Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remove my kids from RHSP lessons?

231 replies

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 07:52

AIBU to ask if I am the only one who wants to do this? Has anyone here done this? Were there any negative consequences?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ExhaustedFlamingo · 11/12/2022 09:01

Rather than withdrawing your DC, I would initially ask the school for more information and if they're following Mermaids, I would challenge them, citing the recent investigation by the Charity Commission. Only withdraw your DC as a last possible measure.

Tiredallofthetime · 11/12/2022 09:03

I wouldn’t hesitate to do so. I don’t like or trust a lot of the content that is taught in schools.

LlynTegid · 11/12/2022 09:06

Please do not quietly withdraw your child from these lessons. If ultimately you decide to do so, make it very clear to the school why you are doing so, and let the Governors know as well.

Sugargliderwombat · 11/12/2022 09:07

I really think you should just ask to see the contents of the lessons. Plenty of people will ask that, I don't think you need to just pull them out straight away.

BatCheeseIsFine · 11/12/2022 09:09

The trouble is there is no evidence that anyone is born in the wrong body - it’s not scientific or verifiable and it shouldn’t be presented as fact, and certainly not as an unproblematic option for any child who doesn’t fit in with gender stereotypes. It also shouldn’t be “celebrated” and praised as if anyone who is “trans” is extra special and wonderful. And that is what’s happening. I have a 12yo girl, we’re in scotland - luckily (I hope) she now sees through it, I think starting periods and the way some boys behave has made her realise being female is a reality - but at about 10 she and all her friends had to have a gender identity or LBGTQ+++ status because it was uncool not to.

This wouldn’t be so bad if it was just seen as a cultural option like being a goth, or or it was like being gay where you can change your mind and no harm done. But there are massive harms awaiting children who go down this route - even if they remain happy with it they will be medicalised for life, and if they change their mind after surgery and hormones they’re left with horrific trauma - and it’s happening now. It’s wrong for anyone to tell kids this is all about feelings and true selves and wrong bodies - it’s not. It’s about mental health and misinformation. The most important thing kids should be learning is that angst and dissatisfaction about your body is very normal in adolescence and how to manage it and get through it, because it tends to resolve. That’s the scientific, tested reality.

I do agree kids should understand the equality act and the general moral responsibility not to persecute and discriminate against people because of various differences. But these differences do not include being born in the wrong body, just a set of beliefs about that which should be treated like other beliefs.

PaterPower · 11/12/2022 09:11

BatCheeseIsFine - your last post is spot on.

Krakinou · 11/12/2022 09:13

YABU as you should be having these conversations with your kids, especially girls. If you don’t believe in gender ideology (and I agree with you), you need to show that other perspective to your kids and teach them to think critically. Your kids might even disagree with you and be sucked in already, but it’s still part of raising functional well rounded adults that you teach them to respect and engage with other peoples beliefs.

There were plenty of times at school where I disagreed with my teachers on politics etc. That didn’t stop me listening to their thoughts on maths, science etc. In fact I think it’s beneficial for kids to question everything and look to understand rather than just learning by rote whatever the teacher tells them.

Pulling them out of classes would be completely counterproductive.

Isitsixoclockalready · 11/12/2022 09:16

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 08:12

I'm in Scotland yes.

I'm not concerned about the teaching of reproduction, I'd be very happy if these lessons stuck to facts and evidence but unfortunately they seem to be a highly politicised lobbying group. Schoolchildren don't need to learn about sex toys.

That's your answer right there - there is nothing 'bigotted' about having a concern over children being taught about sex toys. Reproduction, yes but that should be it.

pointythings · 11/12/2022 09:17

I think if you haven't bothered to ask what's actually in the lessons, you haven't got a leg to stand on.

Whatwouldscullydo · 11/12/2022 09:17

Thereluctantgrownup · 11/12/2022 08:31

Are you sure that this is what is discussed in these lessons?

What is the problem with children learning that some people feel they are born in the wrong body? It doesn't mean that your children are going to decide this applies to them too!

Sex and relationship education (not just the scientific/biological aspect) of reproduction is so important for children. The more they know, the more they are able to keep themselves safe from harm, abuse and inappropriate relationships as they grow up!

That is trsnsphobic I hope you know. The wrong body stuff is no longer used by even mermaids. Its considered transphobic.

Having just had ny dd sit through a pshe lesson ( im.in England) where there is no hope of being able to discuss inappropriate relationships becuase the words men woman boy and girl were not allowed to be used and therefore removes the ability to accurately discuss the situations.

Op is right to be concerned.

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 09:19

Krakinou - the very problem is that disagreement is not permitted. One example of this was a class in which they were taught that kids were born TQ+ one child put their hand up and said that the internet might have something to do with it, many of the kids in the class agreed and the teacher told them that neither they (the teacher) nor the students were allowed to talk about that. That's not education, that's indoctrination.

OP posts:
MsRosley · 11/12/2022 09:20

I just thank god my kids are too old for this to be an issue for me. I completely agree with you though, OP.

