Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be baffled by DH and his commute/working hours?

903 replies

GreatLates · 20/10/2022 16:00

DH started a new job - I used to do the same job in the same industry so I know how it all works. His employer requires him on site from 8.15-4.10 each day and he can do the rest from home as and when suits him as long as it's done. It's uncommon in the industry but DH's employer doesn't have meetings beyond 4.10 - this was something he bragged about when moving to this employer. We currently live two hours away from his site but we're moving (tomorrow, finally) to be about 15 minutes away from it. So, at the moment, DH leaves around 6am and should get home by 6.30 depending on traffic - and that's how it was for the first few weeks. But now, there's suddenly a million reasons why he's leaving early or coming home late. I also work full-time but I don't have set hours - DCs aren't school age so I have DS three days each week and DD every day and then start work when DH gets home. So, every time DH is late, I have to stay up even later working and/or lose time out of my weekend (I work 45 hours per week).

To take this week as an example, he told me last week that he had signed up for an extension to his shift for Monday this week which would mean he left an hour later but he'd get paid above his usual rate - which is fine. Then, over the weekend he said "oh, remember I can't collect DS from nursery on Tuesday because I'm doing the shift extension" and I said "you told me it was on Monday", "oh, yeah, yeah, it is, sorry". Then, later he said "I can't remember if I told you, I've signed up to a shift extension on Tuesday so I'll be home late" and I said again "you told me Monday" and, again, he said "oh, yeah, my bad, it is". So, Monday rolls around and he messages me to say he's just double-checked the rota and he's not staying late on Monday, he's staying late on Tuesday. It makes no difference to me which day it is so I said it's fine or whatever and said "so I'll see you at 6.30 then" and he didn't reply but he messaged me again at 4.30 to ask me to call our mortgage lender because they tried to phone him and he won't be finished by 5 (when they close). I asked why he's not finishing at 4.30 and he said he has a meeting (but he made a big thing when he took this job about how great it is that they never do meetings outside of the allotted time).

Then on Tuesday, I woke up at just gone 5.15 which is when we normally get up because DH has to leave at 6. I was feeding DD so I phoned DH at 5.37 (I have the call log) thinking he was downstairs getting ready (and I was going to pester him to make me a cup of tea) - but when he answered he was in the car driving so I said it doesn't matter and I didn't realise the time (thinking I must've got the time wrong if he'd already left). So, then, at 6.05, I realised I wasn't wrong on the time so I phoned him and I asked him where he was and he said he was at the petrol station near our house. I asked him why he'd left early and flatly refused to accept that he'd left early and said he let at 6... but I have the call log!

So, yesterday, I had a work meeting (which I only have on Wednesdays) starting from 6.30 so I needed him to be prompt - but he didn't arrive through the door until almost 8! No explanation from him for why he was late - and I had to try and do the meeting with DS bouncing around and DD on my lap.

Because we're completing on our sale tomorrow, DH and I packed up the car last night and DH was going to drive it down today and put the stuff into the storage unit we've rented near his work so everything we have left will fit in the car tomorrow. So, this morning, he left at 5 so he'd have time to unload the stuff into the unit. I just spoke to him now and he's said he won't be coming back as soon as he finishes because he needs to go to the unit to empty the car. He said it was never his intention to go before work and didn't realise that I thought he was going to - but then why did he leave an hour early?!

It honestly feels like he's trying to avoid spending time with me but a) when he's leaving early in the morning he would be sleeping and so would I, so even if he can't stand me, surely he'd rather be asleep? and b) the rest of his behaviour isn't indicating that. He says he loves me, he's very happy etc. At the end of the day, we're completing tomorrow so it's not going to be going on much longer but I am exhausted from having the kids on my own for additional hours and then having to do a full day of work myself! He's not usually like this (usually rushing home, mostly to see the kids) so the sudden change has concerned me - is he depressed? He seems fine in every other way. Any thoughts?

OP posts:
JoanOfAllTrades · 02/11/2022 01:45

@GreatLates I'm so sorry to read the updates. If you’re certain that there is no way it could be some sort of neurodiverse condition such as ADHD, take a look at the stress vulnerability model for mental health.

