Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this wasn't handled brilliantly

100 replies

Runlulurunandrun · 05/07/2022 23:26

My DD8 (yr3) has been having friendship problems at school this year with being in/out of a particular group. It's escalated over the last few months and (I think) may be the cause of extremely defiant, difficult behaviour at home as she has a habit of behaving badly at bedtime when she's upset.

To try and solve the problem I went into school to see her teacher to see if they could help by encouraging other friendships, and whether she had any advice for DD (ie was contributing to situations) . I was also going tk mention that DD is scared of the teacher so she won't come to her with a problem, but had good chat with Teacher and saw no need to mention it when it came to it. Teacher was very reassuring, said she'd been bullied at school and she was keen to support DD here - she said she would speak to a 2nd group of friends that DD sometimes plays with to ask them to support DD, and also put her on the list for weekly chat with Senco (Didn't know schools did this as Dd doesn't have SEN.. I think.. But that's another thread!) At one point, I got a bit emotional because I have a very frustrating tendency to cry when stressed! However, all seemed fine and the last week or so DD has been happier, sometimes playing with new friends, sometimes playing with old friendship group happy enough.

Anyway, teacher called me at lunchtime today as there'd been an incident between a group of girls that culminated in them all being taken in at lunch and told off. Apologies, I don't know how to describe the incident without it all sounding terribly petty but it's relevant to me being a bit unsure of the teachers reaction.

Two girls from DD's new friendship group had an argument and DD told a playground assistant as one of them was crying. DD's teacher came out and ordered them all 'Inside Now' ('them' being new and old friendship group who were all somehow involved)

This culminated in DD being formally banned from playing with one of the girls in her previous friendship group (the one she has the most trouble with). Her teacher didn't have much explanation for this except that they'd made the situation worse by getting involved as what was an argument between 2 people became a group drama. I think it was also on the basis that 'everything had been fine till they played together again'.

The arguments are petty and I'm prepared to go with the teachers judgement here, but this is where I'm not sure it was handled well. Most of the six girls that got pulled in ended up crying as they were all shouted at. The teacher complained that she 'was upset dealing with it, had upset children and had upset parents coming in to see her'. It's hard to convey tone with text but it was anger at having to deal with their problems. From what DD says, It sounds to me like she went off at them in a temper and I'm particularly pissed off about the upset parents comment. DD knows that would have been me and I feel pretty annoyed that the teacher has said I was upset! DD is now adamant that I'm not to talk to school again.
My questions are
Is it normal for children to be scared of their teacher?
Is banning children from playing together realistic? We discussed this option when I met the teacher and said we'd leave it. I think it makes life harder for DD
Would you do anything? Or just grit your teeth till the end of term?

FWIW my son is just finishing year six and I've never asked school for help before.

OP posts:
WhatTheWhoTheWhatThe · 05/07/2022 23:34

Sounds like an exasperated teacher who lost her rag over a whole lot of he said she said nonsense. It is mind numbingly exhausting getting to the bottom of most playground drama’s especially when they’re ongoing and not everyone is an innocent party.

Fulbe · 05/07/2022 23:35

Sorry this post is just too long to get many answers. Can you summarise the points more succinctly?

I have made the effort to read it all through though.

I remember having a scary teacher who flew off the handle at primary school and it hindered my learning in that year. It's not that long until the end of term so I would recommend being a supportive person in your daughter's life outside school (rather than describing her as behaving badly) and having a conversation with her about it. She needs to try to stay away from those girls so she stays out of trouble. That's it really.

Runlulurunandrun · 05/07/2022 23:42

@fulbe apologies for the length, and thanks for taking the time to read it. It was about 3 times as long with all the back story - Quite a lot of what I chopped out was to do with DD 'behaving badly' to try and explain why I am worried about her and why it's bad enough that I thought it was worth talking to school. Phrasing it that way doesn't mean I'm not supportive, was just trying to explain it's having a real effect at home

OP posts:
DespicablyYou · 05/07/2022 23:44

I agree that it wasn’t handled brilliantly but teachers are human and your child needs to learn that.

Just let her talk about it, explain that you understand why she found it upsetting, that you would have too, and that unfortunately adults do sometimes get it wrong.

What matters now is that the relationship with the teacher is repaired, and that your daughter learns to steer clear of drama.

It won’t be the last time that your child is told off for something she didn’t do or thinks she didn’t do, or has drama with friends. The important thing is giving her the skills to navigate these instances.

Duttercup · 05/07/2022 23:47

Just sounds like they got a bollocking, to be honest. Maybe it wasn't handled perfectly, but the teacher is only human and your post suggests this has been going on for a while

Also, do you know for sure you're the only parent who's been in about this?

I was scared of my Y2 and Y4 and a variety of secondary school teachers. I assume it's fairly normal for children to be scared of adults in authority to some degree.

PoisonedIvydaffs · 05/07/2022 23:48

They shouldn’t be scared of the teacher, but it’s fairly normal for children to get upset about being told off.

It might not have been perfect handling of a situation but I don’t think it’s bad or concerning. Pointing out that their behaviour upsets not only the other children, but is also not nice for the teacher and worrying for parents is ok too; they need to understand that their actions have wider consequences.

If two individuals have stirred up a group drama from a much smaller fall out then I think encouraging them to stay away from each other is a sensible solution, especially as the issues have been ongoing.

Runlulurunandrun · 05/07/2022 23:54

@WhatTheWhoTheWhatThe yes I did think that when I was trying to describe it! And yes I am also sure innocent parties are few and far between.

I will try better to summarise what's bothering me. I asked school whether DD was contributing to problems, as she's and for help encouraging new friendships. Teacher was sympathetic offered many ways of helping her including referring to the other girls in the group as 'little b**ches that would only get worse'.

I reassure DD that her teacher is looking out for her and she can go to her with a problem.

DD sees a problem (upset friend) tells staff. End result is DD is banned from playing with another girl (neither of whom were part of the original upset..)

From the outside, I know how this reads. Surely this must have been my DD's fault but the teacher specifically said the argument wasn't actually her. This sounds trivial because I am describing one incident - but DD has been unhappy for months.

Now DD has an even more difficult friendship situation (since she's already being excluded) is more scared of her teacher, doesn't trust my judgement (after I've reassured her her teacher is OK) And her teacher has told her i was upset which also really bothers me since I am meant to be absorbing DD's problems and I hate the thought of her knowing I was upset.

OP posts:
P205 · 05/07/2022 23:55

I agree with you. Friendship drama is part of the job.

Is it near the end of the school year?

I think maybe the teacher was stressed out and just exploded. It happens. Teachers are human too.

I wouldn't say anything, but you were right to talk to the school.

P205 · 05/07/2022 23:57

Hopefully, you'll get a nicer teacher next year is what I meant.

NoSquirrels · 05/07/2022 23:58

The teacher called some of the children “little bitches” when you went to discuss? Really?

My advice if that is true is very different to my advice on the he-said-she-said teacher loses patience with 3 weeks of term to go.

Notimeforaname · 06/07/2022 00:02

She said "upset parents" she didn't actually tell your daughter and the others that it was you. It could be any number of parents from the group also. And you were upset, so she wasn't wrong in that.
I feel for everyone in this situation but the teacher really doesn't have the time and I'm sure is doing the best she can.
I do think it's best those who dont get along, try to stay away from each other. It's the best option.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 00:03

I do agree with all the comments that teachers are only human, and that is exactly what I say to DD

I have been encouraging DD for months to play with other friends but it's not always that easy (I think the details will sound petty) but even going off and playing with her other friends causes dramas with this particular friendship group. They demand she comes back and then exclude her again. I don't think DD is perfect, and I am honestly trying to be objective (she certainly scraps with her brother) but she's never had any trouble with friendships outside of school.

I think I just feel sorry for her - she trusted me to help her, I reassured her that her teacher would help and it's massively backfired.

OP posts:
DespicablyYou · 06/07/2022 00:04

Quite the drip feed. How interesting that you omitted the little bitches comment from your original post 🤔 I am guessing you didn’t get the sympathy you had hoped for?

DespicablyYou · 06/07/2022 00:05

Anyway, fact remains your daughter needs to learn to navigate friendships and coping mechanisms. Teaching her that is your role.

