Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask about a trial involving multiple counts with same jury

79 replies

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 05:37

I've a specific case in mind, though the last thread on it was deleted here, so I'm not going to mention it specifically.

My question is about multiple counts against different victims (some against same victim).

Each charge holds different evidence. Each case, holds different evidence. In fact, a lot of the cases allege different methods of alleged criminality against different alleged victims (sorry, I'm trying to choose my words carefully here).

My question is this one. Are the jury asked to consider each count separately or are they asked to consider for example that while the weight of evidence for 2 counts out of 10 isn't strong enough with EMPHASIS ON "FOR EXAMPLE", that you should still reasonably conclude that those two counts are also to be considered to be proven?

I'm sorry if that post or question seems garbled.

I can try to clarify if the question doesn't seem clear.

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:40

Intuition plays a lot in medicine. Not so much in a court of law.

OP posts:
sheepandcaravan · 26/10/2022 08:42

Scotland here OP.

We have a doctrine called Moorov which might interest you to read about.

Not exactly the same but explanations about how corroboration can occur by linking different offences by time and circumstance.

It's often, for example, used with sexual assault cases.

toastofthetown · 26/10/2022 08:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You said in the OP you didn’t want to discuss a specific case specifically but you very clearly do. Mumsnet take a very careful approach to threads on live trials as they can very quickly turn to contempt of court. Maybe you’d be better posting on Reddit or somewhere else which does allow live cases to be discussed.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:51

toastofthetown · 26/10/2022 08:50

You said in the OP you didn’t want to discuss a specific case specifically but you very clearly do. Mumsnet take a very careful approach to threads on live trials as they can very quickly turn to contempt of court. Maybe you’d be better posting on Reddit or somewhere else which does allow live cases to be discussed.

I'm not discussing details of the case.

OP posts:
toastofthetown · 26/10/2022 08:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 09:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Posting my view is not posting a detail of the case.

Posting a reported fact that one alleged victim did not have a post-mortem carried out is not me posting details already fully public and reported and commented on.

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 09:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What is your concern exactly about what I've posted? That I'll prejudice a case? If that's your concern, I suggest you report it. Nothing I have posted suggests a prejudice to either side of any case.

OP posts:
notdaddycool · 26/10/2022 09:10

It is interesting as becase there is overlap in the charges you don't need 99% the same trial many times, but when you hear that weight of evidence, there must be a chance that the sheer weight of allegations makes you think they must be guilty of at least a couple of the charges.

I had two teachers at school who were tried together for paedophilia, the one on the lesser charges successfully appealed on the basis that as their alleged crimes were not linked, (I think they may have assaulted the same boy but at different times and the assaults were not coordinated) they should not have been tried together as it made the jury more likely to see him as guilty by association. Don't even think he had a retrial, but did spend a couple of years behind bars.

Princessglittery · 26/10/2022 09:12

@TheNosehasit unless you attend court each day you cannot know all the evidence presented in any case. Some evidence can be photo’s, printed information, recordings of CCTV etc. which are not always shown to observers. Additionally a judge can decide whether or not the defendant(s) have previous convictions can be revealed to the jury.

In my case we found out afterwards the judge had refused numerous requests for us to be told about previous convictions.

As pp have said it is possible to have multiple charges against one victim e.g. assault and theft. In a criminal court a jury has to decide if it is beyond reasonable doubt they are guilty rather than civil courts where it is on the balance of probability. So a much higher threshold. This is why it is so hard to get a conviction in rape cases.

The media will tell the story they want from any trial and only present the evidence that supports their narrative, so you are not getting anything like a true picture of all the evidence being presented.

toastofthetown · 26/10/2022 09:13

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 09:04

What is your concern exactly about what I've posted? That I'll prejudice a case? If that's your concern, I suggest you report it. Nothing I have posted suggests a prejudice to either side of any case.