You and DH have been through some very stressful times recently; house-move, pregnancy, new job, new baby, buying a house. All of these thing alone are big stressors that affect mental, emotional, and psychological health and combined, they are all a big enough stressor that they can push someone over the edge.

I think it’s definitely worth considering some kind of breakdown/depression or anxiety issues. Of course, it’s that much harder when the other person won’t open up! I’m so very sorry that you’re going through this.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 02/11/2022 07:58

I agree with @Smidge001 turn it around-

“You say nothing is wrong; there clearly is otherwise I wouldn’t be asking.

You’ve changed, you’re gone all hours, you’ve checked out of family life, you’re different towards me with no affection or time. If something is going on, please tell me. If there is something worrying you or you are depressed, please tell me. If you’re worried about money, please tell me. If you are having an affair, please tell me.

I am deeply unhappy with things as they are; it is effecting my mental health and I can not and will not live like this. So we either deal with it so that we can move forward together or deal with it so we can split. Which is it to be?’

ProjectTiger · 02/11/2022 08:03

It may have already been suggested but could you get an apple Itag and hide it in his car somewhere? When he goes out this will tell you where he is going. Some may say it is underhand but you have tried asking.

ProjectTiger · 02/11/2022 08:05

You could tape an Itag to the underside of a car mat in the back seat of car etc. I would be doing this at this stage.

Arenanewbie · 02/11/2022 08:31

Only 27? Are you older then him by the way? You do sound more mature then 27.
I think you need to dig deeper and check his phone. Something’s going on you have to know what it is.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 02/11/2022 08:55

GreatLates · 01/11/2022 18:34

I don’t want him to leave - I just want him back. What can I do?

I’m really sorry op but if he doesn’t want to be there you can’t make him stay. I think given what you’ve said think it’s pretty likely that he’s having an affair. Men don’t tend to just leave because it’s far easier to have their cake and eat it. Are you happy for him to continue to treat you like this indefinitely?

You need to find your anger. You are pretty much coping as a single mum, you say you don’t need his income so tell him that you’re not living like this. If he doesn’t want to pay you any consideration he needs to leave. He’ll either realise he’s going to lose you by being such a twat and sort himself out or he’ll leave. It won’t be easy, it will be heartbreaking and shit, but you’ll have your self respect and you’ll know where you stand. I know it’s tough but at this stage peace of mind is far more beneficial to you than clinging on to someone who is treating you and your kids badly.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 02/11/2022 09:01

OP, are the poster that is doing the MA on Mat leave so it ‘funds’ Mat leave ? If so can you not take a small break from it whilst you sort all this out. It must be taking a toll on your mental health and it can’t be good for you. You also said the house you’re living in needs extensive work - has DH stepped up with this at all or has he totally checked out, leaving you with two small kids in a shit hole ?! If so his behaviour is really unforgivable IMO. I’d NEVER advocate for tracking him or anything like that but at this point I admit I’d be tempted. The trust has surely gone anyway.

Alice786 · 02/11/2022 09:12

I think you need a break. Time apart could actually help, give you both time to think and re-evaluate what you really want to do. You can't control how he feels and acts but you have control on how you respond. You need to be strong and have a plan x

emptythelitterbox · 02/11/2022 09:18

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 02/11/2022 07:58

I agree with @Smidge001 turn it around-

“You say nothing is wrong; there clearly is otherwise I wouldn’t be asking.

You’ve changed, you’re gone all hours, you’ve checked out of family life, you’re different towards me with no affection or time. If something is going on, please tell me. If there is something worrying you or you are depressed, please tell me. If you’re worried about money, please tell me. If you are having an affair, please tell me.

I am deeply unhappy with things as they are; it is effecting my mental health and I can not and will not live like this. So we either deal with it so that we can move forward together or deal with it so we can split. Which is it to be?’

Excellent advice. Better to get whatever it is out in the open than limp along in limbo wondering what is up because he won't tell you.

Like PP mentioned, maybe he is being so checked out, passive aggressive, difficult that you get fed up, call him out, and want to leave. He then gets to look like the good guy who can get sympathy for "my wife left me for no reason. poor poor me."

billy1966 · 02/11/2022 09:52

OP, you are clearly in a fog of confusion.