Notimeforaname · 06/07/2022 00:07

'little bches that would only get worse'
Ok this changes it. I would make a complaint about that or speak to the teacher directly and tell her how disgraceful it is to speak about the children she teaches like that.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 00:08

@NoSquirrels she said 'little' and mouthed the bitches part

She'd just told me that she was bullied at school and she felt strongly about stamping out this behaviour and supporting DD- I was uncomfortae at the time because my original conversation wasn't to complain about the other children (I don't think it's that simple) but I felt like she was projecting her own experience and feeling on to the situation and that's why she worded it so strongly.

OP posts:
Notimeforaname · 06/07/2022 00:11

but even going off and playing with her other friends causes dramas with this particular friendship group. They demand she comes back and then exclude her again

This somthing most if not all kids go through at one point or another. Even adults. Yes its cruel but all children need the social practice, meeting and dealing with different personalities.
Its tough but they wont be 8 forever.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 00:11

@DespicablyYou is it though?? There's plenty of other stuff I could put in but it was long enough already!
If anything I ommitted that part because I was trying not to paint it that the other girls were awful because they are all also 8 years old

OP posts:
PortMac · 06/07/2022 00:15

No offence but I think you’re overthinking it a bit.
The teacher is probably dealing with understaffing, overwork, Covid and having a bunch a girls who are caught up in drama.
Young girls behave poorly at times and groups at this age can be tricky.
Your daughter may not be as innocent as you think.
Teach your daughter how to deal with conflict and be confident and let the school deal with.
You crying at the interview didn’t help and the teacher wasn’t using you as an example ( nobody would know).
Your daughter should not have guilt tripped you like that.
Step away.

MangyInseam · 06/07/2022 00:24

I tend to agree that the exclusion thing is very common among groups of girls.

The only way to learn to handle it is to opt out, but lots of kids won't, and usually you can't make them. Usually they eventually learn from experience that such people are not friends but it can take a long time. My dd didn't figure it out until she was 15.

The little bitches comment was unwise, but I'd be inclined to be somewhat generous. She's very possibly right. Kids that are nasty manipulators turn into teens that are nasty manipulators in a lot of cases.

BonjourCrisette · 06/07/2022 00:35

The little bitches comment was massively inappropriate (she is probably right, but it's unprofessional). It is not at all normal for primary aged children to be scared of their teachers. I would be asking for a conversation with the head or deputy head to work out how this situation can be improved.

Melroses · 06/07/2022 00:38

There was a tv series, I think Ch 4, called 'The Secret Lives of Year three'. I can't find it now, and there seem to be lots of other 'secret lives' programmes.

It was fascinating because this is the age that they are making and breaking friendships and develop stronger friendships - it is a developmental stage. I remember having a lot of dramas with my DDs and their school friends at this age but fortunately we had a lovely teacher who used to just have little chats and it was all smoothed over by the end of the day. Anyone teaching this age should be familiar with it - you seem to be unlucky.

I would keep encouraging your DD to make friends with new people until the end of term and hope you have better luck with the teacher next year.

GoldenSongbird · 06/07/2022 00:52

I think you're being overly sensitive tbh. Your DD doesn't know you cried or that you were the upset parent. You're embarrassed and feel caught out but you may not be the only parent who has contacted the school about the friendship issues. Also DCs' recall when they're in a situation isn't usually reliable so the teacher might not have used 'upset parents' at all.

The teacher dealt with the situation as she saw fit. You can reassure your DD that this is exactly what should have happened. Sometimes DCs do need a break from playing with each other and the teacher may have judged the other girl's involvement differently from how your DD judged it. Or the other girl's parents may have contacted the school and said if there was any more drama, they wanted the groups to be separated. You need to tell DD that you will talk to the school when necessary. It's important that you're honest about that channel of communication existing. It means you can support the school and vice versa.

Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 01:00

@GoldenSongbird she probably has a good idea that was me as she knows I saw her teacher last week!

This is a bit of a leap from what I've said though:
'You're embarrassed and feel caught out but you may not be the only parent who has contacted the school about the friendship issues.'

Why would I feel caught out or embarrassed?

OP posts:
Runlulurunandrun · 06/07/2022 01:02

@Melroses and @MangyInseam
Thank you both, your advice is reassuring. It's hard being a child!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread