Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask about a trial involving multiple counts with same jury

79 replies

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 05:37

I've a specific case in mind, though the last thread on it was deleted here, so I'm not going to mention it specifically.

My question is about multiple counts against different victims (some against same victim).

Each charge holds different evidence. Each case, holds different evidence. In fact, a lot of the cases allege different methods of alleged criminality against different alleged victims (sorry, I'm trying to choose my words carefully here).

My question is this one. Are the jury asked to consider each count separately or are they asked to consider for example that while the weight of evidence for 2 counts out of 10 isn't strong enough with EMPHASIS ON "FOR EXAMPLE", that you should still reasonably conclude that those two counts are also to be considered to be proven?

I'm sorry if that post or question seems garbled.

I can try to clarify if the question doesn't seem clear.

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 05:44

I'm asking about the English court system btw.

OP posts:
BonesOfWhatYouBelieve · 26/10/2022 06:26

I see what you mean I think - like if the evidence individually isn't as strong for some of it (hypothetically), can the jury think something along the lines of "what are the chances that they are guilty of all the others but not this one if a pattern of behaviour has been shown?"

I don't know the legal answer but realistically I imagine any jury would find it hard to separate everything out. Even if they consciously tried to, their view of that person and one specific charge will clearly be influenced by everything else. I think I know the case you mean and if I had to guess I'd say legally they have to consider it all separately.

Double0FeckingBollocks · 26/10/2022 06:33

Please tell me you're not currently on jury duty OP!

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:10

Double0FeckingBollocks · 26/10/2022 06:33

Please tell me you're not currently on jury duty OP!

Oh hell no. I've never been on jury duty. It's just a current case and the question popped up in my mind as some of the evidence for some is compelling but some is more open to ambiguity but it's the same jury for all charges.

It's just a general question but it's a specific case which prompted the question.

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:12

Double0FeckingBollocks · 26/10/2022 06:33

Please tell me you're not currently on jury duty OP!

If I was on the jury, I'm sure I'd have been instructed what to do. I just don't know how the system works.

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:13

BonesOfWhatYouBelieve · 26/10/2022 06:26

I see what you mean I think - like if the evidence individually isn't as strong for some of it (hypothetically), can the jury think something along the lines of "what are the chances that they are guilty of all the others but not this one if a pattern of behaviour has been shown?"

I don't know the legal answer but realistically I imagine any jury would find it hard to separate everything out. Even if they consciously tried to, their view of that person and one specific charge will clearly be influenced by everything else. I think I know the case you mean and if I had to guess I'd say legally they have to consider it all separately.

That's precisely the question and I suppose I'm wondering is it fair on the jury or each of the individual alleged victims to have them all considered in one case?

OP posts:
AFS1 · 26/10/2022 07:14

They will be instructed to consider each count individually and to weigh up the evidence in support of that specific count. You often get verdicts where someone is convicted of some counts and not others. For example if there is corroborative evidence in support of some allegations, but not of others, they may convict only on those.

I suspect I know what case you’re talking about. There is inevitably a temptation for jurors to consider the case as a whole, but they will be told not to.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:17

It's a high profile current case involving a nurse. I'm pretty sure the question I asked is generic enough to not warrant deletion as I suspect that there are other cases where are a jury has to rule on similar.
I saw verdicts read out last week from a US shooting for e.g. Same shooter. 17 counts (I think). The same jury had to make the decision on all counts. However, in that case (US mass shooting), the murders all occurred during one event.

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:19

AFS1 · 26/10/2022 07:14

They will be instructed to consider each count individually and to weigh up the evidence in support of that specific count. You often get verdicts where someone is convicted of some counts and not others. For example if there is corroborative evidence in support of some allegations, but not of others, they may convict only on those.

I suspect I know what case you’re talking about. There is inevitably a temptation for jurors to consider the case as a whole, but they will be told not to.

Your last sentence is what I'm wondering too because so far, it's just the prosecution evidence that's being heard and they repeat a lot that 'this is something that you will hear throughout this trial' sort of thing (not verbatim quote).

OP posts:
AFS1 · 26/10/2022 07:30

They are told that the fact that they are sure of guilt on one allegation must not lead them to convicting on all of them. The Judge will spell that out in the summing up. And if there is a possibility of a medical cause of death in some of the cases and not others, they will have to think very carefully about whether they are sure of culpability in those ones. Not an easy task, and no-one will ever know how the jury actually analyse the case as a whole except for the 12 of them in the room.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:34

AFS1 · 26/10/2022 07:30

They are told that the fact that they are sure of guilt on one allegation must not lead them to convicting on all of them. The Judge will spell that out in the summing up. And if there is a possibility of a medical cause of death in some of the cases and not others, they will have to think very carefully about whether they are sure of culpability in those ones. Not an easy task, and no-one will ever know how the jury actually analyse the case as a whole except for the 12 of them in the room.

