Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Racism

98 replies

Bloominggoodvibes · 21/06/2022 21:47

AIBU.

Incident in school last week resulting in my child (12) being disciplined by the school.

My child asked another pupil questions during one conversation last week. At the time of the conversation the other pupil didn’t become upset and my child was unaware they had caused any distress until Monday morning when a teacher pulled my child for a chat.

The teacher questioned my child and
they admitted what they had asked and explained they hadn’t meant to cause any upset or embarrassment and requested to apologise to the pupil. The questions were of a curious nature in their eyes but on reflection they can see why the other person is upset over
it.

The teacher
called me to explain what had happened and the subsequent punishment, of suspension, due to the school’s zero tolerance policy regarding racism.

The teacher also explained that the pupil was called racist names by another pupil on the same day but not at the same time and in a separate
incident.
My child was not a part of or aware of the name calling incident.

I have had a chat with my child about their behaviour and understand that the school have to follow there discipline policies so have no issue with this.

HOWEVER today my child has now received lots of messages from friends in school saying there was a year group assembly about racism were the teacher holding the assembly has named my child and the other child who used the racist names and explained that these pupils had been suspended for being racist.

AIBU for thinking that the teacher and school are wrong to have done this ?

My child , who was already mortified and apologetic that they had offended another person is now beside themselves with upset thinking they have been labelled racist to their whole year group.

OP posts:
PAFMO · 23/06/2022 14:55

RedWingBoots · 23/06/2022 14:51

OP this isn't the place to put a thread about them naming and shaming your child at secondary school if you want to deal with it. You should put your thread here - www.mumsnet.com/talk/secondary

She should take it up with the school, which is what she says she's going to do.
She might want to drop the "he's not racist but" bullshit first though.

Nowfeeltheneedtopost · 23/06/2022 14:58

Bloominggoodvibes · 23/06/2022 14:44

@Danzig I don’t feel I have.

Its frustrating that people reply on the thread saying it’s not true that my child has been named and shamed and that I can’t admit my child wrong doing.

People also posting saying what my child has told me is not a true reflection of what’s said when this was the story from the school aswell.

I have said more than once that my child was in the wrong.

My AIBU was asking if the school was BU in naming and shaming my child.

So your question is actually “I acknowledge my DS made racist remarks but am questioning if he should have have been named in assembly”? In which case my response is that it is unusual that he was named but that I would suggest you focus your energies on helping him understand that what he did was wrong.

PAFMO · 23/06/2022 15:20

Comefromaway · 23/06/2022 14:55

I absolutely cannot see that this was racist. It's just asking about their parents jobs.

My mum ran a corner shop, the kids at school used to ask me if I got to eat all the sweets.

My auntie ran a newsagents, a girl who lived nearby asked if I could get her Smash Hits magazine.

It would be different if the child called the other a racist name, or said the child smelt of curry or was laughing at them for living above a takeaway.

"you live above the takeaway, does your Dad cook the curry"

"what does your Dad do?"

Spot the difference.

TeddybearBaby · 23/06/2022 15:21

Op, just know that mumsnet is a crazy place at times and in RL you’ll have a very different response I suspect.

I still say the wrong thing now and do the wrong thing. Say things I regret or in a way that’s interpreted in a way I didn’t mean. I dread to think about the mistakes I made at age 12 - the things I’d be labelled and unable to shift because of a momentary lapse of judgement / innocent mistake makes me cringe. This is why naming your son in assembly is so so dangerous.

So nice for all these perfect people and their perfect children 🙄💐

Comefromaway · 23/06/2022 15:27

The child was told the other child lived in/at the takeaway, NOT above/next to which implied their parent owns said takeaway.

My mum didn't live above her shop. The tenant lived above the shop.

My cousin's lived AT their parents' shop/food outlet. Their dad did the food incidentally.

Moooooooooooooooooo · 23/06/2022 15:50

I believe you OP. I do think your son‘s remarks were innocent. I also think his punishment together with the naming and shaming was harsh. A sensible approach would have been much better all round.

riesenrad · 23/06/2022 15:51

I think it was wrong to name your child in assembly. There is no justification for that.