It was a passing comment on how you said in your OP that you didn’t want to mention a specific case, then in your comments went on to refer to that case. I’m not hugely concerned that it would prejudice a trial (unless people start identifying victims or start discussing materials which deliberately aren’t mentioned in the case that could prejudice a jury) or I wouldn’t have signposted you to somewhere the case is discussed freely! Just that MN do not like cases on live trials and if this thread becomes a thread about the Letby trial through the back door, then it will be deleted, which is a shame because the subject
of how and why people are tried as they are is an interesting one, current trials not withstanding. I won’t lose any sleep either way though.

x2boys · 26/10/2022 09:18

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:44

Why not have different trials for A and B then?

Because its all part of the same alleged "crime,s ,I'm pretty sure the other high profile nurse convicted of multiple murders in the early 90,s only had one trial too ,and she had to be found guily/ not guilty for each murder, attempted murder.

x2boys · 26/10/2022 09:21

toastofthetown · 26/10/2022 09:13

It was a passing comment on how you said in your OP that you didn’t want to mention a specific case, then in your comments went on to refer to that case. I’m not hugely concerned that it would prejudice a trial (unless people start identifying victims or start discussing materials which deliberately aren’t mentioned in the case that could prejudice a jury) or I wouldn’t have signposted you to somewhere the case is discussed freely! Just that MN do not like cases on live trials and if this thread becomes a thread about the Letby trial through the back door, then it will be deleted, which is a shame because the subject
of how and why people are tried as they are is an interesting one, current trials not withstanding. I won’t lose any sleep either way though.

There is another thread running currently about the trial ,posters are trying to just state facts as a few previous threads were deleted for speculation.

x2boys · 26/10/2022 09:29

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:53

Why then, are 22 counts and 17 alleged victims in the same trial?

I believe she has been accused of attempting to murder at least one of the babies on three occasions, each incident will have too be considered separately.

WeAreTheHeroes · 26/10/2022 10:25

@TheNosehasit if the jury believes there is a chance they didn't do Y either then that would mean the jury is not sure they did Y ergo they must find the defendant not guilty.

We cannot have a legal system where innocent people are found guilty and get a criminal record/lose their liberty as a consequence of insufficient proof of the facts. Even worse would be if there were still the death penalty. I firmly believe that one miscarriage of justice which results in the death of an innocent person makes the death penalty wholly wrong aside from any other arguments around it.

However awful the charges on the indictment and what the evidence seems to show, you cannot take a "no smoke without fire" approach. The jury decides the facts based on the evidence and the judge directs the jury as to what is needed to be sure the defendant is guilty of each charge.

Difficult cases go to jury trial because they are difficult cases.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 10:31

WeAreTheHeroes · 26/10/2022 10:25

@TheNosehasit if the jury believes there is a chance they didn't do Y either then that would mean the jury is not sure they did Y ergo they must find the defendant not guilty.

We cannot have a legal system where innocent people are found guilty and get a criminal record/lose their liberty as a consequence of insufficient proof of the facts. Even worse would be if there were still the death penalty. I firmly believe that one miscarriage of justice which results in the death of an innocent person makes the death penalty wholly wrong aside from any other arguments around it.

However awful the charges on the indictment and what the evidence seems to show, you cannot take a "no smoke without fire" approach. The jury decides the facts based on the evidence and the judge directs the jury as to what is needed to be sure the defendant is guilty of each charge.

Difficult cases go to jury trial because they are difficult cases.

That's the basis of my question though. Whether the sheer volume of charges might not prejudice a jury somehow and similarly faults in evidence, and if any individual victim (not defendant) is getting a fair trial in that sense?

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 10:37

And indeed on the other end, is a defendant getting a fair trial if you pile so many severe charges on them and leave that in the hands on one jury.

OP posts:
WeAreTheHeroes · 26/10/2022 10:40

Then your question is actually about whether jury trials are the best way to try such cases. There is always the chance a jury will make what is called a perverse decision, but it's the judge's job to ensure her direction to the jury means this does not happen. Most jurors are acutely aware that their decision has a profound affect on all concerned. I can't go into detail, but discussions in the jury room are often very difficult. As a juror you bring your life experience to the court and use that to help you decide the facts from the evidence presented.

On the case I was on, there were 11 charges on the indictment. 2 were removed after a number of days for legal reasons the judge explained to us. Of the remaining charges we found the defendant guilty of 5. I was sure the defendant was guilty of those charges. I was not sure about the other 4 because the necessary facts were not proved.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 10:57

WeAreTheHeroes · 26/10/2022 10:40

Then your question is actually about whether jury trials are the best way to try such cases. There is always the chance a jury will make what is called a perverse decision, but it's the judge's job to ensure her direction to the jury means this does not happen. Most jurors are acutely aware that their decision has a profound affect on all concerned. I can't go into detail, but discussions in the jury room are often very difficult. As a juror you bring your life experience to the court and use that to help you decide the facts from the evidence presented.

On the case I was on, there were 11 charges on the indictment. 2 were removed after a number of days for legal reasons the judge explained to us. Of the remaining charges we found the defendant guilty of 5. I was sure the defendant was guilty of those charges. I was not sure about the other 4 because the necessary facts were not proved.

Thank you for the explanation and again, I'm sorry that you had to be a juror on a complex case as I imagine it must be incredibly difficult. The details of some cases and indeed of some lives are so appalling as to be unbelievable at times.

I often wonder actually what I'd be like as a juror (I have exemptions to abstain if ever called). I form quick judgments of people, I jump to conclusions and I 'feel' people (that won't make sense to you unless you also feel it - I suppose the best way to describe it would be to get a sense of people?).

If I don't like you, I'm not going to like what you're saying. If I like you, I'll find it hard to not believe what you're saying. I believe there are studies on the 'credibility' of witnesses based on how attractive they are for example.

On the other side of me though (there's always another side), I'm a stickler for detail and precision and accuracy and I will quickly pick up on any inconsistencies. I suppose I just wonder about the whole trial system in a case like this.

I just think it's too many counts and too many severe counts balancing on the shoulders of one jury.

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 11:04

sheepandcaravan · 26/10/2022 08:42

Scotland here OP.

We have a doctrine called Moorov which might interest you to read about.

Not exactly the same but explanations about how corroboration can occur by linking different offences by time and circumstance.

It's often, for example, used with sexual assault cases.

I'll have a look, thanks.

OP posts:
AllThoseDirtyWords · 26/10/2022 11:12

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:14

I suppose I'm thinking of it working in reverse. If they were accused of doing X, Y and Z and the jury were clear that there was no evidence of them doing X or Y, then does that mean that they believe that maybe there's a chance that they didn't do Z either?

@TheNosehasit In your example there should be no supposing for count Z based on evidence of X & Y. They would need to consider the evidence presented for count Z and decide if they did it. So X & Y have no evidence, not guilty. Z has evidence, guilty.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 11:26

AllThoseDirtyWords · 26/10/2022 11:12

@TheNosehasit In your example there should be no supposing for count Z based on evidence of X & Y. They would need to consider the evidence presented for count Z and decide if they did it. So X & Y have no evidence, not guilty. Z has evidence, guilty.

Same trial, largely the same evidence?

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 11:31

I guess it depends on what the overlying evidence is because if that is not believed by a jury, then there are 22 very serious allegations at jeopardy.

OP posts:
BorisIsaSpider · 26/10/2022 12:39

I would let it be with them

WeAreTheHeroes · 26/10/2022 12:56

AllThoseDirtyWords · 26/10/2022 11:12

@TheNosehasit In your example there should be no supposing for count Z based on evidence of X & Y. They would need to consider the evidence presented for count Z and decide if they did it. So X & Y have no evidence, not guilty. Z has evidence, guilty.

It's not evidence that is key though. Evidence helps to establish the facts. It is on the facts that a jury reaches a verdict in respect of each charge on the indictment. It's really important to be precise about this. The judge's direction will make it clear what the jury need to be sure if in order to find the defendant guilty. If the jury is not sure, the defendant cannot be found guilty.

Swipe left for the next trending thread