Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be baffled by DH and his commute/working hours?

903 replies

GreatLates · 20/10/2022 16:00

DH started a new job - I used to do the same job in the same industry so I know how it all works. His employer requires him on site from 8.15-4.10 each day and he can do the rest from home as and when suits him as long as it's done. It's uncommon in the industry but DH's employer doesn't have meetings beyond 4.10 - this was something he bragged about when moving to this employer. We currently live two hours away from his site but we're moving (tomorrow, finally) to be about 15 minutes away from it. So, at the moment, DH leaves around 6am and should get home by 6.30 depending on traffic - and that's how it was for the first few weeks. But now, there's suddenly a million reasons why he's leaving early or coming home late. I also work full-time but I don't have set hours - DCs aren't school age so I have DS three days each week and DD every day and then start work when DH gets home. So, every time DH is late, I have to stay up even later working and/or lose time out of my weekend (I work 45 hours per week).

To take this week as an example, he told me last week that he had signed up for an extension to his shift for Monday this week which would mean he left an hour later but he'd get paid above his usual rate - which is fine. Then, over the weekend he said "oh, remember I can't collect DS from nursery on Tuesday because I'm doing the shift extension" and I said "you told me it was on Monday", "oh, yeah, yeah, it is, sorry". Then, later he said "I can't remember if I told you, I've signed up to a shift extension on Tuesday so I'll be home late" and I said again "you told me Monday" and, again, he said "oh, yeah, my bad, it is". So, Monday rolls around and he messages me to say he's just double-checked the rota and he's not staying late on Monday, he's staying late on Tuesday. It makes no difference to me which day it is so I said it's fine or whatever and said "so I'll see you at 6.30 then" and he didn't reply but he messaged me again at 4.30 to ask me to call our mortgage lender because they tried to phone him and he won't be finished by 5 (when they close). I asked why he's not finishing at 4.30 and he said he has a meeting (but he made a big thing when he took this job about how great it is that they never do meetings outside of the allotted time).

Then on Tuesday, I woke up at just gone 5.15 which is when we normally get up because DH has to leave at 6. I was feeding DD so I phoned DH at 5.37 (I have the call log) thinking he was downstairs getting ready (and I was going to pester him to make me a cup of tea) - but when he answered he was in the car driving so I said it doesn't matter and I didn't realise the time (thinking I must've got the time wrong if he'd already left). So, then, at 6.05, I realised I wasn't wrong on the time so I phoned him and I asked him where he was and he said he was at the petrol station near our house. I asked him why he'd left early and flatly refused to accept that he'd left early and said he let at 6... but I have the call log!

So, yesterday, I had a work meeting (which I only have on Wednesdays) starting from 6.30 so I needed him to be prompt - but he didn't arrive through the door until almost 8! No explanation from him for why he was late - and I had to try and do the meeting with DS bouncing around and DD on my lap.

Because we're completing on our sale tomorrow, DH and I packed up the car last night and DH was going to drive it down today and put the stuff into the storage unit we've rented near his work so everything we have left will fit in the car tomorrow. So, this morning, he left at 5 so he'd have time to unload the stuff into the unit. I just spoke to him now and he's said he won't be coming back as soon as he finishes because he needs to go to the unit to empty the car. He said it was never his intention to go before work and didn't realise that I thought he was going to - but then why did he leave an hour early?!

It honestly feels like he's trying to avoid spending time with me but a) when he's leaving early in the morning he would be sleeping and so would I, so even if he can't stand me, surely he'd rather be asleep? and b) the rest of his behaviour isn't indicating that. He says he loves me, he's very happy etc. At the end of the day, we're completing tomorrow so it's not going to be going on much longer but I am exhausted from having the kids on my own for additional hours and then having to do a full day of work myself! He's not usually like this (usually rushing home, mostly to see the kids) so the sudden change has concerned me - is he depressed? He seems fine in every other way. Any thoughts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BloaterW1 · 14/11/2022 07:02

How are you feeling OP ? Hopefully you have had some way forward with this.

ADifferentKindOfWonderful · 09/11/2022 04:06

Hi @GreatLates
I hope a bit of time away has done you both some good. I'm so sorry for what you're going through. I hope your situation resolves quickly.
Your hair looks beautiful btw xxx

UmmMaryam2019 · 08/11/2022 23:17

Hey

Hope you are OK.
Its a big step you've taken. Time apart should help both of you. I hope you do have support and help with the kids, your baby is very young, you need time out too.
Glad you got to do your hair, that is just the best feeling.
You are past the worst of it. He'll realise something is wrong at least! Hopefully things will get better for you all.

Honestly would love to help, but in reality only you and him know your situation in full and you will find the right way forward for yourselves.

😘 ❤️ hugs

BestMammyEver · 08/11/2022 18:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

BestMammyEver · 08/11/2022 18:37

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 08/11/2022 18:31

Yeah, as I thought.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 08/11/2022 18:08

And how are the children?

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 08/11/2022 17:59

Are you ok , financially, now that you've moved?
Was he present when you moved?

Oddieconvert · 08/11/2022 11:15

ProFannyTea · 08/11/2022 11:13

That bit seems to have been clear from page one to everyone except the OP sadly. And not for the want of trying to tell her either.

But loads of posters started screaming abusive

to me - just a very unhappy marriage. And he just couldn’t be straight with his wife.

now she kicked him out and I imagine he breathed a sigh of relief as he longer had to do it

ProFannyTea · 08/11/2022 11:13

Oddieconvert · 08/11/2022 11:10

Not against the OP

i see numerous posters squealing that the dh is abusive despite no evidence whatsoever as far as I can see. Just an unhappy marriage where the man is too weak to actually tell his partner

That bit seems to have been clear from page one to everyone except the OP sadly. And not for the want of trying to tell her either.

Oddieconvert · 08/11/2022 11:10

reigatecastle · 08/11/2022 11:03

OP, I don't see any accusation of abuse there, the pp was defending you.

Not against the OP

i see numerous posters squealing that the dh is abusive despite no evidence whatsoever as far as I can see. Just an unhappy marriage where the man is too weak to actually tell his partner

reigatecastle · 08/11/2022 11:03

GreatLates · 04/11/2022 16:37

And where is your evidence that I’m abusive for not wanting to be with someone who no longer loves me? Because that’s the accusation you just made. I didn’t call him abusive, you called me abusive.

OP, I don't see any accusation of abuse there, the pp was defending you.

ProFannyTea · 08/11/2022 10:49

GreatLates · 04/11/2022 17:06

For the first day in forever I did something for me. I finally felt good. I finally convinced myself I was ok to expect more and she decided to call me abusive and a liar. I’m not letting one stupid, ignorant, nasty person drag me back to where I was yesterday. I deserve basic respect. I actually do. I won’t just ignore and put up and accept when someone disagrees with that anymore.

Yet quite happy to put up with it from DH..

Oddieconvert · 08/11/2022 10:47

and did the op just sit in her own home watching her dh eat and then went to bed hungry? Really?

Oddieconvert · 08/11/2022 10:46

deeperthanallroses · 07/11/2022 03:26

I don’t how withdrawing explains actively choosing to not buy the op food when he goes to get food, or to go out with her and others to somewhere she can’t eat. That behaviour is both far more active and hostile than withdrawing.

There was a mix-up last night with food and (for allergy reasons) I had no food - so he just sat there eating while I had nothing and then went to sleep

was there anything stopping the op sort herself out with food? I too suffer from allergies. It’s my allergy so I tend to sort out any food “mix ups”!

deeperthanallroses · 07/11/2022 03:26

bedazzled82 · 05/11/2022 08:54

You sound very sensible. I don’t think this thread is for you. I do not see abuse on either side. Neither the op nor her partner.

i see a partner that is not happy and withdrawing. Rather than behaving like he should and being honest, he is being a coward and withdrawing, and limiting his time and interaction with the OP

I don’t how withdrawing explains actively choosing to not buy the op food when he goes to get food, or to go out with her and others to somewhere she can’t eat. That behaviour is both far more active and hostile than withdrawing.

JoanOfAllTrades · 07/11/2022 01:22

bedazzled82 · 05/11/2022 08:54

You sound very sensible. I don’t think this thread is for you. I do not see abuse on either side. Neither the op nor her partner.

i see a partner that is not happy and withdrawing. Rather than behaving like he should and being honest, he is being a coward and withdrawing, and limiting his time and interaction with the OP

Withdrawing, limiting time and interaction, not caring about OP and her food allergies - these are all examples of emotional abuse.

Abuse doesn’t have to be screaming at someone all the time, or constant beatings. It can be more insidious and the fact that his withdrawing, limiting time and interaction and lying made the OP feel how she did, that is emotional abuse!

JoanOfAllTrades · 07/11/2022 01:18

dogmandu · 05/11/2022 08:43

It honestly feels like he's trying to avoid spending time with me but a) when he's leaving early in the morning he would be sleeping and so would I, so even if he can't stand me, surely he'd rather be asleep? and b) the rest of his behaviour isn't indicating that. He says he loves me, he's very happy etc. At the end of the day, we're completing tomorrow so it's not going to be going on much longer but I am exhausted from having the kids on my own for additional hours and then having to do a full day of work myself! He's not usually like this (usually rushing home, mostly to see the kids) so the sudden change has concerned me - is he depressed? He seems fine in every other way. Any thoughts?

@JoanOfAllTrades

I'm not sure she is being abused. There is another thread of hers mentioned on here which I haven't read so I may not have the full picture. whichever way, for many years I worked with HR in a role in which I had to resolve employee issues., usually between each other or with management. And very often I'd get a story where there was clear blame on another person and the solution was pretty clear. After talking to the other person, the picture changed somewhat and nothing was clear anymore. After much tooing and froing (sp??) a completely different picture emerged and the solution offered was very different to the one suggested at the beginning.

It just seems on here that some posters don't want anything different to emerge than posted at the beginning because it suits nicely their solutions and doesn't muddy the picture.

It makes perfect sense to always examine the emerging situation and react accordingly.

I feel like there was some type of emotional or psychological abuse. Not getting her hair cut? I don’t understand that at all. Getting food orders mixed up? Not understanding that either. I think there is a lot more here than initially thought and of course, you are right, there are two sides to every story. Well, three really, her side, his side, the truth! I don’t think we can be expected to be Solomon though and have to take what we read at face value, if someone lies, that’s on them!

I do often wonder if sometimes the picture were are given is deliberately cast in a certain light, but then people are human. They aren’t willingly going to admit to things that put them in a bad light. It’s quite obvious that OP is quite clever. Whether she misuses that to put all the negative attributes of human nature on to her husband, I don’t know.

What I do dislike is seeing a pile on like the one here where people are being persistent in badgering OP about her seemingly change of personality - she’s allowed to be spirited and angry! And we don’t have the right to cross examine her - she isn’t on trial!

bedazzled82 · 05/11/2022 08:54

dogmandu · 05/11/2022 08:43

It honestly feels like he's trying to avoid spending time with me but a) when he's leaving early in the morning he would be sleeping and so would I, so even if he can't stand me, surely he'd rather be asleep? and b) the rest of his behaviour isn't indicating that. He says he loves me, he's very happy etc. At the end of the day, we're completing tomorrow so it's not going to be going on much longer but I am exhausted from having the kids on my own for additional hours and then having to do a full day of work myself! He's not usually like this (usually rushing home, mostly to see the kids) so the sudden change has concerned me - is he depressed? He seems fine in every other way. Any thoughts?

@JoanOfAllTrades

I'm not sure she is being abused. There is another thread of hers mentioned on here which I haven't read so I may not have the full picture. whichever way, for many years I worked with HR in a role in which I had to resolve employee issues., usually between each other or with management. And very often I'd get a story where there was clear blame on another person and the solution was pretty clear. After talking to the other person, the picture changed somewhat and nothing was clear anymore. After much tooing and froing (sp??) a completely different picture emerged and the solution offered was very different to the one suggested at the beginning.

It just seems on here that some posters don't want anything different to emerge than posted at the beginning because it suits nicely their solutions and doesn't muddy the picture.

It makes perfect sense to always examine the emerging situation and react accordingly.

You sound very sensible. I don’t think this thread is for you. I do not see abuse on either side. Neither the op nor her partner.

i see a partner that is not happy and withdrawing. Rather than behaving like he should and being honest, he is being a coward and withdrawing, and limiting his time and interaction with the OP

dogmandu · 05/11/2022 08:43

It honestly feels like he's trying to avoid spending time with me but a) when he's leaving early in the morning he would be sleeping and so would I, so even if he can't stand me, surely he'd rather be asleep? and b) the rest of his behaviour isn't indicating that. He says he loves me, he's very happy etc. At the end of the day, we're completing tomorrow so it's not going to be going on much longer but I am exhausted from having the kids on my own for additional hours and then having to do a full day of work myself! He's not usually like this (usually rushing home, mostly to see the kids) so the sudden change has concerned me - is he depressed? He seems fine in every other way. Any thoughts?

@JoanOfAllTrades

I'm not sure she is being abused. There is another thread of hers mentioned on here which I haven't read so I may not have the full picture. whichever way, for many years I worked with HR in a role in which I had to resolve employee issues., usually between each other or with management. And very often I'd get a story where there was clear blame on another person and the solution was pretty clear. After talking to the other person, the picture changed somewhat and nothing was clear anymore. After much tooing and froing (sp??) a completely different picture emerged and the solution offered was very different to the one suggested at the beginning.

It just seems on here that some posters don't want anything different to emerge than posted at the beginning because it suits nicely their solutions and doesn't muddy the picture.

It makes perfect sense to always examine the emerging situation and react accordingly.

Bumzoo · 05/11/2022 07:34

Your hair looks great.

JoanOfAllTrades · 05/11/2022 02:54

dogmandu · 04/11/2022 20:17

There is nothing poisonous in noticing a sudden massive change of character in somebody. This is not in any way questioning her handling of the situation. In this case it is strange that after her extreme passiveness and unwillingness to even seriously question the behaviour of her DH she shows another side to her character that has been missing completely on this thread.
Unless we understand the honest situation how on earth can we offer helpful suggestions? I wonder if we only have a part if the story here and none of the suggestions will help until we understand more.
I'm not suggesting that the OP is deliberately hiding anything, but rather that this new behaviour opens new lines of understanding and offering helpful suggestions.

I understand where you’re coming from, but I’m sure you understand that when someone is abused, as @GreatLates was, for many years from the sound of it, and suddenly they realise that, there is often an epiphany and on the other side of that is anger, for being so misused, for the loss of their marriage, for the loss of their children’s father, for the loss of their whole life in fact, and that is what OP is now displaying.

ImustLearn2Cook · 05/11/2022 01:01

Shoopideedoop · 04/11/2022 20:53

Hey OP,
I just wanted to say that I've been following this thread...first feeling so sorry for you...but now, I am so proud of you!!!
Well done for being strong enough to stand up for yourself and...for going to get your hair done!
I'm sure your thoughts and feelings are all over the place at the moment...but I'm so glad that you can see that you deserve to be treated well...by others and yourself :)

My thoughts exactly. Your hair looks amazing. And if I could high five you for the way you stood up for yourself a few posts back, I would. Keep empowering yourself.

Tesal · 04/11/2022 23:47

Isthisforeal · 04/11/2022 20:11

Oh, did you think I was talking about you?
But anyway, you might find it helpful to read the thread before you 'chime' in.

Oh, was I mistaken in my belief that you were talking about me?
I have read the thread before I ‘chimed’ in. Which is precisely why I did.
OP is showing a completely different side to her persona.

Shoopideedoop · 04/11/2022 20:53

Hey OP,
I just wanted to say that I've been following this thread...first feeling so sorry for you...but now, I am so proud of you!!!
Well done for being strong enough to stand up for yourself and...for going to get your hair done!
I'm sure your thoughts and feelings are all over the place at the moment...but I'm so glad that you can see that you deserve to be treated well...by others and yourself :)