I think it is wrong to assume that because someone is not white, that they live in a takeaway. Or that it must be an Indian takeaway as opposed to say a fish and chip shop.

If you know that the person's family run an Indian takeaway, it is not unreasonable to ask the questions your son asked.

It all depends on the distinction between assumption and knowledge in my view.

Glitternails1 · 23/06/2022 21:01

@Bloominggoodvibes I’d understand a child under 10 making that comment, but your son is 12. He’s in high school. He did not ask that “innocently.” He would’ve known it was a stereotype. He probably said it to make others laugh. Also, it’s YOUR job, not the young victim, to educate your son to not bully. Hopefully your son will learn from this.

Bloominggoodvibes · 23/06/2022 21:31

@Glitternails1, I have not said it’s the child job to teach my son not to bully - I’ve said open conversations could help promote understanding around these topics.

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 24/06/2022 08:16

I do not think racism should be tolerated however I don’t think the answer to stamping it out lies with ‘jumping on’ borderline , in my opinion due to context and childs age, racist conversation

The "not my Nigel" denial.

Additionally wouldn’t it be great if as well as teaching children to be kind of people taught there children to be resilient. When my child questions hurt the other child wouldn't it have been been better for that child to say , ‘ hey that’s rude because of XYZ. Don’t you realise your question towards me feels racist to me ?’

The "its the target's responsibility to educate my Nigel"

IF , as many if you have posted , a 12 year old ‘OUGHT TO KNOW BETTER‘ then surely the other child (12) is quiet capable of using there experience to educate , peer to peer , during conversation

The "its the target's responsibility to educate my Nigel if they choose to be offended by my Nigel's totally innocent words"

After all we all know that the real problem here is not the racism, its trying to hold any Nigel to account for racism.

Apple certainly hasn't fallen far from the tree.

durianeater · 24/06/2022 08:28

To get back to the naming and shaming - if the headteacher was reporting to governors that there had been two racist incidents it would have to be done anonymously. Even governors are not entitled to know the names of children who have been disciplined or excluded. (At least not unless they end up having to form a panel and even then only the panel would know the name). So no, it wasn't appropriate for them to be named and shamed in assembly and you should be making a complaint about that.
As for what constitutes a racist comment... the world's gone fucking mad.

Bloominggoodvibes · 24/06/2022 17:20

Just to update those who agreed that the naming and shaming of my child was wrong I have just come from a really helpful meeting with the Head to further discuss this. The Head is also going to speak to all the pupils involved as they were not aware that the incidents reported by the other child happened separately and agree that they may have not gathered all the facts before the situation was dealt with. We will have a follow up meeting next week to discuss.

OP posts:
RedHelenB · 24/06/2022 18:23

TeddybearBaby · 22/06/2022 20:21

Your poor son! How inappropriate of the school. I’d seriously think about changing schools. They’ve actually put him in danger!

Over reaction much, out him in danger how?

WaffleIron · 24/06/2022 18:34

Really good to hear @Bloominggoodvibes

I'm sure the school will sort everything out and make sure the rest of the kids know it was just the good kind of racism that your kid did, and not the bad kind the other kid did. All sorted.

Dear oh dear.

TeddybearBaby · 24/06/2022 18:41

@RedHelenB he’s just been publicly named as a racist which means he could be a target of hate and violence himself. Didn’t realise it would be hard to understand 🤣. Have you read some of the messages on this board alone. I doubt he’ll shake this label he has now. Glad the op has a productive meeting though.

Hornbostel · 24/06/2022 18:55

TeddybearBaby · 24/06/2022 18:41

@RedHelenB he’s just been publicly named as a racist which means he could be a target of hate and violence himself. Didn’t realise it would be hard to understand 🤣. Have you read some of the messages on this board alone. I doubt he’ll shake this label he has now. Glad the op has a productive meeting though.

