offence.

meditrina · 20/12/2022 09:01

WoosteriaLane · 20/12/2022 08:57

Is drowning a child in a toilet, "bog washing"? What an adorable name for the feeling of drowning while being humiliated by your peers. And how unsurprising that several of you seem to see no real issue with it and use the silly little name for it.

There's your answer OP. People thing their little darlings acting like cunts is no big deal. Especially if they can afford to buy their way out of it.

I see a great deal wrong with it.

I do not however equate it to waterboarding.

It's no worse a nickname for the act than say shop-lifting or twocking, for theft, or joyriding for theft+dangerous driving. Knowing the vernacular doesn't mean I support any of the actions

FrancescaContini · 20/12/2022 09:01

WoosteriaLane · 20/12/2022 08:57

Is drowning a child in a toilet, "bog washing"? What an adorable name for the feeling of drowning while being humiliated by your peers. And how unsurprising that several of you seem to see no real issue with it and use the silly little name for it.

There's your answer OP. People thing their little darlings acting like cunts is no big deal. Especially if they can afford to buy their way out of it.

Quite. It’s appalling.

”Oh, it was all the rage in the 90s! Bog washing is nothing - my husband was put in a cupboard and set on fire when he boarded!!”

As I said upthread, this is an issue for the police and for SS. What’s going on in the children’s home lives to turn them into such sadists?

Legoninjago1 · 20/12/2022 09:02

If it's true then your ire should be directed at the school admissions dept of the council surely? Water boarding sounds dreadful. Bloody hell. I had my head shoved into a toilet at one boarding school. But my godson saw a boy stabbed to the point of life changing injuries outside his inner city comp. Kids' violence is not a 'top public school' issue. Your title is trying to push the argument in one particular direction.

Scepticalwotsits · 20/12/2022 09:04

WoosteriaLane · 20/12/2022 08:57

Is drowning a child in a toilet, "bog washing"? What an adorable name for the feeling of drowning while being humiliated by your peers. And how unsurprising that several of you seem to see no real issue with it and use the silly little name for it.

There's your answer OP. People thing their little darlings acting like cunts is no big deal. Especially if they can afford to buy their way out of it.

No one has said that

FrancescaContini · 20/12/2022 09:05

Jumblymother · 20/12/2022 07:59

My AIBU is not with the public school. They dealt with it. There were sanctions.
My AIBU is - AIBU to be furious that a state school which is over PAN suddenly have 3 or 4 places available for children who suddenly found themselves without a place at school?
Of course they need education and a second chance but who pulled the strings to get them a place all together at an over subscribed school where others are on a waiting list?
I care because it’s hard enough telling a 16 year old not to be an idiot with their friends - to stand out from the crowd and challenge obnoxious behaviour.
Bit he now knows that it depends on who you are (or who your parents are)

For those who think it’s a bit of banter and it’s character building….

What?!?!

Its bullying.

It’s damaging and can have long term consequences for the person it happens to.

I can’t believe you’re more outraged by the school places issue than by the sadistic, criminal behaviour you refer to.

Legoninjago1 · 20/12/2022 09:10

Quite @FrancescaContini
Presumably OP's son tried to get into the school and didn't and that's why she's spreading this?

NewToWoo · 20/12/2022 09:13

Anotherlamp · 20/12/2022 06:28

Or does “Whiff” imply Whitgift? In which case it would be another superselective having to take the pupils.

Are there two Whitgifts? teh one I know is not in Kent and is independent. But also has form for taking pupils expelled elsewhere for really nasty behaviour.

FrancescaContini · 20/12/2022 09:14

Legoninjago1 · 20/12/2022 09:10

Quite @FrancescaContini
Presumably OP's son tried to get into the school and didn't and that's why she's spreading this?

Yes, I think so. The word “waterboarding” is used very glibly in the thread title yet the first post focuses on potential “scandal” around school places.

Halfway through his/her second post, the OP turns attention to the issue of bullying, only once other posters have focused on this glaring issue rather than the school places.

FFS

SnowlayRoundabout · 20/12/2022 09:23

Being over PAN doesn't necessarily mean that every year group is oversubscribed. By Year 11 there are often a few gaps because people have left due to normal pupil movement but haven't been replaced for various reasons. Also it's easier to fit extra bodies into Year 11 anyway because class groups tend to be smaller for different subjects. These boys may well struggle to get into Year 12 because changing schools in year 11 is potentially fairly disastrous for GCSE results.

TulipCat · 20/12/2022 09:24

You seem to be conflating your dislike of the public school system with the actual issue here. A small group of Y11 boys have been expelled from school for violent behaviour. Good, and appropriate. They need somewhere to finish their education at short notice. You are unhappy that they have remained as a group (I agree with this, that seems unwise). But you are mainly unhappy that they have got places at a selective school you think is full. How do you know it is full? Have you tried to get in-year places there for your son and been turned away? Why does your son care- what's the connection to this state school for him if it isn't that he wanted to go there and didn't get in?

Keyansier · 20/12/2022 09:24

PicaNewName · 20/12/2022 06:44

I bloody hope you're joking.

No, I'm not joking?? Confused Boys boarding schools are hell on earth. I wouldn't send my worst enemy's son to one. I don't know if girls boarding schools are like it, or if schooling has changed now, but they are a different kind of experience and I have been to both boarding school and day school and boarding school is a different kind of hellscape. I can guarantee that even though I have not met the partners of @Simonjt and @AngelicaElizaAndPeggy that if I did, and we got onto the subject, we could relate and share similar experiences and feelings despite whichever schools we each went to. It's kind of like Fight Club. Actually, it's a lot like Fight Club.

MilkyYay · 20/12/2022 09:25

I'm assuming the issue is the highly selective state school suddenly finding spaces for rich kids when they didn't have space to take hard working kids with less affluent parents.

This. This happened where i live too. A very famous individual moved to the area. The highly selective grammar immediately found places for both his kids despite having a waiting list. They are an academy so of course their admissions are their own business.

Most of these super selectives will snap up GCSE year kids expelled from top privates because 6 months before exams, they are likely to get top grades and will boost the school performance.

Its disgusting.

MilkyYay · 20/12/2022 09:26

I just don't believe a Local Authority school would absorb four new students in these circumstances

Most selective state schools are academy not local authority, and control their own admission criteria. The local council won't get involved.

SnowlayRoundabout · 20/12/2022 09:29

OP, have you asked the head and governors of the state school in question why they took these boys?

SnowlayRoundabout · 20/12/2022 09:30

Most of these super selectives will snap up GCSE year kids expelled from top privates because 6 months before exams, they are likely to get top grades and will boost the school performance.

Unlikely. The chances of the selective schools doing the same GCSE syllabuses for the same exam boards at the same pace and in the same order as the public schools are, realistically, nil.

Purplecatshopaholic · 20/12/2022 09:33

This sounds like a lesson for your son that Money Talks (it does), and Life isn’t Fair (it isn’t). If this happened as you say, I don’t approve, but I am not surprised, not at all…

euff · 20/12/2022 09:34

Although the school may be oversubscribed could there have been places available in year 11? I'm thinking not many people would be keen to move schools from year 9 up so if they have spaces due to people leaving the area etc they may not have been filled in the same way as if spaces became available in year 7/8?

I wouldn't want those boys joining my school and would hope that if it was serious there were more repercussions that just being expelled. I don't really understand the people commenting about the difference between bog washing and water boarding like one is just a minor thing. Sadly it wouldn't surprise me if what you think happened did happen but that's because we know these things do happen and people with money often do get away with things. Not a lesson I want my DC to have to learn, it shouldn't be the way but it is so they will have to learn.

FancyFanny · 20/12/2022 09:35

So you actually think a state school accepted a monetary bribe to take these boys? Really?

MilkyYay · 20/12/2022 09:35

”Oh, it was all the rage in the 90s! Bog washing is nothing - my husband was put in a cupboard and set on fire when he boarded!!”

As I said upthread, this is an issue for the police and for SS. What’s going on in the children’s home lives to turn them into such sadists?

The point being at boarding school they aren't home much and a house master is no substitute for a loving parent. My D friend boarded and the lack of adult supervision of teens led to some horrifying things. Lots pressured to explore sexual activities very, very young, ALL the drugs and alcohol, lots of watching horrendous hardcore porn & violent content on laptops. Its like prison, these things are supposedly not allowed but are easily snuck in and concealed.

MilkyYay · 20/12/2022 09:37

So you actually think a state school accepted a monetary bribe to take these boys? Really?

Isn't the implication that they are bending over backwards to take these posh kids who are likely to get top grades in june having been hothoused in a top private for years, but don't have space for other local kids.

Circe7 · 20/12/2022 09:37

It seems a bit unlikely to me that a state school (whose staff are typically left wing and anti private schools anyway) would go out of their way to take on a group of bullies just because their parents were rich enough to send them to private school. They probably had to take them. And we don’t know the facts of what happened anyway so it’s really not possible to judge how appropriate it was for the new school to take them.

Just because a state school is allowed to be academically selective it shouldn’t necessarily be allowed to select for behaviour.

Swipe left for the next trending thread