Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be baffled by DH and his commute/working hours?

903 replies

GreatLates · 20/10/2022 16:00

DH started a new job - I used to do the same job in the same industry so I know how it all works. His employer requires him on site from 8.15-4.10 each day and he can do the rest from home as and when suits him as long as it's done. It's uncommon in the industry but DH's employer doesn't have meetings beyond 4.10 - this was something he bragged about when moving to this employer. We currently live two hours away from his site but we're moving (tomorrow, finally) to be about 15 minutes away from it. So, at the moment, DH leaves around 6am and should get home by 6.30 depending on traffic - and that's how it was for the first few weeks. But now, there's suddenly a million reasons why he's leaving early or coming home late. I also work full-time but I don't have set hours - DCs aren't school age so I have DS three days each week and DD every day and then start work when DH gets home. So, every time DH is late, I have to stay up even later working and/or lose time out of my weekend (I work 45 hours per week).

To take this week as an example, he told me last week that he had signed up for an extension to his shift for Monday this week which would mean he left an hour later but he'd get paid above his usual rate - which is fine. Then, over the weekend he said "oh, remember I can't collect DS from nursery on Tuesday because I'm doing the shift extension" and I said "you told me it was on Monday", "oh, yeah, yeah, it is, sorry". Then, later he said "I can't remember if I told you, I've signed up to a shift extension on Tuesday so I'll be home late" and I said again "you told me Monday" and, again, he said "oh, yeah, my bad, it is". So, Monday rolls around and he messages me to say he's just double-checked the rota and he's not staying late on Monday, he's staying late on Tuesday. It makes no difference to me which day it is so I said it's fine or whatever and said "so I'll see you at 6.30 then" and he didn't reply but he messaged me again at 4.30 to ask me to call our mortgage lender because they tried to phone him and he won't be finished by 5 (when they close). I asked why he's not finishing at 4.30 and he said he has a meeting (but he made a big thing when he took this job about how great it is that they never do meetings outside of the allotted time).

Then on Tuesday, I woke up at just gone 5.15 which is when we normally get up because DH has to leave at 6. I was feeding DD so I phoned DH at 5.37 (I have the call log) thinking he was downstairs getting ready (and I was going to pester him to make me a cup of tea) - but when he answered he was in the car driving so I said it doesn't matter and I didn't realise the time (thinking I must've got the time wrong if he'd already left). So, then, at 6.05, I realised I wasn't wrong on the time so I phoned him and I asked him where he was and he said he was at the petrol station near our house. I asked him why he'd left early and flatly refused to accept that he'd left early and said he let at 6... but I have the call log!

So, yesterday, I had a work meeting (which I only have on Wednesdays) starting from 6.30 so I needed him to be prompt - but he didn't arrive through the door until almost 8! No explanation from him for why he was late - and I had to try and do the meeting with DS bouncing around and DD on my lap.

Because we're completing on our sale tomorrow, DH and I packed up the car last night and DH was going to drive it down today and put the stuff into the storage unit we've rented near his work so everything we have left will fit in the car tomorrow. So, this morning, he left at 5 so he'd have time to unload the stuff into the unit. I just spoke to him now and he's said he won't be coming back as soon as he finishes because he needs to go to the unit to empty the car. He said it was never his intention to go before work and didn't realise that I thought he was going to - but then why did he leave an hour early?!

It honestly feels like he's trying to avoid spending time with me but a) when he's leaving early in the morning he would be sleeping and so would I, so even if he can't stand me, surely he'd rather be asleep? and b) the rest of his behaviour isn't indicating that. He says he loves me, he's very happy etc. At the end of the day, we're completing tomorrow so it's not going to be going on much longer but I am exhausted from having the kids on my own for additional hours and then having to do a full day of work myself! He's not usually like this (usually rushing home, mostly to see the kids) so the sudden change has concerned me - is he depressed? He seems fine in every other way. Any thoughts?

OP posts:
Hollypups · 01/11/2022 18:51

GreatLates · 01/11/2022 18:18

If he's having an affair then why wouldn't he just leave? He can afford to leave, he knows we'd do 50/50 with DCs - I don't get why he'd deny it. Surely, if he wants to be with me then he'd stop the affair and if he doesn't then he'd leave - why all the carry-on?

Because he gets the best of both worlds.

Goldpaw · 01/11/2022 18:52

GreatLates · 01/11/2022 18:18

If he's having an affair then why wouldn't he just leave? He can afford to leave, he knows we'd do 50/50 with DCs - I don't get why he'd deny it. Surely, if he wants to be with me then he'd stop the affair and if he doesn't then he'd leave - why all the carry-on?

A lot of men don't want to be the baddie and leave, they want the whole splitting up thing to be something the partner does, leaving them secure in the knowledge that it wasn't them that split up the family.

Ladybird11 · 01/11/2022 18:55

Might he have post natal depression? There's good material on BBC Tiny Happy People about this with dads.. perhaps ask your health visitor to call out and open the conversation with you both?

crochetmonkey74 · 01/11/2022 18:56

Oh god OP please try to listen to those of us on here , I've been through this to the letter.
He's more interested in someone else, he's a coward so he is making you be the one who calls it off.
You HAVE to get proactive here.

Macaroni1924 · 01/11/2022 19:07

Hi OP I’m so sorry to see the update and that things have got worse instead of better. Could he be having a breakdown? I went through something similar a good few years ago with my DH all I can say is I could see a change in his eyes when he spoke to me they were empty. Working late, long dog walks etc no good reason for having to stay on. It felt like he was avoiding us and didn’t love us or want to be with his family. People on here straight away jumped on the LTB train and said 100% affair. What actually was happening was that he was severely depressed due to several things we were going through at the time, change of job, moving home all whilst having a very difficult time with dd. At the time he didn’t know what was wrong and it took me going to my SIL for help to get him the help he needed. Thankfully with some counselling he came out the other end. You must know deep down in your gut. I knew hand on heart that he wasn’t cheating, I knew something was wrong and tbh I didn’t even care if he was cheating by that point my biggest concern was that he would harm himself and not be there for our dd. I am so glad that I stood by him and that I was able to recognise something wasn’t right with him. It wasn’t easy to get him to realise that’s a major hurdle of this could be the issue for your DH.

FreedomForties · 01/11/2022 19:21

Macaroni1924 · 01/11/2022 19:07

Hi OP I’m so sorry to see the update and that things have got worse instead of better. Could he be having a breakdown? I went through something similar a good few years ago with my DH all I can say is I could see a change in his eyes when he spoke to me they were empty. Working late, long dog walks etc no good reason for having to stay on. It felt like he was avoiding us and didn’t love us or want to be with his family. People on here straight away jumped on the LTB train and said 100% affair. What actually was happening was that he was severely depressed due to several things we were going through at the time, change of job, moving home all whilst having a very difficult time with dd. At the time he didn’t know what was wrong and it took me going to my SIL for help to get him the help he needed. Thankfully with some counselling he came out the other end. You must know deep down in your gut. I knew hand on heart that he wasn’t cheating, I knew something was wrong and tbh I didn’t even care if he was cheating by that point my biggest concern was that he would harm himself and not be there for our dd. I am so glad that I stood by him and that I was able to recognise something wasn’t right with him. It wasn’t easy to get him to realise that’s a major hurdle of this could be the issue for your DH.

I fully agree with this. Could be very well be depression, not an affair, I came on here to write something similar!

Algor1thm · 01/11/2022 19:26

Weirdly people do have affairs all the time and don't leave, even when financially they have the means to do so. Often they don't see the other person as a long term investment, or they're biding their time to assess whether they are. The other person might also have a family and be refusing to leave - why destroy your own family if the other person won't leave theirs, and you end up single? Custody wise, maybe (especially with such a young baby) he doesn't feel 50/50 would be enough contact. I know for my husband that would be heartbreaking and definitely a barrier to him leaving me.

I have a friend whose husband had an affair for 10 whole years, had kids with another woman and was fully living a double life with no real reason for it. The level of stress it caused him was so high he admitted he'd been completely miserable the entire time, and not enjoying either relationship or either set of kids. When she asked why he hadn't just come clean, he couldn't really explain it. He just said he loved both of them and hadn't wanted to hurt her.

Sorry to be blunt but I do think it's important you consider the chance that this is what is happening. Alternatively there's a strong chance it's something else nefarious like a drinking/drug/gambling problem. But it's not nothing.

Algor1thm · 01/11/2022 19:30

I also agree with people who have said breakdown/mental health crisis. My dad had a breakdown when I was a teenager and acted similar, but it was also associated with a drinking problem. He was disappearing for long periods to drink and then sober up before coming home. He was also driving to 'work' and drunk driving back which I presume were day long benders. My mum was in full denial that he was drinking and said he was just tired/depressed all the time.

FennelAndOnions · 01/11/2022 19:33

but he insists he does and nothing is changed.

Thats just not true though, regardless of the reason, he’s not telling you the truth. Something has changed. He’s not being fair.

Have you specifically told him how he’s changed?

picklemewalnuts · 01/11/2022 19:38

Does he have a supportive family? Friends? You might need to get someone else to talk to him.

MsDogLady · 01/11/2022 20:06

@GreatLates, when your marriage is going down in flames and your emotional health is being badly affected, it’s time to investigate. The answers may be on his phone. As all of your questions/concerns have been met with his stonewalling, I wouldn’t hesitate to investigate his phone and statements.

His atrocious behavior toward you and the children has escalated: no physical or emotional presence, no affection, disdain & disregard, blocking transparency re his absences, selfishness in bed. He knows that his behavior toward you has changed. Yet he’s a delight for friends, colleagues and neighbors.

@GreatLates, this destructive dynamic is unsustainable. You’re in dire need of answers, and you’ve got sources of information that you haven’t used.

forrestgreen · 01/11/2022 20:38

I could have written that post.
He'd been having an affair for a year.

I didn't want him back

withaspongeandarustyspanner · 01/11/2022 20:39

My XH did similar. It took him about 3 months to leave. I remember posting a similar thread on here, and tried to ignore what everyone was telling me. It turns out that MN was absolutely spot on. He had checked out, there was an OW. It was so painful hearing the things that MN was telling me - but it was advice that was so valuable in the end.

withaspongeandarustyspanner · 01/11/2022 20:41

Oh, and my XH didn't admit having an affair at the time (and still doesn't, changing the timescale and narrative), because he 'didn't want to be that kind of man'. I think he felt he could be so atrocious that I would Chuck him out and he could leave with a clear conscience.

kateandme · 01/11/2022 20:50

Oh ok.im sorry for this update. But it seems if anything it's gotten worse.and getting more so.
Can you live.like this.and possibly worse.
You sound so deflated and sad.
Is this worth it.
If this is who he is now.if this is him what s the point.
Trying to find out why on the end doesn't matter.hes changed,he's hurting you and your family,he's upsetting home life,your every day life. Is this how you think you can bare to live?
Do you love THIS man.because it seems he is not for changing.
Don't hold onto to a memory of someone who has clearly become someone different. Because if he says there is no reason or nothing wrong then this is who he is.
And you sound miserable.
And you know what op you deserve to be happy.cared for,supported and loved.
Or at the very least not spending your days feeling confused and shitty.

LicoricePizza · 01/11/2022 21:18

OP plse consider mh /depression /breakdown.

Avoidance (of you & family), irritability, forgetfulness, blanking out, being detached, being unable to face daily normal tasks & activities & running away from them are all classic signs of depression & anxiety.

He may not know he’s depressed but that something is very off & that he can’t shake it. Fears, catastrophising, ruminating & being consumed by negative thoughts, perceived failings, ability to rationally problem solve or reassure are all part of depression.

He may not be able to tell you he’s feeling this way because of the fears of what you’ll think, letting you down, being weak, not being a provider, strong man etc etc.
Esp after you’ve just had a baby, house move. He is needed & depended on & if he doesn’t know what’s happening to him it’s very normal to literally hide from these awful feelings in a bid to avoid them.

Plus the burden of masking how he feels which could be overwhelming can make it even harder & so he avoids you because it’s just too difficult after a day of pretending to be ok at work - possibly.

What’s his sleep, appetite, concentration, mood, speech,movement like? Does he seem emotionless, lost his spark, seem vacant? Is he slower than normal or faster?

Inability to think clearly, rationally & concentrate, time keep etc are all depression symptoms.

Alcohol can often be a go to to cope & escape from the feelings.

You say he knows you could survive off your salary if he had to work in a minimum wage job & so wouldn’t be worrying about something like that.

But if depressed he won’t rationally be able to view things like that. How wld he feel having to tell you something like that given you’ve got a young family, so many commitments, responsibilities?

The shame, guilt of letting you or loved ones down, being a failure or the shame & stigma may stop him being able to share this with you.

He may not even know what is happening to him & is literally trying to hide from it & conceal it. It can be a terrifying place to be.

The danger as other posters have said is that though common in depression, suicidal thoughts have the power to trick a person into believing they are the right course of action in the face of what they feel is an unrelenting, unsolveable & unbearable & horribly anguished predicament.

Sadly men statistically are more likely to respond to suicidal ideation on impulse. Out of the blue. When nobody even knew they were depressed. And are more successful in carrying them out as well.

He could be at risk. Please consider this as a matter of some urgency.

Asking him what’s wrong might naturally get him defensive.

Have you said you will support him if he’s in terrible trouble? That he knows he can come to you if he’s in pain or hurting or somethings not right? That you’re desperately worried about him as you can tell somethings not right & you want to help? It won’t be terrible & unless you know you can’t help fix it? If he’s done something that he is terrified of telling you about you won’t judge & just will hear him & find a way through it?

This is a useful self check tool which may be worth you reading & considering before finding a way together of going to see his GP. Medication can really help him get back some control if he is having a breakdown.

www.nhs.uk/mental-health/self-help/guides-tools-and-activities/depression-anxiety-self-assessment-quiz/

www.mind.org.uk/information-support/types-of-mental-health-problems/depression/about-depression/

Good luck 🍀

Alice786 · 01/11/2022 21:25

I'm really sorry to hear things have hotten so bad. You have to either snoop for the sake of your own sanity or keep asking and not let it go until you get an answer. If it was me I would not let it go, I would literally do his head until the only choice he would have it to confess for his own sanity. Also I would make him feel safe by letting him know to just tell me even if it is an affair that i would understand, even if i wouldn't. I would just have to know otherwise I wouldn't be able to do anything else. At least once it's out there you can start dealing with it and moving on one way or another. I wish you all the luck xx

PyongyangKipperbang · 01/11/2022 21:52

The problem with "needing to know" is that even if you find something out, what difference will it make?

If he is ill and refusing to address it then you cant force him to. If he is cheating and refusing to admit then he will still refuse to admit it with the evidence in front of him (trust me on this).

All you can do is make a decision based on the facts you know. You know he has changed, you know he has checked out and you know that his feelings have changed. What you do about that is the decision you have to make. It comes down to either coming to peace with living with a housemate who can barely acknowledge your existence and avoids your company at all costs. Or choosing to not live like that and giving him an ultimatum and MEANING it. He sees the GP, he admits if there is anything else going such as an affair and you (as a couple) will decide if you can save the marriage or he leaves. Thats it. No other options. No falling for the old "I'm just stressed, its you thats the problem by going on about it... blah blah gaslight gaslight"

MmeArnault · 01/11/2022 21:54

PyongyangKipperbang · 01/11/2022 21:52

The problem with "needing to know" is that even if you find something out, what difference will it make?

If he is ill and refusing to address it then you cant force him to. If he is cheating and refusing to admit then he will still refuse to admit it with the evidence in front of him (trust me on this).

All you can do is make a decision based on the facts you know. You know he has changed, you know he has checked out and you know that his feelings have changed. What you do about that is the decision you have to make. It comes down to either coming to peace with living with a housemate who can barely acknowledge your existence and avoids your company at all costs. Or choosing to not live like that and giving him an ultimatum and MEANING it. He sees the GP, he admits if there is anything else going such as an affair and you (as a couple) will decide if you can save the marriage or he leaves. Thats it. No other options. No falling for the old "I'm just stressed, its you thats the problem by going on about it... blah blah gaslight gaslight"

Exactly.

Lulanna · 01/11/2022 22:06

What would his response be if you spoke to him about how worried you are about him - his physical or mental health?
Perhaps this is the way forward.

PyongyangKipperbang · 01/11/2022 22:12

And I feel that I should add that I spent 3 years tying myself in knots when I KNEW something was going on, either MH or an affair or something work related and being stonewalled each time. By the time I found out it was cheating (many women, many times and also sexting etc), forget his MH, my own MH was utterly fucked. I was a shell of my former self. All because of a "need to know" and to this day, 4 years after we split, he still denies an affair when I had printed off the reams of FB messages between them. What good did it do me? None. I was hanging on the hopes I was wrong and he would prove I was wrong. Please dont put yourself through that, I am only in the last year or so anything like the woman I was before, I fear I will never really be her again.

Dont be me xx

RavensClaw · 01/11/2022 22:25

Hope you’re ok OP

Livetoplay · 01/11/2022 22:47

This happened to my friend after the birth of their 2nd child… he swore blind all was fine, nothing has changed, she was mad …
turns out he was fucking his 21 year old colleague while his DW was looking after a toddler, a newborn, working PT and moving them into their new home.
My friend found out, finally, kicked him out and he went off with the GF for a few months before coming f crawling back.
she took him back - new house, tiny kids etc - but they spilt about 2 years later cos he was a miserable git who thought she should be grateful he’d returned to the marital home.

friend doing great now, new fella, new house,
kids happy and the sad sack ex is still sulking,
furious that he now has to look after his kids himself half the week, and tells anyone who’ll listen that she dumped him for no reason…

deeperthanallroses · 01/11/2022 23:45

Is snooping a betrayal here? He’s totally checked out, he’s not in any way there for you or the dc when you have tiny baby and his family really needs him. It’s either mental health or an affair really. You’ve tried talking. You could ask him to leave. Or you could snoop- if you don’t find anything it’s mental health and he needs your help. If you do, you’re hardly the one betraying him. I assume you don’t want to jump straight to kicking him out for abandoning his family, so I’d snoop.

Smidge001 · 02/11/2022 01:24

GreatLates · 01/11/2022 18:34

I don’t want him to leave - I just want him back. What can I do?

OK, so you say he claims nothing is wrong when you ask about him. So why not turn this around and say something is wrong for you. That you're not happy anymore in life or in the marriage and don't know why. And that therefore you've booked the two of you into counselling to try to save the marriage. It's no good then him saying he doesn't need it or want it - coz you're going because YOU need it.

Then maybe the counsellor can get to the bottom of what's really going on.

He says nothing has changed and that he loves you (despite not showing it) so you can use this to make him come along to the sessions, to help you feel better.