@PyongyangKipperbang has written very wisely.

The truth is, SOMETHING is going on.

The truth is, that your marriage may be over.

The truth is, he is lying and gaslighting you by his denial.

The truth is, you HAVE to protect yourself and your children from who he is right now.

You have to put your emotions on hold.

I would ask him to leave.
I would not allow the lying and gaslighting to continue.

I would openly talk to family and friends that you are not sure what IS going on but his lies and unexplained absences cannot continue.

There are many many men who will indeed have an affair without any intention of leaving the comfort of the family home.

Try and find the strength to detach from this situation.

I wouldn't trust one word out of his mouth.

He is lying and gaslighting you.
He may well have another phone.

Whatever it is, he needs to leave while he is lying.

My bet is that if you ask him to leave because of HIS unreasonable behaviour, he will turn very nasty, and you will get a greater insight into who he is right now.

But turn to family and friends for support and protect your MH at all cost.

He is 27, what age are you and your children?

Bookworm20 · 02/11/2022 09:55

Unfortunately it sounds like textbook behaviour for someone having an affair. He is justifying it to himself by starting to try and think of you as the bad guy. Witholding intimacy, not caring about how you are, upsetting you and not caring about that. Soon he will be rewriting history, which will be hard for you to hear as he'll say things like he never loved you (its all bollocks of course and his way of justifying what he is doing).

He isn't leaving because he has everything lovely at home, and his affair hasn't reached the point of them wanting to live together. He isn't going to leave until he absolutely has to.

But he has checked out.

If he is open with his phone, he may have a second one someone.

If he is going off places and not telling you where, you need to try and find out where he is going that he needs to be so secretive about. I would not suggest an itag in the car. But could you get another phone and 'accidently' leave it in his car, activate location history on it and then you'll at least have an idea of where he is going.
Its not snooping, its getting some answers because he isn't willing to give you any. If you then find he is consistently going to a certain address or place you'll at least have something you can work with.

I'm so sorry OP. I hope its nothing. But unfortunately it does not seem innocent from what you have written.

Chickenvoicesinmyhead · 02/11/2022 11:24

JoanOfAllTrades · 02/11/2022 01:45

@GreatLates I'm so sorry to read the updates. If you’re certain that there is no way it could be some sort of neurodiverse condition such as ADHD, take a look at the stress vulnerability model for mental health.

You and DH have been through some very stressful times recently; house-move, pregnancy, new job, new baby, buying a house. All of these thing alone are big stressors that affect mental, emotional, and psychological health and combined, they are all a big enough stressor that they can push someone over the edge.

I think it’s definitely worth considering some kind of breakdown/depression or anxiety issues. Of course, it’s that much harder when the other person won’t open up! I’m so very sorry that you’re going through this.

The H is fine with other people though? I don't know enough about breakdowns but surely his behaviour would be across the board?

I wondered about a medical/brain issue but the same applies.

He is fully in control of his behaviour. I believe he's checked out but hasn't got the balls to come clean.

I agree with a pp that he's driving the OP to call time on the marriage so he can blame her. It happened to me.

Whatever's going on @GreatLates I'm so sorry you are having to contend with this shit.

PossiblyOverstepping · 02/11/2022 11:36

I’m so sorry you are going through this. I was you 7 years ago and thought I was going mad. In our case it was MH issues which then led to substance abuse. We came out the other end but we were two different people by the end of it . Sometimes I think a split would have been cleaner. My thoughts are with you. Womens Aid are amazing, it doesn’t have to be text book abuse for you to ring them . Just have a chat… things will be a lot clearer. You deserve mental peace xx.

reigatecastle · 02/11/2022 11:49

It could be an affair but it could also be mental health problems. You haven't confirmed that he is a teacher but teacher plus new baby plus new home screams stress to me! I think it's quite possible to mask with other people but not make any effort at home.

I think you've got to get tough and say he either tells the truth about what's going on, or he moves out. I couldn't be doing with any of this.

ItsHitTheFanNow · 02/11/2022 13:36

My ex acted exactly like that. He was having an affair. We had a newborn too.

JoanOfAllTrades · 02/11/2022 13:59

Chickenvoicesinmyhead · 02/11/2022 11:24

The H is fine with other people though? I don't know enough about breakdowns but surely his behaviour would be across the board?

I wondered about a medical/brain issue but the same applies.

He is fully in control of his behaviour. I believe he's checked out but hasn't got the balls to come clean.

I agree with a pp that he's driving the OP to call time on the marriage so he can blame her. It happened to me.

Whatever's going on @GreatLates I'm so sorry you are having to contend with this shit.

Sometimes it’s about controlling yourself when you’re with other people, but being able to be “yourself” with the people whom you love. Of course, if the H is having an affair, none of the would be true.

Since H is sticking with “nothing is wrong”, until/unless something changes in terms of OP herself finding something out or H adding something more to the nothing being wrong, we can all sit and surmise till the cows come home but we won’t get any forrader.

One thing that strikes me is H’s age. 27 and 2 children, a house that’s been renovated, a house that needs renovating, a new baby, a new job, a toddler that requires care whilst his wife works. It just seems like a lot.

Don't get me wrong, I’m not judging, I had 5 children, a busy career, a house, etc., etc., at 27, although my DH is older than me so I think that probably helped. Plus I only worked 4 shifts one week and 3 the next as the shifts were 12 hours so I think that also helped as I had a lot of time at home as well with the kids and there wasn’t necessarily some frenetic rush to do everything in a day.

I wish there was some kind of resolution for the OP to give her some piece of mind.

peridito · 02/11/2022 14:00

I think it's quite possible to mask with other people but not make any effort at home.

^^ I think that's an important point .It could be the case that someone is particularly "off" at home because they've expended all their energy pretending to be ok outside it .

5yearplan · 02/11/2022 14:23

Well it’s not a typical mid-life crisis breakdown (seen a few of them) if he’s only 27. It could be general family life and work stress if not the obvious affair.

Gymnopedie · 02/11/2022 14:29

The thing that puts me off the MH angle is that he's changing into nice clothes. That would perhaps be reasonable if he was saying he wanted to forget about work at home, but he doesn't seem to be doing.

OP even the worst liars can become convincing if they're sure enough there's a good reason to lie.

JoanOfAllTrades · 02/11/2022 14:36

Gymnopedie · 02/11/2022 14:29

The thing that puts me off the MH angle is that he's changing into nice clothes. That would perhaps be reasonable if he was saying he wanted to forget about work at home, but he doesn't seem to be doing.

OP even the worst liars can become convincing if they're sure enough there's a good reason to lie.

But that was only once? If he was always changing clothes after work, that’s a different matter, but @GreatLates said it was once.

A thought? What happened to the clothes he went to work in that day and then changed before coming home?

JulesCobb · 02/11/2022 18:14

Lulanna · 01/11/2022 18:34

Sometimes, this treatment is to make the other partner take the decision to end the relationship, so that the person who really wants to go remains faultless. He can blame you if the future is tricky.

You need some really honest answers without accepting what he is saying …and to keep digging.

This. He was blaming a long commute. Now he has no commute and is still out without explanation. And has ramped it up to being awful to you.

apple AirTag in his car.

CombatBarbie · 02/11/2022 18:26

Air tags will only go undetected if he has an android phone and OP has an iPhone though.

An iPhone will pick up an air tag and notify the phone, there's been threads on here where an unknown airtag was showing on the ops phone. Turned out the ex had planted one in her car or bag or similar.

catfunk · 02/11/2022 18:54

Sorry op but if he fucking fuming if I were him. Time to get angry.
Affair or MH, he's stonewalling you and gaslighting you. These are abusive behaviours.
I've never said this before but honestly check his phone - WhatsApp and search history.

GreatLates · 02/11/2022 18:56

Arenanewbie · 02/11/2022 08:31

Only 27? Are you older then him by the way? You do sound more mature then 27.
I think you need to dig deeper and check his phone. Something’s going on you have to know what it is.

I'm 26. I think many people on this site underestimate people by their age - every time someone's being a drama queen all the "are you very young?" comments come out but, in truth, I think some people will always be dramatic and some people won't be.

OP posts:
MmeArnault · 02/11/2022 19:16

Even more reasons to not put up with this shit@GreatLates