It must be a truly horrendous case to be involved in. A truly horrendous case for the parents and medical professionals too. I've discussed it briefly with a friend who is a doctor. The medical evidence so far presented is not unambiguous. There is intuition and there are obvious conclusions but God, this case? It's beyond belief in some ways.

OP posts:
DisplayPurposesOnly · 26/10/2022 07:35

Kind of. I was one of the jury involving three charges (three separate events), one complainant and one defendant.

I can't remember the exact words of the judge but it was to the effect that if we thought the defendant was guilty of one or more, we might consider this added evidence of guilt to the other charge(s).

We did debated all three charges - you can't not, as you have to give three verdicts - and we could well have concluded the defendant was a mix of guilty/not guilty.

AFS1 · 26/10/2022 07:36

I agree -it’s just heartbreakingly awful on every level. I suspect (and hope) the jury will be offered counselling at the end of it.

Jampage · 26/10/2022 07:38

I have 1st hand experience of this. Each count will be considered separately and will carry it's own separate charging sentence should the perpetrator be found guilty. It doesn't matter that some charges are thinner than others. At the end the jury will report their findings, one charge at a time.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:39

Jampage · 26/10/2022 07:38

I have 1st hand experience of this. Each count will be considered separately and will carry it's own separate charging sentence should the perpetrator be found guilty. It doesn't matter that some charges are thinner than others. At the end the jury will report their findings, one charge at a time.

It's an onerous task to set on a jury. It's not fair to the jury nor to the alleged victims.

OP posts:
Sandinmyknickers · 26/10/2022 07:42

You'd have to consider each count separately
I have been on jury duty (albeit a long time ago now!!) and I remember that we convicted guilty on the majority of charges, but not one, as there wasn't enough evidence for that (although we were all pretty sure that they were guilty of it, just on balance of evidence there wasn't enough). It didn't really matter im the grand scheme, or probably didn't affect their sentence though as it was a lesser charge compared to all the others(and it wasn't a multiple victims issue so I suppose there wasn't the emotional hit for a victim who technically didn't get a conviction)

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:43

DisplayPurposesOnly · 26/10/2022 07:35

Kind of. I was one of the jury involving three charges (three separate events), one complainant and one defendant.

I can't remember the exact words of the judge but it was to the effect that if we thought the defendant was guilty of one or more, we might consider this added evidence of guilt to the other charge(s).

We did debated all three charges - you can't not, as you have to give three verdicts - and we could well have concluded the defendant was a mix of guilty/not guilty.

That's hard. I suppose because it's almost like 'they have previous'? (I watch too many US shows lol).

OP posts:
OnTheBrinkOfChange · 26/10/2022 07:43

Isn't it pretty obvious that they will be asked at the end is the defendant guilty of killing A? Is the defendant guilty of killing B? Etc.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:44

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 26/10/2022 07:43

Isn't it pretty obvious that they will be asked at the end is the defendant guilty of killing A? Is the defendant guilty of killing B? Etc.

Why not have different trials for A and B then?

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:46

Why expect the same jury to make a decision on all counts against the same defendant?

OP posts:
Sandinmyknickers · 26/10/2022 07:46

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:44

Why not have different trials for A and B then?

Way less likely to get a conviction that way!
My trial i was on had two victims (but we found guilty for both), and the case the prosecution builds is often inextricably linked, it would be hard to evidence one without the other and it does add more weight and credibility to each charge....but you still need evidence aswell. But trying them together helps to combine evidence and narrative

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:48

Sandinmyknickers · 26/10/2022 07:46

Way less likely to get a conviction that way!
My trial i was on had two victims (but we found guilty for both), and the case the prosecution builds is often inextricably linked, it would be hard to evidence one without the other and it does add more weight and credibility to each charge....but you still need evidence aswell. But trying them together helps to combine evidence and narrative

That answers my question. If evidence is inextricably linked by showing a pattern for e.g., how then, can a jury separate each case?

OP posts:
Sandinmyknickers · 26/10/2022 07:51

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:48

That answers my question. If evidence is inextricably linked by showing a pattern for e.g., how then, can a jury separate each case?

I suppose don't think of it as separating each case. It's one case. But at the end you have to just break down the verdict and on balance of reasonable doubt are they guilty of each charge?
In a case with a high number fo victims it could means that someone doesn't technically get the conviction, but enough might stick at guilty that the guilty person gets sent away for a long long time!!!

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:52

I'm pretty sure that there are 22 charges in this case. There are not 22 victims involved (as some of the charges relate to the same victim). What if your family member (again, trying to be as neutral as I can) happens to be one of the alleged victims for whom the evidence isn't as compelling. Do you get me?

OP posts:
Fayrazzled · 26/10/2022 07:52

I’ve been on a jury and the judge will give the jurors very clear guidance as to how to reach their decision. One of the cases I was on was a sexual offence and we the jurors were given very clear, written guidance to follow in the deliberation room. It was almost step bu step: if you believe this, then this, then this. Jurors are also allowed to pass written notes to the judge during the case for the judge to answer as he/she sees fit.