Maray1967 · 11/12/2022 09:20

What concerns me about the example you gave is the normalisation of anal sex in straight relationships- with the risk that girls/women who say no are pressurised into it with all the risks that comes with it. I’d be concerned about how that is being taught. A proper discussion of the physical risks women are running doing this needs to feature as well as ‘use lubricant’.
And yes - you need to query why there is any use of mermaids content.

Coolyule · 11/12/2022 09:20

You can’t ask for them to be withdrawn from lessons you don’t agree with when you haven’t seen the lessons. You need to ask to see the lessons and what is involved so you have a solid argument.

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 09:23

Maray1967- I found the sex toys and anal sex advice in the 'women and women' sex advice resources - you can visit LGBT Youth Scotland, it's a guide you can download under "resources"

OP posts:
BatCheeseIsFine · 11/12/2022 09:24

Another problem is that these ideas have been disseminated and embedded into schools and lessons now and many people have swallowed them, including teachers who now do see it as simplistically as being born in the wrong body. People who mean well and want to not be bigots still often understand it this way, even if the concept gets refined and discussed on Twitter and things move on, it’s there now and loads of people think it. It’s now the culture among many kids and in many schools to think someone is trans and “born in the wrong body” if they simply don’t fit a sex-based stereotype. And to say that to them, which in some cases they will go with and end up on a medical pathway, sometimes encouraged by parents who are either well-meaning or keen to have a special child. It’s a disaster for all these kids.

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 09:24

Coolyule - I don't trust that I will be shown the full lessons. And as I said that then requires the opening of a potentially long and complicated dialogue where I have to pick and choose which bits are acceptable and which aren't. I just want to not have to confront this

OP posts:
Msloverlover · 11/12/2022 09:29

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 11/12/2022 08:40

There's a big difference between saying some people in God, some people believe you can change sex and become a woman / man and saying God does exist and it possible to change sex. The first are presented as a range of beliefs which can be taught as part of a discussion and helps students to understand why others may make choices they wouldn't. The second is misleading, wrong and shouldn't happen in a RS or Sex Ed lesson (I teach both).

As to sex toys etc, I think it's fine, for older students, to be told that sex isn't always easy or like they see in films and there are things that consenting adults use to help, enhance the experience but actually, beyond contraception methods and lubricant which has a fairly boring, mechanical but important function, I wouldn't be teaching about other toys. Teaching time is limited and it goes further than is needed at school.

I don't know the rules in Scotland re withdrawing and I get your concerns about being labelled bigoted. I would talk to your child at home and widen the viewpoint.

Im also a teacher and have taught both. At my daughter’s c of e school, Christian beliefs are taught as fact. I am the one who explains that they are beliefs.

SuffolkUnicorn · 11/12/2022 09:29

I tried and was told he would have to have an RE lesson instead I said but you aren’t even a religious school 🙄

LlynTegid · 11/12/2022 09:29

Demand to see the full lessons, and if you are refused, then raise it as a safeguarding concern.

Frapped · 11/12/2022 09:32

I removed my children. They had already had a very good understanding of sex and relationships for years at that point. I was able to teach it in the old fashioned way that called vagina owners, "women" which I felt more comfortable with.

Whatwouldscullydo · 11/12/2022 09:33

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 09:24

Coolyule - I don't trust that I will be shown the full lessons. And as I said that then requires the opening of a potentially long and complicated dialogue where I have to pick and choose which bits are acceptable and which aren't. I just want to not have to confront this

I believe miriam cates recently discussed this theres a clip on the fwr board. I realise again its probably uk but what she did say was that schools were using copyright to hide behind with regards to sharing the material via email

However there is no such issue in person. So your best bet is to arrange a meeting to view the materials on the premises

BatCheeseIsFine · 11/12/2022 09:33

And yes as for inappropriate sex content - there is such a thing as TMI and misrepresenting what sex it meant to be like. It’s been pornified and essentially kids are being taught about things that used to be niche in a way that will make them think these are things they are expected to do.

I want my kids to have sex education but that should be about biology, how it works, what it’s for, how pregnancy happens and how to prevent it, and consent and that you can say no to anything you want to and that you must respect other people’s no. Not how to emulate porn. Not presenting sex a cool fun thing that you are expected to do in particular ways, or expected to do at all. And why the fuck has this happened? Someone is pushing it. It came from somewhere, and it came along with the trans stuff. I’m not blaming trans people themselves, but the movement and ideology is closely tied to “breaking down boundaries” in highly suspect ways and often seems to involve trying to explode kids to unsuitable sexualised stuff.

Frapped · 11/12/2022 09:34

I honestly can't see any harm at removing your child from any lesson as long as you are suitably explaining it at home.

Millana · 11/12/2022 09:35

Genuine questions.

I understand you don't want them to hear parts of it but there are some other bits that are really important but not mandatory eg relationships. How will you make sure that get those? It can be really helpful to go through those with peers, not your mum.

Also, they will be exposed to gender stuff irl. Surely letting them hear the one side with school and then discussing it with them at home and helping them to digest what has been said is more helpful than just removing them or them having half an idea?

Swipe left for the next trending thread