Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask about a trial involving multiple counts with same jury

79 replies

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 05:37

I've a specific case in mind, though the last thread on it was deleted here, so I'm not going to mention it specifically.

My question is about multiple counts against different victims (some against same victim).

Each charge holds different evidence. Each case, holds different evidence. In fact, a lot of the cases allege different methods of alleged criminality against different alleged victims (sorry, I'm trying to choose my words carefully here).

My question is this one. Are the jury asked to consider each count separately or are they asked to consider for example that while the weight of evidence for 2 counts out of 10 isn't strong enough with EMPHASIS ON "FOR EXAMPLE", that you should still reasonably conclude that those two counts are also to be considered to be proven?

I'm sorry if that post or question seems garbled.

I can try to clarify if the question doesn't seem clear.

OP posts:
WeAreTheHeroes · 26/10/2022 12:56

AllThoseDirtyWords · 26/10/2022 11:12

@TheNosehasit In your example there should be no supposing for count Z based on evidence of X & Y. They would need to consider the evidence presented for count Z and decide if they did it. So X & Y have no evidence, not guilty. Z has evidence, guilty.

It's not evidence that is key though. Evidence helps to establish the facts. It is on the facts that a jury reaches a verdict in respect of each charge on the indictment. It's really important to be precise about this. The judge's direction will make it clear what the jury need to be sure if in order to find the defendant guilty. If the jury is not sure, the defendant cannot be found guilty.

OneTC · 26/10/2022 13:08

One thing I found uncomfortable on jury service was the jury having to decide whether what he did amounted to A abh or B attempted murder. Having to explain why you feel the defendant did A despite the fact that you are going to vote not guilty at the next stage seems very counterintuitive

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 14:44

OneTC · 26/10/2022 13:08

One thing I found uncomfortable on jury service was the jury having to decide whether what he did amounted to A abh or B attempted murder. Having to explain why you feel the defendant did A despite the fact that you are going to vote not guilty at the next stage seems very counterintuitive

This is worrying to me. I presume intent is the differentiating characteristic there? So to prove B, then you'd need to prove intent?

Multiply that by 22 counts and can you see how this trial is too much for one jury?

OP posts:
WeAreTheHeroes · 26/10/2022 19:19

As someone who has done jury service on a complex case relatively recently, I think you are making assumptions about lots of different aspects of a case. Yes, it will be hard, but judges try to manage the time the jury is in court, with frequent breaks if things are difficult. They are often specialists in certain types of case. There are evidence packs the jury can consult. The jury can consult the judge when they need help. They can ask their own questions in court via the judge too - we did several times. There are rules which cover what you can ask, but there were some gaps in the evidence and questions a number of the jurors felt were unanswered by what counsel asked. The other thing you probably don't realise is that the case won't be in court 7 - 8 hours a day. There are procedural matters the judge deals with in chambers or in court, but not in public. Judges are working on several cases at once too.

It's a strange bubble being on a jury. Fascinating, but harrowing at the same time. Took me weeks to stop thinking about it. I can't remember some aspects now. I can remember some minute details though.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread