My DD8 (yr3) has been having friendship problems at school this year with being in/out of a particular group. It's escalated over the last few months and (I think) may be the cause of extremely defiant, difficult behaviour at home as she has a habit of behaving badly at bedtime when she's upset.
To try and solve the problem I went into school to see her teacher to see if they could help by encouraging other friendships, and whether she had any advice for DD (ie was contributing to situations) . I was also going tk mention that DD is scared of the teacher so she won't come to her with a problem, but had good chat with Teacher and saw no need to mention it when it came to it. Teacher was very reassuring, said she'd been bullied at school and she was keen to support DD here - she said she would speak to a 2nd group of friends that DD sometimes plays with to ask them to support DD, and also put her on the list for weekly chat with Senco (Didn't know schools did this as Dd doesn't have SEN.. I think.. But that's another thread!) At one point, I got a bit emotional because I have a very frustrating tendency to cry when stressed! However, all seemed fine and the last week or so DD has been happier, sometimes playing with new friends, sometimes playing with old friendship group happy enough.
Anyway, teacher called me at lunchtime today as there'd been an incident between a group of girls that culminated in them all being taken in at lunch and told off. Apologies, I don't know how to describe the incident without it all sounding terribly petty but it's relevant to me being a bit unsure of the teachers reaction.
Two girls from DD's new friendship group had an argument and DD told a playground assistant as one of them was crying. DD's teacher came out and ordered them all 'Inside Now' ('them' being new and old friendship group who were all somehow involved)
This culminated in DD being formally banned from playing with one of the girls in her previous friendship group (the one she has the most trouble with). Her teacher didn't have much explanation for this except that they'd made the situation worse by getting involved as what was an argument between 2 people became a group drama. I think it was also on the basis that 'everything had been fine till they played together again'.
The arguments are petty and I'm prepared to go with the teachers judgement here, but this is where I'm not sure it was handled well. Most of the six girls that got pulled in ended up crying as they were all shouted at. The teacher complained that she 'was upset dealing with it, had upset children and had upset parents coming in to see her'. It's hard to convey tone with text but it was anger at having to deal with their problems. From what DD says, It sounds to me like she went off at them in a temper and I'm particularly pissed off about the upset parents comment. DD knows that would have been me and I feel pretty annoyed that the teacher has said I was upset! DD is now adamant that I'm not to talk to school again.
My questions are
Is it normal for children to be scared of their teacher?
Is banning children from playing together realistic? We discussed this option when I met the teacher and said we'd leave it. I think it makes life harder for DD
Would you do anything? Or just grit your teeth till the end of term?
FWIW my son is just finishing year six and I've never asked school for help before.