Some of the messages on this board? People saying the boy made a racist comment are putting him in danger how?

RedHelenB · 24/06/2022 19:01

TeddybearBaby · 24/06/2022 18:41

@RedHelenB he’s just been publicly named as a racist which means he could be a target of hate and violence himself. Didn’t realise it would be hard to understand 🤣. Have you read some of the messages on this board alone. I doubt he’ll shake this label he has now. Glad the op has a productive meeting though.

But how does that put him in danger?

TeddybearBaby · 24/06/2022 19:51

I didn’t say the people on this thread were putting him in danger. The way words are twisted on here is hysterical. I’m saying a boy of 12 who is learning who he is and all the stuff that comes with it has made a mistake and he will now be labelled a racist. You can tell from some of the comments on here what a sensitive subject this is.

A child even more than an adult deserves and needs to have this sort of thing handled sensitively. They are vulnerable.

I’m not going to go into detail on here because of confidentiality but I have seen a boy beaten to a pulp after a similar thing as the op. Word got out he was racist and he was attacked by a group of boys who decided he needed to be taught a lesson.

I don’t think labelling a child in any way is ever a good idea. We are human and we make mistakes. I can’t understand why a school setting would ever think shaming children was a good idea and I’d be outta there like a shot if it was me.

Happy to not agree!

kmblark · 24/06/2022 20:34

TeddybearBaby · 24/06/2022 19:51

I didn’t say the people on this thread were putting him in danger. The way words are twisted on here is hysterical. I’m saying a boy of 12 who is learning who he is and all the stuff that comes with it has made a mistake and he will now be labelled a racist. You can tell from some of the comments on here what a sensitive subject this is.

A child even more than an adult deserves and needs to have this sort of thing handled sensitively. They are vulnerable.

I’m not going to go into detail on here because of confidentiality but I have seen a boy beaten to a pulp after a similar thing as the op. Word got out he was racist and he was attacked by a group of boys who decided he needed to be taught a lesson.

I don’t think labelling a child in any way is ever a good idea. We are human and we make mistakes. I can’t understand why a school setting would ever think shaming children was a good idea and I’d be outta there like a shot if it was me.

Happy to not agree!

OPs son is not the victim here.

TeddybearBaby · 24/06/2022 20:36

Thank you for proving my point so beautifully

Bloominggoodvibes · 24/06/2022 20:58

My child has been in shamed,
intentionally, by there school. I think, as a pre-teen child who’s made a mistake they should not be labelled with a title that’s hard to shake for such an emotive and delicate topic , like racism.

My child can be in the wrong but still be entitled to have there emotional well being protected aswell.

The replies on this post have only further convinced me how wrong the naming and shaming of any child would be in these circumstances.

Naming and shaming is used to cause
humiliation, embarrassment, and guilt.

The punishment of suspension was justified in my eyes as the school had to follow policy . A policy I do not disagree with.

The naming and shaming is not a justified discipline and I’m resolved in the option
that the teacher / school should have know better.

OP posts:
PAFMO · 24/06/2022 21:53

Bloominggoodvibes · 24/06/2022 20:58

My child has been in shamed,
intentionally, by there school. I think, as a pre-teen child who’s made a mistake they should not be labelled with a title that’s hard to shake for such an emotive and delicate topic , like racism.

My child can be in the wrong but still be entitled to have there emotional well being protected aswell.

The replies on this post have only further convinced me how wrong the naming and shaming of any child would be in these circumstances.

Naming and shaming is used to cause
humiliation, embarrassment, and guilt.

The punishment of suspension was justified in my eyes as the school had to follow policy . A policy I do not disagree with.

The naming and shaming is not a justified discipline and I’m resolved in the option
that the teacher / school should have know better.

Have you decided yet that so should a 12 year old?
The knowing better than to be racist thing?

Bloominggoodvibes · 24/06/2022 22:16

@PAFMO I have already agreed with another poster, way up this thread , that yes - my child should have known better.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page