Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this wasn't handled brilliantly

100 replies

Runlulurunandrun · 05/07/2022 23:26

My DD8 (yr3) has been having friendship problems at school this year with being in/out of a particular group. It's escalated over the last few months and (I think) may be the cause of extremely defiant, difficult behaviour at home as she has a habit of behaving badly at bedtime when she's upset.

To try and solve the problem I went into school to see her teacher to see if they could help by encouraging other friendships, and whether she had any advice for DD (ie was contributing to situations) . I was also going tk mention that DD is scared of the teacher so she won't come to her with a problem, but had good chat with Teacher and saw no need to mention it when it came to it. Teacher was very reassuring, said she'd been bullied at school and she was keen to support DD here - she said she would speak to a 2nd group of friends that DD sometimes plays with to ask them to support DD, and also put her on the list for weekly chat with Senco (Didn't know schools did this as Dd doesn't have SEN.. I think.. But that's another thread!) At one point, I got a bit emotional because I have a very frustrating tendency to cry when stressed! However, all seemed fine and the last week or so DD has been happier, sometimes playing with new friends, sometimes playing with old friendship group happy enough.

Anyway, teacher called me at lunchtime today as there'd been an incident between a group of girls that culminated in them all being taken in at lunch and told off. Apologies, I don't know how to describe the incident without it all sounding terribly petty but it's relevant to me being a bit unsure of the teachers reaction.

Two girls from DD's new friendship group had an argument and DD told a playground assistant as one of them was crying. DD's teacher came out and ordered them all 'Inside Now' ('them' being new and old friendship group who were all somehow involved)

This culminated in DD being formally banned from playing with one of the girls in her previous friendship group (the one she has the most trouble with). Her teacher didn't have much explanation for this except that they'd made the situation worse by getting involved as what was an argument between 2 people became a group drama. I think it was also on the basis that 'everything had been fine till they played together again'.

The arguments are petty and I'm prepared to go with the teachers judgement here, but this is where I'm not sure it was handled well. Most of the six girls that got pulled in ended up crying as they were all shouted at. The teacher complained that she 'was upset dealing with it, had upset children and had upset parents coming in to see her'. It's hard to convey tone with text but it was anger at having to deal with their problems. From what DD says, It sounds to me like she went off at them in a temper and I'm particularly pissed off about the upset parents comment. DD knows that would have been me and I feel pretty annoyed that the teacher has said I was upset! DD is now adamant that I'm not to talk to school again.
My questions are
Is it normal for children to be scared of their teacher?
Is banning children from playing together realistic? We discussed this option when I met the teacher and said we'd leave it. I think it makes life harder for DD
Would you do anything? Or just grit your teeth till the end of term?

FWIW my son is just finishing year six and I've never asked school for help before.

OP posts:
Minimalme · 06/07/2022 07:04

Firstly, I don't think the teacher was referring to you crying, don't worry about that.

Secondly, yes two of mine are generally terrified of authority. They are both on the spectrum though.

Is it possible that your dd has some social communication difficulties? My niece has just had a diagnosis and I was shocked (3 boys with ASD) at how differently it presented in a girl.

Minimalme · 06/07/2022 07:08

It may not have been a bollocking though op.

My youngest is 8 and sensitive to criticism.

If I say anything remotely critical, he is wanting to call Childline to put in an official complaint Grin

ColouringPencils · 06/07/2022 07:16

Your DD need never know it was you who was upset, you could say 'well obviously several parents have been in to complain then' as if the upset parent was someone else. It might even be true. This does seem the least of the problems to be honest.
It does all sound fairly exhausting, especially for your DD, but maybe the teachers is right that not playing with the other girl will result in her having a better time? There are only a few weeks left until the end of term, so maybe it is handy if the 'ban' stays in place to help her play more with the different group. I don't personally like the feeling of a ban though.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 07:18

@Minimalme it's not impossible. It has crossed my mind before for various reasons (finds it hard to control emotions at home, paralysed by pressure, massively mimics others behaviours) Ironically, one of the reasons I've never pursued it is because school have always complimented her social skills (both explicitly, and by referring to her as mature, kind, a good friend etc)

OP posts:
Hurstlandshome · 06/07/2022 07:22

@Runlulurunandrun

I copied this from the website:

School have a highly trained ELSA (emotional literacy support assistant). You will be notified by the school’s SENCo should we feel your child would benefit from seeing our ELSA. Examples of work covered during their sessions are social skills, emotions, bereavement, attachment, social stories and therapeutic stories, anger management, self-esteem and friendships.

I suspect this is the person your school is suggesting - I hope your little one gets so much out of it. I think my daughter saw the YMCA councillor - same therapy but not through SENCO, your school may not have that resource. It's the same thing anyway.

Shame your daughter won't get a good run of sessions, but great that they have prioritised her.

Try not to get caught up in the cattyness of it, or upset with how frustrated the teacher is. I've had candid conversations with a few teachers at the school and they find these friendship circle issue utterly exhausting and so distracting.

Your DD will find her feet and learn to manage without teacher intervention. My DD did and she's so much happier. Hope all goes well.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 07:22

Also @Minimalme the reasons I describe for wondering may not even be correct, I just mention them because my niece was assessed for ASD and the two of them are very similar. She was diagnosed with inattentive ADD in the end though

OP posts:
LondonQueen · 06/07/2022 07:23

WhatTheWhoTheWhatThe · 05/07/2022 23:34

Sounds like an exasperated teacher who lost her rag over a whole lot of he said she said nonsense. It is mind numbingly exhausting getting to the bottom of most playground drama’s especially when they’re ongoing and not everyone is an innocent party.

Pretty much this, as a teacher it can be exhausting to sort out playground dramas that are cutting into learning time.

EntertainingandFactual · 06/07/2022 07:24

I agree with previous posters.
Sounds like they all got a bollocking because the teacher is sick to death of petty squabbles and mischief from groups of girls.
Your DD and a girl from the original group have been banned from socialising together presumably because there was some sort of spat between them as a result of this latest incident. The ‘banning’ can’t have come from nowhere.

Let the teacher continue to monitor the situation and act as she sees fit.

Yes, schools do ban students from associating and socialising with certain others if there is trouble when they are together (high school here).

GreensInMyRoom · 06/07/2022 07:25

Bednobsbroomsticks · 06/07/2022 06:50

Two girls later and this is usual stuff. Girls are like wolf packs quite honestly and turn at moments notice. Thread is quite confusing but all I can say is if you get involved in these things every time they happen you will not have time for anything else.
My kids were bullied and left out and told off. We taught them resilience and comebacks and to always be better person. They got through fine and tough as old boots now. Yours will too

@Bednobsbroomsticks please could you share some of the comebacks, I would like to advise my dd.

OP, are you 100% sure it's not your dd causing the drama? We have a situation (year 5) where dd's friend has become competitive, jealous and negative with her friendship group. This has been going on for at least 2 terms. The other girls are understandably fed up and are turning away one by one after having given their friend many chances to be friends and play nicely. At the end of the day, no-one likes to be treated in an unkind way and they've had enough of this girls unpredictability, dramas and being shouted at just because they are not dancing to this girls' tune. It's sad as the girl is lovely but a bit of a catch 22, she is causing lots of drama, friends get hurt and turn away and she gets more insecure causing more and more dramas. Any advice how to support this girl and dd would be greatly appreciated. DD is very sad that her friend behaves in this unsupportive and erratic manner.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 07:30

@GreensInMyRoom no I can't be certain. This was one of the reasons I spoke to the teacher in the first place, to hear a more objective view, to work out whether I need to be encouraging her to play elsewhere or concentrating on improving her social skills

OP posts:
LizzieSiddal · 06/07/2022 07:33

I too think you’re massively over thinking the whole thing. It’s the end of term, everyone is frazzled- including you by the sounds of it, your dd will have a new teacher soon and you can help Dd with her friendships through the summer holidays by having play dates.

LetItGoHome · 06/07/2022 07:43

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 01:00

@GoldenSongbird she probably has a good idea that was me as she knows I saw her teacher last week!

This is a bit of a leap from what I've said though:
'You're embarrassed and feel caught out but you may not be the only parent who has contacted the school about the friendship issues.'

Why would I feel caught out or embarrassed?

I'd feel pretty embarrassed if I cried because I was stressed in front of my child's teacher.
If your daughter assumed it was you that was upset without you telling her, it must be because she knows you cry when stressed.

RhiWrites · 06/07/2022 07:45

At 8 years old everything is very binary.
these girls are nice or mean
this teacher is kind or scary
being shouted at was a bad thing and now I’m in trouble
mum got it right it or got it wrong

OP, you need to provide nuance. Sometimes these girls are nice and sometimes they are mean, the teacher doesn’t want you to play with this one girl because she’s worried about you. The teacher is kind but also sometimes scary, she shouted because she was upset. Going to see the teacher was the right thing to do - even if the teacher hasn’t handled it exactly as either of us might like.

Try to build up DDs resilience and ability to think with more subtlety. And don’t get too sucked into the details. The teacher is probably trying to help. You may not be the only concerned parent. And although being shouted at is never nice, it’s over now.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 07:59

Thank you there's been some useful advice here.
I've asked for it to be removed now as it's grown in size and I don't want to make the situation worse by any of the people involved picking up on it

OP posts:
eatingapie · 06/07/2022 07:59

No one feels good after a bollocking but that’s normal - I don’t think it’s wrong for kids to feel bad If they’ve done something they should feel bad about.

the little bitches comment was very stupid on the part of the teacher - it’s the one bit of your posts o think is bad. The telling off and a friendship ban sounds proportionate to me.

also I’ve had kids tell me - ooh sir shouted at me earlier/miss had a go at me - and I’ve actually seen what happened and it was a teacher saying something like “right I’ve had enough of this it needs to stop” in a stern voice. Which is not a bollocking.

alternatively the teacher is a mean bully who can’t relate to kids 🤷🏻‍♀️ At the end of the day you’re the one who will know what’s more likely

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 08:03

Or option 3, a frazzled and inexperienced teacher who means we'll but doesn't understand children yet and could do with support

OP posts:
Itwasntmeright · 06/07/2022 08:17

Christ, since when did parents get so all up in there little kids’ dramas?

Group of eight-year-olds had an argument. Teacher bollocked them all and split the two who she judged were having conflict. What is wrong about that?

OP, you went to talk to the teacher because your DD was having friendship issues. The teacher acted and all was well for a week, then your DD got involved in some more drama. It may or may not have been her fault and she may or may not have been involved, but seriously, you need to take a big step back here. It’s three weeks till the end of term, eight year olds have friendship dramas, that’s how they learn to navigate the world. They also occasionally get caught up in bollockings for stuff that wasn’t their fault, which may or may not have been the case here. Stop getting so invested.

oh, and kids tend to be scared of teachers who don’t pander to them.

Rather than getting all upset at the teacher for doing her job, encourage your DD to make sensible decisions and avoid drama, otherwise you’re going to end up with an absolute nightmare for the next 10 years and a child who lacks resilience.

NaTFlop · 06/07/2022 08:20

That's a shame to have the thread deleted OP, I doubt it's recognisable.

The teacher should definitely NOT have used the term bitches, it's out of order and I would complain if a teacher called my dd this.

At the same time, you cannot expect a teacher to be always totally zen and if they have all been misbehaving for a long time, it's understandable for her to be robust.

I don't think there is ANY shame in crying when stressed, it's scoping mechanism and you must have felt worried and helpless.

I would definitely try and teach your dd resilience and social skills, help her not to catastrophise and expect too much from a single friendship. Talk with your dd and get her to tell you in detail what's happening at school and what she is doing and saying. If you dd is very thin skinned, she'll have many dramas ahead of her. teach her to be a good and steady friend and avoid drama. If she is kicking off at home, she may well be kicking off at school.

Totheweekend · 06/07/2022 08:26

I’m shocked at the teacher labelling 8 year olds as ‘little bitches’. Seems a bit early to write them off and certainly makes me wonder st her professionalism, end-of-term-frazzled or not.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 06/07/2022 08:33

My daughter had friendship issues from reception to Y3

She was also terrified of one particular teacher.

Shes 15 now, and is still terrified of several teachers. Is it normal? Not sure. But she’s waiting for an ASD assessment.

Itwasntmeright · 06/07/2022 08:37

I’m shocked that so many people are horrified at the teacher mouthing that a group of girls are little bitches. she’s probably right, they probably are little bitches when they get together, in fact isn’t that the whole premise of this post? also it seems the OP didn’t have an issue with it until this latest drama kicked off.

OP, I say this kindly, but you seem really thin skinned yourself. You’re embarrassed about getting upset in front of the teacher, and now you’re worried about this thread remaining up. You seem anxious about your own behavior and how other people perceive it. It’s no wonder your DD gets upset at things if you do the same.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 08:37

I feel a bit like I'm damned if I do and damned if I don't here.

There's a repeated assumption that this is DD's fault, but if I go into much detail about why I'm not sure that's the case then I'm over invested and petty.

I shouldn't assume my DD is innocent but if I try and get clarity on this from her teacher I'm bothering her with petty arguments.

To summarise, I've embarrassed myself by feeling upset when bothering my teacher about my awful DD who is a tell tale and savaged two seperate friendship groups.

Just had another chat as she doesn't want to go to school today. Reminded her it's only a few weeks till the end of term and passed on some of the advice about keeping a low profile. If someone is upset then distract them by starting a good game rather than having lots of chats with everyone concerned which makes it a bigger drama. She did agree this is part of the problem.

OP posts:
Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 08:45

@Itwasntmeright i get what you are saying. I would say 'in real life' I am generally quite robust/confident but am probably a bit over sensitive on this topic.

OP posts:
Eatingchips · 06/07/2022 08:51

Hi OP I haven’t read this all through but I wanted to say that we went through a similar experience with DD in her first year of secondary. Big personality clash with another girl, other girl was a bit controlling, DD very people pleasing but also can be sarky and the intent can be lost to others who naturally then see comments as jibes.

I would agree with the teacher that the less time those with the personality clash spend together rubbing each other up the wrong way the better all around. The ultimate goal I would have is figuring out my child’s contributions to the issues and working on those with her - there are always some. Then I would work on trying to get her to leave behind people who exclude her and make her feel bad. However I agree with you that the separation should be coming from the children themselves when they are ready for it and not from a decree from the teacher.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 06/07/2022 08:56

I am surprised we've gone from 'here's all the support we can give you' to giving her a bollocking and friendship ban in less than 2 weeks

Do you see these things as opposing? Sometimes the support is helping you to stay out of the dramas you are getting dragged into or dragging yourself into. Giving someone support also does not mean that they have a get out of jail free card - i.e. they can still get a 'bollocking' whilst being offered support.

I think you need to challenge your own thinking about being the upset parent she is referring to. Lots of other parents will also be upset at the moment so there is no need to assume that it's you she's talking about. Having seen the teacher last week is not evidence here. She may have also seen or spoken to other parents.

Your DD clearly does need some help negotiating friendships so I'd concentrate on that if I were you. 8 can be a difficult stage for friendships.

Swipe left for the next trending thread